BARBER V POLICE
[1999] SASC 384
Magistrate’s Appeal
MARTIN J. (Ex tempore) The appellant was convicted of driving a motor vehicle on Jeffcott Street while there was present in his blood the prescribed concentration of alcohol as defined by section 47A of the Road Traffic Act 1961 (“the Act”) contrary to s 47B of the Act. It was alleged that the concentration of alcohol was .081 grams in 100 millilitres of blood.
The appellant appeals against the conviction on a number of grounds. Primarily he complains that the magistrate erred in admitting the result of the breath analysis and in applying the statutory presumption found in s 47G(1) of the Act. It is also said that the magistrate erred in finding that the procedures referred to in s 47G(1) were complied with and failed to distinguish the case of Johnson v Semple (1988) 8 MVR 217,
At about 4.10 a.m. on Sunday, 21 February 1999, the only prosecution witness, Senior Constable First Grade Birkner, was on duty at a random breath station situated on Jeffcott Street, North Adelaide. The defendant was driving a motor vehicle and was required to drive the vehicle into the breath testing station. He complied with a requirement to submit to a screening test commonly known as an alcotest by blowing into the mouthpiece of a Lyon Alcometer SD-400 of the alcotest. The alcotest was positive. The officer informed the appellant of the positive result and indicated that he would be required to submit to a breath analysis.
During the ensuing conversation, the appellant advised the officer that his last drink had been consumed a few minutes earlier. Due to his experience and knowledge of alcohol in the mouth giving inaccurate alcotest readings, Constable Birkner offered the appellant the opportunity of having a second alcotest 10 minutes later. If the second test had proved negative, Constable Birkner would have allowed the appellant to leave and thus would have avoided unnecessarily inconveniencing the appellant by requiring him to wait and then undergo the breath analysis.
Constable Birkner said in circumstances where he had reason to suspect that the alcotest might be inaccurate, it was his common practice to offer the driver an opportunity to take a second test. This practice was in accordance with police general order 8760. That general order refers to the possibility of the accuracy of screening units being affected by a number of matters, including alcohol in the mouth of the driver, and directs that when a member suspects that an alcotest is inaccurate, unfair or incorrect the member “may require the driver to submit to a second test”.
The appellant accepted the offer and submitted to a second test 10 minutes after the first test. The second test was also positive. Constable Birkner arranged for a breath analysis to occur as soon as practicable. He said the positive result of the first test was the condition precedent that triggered him requiring the appellant to submit to the breath analysis test.
During cross-examination…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Barber v Police No. Scgrg-99-923 Judgment No. S384 and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1999] SASC 384
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court held that the police officer did not require the appellant to submit to a second breath test; instead, he offered the appellant the opportunity to do so. The appellant voluntarily accepted that offer. The court found that the second test was irrelevant and there was no requirement to mention the second test in the certificates prepared pursuant to section 47G(3a) and (3b). Furthermore, there was no requirement to prepare a separate certificate with respect to the second breath test. The court also found that Constable Birkner complied with all relevant procedures and no unlawfulness occurred. The appeal was dismissed.
The court ruled that section 47DA(1) of the Act empowers the police to establish breath testing stations "for the purpose of enabling alcotests to be conducted in relation to persons driving motor vehicles on the road." Subsection (3) enables a member of the police to require a driver to submit to an alcotest at a breath testing station. Section 47DA does not create any offence as a consequence of the positive reading through an alcotest and does not mention breath analysis. That section is to be read with section 47E. Subsection (2b) of section 47E provides that where an alcotest conducted under subsection (2a) indicates that the prescribed concentration of alcohol may be present in the blood of any person, a member of the police force may require that person to submit to a breath analysis. In the circumstances, the court held that there was no requirement to prepare a separate certificate with respect to the second breath test. The appeal was dismissed.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Established by: MARTIN J