Banwell v Attorney-General (Qld)

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Banwell v Attorney-General (Qld) [2020] QSC 239

PARTIES:

FIONA BANWELL AS ADMINISTRATOR OF THE ESTATE OF MARIE ALICE CRUICE

(applicant)

v
ATTORNEY-GENERAL FOR THE STATE OF QUEENSLAND

(respondent)

FILE NO/S:

BS No 5383 of 2019

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:


Supreme Court at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

13 August 2020

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

Heard on the papers

JUDGE:

Bradley J

ORDER:

The Order of the Court is that:

1.   The Court declares that, on the proper construction of the will of Marie Alice Cruice dated 13 July 2012 (the “Will”), each of the gifts referred to in paragraphs 3(b)(i), (ii), (iii), (vi) and (vii) is a gift of general charitable intention.

2.   The Court directs that:

(a)   The applicant pay the gift referred to in paragraph 3(b)(i) of the Will to the National Heart Foundation of Australia ABN 98 008 419 761, to be applied for research in this foundation;

(b)  The applicant pay the gift referred to in paragraph 3(b)(ii) of the Will to Metro South Hospital and Health Service ABN 86 834 068 616, for the benefit of the Princess Alexandra Hospital’s fund for research purposes;

(c)   The applicant pay the gift referred to in paragraph 3(b)(iii) of the Will to St Vincent’s Private Hospitals Ltd ABN 61 083 645 505, for such purposes as may be determined by its Chief Executive Officer;

(d)  The applicant pay the gift referred to in paragraph 3(b)(iv) of the Will to Yourtown ACN 102 379 386, for such purposes as may be determined by its Chairman or Board;

(e)   The applicant pay the gift referred to in paragraph 3(b)(v) of the Will to The Council of the Queensland Institute of Medical Research ABN 31 411 813 344, for research purposes;

(f)    The applicant pay the gift referred to in paragraph 3(b)(vi) of the Will to the Caboolture local ambulance committee (the “Committee”) or, failing that, to the State on trust for the Committee, for such purposes as may be determined by the Committee;

(g)   The applicant pay the gift referred to in paragraph 3(b)(vii) of the Will to Metro North Hospital and Health Service ABN 18 496 277 942, for the benefit of Caboolture Hospital, for such purposes as may be determined by its Chairman or Board; and

(h)  The applicant pay the gift referred to in paragraph 3(b)(viii) of the Will to Cancer Council Queensland ACN 009 784 356, for research purposes.

3.   The applicant’s costs of the proceeding be paid out of the estate of Marie Alice Cruise on an indemnity basis.

CATCHWORDS:

SUCCESSION – CONSTRUCTION AND EFFECT OF TESTAMENTARY DISPOSITIONS – TESTAMENTARY DISPOSITIONS GENERALLY – LAPSE – where a deceased left gifts in her Will to eight “charitable organisations” – where each of the donees was either misdescribed, never existed as a legal entity or is now known by a different name than that used by the deceased in her Will – whether each of the donees was in existence…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Banwell v Attorney-General (Qld) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] QSC 239
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Banwell v Attorney-General (Qld), the Court was tasked with determining the validity and beneficiaries of specific charitable bequests made in the Will of the deceased, Marie Alice Cruice, who passed away on 8 January 2015. The applicant, acting as the administrator of the estate, sought guidance on the proper allocation of the estate's residue, which the deceased had bequeathed equally to various charitable organisations. The key issue was whether the named charities existed at the time of the deceased's death or had changed their names, as this would affect the enforceability of the bequests. The Court's role was to interpret the Will in a manner that best reflects the deceased's intentions, considering the context and purpose of the Will.

The legal issues before the Court revolved around the interpretation of the Will's language and the applicability of the lapse rule to charitable bequests. The Court had to determine if the charitable gifts lapsed because the named organisations either did not exist, were misdescribed, or had changed their names. The Court also considered whether the general charitable intention of the bequests could be upheld despite the changes in the named organisations. The Court applied principles of construction to ascertain the deceased's intention, taking into account the objective aim of the Will and the circumstances surrounding its creation.

The Court concluded that several of the named charitable organisations did not exist at the time of the deceased's death or had changed their names. However, the Court found that the gifts were of general charitable intention, allowing for the identification of suitable alternative beneficiaries. The Court directed the applicant to distribute the bequests to the appropriate modern entities that align with the original charitable purposes intended by the deceased. The Court's decision ensured that the charitable intentions of the deceased were fulfilled as closely as possible, despite the changes in the named organisations.

