Barnes v Northern Territory of Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 51 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Barnes v Northern Territory of Australia [2011] FCA 879

Citation: Barnes v Northern Territory of Australia [2011] FCA 879
Parties:

RODNEY BARNES v NORTHERN TERRITORY OF AUSTRALIA, COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA, ARCHIE ALLEN, BEAZLEY ANDERSON, GORDON NOONAN, HENRY MORRISON, LUCY O’KEEFE, TONY CUTTER AND TONY WILLY (ON BEHALF OF THE KUTINJA, THE KUNAPA AND MANGIRRIJI, AND THE KUNAKIJI AND THE LUKKURNU GROUPS OF THE WARRAMUNGU, THE KUJULUWA, THE MARRARRABANA AND THE GARRGARRGUWARJA GROUPS OF THE WAMPAYA, THE PURRUKWARA GROUP OF THE WAYAKA, AND THE NGAPA GROUP OF THE WARLMANPA) and AUSTCATTLE HOLDINGS PTY LTD ACN 010 055 384

ARCHIE ALLEN, BEAZLEY ANDERSON, GORDON NOONAN, HENRY MORRISON, LUCY O’KEEFE, TONY CUTTER AND TONY WILLY (ON BEHALF OF THE KUTINJA, THE KUNAPA AND MANGIRRIJI, AND THE KUNAKIJI AND THE LUKKURNU GROUPS OF THE WARRAMUNGU, THE KUJULUWA, THE MARRARRABANA AND THE GARRGARRGUWARJA GROUPS OF THE WAMPAYA, THE PURRUKWARA GROUP OF THE WAYAKA, AND THE NGAPA GROUP OF THE WARLMANPA) v NORTHERN TERRITORY OF AUSTRALIA

File numbers: NTD 18 of 2009
NTD 6001 of 2003
Judge: MANSFIELD J
Date of judgment: 5 August 2011
Catchwords: NATIVE TITLE – whether native title rights and interests are held by a competing claim group, who form a subset of a wider claim group, in respect of a narrow area within the larger claim area of the wider claim group – or whether the native title rights and interests claimed by the smaller claim group are held in conjunction with, and as members of, the wider claim group –application dismissed
Legislation: Native Title Act 1991 (Cth)
Cases cited:

King v Northern Territory (2007) 162 FCR 89
King v The Northern Territory [2007] FCA 1498
Long v Northern Territory of Australia [2011] FCA 571 Rosewood v Northern Territory of Australia [2011] FCA 572
Button Jones v Northern Territory of Australia [2011] FCA 573
Paddy v Northern Territory of Australia [2011] FCA 574
Simon v Northern Territory of Australia [2011] FCA 575
Carlton v Northern Territory of Australia [2011] FCA 576
Campbell v Northern Territory of Australia [2011] FCA 580
Wavehill v Northern Territory of Australia [2011] FCA 581
King v Northern Territory of Australia [2011] FCA 582
Young v Northern Territory of Australia [2011] FCA 583
Wavehill v Northern Territory of Australia [2011] FCA 584
Young v Northern Territory of Australia [2011] FCA 585
Rose (on behalf of the Kurnai Clans) v Victoria [2010] FCA 460
Rubibi Community (No 5) v State of Western Australia [2005] FCA 1025

Members of the Yorta Yorta Aboriginal Community v State of Victoria (2002) 214 CLR 422

Date of hearing: 14 - 16 March 2011
Place: Adelaide (via video link with Darwin)
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 73

In Matter NTD 18 of 2009:

Counsel for the Applicant: The applicant appeared in person
Counsel for the First Respondent: S Brownhill
Solicitor for the First Respondent: Solicitor for the Northern Territory
Counsel for the Second Respondent: The Second Respondent did not appear
Counsel for the Third Respondent: T…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Barnes v Northern Territory of Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] FCA 879
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Federal Court of Australia was asked to determine a dispute regarding native title rights in the Nanara/Darima area between the Barnes claim group and the wider Rockhampton/Brunette Downs claim group. The Barnes claim group, represented by Mr Barnes, argued that they held exclusive native title rights over the Nanara/Darima area. They sought a declaration that their rights and interests were not held in conjunction with, and as members of, the wider Rockhampton/Brunette Downs claim group. The central legal issues before the court were whether the Barnes claim group held exclusive native title rights over the Nanara/Darima area, or whether their rights and interests were held in conjunction with, and as members of, the wider Rockhampton/Brunette Downs claim group.

The court considered the definition of "native title rights and interests" under section 223 of the Native Title Act 1993 (NT Act) and the nature of a determination of native title under section 225. The court also examined the evidence provided by Mr Barnes, including his affidavit and written submissions. The court acknowledged the Barnes claim group's strong belief in their entitlement to live on the Nanara/Darima area and control its use. However, the court found that the Barnes claim group's rights and interests were not exclusive and were held in conjunction with, and as members of, the wider Rockhampton/Brunette Downs claim group. The court concluded that the Barnes claim group's native title rights and interests were not held separately from the wider claim group.

The court dismissed the Barnes claim group's application, finding that their native title rights and interests were not held exclusively but were held in conjunction with, and as members of, the wider Rockhampton/Brunette Downs claim group. The application was dismissed, and the application in Matter NTD 6001 of 2003 was stood over for further directions.

