[2013] QDC 90
DISTRICT COURT
APPELLATE JURISDICTION
JUDGE ROBIN QC
No 587 of 2012
| GEOFFREY JAMES BARLOW | Appellant |
| and | |
| QUEENSLAND POLICE SERVICE | Respondent |
SOUTHPORT
..DATE 04/04/2013
JUDGMENT
CATCHWORDS
Appeal against conviction for possession of tainted property - appellant gave no evidence at trial notwithstanding magistrate’s clear advice that he could not rely on argument as evidence- inappropriate to allow introduction of evidence in the appeal which was not available at the trial - appeal against conviction dismissed - appeal against imposition of a fine as a penalty allowed - community service orders made
Justices Act 1886 s222, s229
Criminal Code s1, s433
Penalties & Sentences Act 1992, s48
HIS HONOUR: This an appeal under section 222 of the Justices Act 1886 by Mr Barlow who was convicted by a Magistrate on the 9th of November 2012, although the Notice of Appeal says 8th of November 2012, of receiving tainted property. No conviction was recorded but a fine of $750 was imposed and an order for costs and witness expenses made against Mr Barlow.
The appeal is against conviction and also against sentence, Mr Barlow volunteering that because of strained financial circumstances if the conviction is to remain, a community service order would be a preferable punishment; he's consented to such an order being made.
The appeal came on two days ago on the initiative of the Registrar, Mr Barlow having failed to comply with the practice direction which requires the filing of a written outline of argument within a nominated time. Perhaps Mr Barlow was hard done by in that regard because his Notice of Appeal did come with a page containing eight dot points attached which raise a number of assertions in support of the appeal.
The respondent made returnable, last Tuesday, an application under section 229 of the Act seeking to have the appeal struck out for want of prosecution. Mr Barlow turned up, so that it was clearly inappropriate for the court to accede to the respondent's application. Mr Barlow asked what he wished the court to do on that day, indicated, in effect, he would like the appeal allowed and the conviction set aside.
He agreed to have the hearing of the appeal today, which involves an abridgement of the time of notice of an appeal hearing usually required. The court had other business last Tuesday which would have precluded considering the appeal on the merits then and there. In any event, the respondent's file has not been Mr Johnson's responsibility. He reasonably required time to get on top of it.
Today we have an additional outline of argument from Mr Barlow which I hear has gone through a couple of drafts. I understand that pursuant to the court’s suggestion last Tuesday, Mr Johnson may have given some hints to Mr Barlow as to what the document would contain. The new one is an improvement on the predecessor
I pause to note that all of the factual assertions [ ] made and those contained in the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Barlow v Queensland Police Service and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2013] QDC 90
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court found that Mr Barlow had failed to provide any evidence at his trial, despite clear advice from the Magistrate that he could not rely on argument as evidence. The court deemed it inappropriate to allow the introduction of evidence in the appeal which was not available at the trial. The court held that the conviction should remain as the prosecution's case was strong and satisfied the criminal onus of proof. However, the court found that the Magistrate did not take into account Mr Barlow's financial circumstances and the burden of the fine when sentencing. Therefore, the appeal against the sentence was allowed, and the fine was vacated. In lieu of the fine, Mr Barlow was ordered to perform 50 hours of community service within 12 months.
The final orders of the court were that the appeal against the conviction was dismissed, and the appeal against the sentence was allowed. Mr Barlow was ordered to perform 50 hours of community service within 12 months, and the fine was vacated. The court also directed the Registrar to send a copy of the order and the reasons to SPER so that the fine imposed previously could be removed.
Background
Background to the litigation
Geoffrey James Barlow has lodged an appeal against his conviction and sentence for possession of tainted property, as determined by a Magistrate on 9 November 2012. The appeal was filed on 8 November 2012, and it concerns both the conviction and the sentence imposed. Barlow was found guilty of receiving tainted property, which included a wallet and its contents such as a driver's licence, credit cards, and a health card. A fine of $750 was imposed, along with an order for costs and witness expenses against Barlow. The appeal was heard on 4 April 2013, initiated by the Registrar due to Barlow's failure to comply with the practice direction requiring the filing of a written outline of argument within a specified time. The Queensland Police Service applied to have the appeal struck out for want of prosecution, but the application was dismissed as Barlow appeared in person. Barlow indicated his desire for the appeal to proceed, consenting to an abridgement of the usual notice period for the appeal hearing. The court received an improved outline of argument from Barlow, who also identified an error in the respondent’s outline which was subsequently corrected. The appeal hinges on the introduction of new evidence not available at the trial, which the court found did not meet the tests for reception, and the adequacy of the Magistrate’s consideration of Barlow’s financial circumstances when imposing the sentence.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the appeal against conviction for possession of tainted property should be dismissed.
