Balachandran Naidu v Baba Products M Sdn Bhd

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Opposition by Balachandran Naidu to application under section 92 of the Trade Marks Act by Baba Products (M) Sdn. Bhd to remove trade mark number 965173(30) - BABAS - in the name of Balachandran Naidu

Delegate: Rowena Beal
Representation: Opponent: Tracey Berger of Spruson & Ferguson of Sydney
Applicant: Ben Fitzpatrick of Counsel, instructed by Davies Collison Cave of Melbourne.
Decision: 2009 ATMO 21/09
Section 92(4)(a): opponent established use - removal application dismissed - trade mark to remain on register – costs awarded against applicant

Background

  1. Balachandran Naidu (‘Mr Naidu’) is the registered owner of a trade mark, current details of which appear below:

    Trade mark number:  965173

    Registered from:                  7 August 2003

    Goods/services:  Class 30: Preparations for making curry powders, rice, pickles, curry pastes

    Trade mark:      BABAS

  2. On 12 November 2004 Baba Products (M) Sdn. Bhd. (‘Baba Products’) filed an application under section 92(4)(a) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (‘the Act’) for removal of the trade mark from the register.

  3. On 25 February 2005 the opponent (‘Mr Naidu’) filed notice of opposition to the removal, rebutting the grounds claimed in the application.

  4. Paragraphs 100(1)(a) and (b) of the Act places the burden of rebutting the allegations made under paragraph 92(4)(a) in relation to the goods to which the opposed application is made on the opponent.

  5. The matter came before me, as a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks, for hearing in Canberra on 5 December 2008. The opponent was represented by Tracey Berger of Spruson and Ferguson Patent and Trade Mark Attorneys of Sydney, and the applicant was represented by Ben Fitzpatrick of Counsel, instructed by Davies Collison Cave Patent and Trade Mark Attorneys of Melbourne.

  6. I also note that the parties were before me in relation to another matter between them, specifically, an opposition under section 52 of the Act in relation to the registration of 977307 in the name of Baba Products.

    Evidence

  7. The following evidence was filed and served:

    Evidence in Support

    Declaration of Betty Florence Booth, customer, made10 June 2005.
               Declaration of Charles Mohandas, businessman, made 26 August 2005
               Declaration of Balachandran Naidu, opponent, made 1 March 2006

    Evidence in Answer

    Declaration of Pagalavan A/L C. Rangasami with exhibits PAG-1 to PAG-8, director of applicant, made 12 January 2007

    Evidence in Reply

    Declaration of Ravendran S/O Vellasamy, businessman, made 9 July 2007

    Balachandran Naidu with exhibits BN-1 to BN-5, opponent, made 26 July 2007.

  8. The first Naidu declaration sets out the history of the use of the trade mark BABAS. Since the early 1980s Mr Naidu had operated a small family run business specializing in the manufacture and of retail Indian, Asian, South African and Sri Lankan food products. Over the course of many years Mr Naidu’s business moved from retail services of his curry preparations to wholesale services of these goods and the importation of other goods. He attests to the fact…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Balachandran Naidu v Baba Products M Sdn Bhd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] ATMO 21
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter came before the Court concerning an opposition filed by Balachandran Naidu against the registration of trade mark 977307 by Baba Products M Sdn Bhd. Mr Naidu, who had been operating a family business since the early 1980s manufacturing and retailing Indian, Asian, South African, and Sri Lankan food products under the trade mark BABAS, alleged a history of use and expansion of this mark. His business evolved from retail to wholesale and importation, including goods from Malaysia. A key point of contention was a verbal agreement in the early 1990s, following a fire that destroyed his premises, where Mr Naidu began importing and distributing products from Baba Products in Australia, believing this to be an exclusive arrangement.