Orders

Orders of the court

2. The application in Matter NTD 18 of 2009 is dismissed.

3. The application in Matter NTD 6001 of 2003 is stood over for further directions to 9:00 am on 30 August 2011.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Order 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

What emerged from the evidence is that Mr Barnes has a passionate belief in his entitlement to live on the Nanara/Darima area, together with the other direct descendants of Sarah Bulumbini, and to control who can enter that land and how that land is used (or perhaps at a lesser level, a right to negotiate those matters), in particular to prevent degradation of it by the present pastoral lessee. The application is verified by a supporting affidavit of Mr Barnes affirming his belief that the native title rights and interests claimed by the native title group have not been extinguished.THE EVIDENCE As I have noted, Mr Barnes’ evidence was the only evidence adduced on behalf of the Barnes claim group. Mr Barnes’ evidence was in part received through written material he had submitted to the Court and which he adopted. One aspect of that concerned the relationship between the Rockhampton/Brunette Downs claim group, and his own claim. He regarded the former as “unlawful” within Aboriginal law and custom. To a degree, Mr Barnes’ assertions about the relationship between the two groups were argumentative rather than descriptive. I also discerned from the course of the evidence some animosity between Mr Barnes and Maurice O’Keefe. Other witnesses did not reveal such animosity towards Mr Barnes or the Barnes claim group (in essence his immediate family) in the course of their evidence. I think they understood and empathised with his particular circumstances. It is neither appropriate nor possible for the Court on a matter such as this routinely to address such animosity or to endeavour to resolve it. The Court’s role is defined by, and limited to, resolution of the particular legal question in issue. I do not consider that that apparent animosity impeded the ability of the Court to resolve that question. I have however made some further comments about it at the conclusion of these reasons for judgment. Mr Barnes adopted the assertions in the Barnes application as amended, including the description of the claim group as Janba Gurdalanji. Mr Barnes repeated what was in the amended application that the Barnes claim group are the direct descendants of the larger Wombi (Wambaya) extended families within the Janba Gurdalanji People, and continue their ancestry dates back to the 1830s. He thus described the claim group as being the descendants of Sarah Bulumbina who was born in 1900 and passed away in May 1982. The application specifically names her children, grandchildren and great grandchildren. The application makes it clear that the claim group is limited to those persons. It also says Sarah Bulumbina was the traditional owner of the area identified as Nguwnera (Nanera), rather than any wider area. Mr Barnes also confined the claim to the “Nguwner and Darima” area. The genealogy prepared and adopted by Dr Graham the anthropologist who gave evidence, traced the ancestry of Sarah Bulumbina back through Djimbu-Walu-Unu (Sarah’s father) and Nyarrarampi (Sarah’s grandfather). Mr Barnes was not aware of those details, although he said that the parents, grandparents and ancestors of Sarah Bulumbina lived on the claim area. The genealogy confirms that Sarah Bulumbina had four children, including Mr Barnes’ mother Vivian Lewis Bibbie Wai-bulla, and then shows her six children and her grandchildren (Sarah’s great grandchildren).

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Despite those criticisms, I have no doubt about Dr Graham’s professionalism or his independence. Nor do I have any reason to doubt the good faith or the commitment of the Northern Land Council. I think Mr Barnes’ criticisms of them are a consequence of his strong emotional belief in his entitlement to be recognised as the native title holder of the confined area, and that not enough has been done to preserve and protect it. I have had the benefit of seeing Dr Graham give his evidence. He was professional, thoughtful and careful. He was thorough. He had solid foundations for his opinions. He strongly and impressively rebutted the suggestion that his views were coloured in any way by a dislike of Mr Barnes. I have no hesitation in accepting him as an impartial and reliable witness.CONSIDERATION Section 223 of the NT Act defines the term “native title rights and interests”. It provides:(1)The expression native title or native title rights and interests means the communal, group or individual rights and interests of Aboriginal peoples or Torres Strait Islanders in relation to land or waters, where:(a)the rights and interests are possessed under the traditional laws acknowledged, and the traditional customs observed, by the Aboriginal peoples or Torres Strait Islanders; and(b)the Aboriginal peoples or Torres Strait Islanders, by those laws and customs, have a connection with the land or waters; and(c)the rights and interests are recognised by the common law of Australia. The term “interest” is defined in relation to land and waters in s 253 to mean:Interest, in relation to land or waters, means:(a) a legal or equitable estate or interest in the land or waters; or(b)any other right (including a right under an option and a right of redemption), charge, power or privilege over, or in connection with:(i) the land or waters; or(ii) an estate or interest in the land or waters; or(c)a restriction on the use of the land or waters, whether or not annexed to other land or waters. The nature of a determination of native title is described in s 225 of the NT Act in the following terms:A determination of native title is a determination whether or not native title exists in relation to a particular area (the determination area) of land or waters and, if it does exist, a determination of:(a)who the persons, or each group of persons, holding the common or group rights comprising the native title are; and(b)the nature and extent of the native title rights and interests in relation to the determination area; and(c)the nature and extent of any other interests in relation to the determination area; and(d)the relationship between the rights and interests in paragraphs (b) and (c) (taking into account the effect of this Act); and(e)to the extent that the land or waters in the determination area are not covered by a non-exclusive agricultural lease or a non-exclusive pastoral lease – whether the native title rights and interests confer possession, occupation, use and enjoyment of that land or waters on the native title holders to the exclusion of all others.Note: The determination may deal with the matters in paragraphs (c) and (d) by referring to a particular kind or particular kinds of non-native title interests.