Bannerhey Pty Ltd v 1800 000 000 Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 80 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Bannerhey Pty Ltd v 1800 000 000 Pty Ltd [2008] FCA 53

TRADE PRACTICES – Misleading or deceptive conduct – representations alleged to be made in relation to sale of master licences to use and to licence others the use of a telephone number and relevant know-how including ‘business systems’, ‘business models’ and ‘business plans’ – state of knowledge of the purchasers – reliance by purchasers on representations found to be made - Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) ss 52, 75B

Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) ss 52, 75B
Fair Trading Act (Vic) 1999
Fair Trading Act (Qld) 1989
Fair Trading Act (NSW) 1987 

Steutel v Kimple Pty Ltd [2005] VSCA 312 cited

BANNERHEY PTY LTD and ENGLERT NOMINEES PTY LTD v 1800 000 000 PTY LIMITED, ANTONY JACOBSON and ANDREW JACOBSON; 1800 000 000 PTY LIMITED, ANTONY JACOBSON and ANDREW JACOBSON v BANNERHEY PTY LTD, TERENCE GREGORY GRETTON and JESSICA JANE GRETTON
NSD 544 OF 2003

DAVID JOHN HORTON and PEGGY-ANN HORTON v 1800 000 000 PTY LIMITED, ANTONY JACOBSON and ANDREW JACOBSON; 1800 000 000 PTY LIMITED, ANTONY JACOBSON and ANDREW JACOBSON v DAVID JOHN HORTON and PEGGY-ANN HORTON

NSD 545 OF 2003

EDMONDS J
8 FEBRUARY 2008
SYDNEY


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

NSD 544 OF 2003

BETWEEN:

BANNERHEY PTY LTD
First Applicant

ENGLERT NOMINEES PTY LTD
Second Applicant

AND:

AND BETWEEN:

AND:

1800 000 000 PTY LIMITED
First Respondent

ANTONY JACOBSON
Second Respondent

ANDREW JACOBSON
Third Respondent

1800 000 000 PTY LIMITED
First Cross-Claimant

ANTONY JACOBSON
Second Cross-Claimant

ANDREW JACOBSON
Third Cross-Claimant

BANNERHEY PTY LTD
First Cross-Respondent

TERENCE GREGORY GRETTON
Second Cross-Respondent

JESSICA JANE GRETTON
Third Cross-Respondent

JUDGE:

EDMONDS J

DATE OF ORDER:

8 FEBRUARY 2008

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The application be dismissed.

2.The applicants pay the respondents’ costs.

3.The respondents’ cross-claim be dismissed.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

NSD 545 OF 2003

BETWEEN:

DAVID JOHN HORTON
First Applicant

PEGGY-ANN HORTON
Second Applicant

AND:

AND BETWEEN:

AND:

1800 000 000 PTY LIMITED
First Respondent

ANTONY JACOBSON
Second Respondent

ANDREW JACOBSON
Third Respondent

1800 000 000 PTY LIMITED
First Cross-Claimant

ANTONY JACOBSON
Second Cross-Claimant

ANDREW JACOBSON
Third Cross-Claimant

DAVID JOHN HORTON
First Cross-Respondent

PEGGY-ANN HORTON
Second Cross-Respondent

JUDGE:

EDMONDS J

DATE OF ORDER:

8 FEBRUARY 2008

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The application be dismissed.

2.The applicants pay the respondents’ costs.

3.The respondents’ cross-claim be dismissed.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

NSD 544 OF 2003

BETWEEN:

BANNERHEY PTY LTD
First Applicant

ENGLERT NOMINEES PTY LTD
Second Applicant

AND:

AND BETWEEN:

AND:

1800 000 000 PTY LIMITED
First Respondent

ANTONY JACOBSON
Second Respondent

ANDREW JACOBSON
Third Respondent

1800 000 000 PTY LIMITED
First Cross-Claimant

ANTONY JACOBSON

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bannerhey Pty Ltd v 1800 000 000 Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] FCA 53
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Bannerhey Pty Ltd and 1800 000 000 Pty Ltd were involved in a legal dispute, with Bannerhey alleging that 1800 000 000 had engaged in misleading and deceptive conduct. The case revolved around the interpretation and reliance on various representations made during negotiations and the signing of a Master Licence Agreement. The central issue was whether Bannerhey had been misled by specific representations concerning the existence of a business system or model that 1800 000 000 promised would be provided to facilitate the promotion and marketing of the telephone number 1800 000 000. The court had to determine the credibility of the witnesses, particularly Mr Gretton from Bannerhey, and whether Bannerhey had indeed relied on the alleged misleading representations in entering into the agreement.

The court meticulously evaluated the evidence, noting the poor recall of Mr Gretton regarding the specifics of the communications with 1800 000 000. It found that many of the alleged representations were either not made or not as claimed. The concept of a unique business system was considered elusive, with no concrete evidence to support its existence at the time of the agreement. The court was particularly critical of the applicants' reliance on vague and unsubstantiated claims, finding that their claims lacked a solid foundation in the evidence presented. Ultimately, the court concluded that the applicants entered into the agreement based on their own assessments and the potential of the telephone number, not on any misleading conduct by 1800 000 000.

The court dismissed the application, finding no basis for the claims made by Bannerhey. It ordered that Bannerhey pay the costs of the proceedings and dismissed the cross-claim made by 1800 000 000. The decision underscored the importance of clear and substantiated evidence in proving allegations of misleading and deceptive conduct, highlighting the court's reluctance to rely on vague and unsubstantiated claims.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application be dismissed.

