Balintad and Australian Skills Quality Authority (Practice and procedure)

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

Balintad and Australian Skills Quality Authority (Practice and procedure) [2025] ARTA 1209 (4 August 2025)

Applicant/s:  Claire Ann Balintad

Respondent:  Australian Skills Quality Authority

Tribunal Number:                2025/2574

Tribunal:General Member R Smith  

Place:Adelaide

Date: 4 August 2025  

Decision:The application for a stay of the decision is refused

..........................[SGND]...............................

General Member R Smith

Catchwords

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application to stay decision – decision to cancel qualifications obtained from a deregistered training organisation – whether desirable for the purpose of ensuring the effectiveness of the review – consideration of factors – prospects of success – consequences to the applicant – public interest – application refused

Legislation

Administrative Review Tribunal Act 2024 (Cth) s32
National Vocational Education and Training Regulator Act 2011 (Cth) ss 56, 57,58

Cases

Bayahow and Australian Skills Quality Authority [2025] ARTA 176
Ekeh and Australian Skills Quality Authority [2025] ARTA 265
Elmi and Australian Skills Quality Authority (Guidance and Appeals Panel) [2025] ARTA 192
McNamara v Secretary, Department of Social Services [2016] AATA 189 at [12] 
Panganiban and Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2016] AATA 703
Poidevin and Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2009] AATA 798
Rozzario and Australian Skills Quality Authority [2025] ARTA 241
Scott v Australian and Securities and Investments Commission [2009] AATA 798
Shi v Migration Agents Registration Authority [2008] HCA 31

Statement of Reasons

  1. Ms Balintad (also referred to as the Applicant) was issued with a Certificate III in Individual Support (CHC33015) (the Qualification) by Gills College Pty Ltd (Gills College) in October 2023. At the time, Gills College was a registered vocational and training (VET) provider under the National Vocational Education and Training Regulator Act 2011 (Cth) (the NVR Act).

  2. In November 2024, the Australian Skills Quality Agency (ASQA or the Respondent) decided to cancel Gills College’s registration as a VET provider under sections 36(2)(f) and 39 of the NVR Act. In making the cancellation decision, the Respondent was satisfied that Gills College was critically non-compliant with its registration obligations and did not provide the training and assessment necessary to ensure students had the skills and knowledge required to be awarded VET qualifications or statements of attainment.

  3. On 26 November 2024, the Respondent wrote to Ms Balintad to notify her that it intended to cancel the Qualification issued to her by Gills College. That notice also invited her to provide a written response to ASQA within 7 days. Ms Balintad did not provide a response to the notice.

  4. On 13 December 2025, the Respondent decided to cancel the Applicant’s Qualification pursuant to section 58(1) of the NVR Act (the Reviewable Decision), to take effect on 20 December 2025. The decision was based on the findings in respect of Gills College, which ASQA says were evident during the period in which she undertook her training.

  5. On 17 March 2025, the Applicant applied to the Tribunal for a review of the Reviewable Decision together with an application seeking a stay of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Balintad and Australian Skills Quality Authority (Practice a... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] ARTA 1209
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Balintad v Australian Skills Quality Authority, the applicant, Ms Balintad, sought a stay of a decision to cancel her qualifications obtained from a deregistered training organisation. The dispute was heard and determined by the Administrative Review Tribunal. The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether it was desirable to stay the decision to cancel Ms Balintad's qualifications for the purpose of ensuring the effectiveness of the review.

The Tribunal considered several factors in reaching its decision, including the prospects of success on the merits of Ms Balintad's application, the consequences to her should the stay not be granted, and the public interest. Ms Balintad argued that she had a reasonable chance of success on the merits of her application, as the cancellation did not arise from any non-compliance or misconduct on her part. She also highlighted the potential consequences to her employment, financial situation, and family if the decision were not stayed. The Tribunal noted that while it was not appropriate to undertake a full consideration of the merits of the substantive application at the stay stage, it must be persuaded that there was sufficient evidence to call into question the merits of the decision. In this case, the Tribunal was not persuaded that Ms Balintad had established such a case.

Ultimately, the Tribunal refused the application for a stay, finding that it was not desirable to do so for the purpose of ensuring the effectiveness of the review. The Tribunal considered that the consequences to Ms Balintad and her family were not so significant as to outweigh the public interest in upholding the decision to cancel the qualifications obtained from a deregistered training organisation. The Tribunal also noted that the application for review would not be rendered nugatory if a stay were not granted.

