CITATION: Barrass v Kaine [1999] NSWSC 245 CURRENT JURISDICTION: Equity Division FILE NUMBER(S): 3930/96 HEARING DATE(S): 25 March 1999 JUDGMENT DATE:
25 March 1999PARTIES :
Robyn Jan Barrass (P1)
Rosemary Steven (P2)
Judith Patricia Kaine (D)JUDGMENT OF: Master McLaughlin
COUNSEL : Ms J. Needham (P)
Mr. B. Skinner (D)SOLICITORS: Pye Rogers Fairfax & Patterson (P)
A.C. Knibb Kaine & Associates (D)CATCHWORDS: ACTS CITED: Family Provision Act 1982 DECISION:
SUPREME COURT OF
NEW SOUTH WALES
EQUITY DIVISIONMASTER McLAUGHLIN
Thursday, 25 March 1999
3930/96 ROBYN JAN BARRASS & ANOR -v- JUDITH PATRICIA KAINE (ESTATE OF WILFRED V. WILLIAMS)JUDGMENT
1 MASTER: By summons filed on 7 November 1996 the plaintiffs, Robyn Jan Barras and Rosemary Gai Stevens, each claim an order for provision for their maintenance and advancement in life out of the estate of their late father, Wilfred Victor Williams (to whom I shall refer as "the deceased"), pursuant to section 7 of the Family Provisions Act 1982. 2 The deceased died aged seventy-eight on 30 April 1996. He left a will dated 15 August 1995, probate whereof was on 27 August 1996 granted to Judith Patricia Kaine, the executrix named in such will (who is the defendant to the present proceedings). 3 The chief assets in the estate of the deceased were two pieces of real property situate at and known as, respectively, 289 Bobbin Head Road, Turrumurra and 289A Bobbin Head Road, Turramurra. The property at 289 Bobbin Head Road, on which there stands a house presently rented, has a present value of $345,000. The property at 289A Bobbin Head Road, on which there also stands a house, has a present value of $425,000. The distributable estate of the deceased is in an amount of $837,492. 4 Having regard to the valuation of the two pieces of real property totalling $770,000, it will be appreciated that of the balance remaining, about $67,000, there will be little left after the payment of the costs of the present proceedings of the defendant executrix, and, in the event that either or both of them be successful, of the plaintiffs in the present proceedings. 5 The deceased was married three times. Of his first marriage, which took place on 10 May 1941, were born the two plaintiffs. In 1958, the deceased and his first wife separated, his first wife leaving the matrimonial home at 289 Bobbin Head Road, Turramurra (which at that stage had not been sub-divided into the two lots which presently comprise that land). 6 The deceased’s first wife, in leaving the matrimonial home was accompanied by each of the plaintiffs. At that time, Robyn (who had been born on 22 April 1942 and who is presently aged fifty-six), was aged about sixteen, and Rosemary (who had been born on 28 October 1943 and who is presently aged fifty-five) was aged about fifteen. 7 The deceased continued to reside at the Bobbin Head Road property. He and his first wife were subsequently divorced, the decree becoming…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Barrass v Kaine and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
Details
- Case
- [1999] NSWSC 245
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The case of Barrass v Kaine involved two daughters, Robyn Jan Barrass and Rosemary Gai Stevens, who sought orders for maintenance and advancement out of their late father Wilfred Victor Williams' estate under section 7 of the Family Provisions Act 1982. The deceased left his estate to his third wife Audrey Clare Williams and his stepdaughter Judith Joy Messing. The daughters argued they were entitled to an order for provision due to their disadvantaged financial circumstances and lack of contact with their father. The court had to decide whether the lack of contact between the daughters and their father deprived them of any entitlement to an order for provision. The court found that the lack of contact did not deprive them of their entitlement and made orders for provision of $100,000 for Robyn and $60,000 for Rosemary, to be borne proportionately by the assets passing to Audrey and Judith under the deceased's will. The court also ordered that the costs of the proceedings be borne proportionately by the interests of Audrey and Judith.
The key legal issues were whether the lack of contact between the daughters and their father deprived them of any entitlement to an order for provision, and if so, what amounts should be ordered and how they should be borne. The court found that the lack of contact did not deprive the daughters of their entitlement, and ordered specific amounts for each daughter to be borne proportionately by the assets passing to the third wife and stepdaughter under the will. The reasoning focused on the disadvantaged financial circumstances of the daughters, the lack of contact with their father, and the obligations of the deceased to the third wife and stepdaughter.
The key legal issues were whether the lack of contact between the daughters and their father deprived them of any entitlement to an order for provision, and if so, what amounts should be ordered and how they should be borne. The court found that the lack of contact did not deprive the daughters of their entitlement, and ordered specific amounts for each daughter to be borne proportionately by the assets passing to the third wife and stepdaughter under the will. The reasoning focused on the disadvantaged financial circumstances of the daughters, the lack of contact with their father, and the obligations of the deceased to the third wife and stepdaughter.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Full text does not contain this section.