Bakir v Tran & Body Corporate for Chevron Renaissance

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read
CITATION: Bakir v Tran & Body Corporate for Chevron Renaissance [2015] QCATA 164
PARTIES: Ron Bakir
(Applicant/Appellant)
v
Teo Tran
Body Corporate for Chevron Renaissance CTS 30946 ACN 068 118 347 Pty Ltd
(Respondents)
APPLICATION NUMBER: APL076-15
MATTER TYPE: Appeals
HEARING DATE: 16 & 17 November 2015
HEARD AT: Brisbane
DECISION OF: Senior Member Brown
Member Howard
DELIVERED ON: 17 November 2015
DELIVERED AT: Brisbane
ORDERS MADE:

1.    The appeal is adjourned to a date to be fixed.

2.    Ron Bakir must serve all lot owners who made submissions to the Commissioner for Body Corporate and Community Management with:

a.    A copy of the application for appeal;

b.    Copies of all submissions filed by the parties in these appeal proceedings;

c.    These orders of the Appeal Tribunal; and

d.    A copy of the Appeal Tribunal’s reasons for decision

by posting copies of the documents to the address for the lot owner identified in their submissions to the Commissioner for Body Corporate and Community Management, by:

      4:00pm on 15 December 2015.

3.    Any person served in accordance with direction 3 who wishes to be heard on the appeal must file in the Tribunal and serve upon the named parties to the appeal an application to be joined as a party to the appeal, by:

     4:00pm on 12 January 2016.

4.    Any party wishing to respond to any application to be joined as a party must file a submission in response in the Tribunal and serve upon the party seeking to be joined and the named parties to the appeal, by:

     4:00pm on 25 January 2016.

5.    Any application to be joined as a party to the appeal in accordance with direction 3 will, unless any party or person making an application requests by 25 January 2015 an oral hearing, be determined on the papers and without an oral hearing, not before:

     4:00pm on 25 January 2016.

6.    Ron Bakir will serve upon any party joined in the appeal with all additional material filed in the appeal proceeding and not specifically referred to in these directions including copies of all affidavits within seven (7) days of any decision of the Tribunal joining a party.

7.    Ron Bakir must file in the Tribunal and provide a copy to each named party to the appeal including any joined party submissions in relation to the determination by the Appeals Tribunal of the preliminary issues raised by him, namely whether the appeal is:

a.    An appeal in the strict sense;

b.    An appeal by way of re-hearing;

c.    Whether, to what extent and when fresh evidence may be admitted in the appeal and whether the leave of the Tribunal is required, by:

                4:00pm on 12 February 2016.

8.    The submissions of all other parties in response to the Applicant’s submissions on the determination of the preliminary issues must be filed in the Tribunal and served upon each named party to the appeal, by:

     4:00pm on 26 February 2016.

9.    Ron Bakir must file in the Tribunal…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bakir v Tran & Body Corporate for Chevron Renaissance and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] QCATA 164
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Ron Bakir has appealed against a decision of the Commissioner for Body Corporate and Community Management, which was made in relation to a dispute with the Body Corporate for Chevron Renaissance. The appeal was heard by the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT). The central issue before QCAT was whether certain lot owners, who had submitted to the Commissioner, were required to be notified of the application for appeal and, if so, by whom and when. This matter hinged on the interpretation of relevant statutory provisions and case law.

QCAT had to consider the applicable statutory provisions, including sections 243 and 289 of the Body Corporate and Community Management Act 1997 (Qld) and sections 28 and 42 of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld), as well as the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Rules 2009 (Qld). The court also examined the decision in the case of Kioa v West (1985) 159 CLR 550. The primary question was whether the lot owners who had submitted to the Commissioner were respondents in the appeal and, if so, whether they should receive notice of the application for appeal. QCAT found that these lot owners were indeed respondents and that they should be served with the necessary documents.