The final orders of the Court were that certain gifts were to be treated as gifts of general charitable intention, and specific modern entities were designated to receive the bequests. The Court provided detailed directions on the distribution of the estate to ensure the charitable purposes were met. Additionally, the Court ordered that the applicant's costs of the proceeding be paid from the estate on an indemnity basis.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Order of the Court is that:

1. The Court declares that, on the proper construction of the will of Marie Alice Cruice dated 13 July 2012 (the “Will”), each of the gifts referred to in paragraphs 3(b)(i), (ii), (iii), (vi) and (vii) is a gift of general charitable intention.

2. The Court directs that:

(a) The applicant pay the gift referred to in paragraph 3(b)(i) of the Will to the National Heart Foundation of Australia ABN 98 008 419 761, to be applied for research in this foundation;

(b) The applicant pay the gift referred to in paragraph 3(b)(ii) of the Will to Metro South Hospital and Health Service ABN 86 834 068 616, for the benefit of the Princess Alexandra Hospital’s fund for research purposes;

(c) The applicant pay the gift referred to in paragraph 3(b)(iii) of the Will to St Vincent’s Private Hospitals Ltd ABN 61 083 645 505, for such purposes as may be determined by its Chief Executive Officer;

(d) The applicant pay the gift referred to in paragraph 3(b)(iv) of the Will to Yourtown ACN 102 379 386, for such purposes as may be determined by its Chairman or Board;

(e) The applicant pay the gift referred to in paragraph 3(b)(v) of the Will to The Council of the Queensland Institute of Medical Research ABN 31 411 813 344, for research purposes;

(f) The applicant pay the gift referred to in paragraph 3(b)(vi) of the Will to the Caboolture local ambulance committee (the “Committee”) or, failing that, to the State on trust for the Committee, for such purposes as may be determined by the Committee;

(g) The applicant pay the gift referred to in paragraph 3(b)(vii) of the Will to Metro North Hospital and Health Service ABN 18 496 277 942, for the benefit of Caboolture Hospital, for such purposes as may be determined by its Chairman or Board; and

(h) The applicant pay the gift referred to in paragraph 3(b)(viii) of the Will to Cancer Council Queensland ACN 009 784 356, for research purposes.

3. The applicant’s costs of the proceeding be paid out of the estate of Marie Alice Cruise on an indemnity basis.

Background

Background to the litigation

The respondent has specific statutory powers to enforce charitable trusts.[1] She also has common law rights, including the general supervision of charitable trusts and enforcement of charitable gifts.[2][1]Attorney-General Act 1999 (Qld), s 7(e); Trusts Act 1973 (Qld), s 106(2)(a). [2]Attorney-General Act 1999 (Qld), s 8; Re Royal Society’s Charitable Trusts [1956] 1 Ch 87 at 91-93 (Vaisey J).Background The deceased died on 8 January 2015. The deceased’s husband and son predeceased her. A grant of letters of administration with the Will was issued to the applicant by the Court on 28 September 2018. The applicant has largely completed the administration of the deceased’s estate and is contemplating making an interim distribution to the beneficiaries. The net value of the estate is approximately $450,000. These funds are currently invested in the trust account of the solicitors for the applicant. By clause 3 of the Will, the deceased relevantly provided:“I GIVE DEVISE AND BEQUEATH the whole of my estate both real and personal whatsoever and wheresoever situate or over which I may have power of appointment disposition or control to my trustees upon the following trusts:- (a)…(b)to give the rest and residue of my estate equally between the following various charitable organisations:-(i)to the National Heart Foundation to be applied for research in this foundation;(ii)to the Princess Alexandra Hospital for research purposes;(iii)to Mount Olivet Hospital in Brisbane for such purposes as may be determined by the Chairman and/or Board of that Hospital;(iv)to Boystown at Beaudesert for such purposes as may be determined by the Chairman and/or the Board;(v)to Queensland Institute of Medical Research for research purposes;(vi)to Caboolture Ambulance, King Street, Caboolture for such purposes as may be determined by the Chairman, Manager and/or Board;(vii)to Caboolture Hospital for such purposes as may be determined by the Chairman and/or Board of the Hospital;(viii)to The Queensland Cancer Fund for the purposes of research.” It appears that some of the named “various charitable organisations” were not legal entities in existence at the date of the deceased’s death and the others had changed their names before or after the Will was executed or the death of the deceased. The ultimate purpose of the originating application is to provide directions to the applicant about the manner and extent to which she should give effect to the clause 3(b) gifts. The Court’s duty is to ascertain and give effect to the testamentary wishes of the deceased. Those wishes are expressed in the language of the Will. Ascertaining them is an exercise in construction.[3] The words in the Will must be interpreted by reference to the meaning they would convey to a reasonable person, having regard to the circumstances surrounding the Will, including the genesis of the Will and its objective aim. [3]Re Broadbent; Imperial Cancer Research Fund v Bradley [2001] EWCA Civ 714 at [20] (Mummery LJ).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.