2. The applicants pay the respondents’ costs.

3. The respondents’ cross-claim be dismissed.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In both proceedings, the Unique Business System Representation was effectively admitted but in the case of all other alleged representations, the vast majority were totally denied. There is thus a preliminary issue as to whether the representations were made and because they are, in nearly every case, said to have been made orally, this inevitably raises issues of credit.THE EVIDENCE At the commencement of the hearing I directed that all evidence in chief of what was said by the Grettons on the one hand and the Jacobsons on the other up to and including the Bannerhey completion meeting on 2 August 2001 and all evidence of what was said by the Hortons on the one hand and the Jacobsons on the other up to and including the Horton completion meeting on 1 August 2001 should be adduced orally. Counsel for Bannerhey indicated some surprise at this, however, I had, at an earlier directions hearing, indicated that was what I proposed to do. Moreover, in the interests of efficiency in cross-examination of witnesses called on behalf of the applicants, all parties agreed that in the Bannerhey matter, as between the Grettons, Mr Gretton was the principal negotiator/decision-maker and that in the Horton matter, as between the Hortons, Mr Horton was the principal negotiator/decision-maker.On behalf of Bannerhey The principal witness called on behalf of Bannerhey was Mr Gretton. Mr Gretton swore four affidavits:(1)Affidavit sworn 9 June 2004 – Ex. 1(2)Affidavit sworn 11 March 2005 – Ex. 3(3)Affidavit sworn 7 June 2005 – Ex. 4(4)Affidavit sworn 19 October 2005 – Ex. 9 I was not impressed with Mr Gretton as a witness. In his evidence in chief, his recall of what he said to the Jacobsons and what each of them said to him at the meetings and telephone conversations they had prior to the signing of the Bannerhey Master Licence Agreement was extremely poor; indeed, in some cases, it was non-existent. He even had difficulty in recalling the subjects discussed during some of the meetings. Moreover, as indicated at [84] below, there is one aspect of his evidence in chief I cannot accept. His evidence in cross-examination was not much better although he was able to deny or confirm that certain things were said to him or by him during the course of these meetings and telephone conversations. On the other hand, I formed the impression that some of his responses were evasive in the sense of concealing more than they disclosed. This was particularly so when he was cross-examined on subjects where an unqualified or forthright response may not have been in his interests. The alleged lack or absence of a business system or model which Bannerhey could work with in promoting sales of sub-licences seemed to permeate the totality of Mr Gretton’s evidence and was at the forefront of his complaint that Bannerhey had been misled in representations made by the Jacobsons on behalf of 1800. I found this whole concept of a business system or model to be elusive. It was never explored with Mr Gretton in chief with the consequence that it was not possible to draw any conclusion as to, or articulate, what exactly it was that was represented to be forthcoming but was not. At one level it was nothing more than the ideas and concepts that the Jacobsons had in mind as to how the telephone number 1800 000 000 might best be promoted and marketed to maximise returns. At this first level, the system or model not only existed, but its structure and content were largely conveyed to Bannerhey via Mr Gretton prior to the signing of the Bannerhey Master Licence Agreement. At another level, it was the manifestation of those ideas and concepts in a material form which could be utilised as promotional and marketing tools – to assist State licensees, such as Bannerhey, in their selling enterprises. At this second level, they did not exist at the time of the signing of the Bannerhey Master Licence Agreement although they did by early 2002. The elusive nature or character of the system or model stemmed from the impression drawn from Mr Gretton’s evidence that a system was represented to exist, but was not forthcoming, at a higher level, although this higher level was never articulated. I deal with these different levels below.

Decision

Reasons for decision

EDMONDS J
The representation in (d) is not supported by any evidence; it fell, presumably, within Mr Horton’s ‘fading memory bank’, but in any event its character and standing is no different from the representation alleged in (c) of the 4 July Representations as to which see [166] above.OVERALL CONCLUSIONS After considerable deliberation which has taken too long, principally because I allowed the parties too much latitude in the submissions they made, both in terms of the time I allowed them and their sheer volume – the applicants filed 290 pages of submissions and the respondents 97 pages – I have come to the conclusion without any real doubt and notwithstanding the time my deliberation has taken, that the applicants’ claims in both proceedings by reference to their respective pleadings and the evidence adduced, or rather not adduced, in support of those pleadings, have no foundation. Moreover, pleadings aside, during the course of hearing the evidence I formed a view, a view which despite having heard oral, and having read voluminous written, submissions, I have not been able to dispel, that the applicants in both proceedings entered into their respective Master Licence Agreements not in reliance on misleading and deceptive conduct on the part of the respondents, but in reliance on their attraction to the telephone number and their respective perceptions, based on their successful experiences in franchise operations, of its potential to make money. There is no doubt that their attraction and interest in this regard was fostered and promoted, indeed flamed, by the enthusiasm of the respondents for the number and the underlying concepts and ideas the respondents had in mind for its exploitation, in particular the unit sub-licensing system. But it was only when the applicants in both proceedings realised that that potentiality was as ‘dead as a doornail’, to use the words of Mr Gretton, that they formed the view they had been misled and deceived. Prior to that time they were ready, willing and able to sell ‘the product’ into the market in respect of which their monopoly existed, and attempted to do so. I have no doubt that the respondents, if not both of them, then certainly Mr Antony Jacobson, through his enthusiasm for ‘the product’ and his belief in what he perceived to be its inevitable success made boasts in relation to its potentiality which went beyond the truth. But I also believe that the applicants in both proceedings recognised these boasts for what they were and did not rely on them for that reason or because they knew them to be false. The unique business system representation illustrates the point, as the respondents concede in their written submissions: ‘There is no question that the initial advertisements and discrete statements contained in 1800 000 000’s website (and Franchise Services Business Plan) were untrue to the extent they asserted that 1800 was a fast growing business’. The evidence establishes that at the time the Master Licence Agreements were executed both applicants knew that this was not so and hence cannot be held to have been deceived.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: EDMONDS J