2. Whether the Magistrate's decision not to grant an adjournment was appropriate.
3. Whether the Magistrate adequately considered the appellant's financial circumstances when imposing the fine.
4. Whether the imposition of community service orders is appropriate as an alternative to the fine.
5. Whether the court should order the Registrar to send a copy of the order and reasons to SPER to ensure the removal of the previous fine.
Held
1. Whether the appeal against conviction for possession of tainted property should be dismissed.
The court concluded that the appeal against the conviction for possession of tainted property should be dismissed. The appeal was dismissed.
2. Whether the Magistrate's decision not to grant an adjournment was appropriate.
The court concluded that the Magistrate's decision not to grant an adjournment was appropriate. The court found no error in the Magistrate's decision.
3. Whether the Magistrate adequately considered the appellant's financial circumstances when imposing the fine.
The court concluded that the Magistrate did not adequately consider the appellant's financial circumstances when imposing the fine. The appeal against sentence was allowed on this ground.
4. Whether the imposition of community service orders is appropriate as an alternative to the fine.
The court concluded that imposing community service orders as an alternative to the fine was appropriate. The court ordered the appellant to perform 50 hours of community service.
5. Whether the court should order the Registrar to send a copy of the order and reasons to SPER to ensure the removal of the previous fine.
The court concluded that it would be appropriate to order the Registrar to send a copy of the order and reasons to SPER to ensure the removal of the previous fine. The court directed the Registrar to send a copy of the order and reasons to SPER.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In Barlow v Queensland Police Service, the District Court considered an appeal against both conviction and sentence. The primary issue regarding the appeal against conviction was whether it should be dismissed. The court held that the appeal against conviction should indeed be dismissed. The reasoning was based on the appellant's failure to present any evidence at the trial despite the magistrate clearly advising him that he could not rely on argument as evidence. The court held that it was inappropriate to allow the introduction of evidence in the appeal that was not available at the trial. The appellant had an opportunity to give evidence and present factual contentions, but chose not to do so. The court found that the prosecution's case was strong, and the appellant's assertions did not cast any doubt on it. Therefore, the conviction remained valid.
Another significant issue was whether the magistrate's decision not to grant an adjournment was appropriate. The court determined that the magistrate's refusal to grant an adjournment was justified. The appellant had failed to demonstrate any incapacity on the day of the hearing due to medical reasons, and the medical certificate provided was dated after the hearing, thus not supporting his claim of incapacity. The court emphasized the need to bring litigation to an end and noted that granting an adjournment in these circumstances would bring the system into disrepute.
The court also examined whether the magistrate adequately considered the appellant's financial circumstances when imposing the fine. It was found that the magistrate did not consider the appellant's financial situation, as required by section 48 of the Penalties and Sentences Act 1992. Consequently, the court vacated the fine but not the court costs and witness expenses, replacing the fine with a community service order which the appellant had consented to.
The court further deliberated on whether the imposition of community service orders was appropriate as an alternative to the fine. Given the appellant's consent and his previous experience with community service, the court found this alternative to be suitable and ordered the appellant to perform 50 hours of community service within 12 months.
Lastly, the court addressed whether it should order the Registrar to send a copy of the order and reasons to SPER ( presumably a collection agency or enforcement body) to ensure the removal of the previous fine. The court decided to direct the Registrar to send such a copy, facilitating communication with SPER regarding the appeal outcome and the vacating of the fine.
In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case is that an appeal against conviction will be dismissed if the appellant fails to present evidence at trial despite being clearly advised that argument alone is insufficient. Additionally, a magistrate's decision not to grant an adjournment is appropriate if there is no demonstrated incapacity on the day of the hearing, and the court must consider an offender's financial circumstances when imposing a fine. Community service orders can serve as an appropriate alternative to fines, and the court may direct the Registrar to notify relevant enforcement bodies of changes in the penal order to ensure compliance.