The Tribunal emphasised that the decision to grant a stay was discretionary and that it must consider the interests of all parties, including the public interest. In this case, the Tribunal found that the public interest in upholding the decision to cancel the qualifications outweighed the potential consequences to Ms Balintad and her family. The Tribunal also noted that the evidence before it was incomplete and untested, and that it was not appropriate to undertake a full consideration of the merits of the substantive application at the stay stage. The Tribunal did not make any final orders in relation to the substantive application for review.

Background

Background to the litigation

Ms Balintad, an employee of Southern Cross Care in an aged care facility, had her qualifications cancelled by the Australian Skills Quality Authority (ASQA). This cancellation led to a change in her duties, precluding her from administering medication and participating in advanced training courses. Southern Cross Care confirmed that if Ms Balintad's review is unsuccessful, her pay rate would be reduced and backdated to the cancellation decision, although her employment is not at risk. Ms Balintad is currently studying a Diploma of Community Services and is concerned that a reduction in her income may prevent her from completing her studies. She is married with a young child and relies on her income, which would be adversely affected by the pay reduction. The cancellation of her qualification does not stem from any non-compliance or misconduct on her part, as she has complied with all course requirements.

Ms Balintad applied for a stay of the decision to cancel her qualifications pending the outcome of her review by the Administrative Review Tribunal (ART). The Tribunal considered the application, taking into account the material provided by Ms Balintad, including her statement, oral evidence, Tribunal documents, and submissions from the Respondent. The Tribunal assessed the application based on the discretion granted under the Administrative Review Tribunal Act 2024 (Cth) to stay the implementation of a decision if it is desirable for ensuring the effectiveness of the review.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

While no party has a specific onus of proof, it is generally accepted that it is the Applicant who will need to provide the Tribunal with sufficient evidentiary material to ensure the discretion is exercised in accordance with the law.[9][9] McNamara v Secretary, Department of Social Services [2016] AATA 189 at [12] EVIDENCE AND SUBMISSIONS BEFORE THE TRIBUNAL The Tribunal had the benefit of the following material in respect of the stay application:·A statement and some supporting documents provided by Ms Balintad dated 3 July 2025;·The oral evidence given by Ms Balintad at the stay hearing;·The Tribunal documents;·Written submissions filed on behalf of the Respondent. In her statement and oral evidence, Ms Balintad deposed that:(a)she is currently employed with Southern Cross Care (Southern Cross) in an aged care facility. She has worked for this employer for approximately two years;(b)her employer is aware of the cancellation decision. Although there is no immediate risk to her employment, there has been a change in the scope of her day-to-day duties. For example, she is no longer able to administer medication and she has been precluded from participating in advanced training courses;(c)Southern Cross has confirmed to Ms Balintad that should she be unsuccessful in this review, her hourly pay rate will be reduced. The change in pay will also be backdated to the cancellation decision and she will be required to repay any overpayment. She is not, however, at risk of losing her employment;(d)Ms Balintad is currently studying a Diploma of Community Services with the Australian Health and Science Institute. She has not advised them of the cancellation decision. She is concerned that a reduction in her income may mean she can no longer afford to complete the Diploma;(e)Ms Balintad is married with a 17-month-old son. Her husband works as a repair technician. They are currently renting and in addition to the normal household bills and expenses, the Applicant has tuition fees associated with the Diploma of Community Services. The family relies upon her income and they will be disadvantaged should her hourly rate be reduced;(f)the cancellation of the Qualification does not arise from any non-compliance or misconduct on her part. She says she has complied with all course requirements including assignments, external certifications and a placement. She could not recall if the Qualification was obtained through a recognition of prior learning but did say that she provided a copy of her Bachelor of Nursing, which she obtained overseas, to Gills College. CONSIDERATION OF ISSUES Prospects of success The Tribunal acknowledges that in considering whether to grant a stay, it is not appropriate to undertake a full consideration of the merits of the substantive application, especially in circumstances where there are a number of factual matters in dispute and the evidence before the Tribunal is untested. The Tribunal must arrive at its opinion on the basis of the material before it at the time of the stay hearing, some of which may not have been before the original decision-maker at the time when the reviewable decision was made.[10] In circumstances where the stay is being considered at a very early stage in the review process, it follows that some caution should be exercised by the Tribunal given the incomplete body of relevant evidence.[11] The Tribunal need only be persuaded that the Applicant has established there is sufficient evidence to call into question the merits of ASQA’s Decisions.[10] Shi v Migration Agents Registration Authority [2008] HCA 31 at [37]. [11] Bayahow and Australian Skills Quality Authority [2025] ARTA 176 at [36]

