SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA
(Magistrates Appeals: Civil)
BARLOW v RURAL CITY OF MURRAY BRIDGE
[2018] SASC 88
Judgment of The Honourable Justice Stanley
26 June 2018
MAGISTRATES - APPEAL AND REVIEW - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - APPEAL TO SUPREME COURT
APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - APPEAL - GENERAL PRINCIPLES - INTERFERENCE WITH DISCRETION OF COURT BELOW - IN GENERAL - JUDGE MISTAKEN OR MISLED
MAGISTRATES - ORDERS AND CONVICTIONS - SENTENCE - FINES
Appeal against sentence and application for extension of time within which to appeal.
The appellant entered pleas of guilty in the Magistrates Court to three contraventions of the South Australian Public Health (Wastewater) Regulations 2013 (SA) (the Regulations). The magistrate entered convictions in respect of each contravention and imposed a single fine of $2,100.
The grounds of appeal are that the magistrate erred in imposing convictions for each contravention of the Regulations to which the appellant pleaded guilty and that the fine is manifestly excessive.
Held:
1. The magistrate declined to exercise the discretion not to record convictions on a mistake of fact. This is sufficient for the court to set aside the convictions and to exercise the discretion afresh.
2. The appeal is allowed to the extent that the convictions for two of the three contraventions are set aside.
3. The respondent is granted an extension of time within which to appeal.
South Australian Public Health (Wastewater) Regulations 2013 (SA); Criminal Law (Sentencing) Act 1988 (SA) s 16, s 18, referred to.
Piva v Brinkworth (1992) 59 SASR 92; Gould v Austral Tree & Stump Services Pty Ltd & Anor (No. 2) [2008] SASC 149; Hili v The Queen (2010) 242 CLR 520; Wong v The Queen (2001) 207 CLR 584, applied.
BARLOW v RURAL CITY OF MURRAY BRIDGE
[2018] SASC 88Magistrates Appeal
STANLEY J:
Introduction
This is an appeal against conviction and sentence.
The appellant carries on business as a builder and master plumber under the business name of Barlow Construction & Plumbing. The appellant was charged on information by the respondent with seven counts of contravening the South Australian Public Health (Wastewater) Regulations 2013 (SA) (the Regulations).
After negotiations, the appellant, who was represented by counsel, entered pleas of guilty in the Magistrates Court to three contraventions of the Regulations. The respondent withdrew four other charges. The matter proceeded on the basis of an informant’s statement of facts which had been agreed between counsel after negotiations.
The charges to which the appellant pleaded guilty were:
Count 1:Undertaking wastewater works and/or causing wastewater works to be undertaken other than in accordance with a wastewater works approval for works at Toora in the State of South Australia, contrary to Regulation 11(1)(b)(i) of the Regulations;
Count 2:Undertaking wastewater works and/or causing wastewater works to be undertaken other than in accordance with clause 4.6.7.3 of the Australia / New Zealand Standard 3500.2:2015 Plumbing and Drainage Part 2: Sanitary Plumbing and Drainage, at Toora in the State of South Australia, contrary to Regulation…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Barlow v Rural City of Murray Bridge and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2018] SASC 88
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues the court was required to determine were whether the magistrate had misapplied the discretion not to convict under section 16 of the Local Government (General) Regulations 1992 and whether the fines imposed were manifestly excessive. The appellant argued that the magistrate had declined to exercise the discretion due to a mistake of fact regarding the severity of the odours resulting from the breaches, and that the fines were disproportionate.
The court found that the magistrate had indeed misapplied the discretion not to convict. The magistrate had treated the breaches as not minor because they caused the owners problems with offensive odours, but this was based on a factual error. The court held that the agreed facts did not support the magistrate's belief that the odours were significant. This misapplication of the discretion warranted setting aside the convictions and allowing the court to exercise the discretion afresh. Furthermore, the court found no error in the imposition of the fines.
Consequently, the appeal was allowed, and the convictions recorded in relation to counts 1 and 7 were set aside. The court also extended the time for the appellant to institute the appeal to 2 May 2018. The conviction in relation to count 2 and the fine of $2,100 were upheld by the court.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Nonetheless, the authorities recognise that there will be cases where the circumstances will invite the application of the power to proceed without conviction in dealing with regulatory or social legislation.[5] Those circumstances include where the court is of the opinion that the defendant is unlikely to commit the offence again or extenuating circumstances or other good reason exists for not recording a conviction. [5] Piva v Brinkworth (1992) 59 SASR 92 at 96.Consideration In this case the exercise of the discretion by the magistrate miscarried. The magistrate declined to exercise the discretion on a mistake of fact. He treated the breaches in counts 2 and 7 as not being minor in nature because they caused the owners particular problems with offensive odours. The agreed facts before the magistrate did not go this far. The relevant fact was that the owners noticed a faint smell and suspected it related to the bath drain and the laundry floor waste gully.[6] As the appellant submits, there was no evidence that established conclusively that there was any factual basis to the owners’ suspicion. This is sufficient for the court to set aside the convictions and to exercise the discretion afresh. [6] Informant’s Statement of Facts at [15]. Re-exercising the discretion In this matter it is necessary for the court to consider whether it was appropriate to exercise the discretion conferred by s 16 in relation to each individual offence. In relation to count 1, the appellant submits that his contravention of the regulation in undertaking the works without obtaining wastewater approval was the result of his reliance upon incorrect advice he had obtained from the respondent. On the hearing of the appeal, I admitted an affidavit of the appellant which deposed, inter alia, to a discussion he had with an officer of the respondent. The appellant said that he had been advised in a telephone conversation with an officer of the respondent that it was unnecessary that he submit an application for wastewater approval in circumstances where another plumber was undertaking works on the property at that time, and that he would be applying for such approval. On appeal, counsel for the respondent acknowledged that there was a record of contact between the appellant and one of its officers. There was no record of the nature of the discussion. In the circumstances, I accept the evidence of the appellant on this topic. I accept that the contravention in count 1 was the result of the appellant’s understandable but regrettable reliance on advice he sought and obtained from the respondent, which proved to be incorrect. The appellant attempted to comply with his obligations in relation to obtaining the requisite approvals for performance of the works. The offending conduct was not the result of negligence or deliberate inadvertence. The contravention was not the result of any disregard by the appellant to comply with relevant regulatory obligations. The inadvertent failure to do so does not call for the imposition of a conviction for the reasons of personal deterrence. The need for personal deterrence will be satisfied in this case by the imposition of a fine. In any event, I am satisfied the appellant is unlikely to commit the offence again. Neither, in my view, do considerations of general deterrence require the imposition of a conviction. The imposition of a conviction is unnecessary to ensure that tradespeople performing works of this kind genuinely endeavour to comply with their regulatory obligations. In my view, this constitutes good reason for not recording a conviction.