Barbeques Galore (Aust) Pty Ltd v Jones Lang LaSalle (SA) Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Appeal from a Master: Civil)

BARBEQUES GALORE (AUST) PTY LTD v JONES LANG LASALLE (SA) PTY LTD

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Besanko

3 February 2006

PROCEDURE - DISCOVERY AND INTERROGATORIES - DISCOVERY AND INSPECTION OF DOCUMENTS - DISCOVERY OF DOCUMENTS - ORDERS FOR FURTHER AND BETTER DISCOVERY

Appeal against two orders for further discovery – appellant brought action against three defendants – appellant and first defendant entered into settlement agreement –appellant seeking to recover losses flowing from settlement agreement from second and third defendants – in challenging appellant’s claim, third defendant sought discovery of two classes of documents – first, appellant’s financial statements and taxation assessments – secondly, non-privileged communications between appellant and first defendant.

Held, dismissing appeal – as to first class of documents, documents relevant to third defendant's allegation that, in assessing damages, any taxation benefit derived by appellant for expenses or outgoings allegedly caused by third defendant's wrongdoing should be taken into account - allegation reasonably arguable – as to second class of documents, documents directly relevant to third defendant’s allegation that settlement agreement between appellant and first defendant not reasonable.

Supreme Court Rules 1987 r 58A.03; Workers Compensation Act 1926 (NSW), referred to.
British Transport Commission v Gourley [1956] AC 185; Pennant Hills Restaurants Pty Ltd v Barrell Insurances Pty Ltd (1980) 145 CLR 625; Milner v Delita Pty Ltd (1985) 9 FCR 299; Neilsen v Hempston Holdings Pty Ltd (1986) 65 ALR 302; Akron Securities Ltd v Iliffe (1997) 41 NSWLR 353; Osric Investments Pty Ltd v Clout (as liquidator of Woburn Downs Pastoral Pty Ltd) [2001] FCA 1402; Williams Aviation Pty Ltd v Santos Ltd (1985) 40 SASR 272; Sands v State of South Australia [2005] SASC 381, considered.

BARBEQUES GALORE (AUST) PTY LTD v JONES LANG LASALLE (SA) PTY LTD
[2006] SASC 31

Appeal from a Master

  1. BESANKO J:        This is an appeal against two orders for further discovery made by a master of this Court.  Barbeques Galore (Australia) Pty Ltd is the appellant.

  2. Under the relevant rule of Court, the appellant was required to discover those documents, which were or had been in its possession, custody or power, which were directly relevant to any issue arising on the pleadings: r 58A.03, Supreme Court Rules 1987.

    Background

  3. The appellant brought an action in this Court against three defendants in relation to a lease of premises which it entered into in 1997.  The appellant’s action was listed for trial to commence on 2 December 2003.  On 3 December 2003, the appellant entered into a settlement agreement with the first defendant under which agreement it was required to pay rent which it alleges was over and above the current fair market value for the premises for a period of five years.  It was also required to pay the first defendant’s legal costs of the action in the sum of $80,000 plus goods and services tax.  The action against the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Barbeques Galore (Aust) Pty Ltd v Jones Lang LaSalle (SA) Pt... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] SASC 31
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal in Barbeques Galore (Aust) Pty Ltd v Jones Lang LaSalle (SA) Pty Ltd concerns two orders for further discovery made in relation to a claim by Barbeques Galore against three defendants regarding a lease of premises. The appellant, Barbeques Galore, initially entered into a settlement agreement with the first defendant, which it now seeks to recover losses from the second and third defendants. The third defendant, Jones Lang LaSalle (SA) Pty Ltd, obtained orders for further discovery and argues the appeal should be dismissed. The legal issues before the court involved the relevance of the documents sought for the respondent's allegations concerning the taxation benefits of the settlement and the reasonableness of the settlement agreement with the first defendant.

The court found that the appellant was required to disclose documents that were or had been in its possession, custody, or power and directly relevant to any issue arising on the pleadings. The court considered the respondent's allegation that the taxation benefit derived by the appellant should be taken into account in assessing damages, deeming this allegation reasonably arguable. The court also found the respondent's allegation that the settlement agreement was not reasonable to be directly relevant to the claim against it. Consequently, the documents sought by the respondent were relevant to these issues. Therefore, the appeal against the orders for further discovery was dismissed.

The court concluded that the appeal should be dismissed, affirming the relevance of the documents sought to the respondent's allegations regarding the taxation benefit and the reasonableness of the settlement agreement. The court's decision underscores the importance of ensuring that discovery orders align with the specific allegations and issues raised in the proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Under the relevant rule of Court, the appellant was required to discover those documents, which were or had been in its possession, custody or power, which were directly relevant to any issue arising on the pleadings: r 58A.03, Supreme Court Rules 1987.Background The appellant brought an action in this Court against three defendants in relation to a lease of premises which it entered into in 1997. The appellant’s action was listed for trial to commence on 2 December 2003. On 3 December 2003, the appellant entered into a settlement agreement with the first defendant under which agreement it was required to pay rent which it alleges was over and above the current fair market value for the premises for a period of five years. It was also required to pay the first defendant’s legal costs of the action in the sum of $80,000 plus goods and services tax. The action against the first defendant has therefore settled, but the appellant now seeks to recover from the second and third defendants the losses flowing from its settlement with the first defendant. Paragraph 52 of the fifth amended statement of claim contains the appellant’s plea of loss and damage and is in the following terms:52.The plaintiff has suffered loss and damage by reason of the conduct complained of in paragraphs 45, 46, 47, 48 and 49 and by reason of the matters set forth in paragraph 51 above.PARTICULARS52.1 the necessity to prosecute the action against the first defendant and its ultimate compromise involved cost to the plaintiff which was caused by the conduct complained of in paragraphs 45, 46, 47, 48 and 49 above namely: The second defendant has taken no part in the hearing of the appeal. The third defendant, Jones Lang LaSalle (SA) Pty Ltd, obtained the two orders for further discovery and it submits that the appeal should be dismissed. I will refer to the third defendant as the respondent. The respondent submits that the further discovery is relevant to two allegations it raises in relation to the appellant’s claim for loss and damage. First, it submits that, assuming for present purposes that liability is established, the additional rent, although an expense or outgoing for the appellant, is an allowable tax deduction and has or will give rise to a taxation benefit for the appellant, and that this should be taken into account in the assessment of the appellant’s damages. It therefore seeks the discovery of the appellant’s financial statements and taxation assessments for the period 3 December 2003 to date. Secondly, the respondent alleges that the action by the appellant against the first defendant was doomed to fail and should not have been brought, or, at least, should have been settled earlier. The respondent further alleges that the settlement agreement between the appellant and the first defendant, insofar as it involved the payment of the first defendant’s legal costs, was not reasonable, and it challenges the appellant’s claim against it for such costs. It therefore seeks discovery of the documents which passed between the appellant and the first defendant in relation to the action, because these will be relevant to establishing the quantum of the first defendant’s legal costs and when they were incurred.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The appellant’s challenge to the second order is rejected.Conclusion In my opinion, the appeal should be dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established