The central legal issues before the Court were the nature and terms of the business arrangement between Mr Naidu and Baba Products regarding the distribution of Malaysian products in Australia, and whether Mr Naidu had established prior rights or a claim to exclusivity in the Australian market for these goods under the BABAS trade mark. The Court was required to determine the extent of Mr Naidu's use of the BABAS trade mark, particularly in relation to the imported products, and to assess the conflicting accounts of the parties regarding their business relationship and any alleged threats made by Mr Naidu.

The Court considered evidence from both parties, including declarations from Mr Naidu and Mr Rangasami, the director of Baba Products. Mr Naidu asserted that he had imported and distributed Baba Products' goods under a perceived exclusive arrangement for a significant period, while also continuing to produce his own curry powders. He also claimed to have taken steps to assert his rights in the BABAS trade mark upon becoming aware of other distributors. Baba Products, however, contended that Mr Naidu was merely one of several distributors and alleged that Mr Naidu had threatened to register his trade mark to secure sole distribution rights. The Court noted the absence of formal documentation clarifying the agreement, making the interpretation of the verbal arrangement and the parties' conduct crucial to the determination.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

I also note that the parties were before me in relation to another matter between them, specifically, an opposition under section 52 of the Act in relation to the registration of 977307 in the name of Baba Products.Evidence The following evidence was filed and served:Evidence in SupportDeclaration of Betty Florence Booth, customer, made10 June 2005. Declaration of Charles Mohandas, businessman, made 26 August 2005 Declaration of Balachandran Naidu, opponent, made 1 March 2006Evidence in AnswerDeclaration of Pagalavan A/L C. Rangasami with exhibits PAG-1 to PAG-8, director of applicant, made 12 January 2007Evidence in ReplyDeclaration of Ravendran S/O Vellasamy, businessman, made 9 July 2007Balachandran Naidu with exhibits BN-1 to BN-5, opponent, made 26 July 2007. The first Naidu declaration sets out the history of the use of the trade mark BABAS. Since the early 1980s Mr Naidu had operated a small family run business specializing in the manufacture and of retail Indian, Asian, South African and Sri Lankan food products. Over the course of many years Mr Naidu’s business moved from retail services of his curry preparations to wholesale services of these goods and the importation of other goods. He attests to the fact that he expanded the range of goods offered under the trade mark to include goods such as pickles, tapioca chips, black rice flour and snack foods. These goods were sold under the trade mark BABAS. After his business premises were destroyed by fire in 1993 Mr Naidu continued to produce curry powders but now sold them to other wholesalers and retailers rather than retailing them himself. He also wholesaled a range of goods that he imported from other countries, including Malaysia. It was during a visit to that country that Mr Naidu made contact with the owner of the applicant company, Mr Rangasami, and established a business relationship with a verbal agreement to allow the Malaysian products from the early 1990s to be sold in Australia through Mr Naidu. The nature and terms of this business arrangement are contentious between the parties and there is no formal documentation available to clarify matters. Mr Naidu has deposed that he imported the Malaysian products in what he believed was an exclusive arrangement and distributed them to his pre-existing customers for sale. Mr Rangasami has deposed that Mr Naidu became one of a number of distributors for his goods. It is significant that the products of the non use applicant were being marketed in Malaysia under a trade mark containing the words BABA or BABA’S (Rangasami declaration para 13). Mr Naidu declares that from 1993 for a period of eight to ten years he received the Malaysian curry powders from Baba Products and distributed them at wholesale level for others to retail. He also declares that he continued to make and distribute his own curry powders during this time (Naidu 1). In the late 1990s into early 2000s Mr Naidu became aware that Baba Products was distributing its goods through other traders in Australia. Mr Naidu engaged the services of a trade mark attorney to issue letters of demand to these Australian businesses where he asserted his rights in the trade mark. He traveled to Malaysia on five occasions to discuss the agreement with the applicant. Over the course of these meetings between the parties the relationship between them broke down. Baba Products alleges Mr Naidu threatened to register his trade mark unless he was allowed sole distribution in Australia. Mr Naidu has denied that allegation.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.