Decision

Reasons for decision

If, after receiving a response, the National VET Regulator still considers that the VET qualification should be cancelled, they must cancel the qualification. Reasonable steps must be taken to give the person concerned notice of the decision and the requirement to return the qualification.[2][2] s 58 of the National Vocational Education and Training Regulator Act 2011 (Cth)STAYING DECISIONS The general rule is that making an application to the Tribunal seeking a review of a decision, does not affect the operation of the decision.[3] There is no automatic right to a stay and the Tribunal will only make an order staying or otherwise affecting the implementation of the decision if the Tribunal considers that it is desirable to do so for the purpose of ensuring the effectiveness of the review.[4] A stay order can be subject to conditions[5] and usually has effect until the decision of the Tribunal on the application for review comes into operation.[6][3] s 32(1) of the Administrative Review Tribunal Act 2024 (Cth) (the ART Act) [4] s 32(2) of the ART Act.[5] s 32(3) of the ART Act [6] s 32(4) of the ART Act Section 32(7) of the ART Act provides that the Tribunal must not make an order staying the decision unless the Tribunal has given the parties to the proceeding a reasonable opportunity to make submissions to the Tribunal. Further, in determining whether to grant a stay, the Tribunal should not limit its enquiry to the interests of the Applicant. Section 32(7)(b) of the ART Act prescribes that the Tribunal must consider the interests of any person who may be affected by the review of the decision. In weighing the potential competing interests, the Tribunal should have regard to the objects of the statutory scheme under which the reviewable decision was made. It is generally accepted that the determinative criterion for the exercise of the Tribunal stay power, being to secure the effectiveness of the review, is not subject to an exhaustive list of permissibly relevant considerations.[7] There are, however, a number of key factors that have been identified in the case law,[8] which can be summarized as follows:·the prospects of success;·the consequences to the Applicant;·the public interest;·the consequences for the Respondent in carrying out its functions depending on whether a stay is granted or not;·whether the application for review would be rendered nugatory if a stay were not granted; and·any other relevant matter.[7] Panganiban and Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2016] AATA 703 at [7][8] The cases frequently cited being Re Scott and Australian Securities and Investments Commission (2009) 51 AAR 114 and Poidevin and Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2009] AATA 798. While no party has a specific onus of proof, it is generally accepted that it is the Applicant who will need to provide the Tribunal with sufficient evidentiary material to ensure the discretion is exercised in accordance with the law.[9][9] McNamara v Secretary, Department of Social Services [2016] AATA 189 at [12] EVIDENCE AND SUBMISSIONS BEFORE THE TRIBUNAL

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Tribunal considered the application to stay the decision to cancel Ms Balintad's qualifications. It acknowledged that the stay power is not an automatic right and is granted only if it is desirable for ensuring the effectiveness of the review. The Tribunal outlined the key factors it should consider in deciding whether to grant a stay, including the prospects of success, the consequences to the Applicant, and the public interest. It noted that the Applicant needed to provide sufficient evidentiary material to support the stay application. In assessing the prospects of success, the Tribunal recognised that it should not undertake a full consideration of the merits of the substantive application at this stage. Instead, it needed to be persuaded that there is sufficient evidence to call into question the merits of ASQA’s decision. The Tribunal examined the evidence provided by Ms Balintad, which included her current employment situation, her studies, and her family circumstances. It also considered the consequences of the cancellation decision on her employment and financial situation. However, the Tribunal concluded that Ms Balintad had not established sufficient evidence to call into question the merits of ASQA’s decision. Therefore, the application for a stay was refused. The court followed the legal principles established in previous cases, including Shi v Migration Agents Registration Authority and Bayahow and Australian Skills Quality Authority. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that a stay of a decision to cancel qualifications will not be granted unless the Applicant can demonstrate sufficient evidence to call into question the merits of the decision, taking into account the key factors identified in the case law.