Bale-Sutch and Bale-Sutch (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

BALE-SUTCH & BALE-SUTCH (No 2) [2007] FamCA 590
FAMILY LAW – ORDERS - Mutual contravention applications – Consideration of a spend time order as a mandatory injunction – Finding that a spend time order does not compel the parent entitled to same to take the time and the alleged contravention in that regard was dismissed – Mother found to have contravened parenting order without reasonable excuse on one count – Father found to have contravened parenting order without reasonable excuse on two counts – Costs
Family Law Act 1975
APPLICANT: Mr Bale-Sutch
RESPONDENT: Mrs Bale-Sutch
INDEPENDENT CHILDREN’S LAWYER: McCormack & Co
FILE NUMBER: MLC 3800 of 2007
DATE DELIVERED: 25 May 2007
PLACE DELIVERED: Melbourne
JUDGMENT OF: Bennett J
HEARING DATE: 25 May 2007

REPRESENTATION

COUNSEL FOR THE APPLICANT: Mr A. Scriva
SOLICITOR FOR THE APPLICANT: Mepstead Lawyers
COUNSEL FOR THE RESPONDENT: Ms Mercader
SOLICITOR FOR THE RESPONDENT: Mercader Barristers & Solicitors
INDEPENDENT CHILDREN’S LAWYER COUNSEL: Mr McCormack
INDEPENDENT CHILDREN’S LAWYER SOLICITOR: Mc Cormack & Co

Orders

  1. That I grant leave to the father to withdraw that count of his contravention application filed on 26 February 2007 as relates to the events on 25 February 2007.

  2. That I grant leave to the father to amend his contravention application filed


    26 February 2007 to delete references therein “3 February 2007” and in lieu thereof insert “2 February 2007” wherever that dates appears.

  3. That I am satisfied that the mother contravened paragraph 1(a) of the Orders made on 30 January 2007 by failing to deliver the children, the elder son born … December 1997 and younger son born … February 2000 to the father at L Police station at 6pm on that day and did so without reasonable excuse.

  4. THE COURT BEING SATISFIED that it is in the best interests of the children, the elder son born … December 1997 and younger son born … February 2000 that the mother attend a post separation parenting program comprised of counselling or the teaching of techniques to assist her to resolve problems with the father which would otherwise adversely affect her carrying out her parenting responsibilities, IT IS ORDERED that pursuant to section 70NEB(1)(a) of the Family Law Act 1975, the mother shall within 7 working days of this order make contact with Relationships Australia, […], ( […], the parenting program provider and attend before the provider for an initial assessment of suitability for a post-separation parenting program.  If assessed by the provider as being suitable to attend a program or part of a program and the provider nominates a particular program for the mother, the mother shall attend that program or that part of the program.

  5. I grant leave to the mother to amend her contravention application filed 19 April 2007 by deleting from the first count a reference to “25 February 2007” and inserting in its place “24 February 2007”.

  6. That I dismiss the first count of the mother’s contravention application (as amended).

  7. That I find count…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bale-Sutch and Bale-Sutch (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] FamCA 590
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned competing contravention applications filed by the father and the mother concerning their children. The proceedings were heard by Bennett J in the Family Court of Australia. The father sought to withdraw and amend certain counts of his contravention application, while the mother also sought to amend her contravention application. The core of the dispute involved allegations of breaches of existing parenting orders relating to the delivery and return of the children.

The court was required to determine whether the mother had contravened parenting orders by failing to deliver the children to the father on a specified date without reasonable excuse. Additionally, the court had to consider whether the father had contravened parenting orders by failing to return the children to the mother on two separate occasions. The court also had to decide on appropriate orders and penalties, if any, for any proven contraventions, and to address the parties' applications for interim parenting orders.

Bennett J granted the father leave to withdraw and amend his contravention application. The court found that the mother had contravened parenting orders by failing to deliver the children to the father on 25 February 2007 without reasonable excuse, and ordered her to attend a post-separation parenting program. The mother was granted leave to amend her application, but her first count was dismissed. However, the court found the father had contravened parenting orders on two occasions by failing to return the children to the mother, imposing a fine of $500 for one contravention and ordering him to attend a parenting program. The father was also ordered to contribute $300 towards the mother's costs. Otherwise, the parties' contravention applications were dismissed, and competing interim parenting orders were transferred to the Senior Registrar.

Orders

Orders of the court

1.

That I grant leave to the father to withdraw that count of his contravention application filed on 26 February 2007 as relates to the events on 25 February 2007.

2.

That I grant leave to the father to amend his contravention application filed

26 February 2007 to delete references therein “3 February 2007” and in lieu thereof insert “2 February 2007” wherever that dates appears.

3.

That I am satisfied that the mother contravened paragraph 1(a) of the Orders made on 30 January 2007 by failing to deliver the children, the elder son born … December 1997 and younger son born … February 2000 to the father at L Police station at 6pm on that day and did so without reasonable excuse.

4.

THE COURT BEING SATISFIED that it is in the best interests of the children, the elder son born … December 1997 and younger son born … February 2000 that the mother attend a post separation parenting program comprised of counselling or the teaching of techniques to assist her to resolve problems with the father which would otherwise adversely affect her carrying out her parenting responsibilities, IT IS ORDERED that pursuant to section 70NEB(1)(a) of the Family Law Act 1975, the mother shall within 7 working days of this order make contact with Relationships Australia, […], ( […], the parenting program provider and attend before the provider for an initial assessment of suitability for a post-separation parenting program. If assessed by the provider as being suitable to attend a program or part of a program and the provider nominates a particular program for the mother, the mother shall attend that program or that part of the program.

5.

I grant leave to the mother to amend her contravention application filed 19 April 2007 by deleting from the first count a reference to “25 February 2007” and inserting in its place “24 February 2007”.

6.

That I dismiss the first count of the mother’s contravention application (as amended).

7.

That I find count two of the mother’s contravention application filed 19 April 2007 is proved in that the father failed to comply with paragraphs 4(a) and 5 of the Orders made on 8 March 2007 by failing to return the children to the mother at L Police station at 6pm on 25 March 2007.

8.

IT IS ORDERED that pursuant to section 70NEB(1)(a) of the Family Law Act 1975, the father shall within 7 working days of this order make contact with Relationships Australia, […], ( […], the parenting program provider and attend before the provider for an initial assessment of suitability for a post-separation parenting program. If assessed by the provider as being suitable to attend a program or part of a program and the provider nominates a particular program for the father, the father shall attend that program or that part of the program.

9.

That I am satisfied that count two of the mother’s contravention application filed 19 April 2007 is proved in that the father failed to comply with paragraphs 4(a) and 5 of the Orders made on 8 March 2007 by failing to return the children to the mother at L Police station at 6pm on 8 April 2007.

10.

That by way of penalty for the second contravention, I impose a fine in the sum of $500 and do so pursuant to section 70NFB(2)(d) and grant a stay of 3 months for payment, such payment to be made to the Registry Manager of the Melbourne Registry of the Family Court of Australia.

11.

That the father make a contribution to the wife’s costs of the contravention proceedings fixed in the sum of $300 and similarly with a stay of 3 months so they need not be paid prior to Monday 27 August 2007 and such payment to be paid direct to the mother’s solicitor.

12.

That the contravention application of the father filed 26 February 2007 and the contravention application of the mother filed 19 April 2007 be otherwise dismissed.

13.

I DIRECT that my reasons for judgment this day be transcribed and a copy be sent to each of the parties and the independent children’s lawyer.

14.

That otherwise the competing applications for interim parenting orders be transferred to the Senior Registrar sitting at 2:15pm this day.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.