The Tribunal ruled that Ron Bakir must serve all lot owners who had made submissions to the Commissioner for Body Corporate and Community Management with various documents related to the appeal. This included a copy of the application for appeal, all submissions filed by the parties, the Tribunal's reasons for decision, and any additional material filed in the appeal proceedings. The Tribunal set out a timeline for these actions, with specific deadlines for serving the documents and filing responses. The appeal was adjourned, and the preliminary issues raised by Mr Bakir were to be determined on the papers unless a party requested an oral hearing. The Tribunal also granted all parties the liberty to inspect the BCCM Adjudication file and to request copies of documents at their own expense. Costs were reserved, and the application for a view and the directions hearing were adjourned to a date to be fixed.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal is adjourned to a date to be fixed.

2. Ron Bakir must serve all lot owners who made submissions to the Commissioner for Body Corporate and Community Management with:

a. A copy of the application for appeal;

b. Copies of all submissions filed by the parties in these appeal proceedings;

c. These orders of the Appeal Tribunal; and

d. A copy of the Appeal Tribunal’s reasons for decision

by posting copies of the documents to the address for the lot owner identified in their submissions to the Commissioner for Body Corporate and Community Management, by:

4:00pm on 15 December 2015.

3. Any person served in accordance with direction 3 who wishes to be heard on the appeal must file in the Tribunal and serve upon the named parties to the appeal an application to be joined as a party to the appeal, by:

4:00pm on 12 January 2016.

4. Any party wishing to respond to any application to be joined as a party must file a submission in response in the Tribunal and serve upon the party seeking to be joined and the named parties to the appeal, by:

4:00pm on 25 January 2016.

5. Any application to be joined as a party to the appeal in accordance with direction 3 will, unless any party or person making an application requests by 25 January 2015 an oral hearing, be determined on the papers and without an oral hearing, not before:

4:00pm on 25 January 2016.

6. Ron Bakir will serve upon any party joined in the appeal with all additional material filed in the appeal proceeding and not specifically referred to in these directions including copies of all affidavits within seven (7) days of any decision of the Tribunal joining a party.

7. Ron Bakir must file in the Tribunal and provide a copy to each named party to the appeal including any joined party submissions in relation to the determination by the Appeals Tribunal of the preliminary issues raised by him, namely whether the appeal is:

a. An appeal in the strict sense;

b. An appeal by way of re-hearing;

c. Whether, to what extent and when fresh evidence may be admitted in the appeal and whether the leave of the Tribunal is required, by:

4:00pm on 12 February 2016.

8. The submissions of all other parties in response to the Applicant’s submissions on the determination of the preliminary issues must be filed in the Tribunal and served upon each named party to the appeal, by:

4:00pm on 26 February 2016.

9. Ron Bakir must file in the Tribunal and serve upon each named party to the appeal any submissions in reply, by:

4:00pm on 4 March 2016.

10. The preliminary issues will be determined by the Tribunal, unless a party requests an oral hearing by 4 March 2016, on the papers and without an oral hearing, not before:

4:00pm on 4 March 2016

11. All parties have liberty to inspect the BCCM Adjudication file and may request, at the party’s expense, copies of documents from the file.

12. The application for a view is adjourned to a date to be fixed.

13. The application is listed for a directions hearing on a date to be fixed.

14. Costs are reserved.

Background

Background to the litigation

The dispute originates from a decision made by the Commissioner for Body Corporate and Community Management under the Body Corporate and Community Management Act 1997 (Qld). Ron Bakir, a lot owner, sought to appeal this decision to the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT). The Body Corporate for Chevron Renaissance and another individual, Tran, opposed the appeal. The case revolves around the proper service and notice of the appeal application and who should be considered as a respondent in the appeal process. The legal issue specifically concerns the interpretation of sections 243 and 289 of the Body Corporate and Community Management Act 1997 (Qld), as well as sections 28 and 42 of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld). The case references the precedent set in the decision of the High Court in the matter of Kioa v West.

The matter was initially brought before the QCAT as an appeal against a decision made by the Commissioner for Body Corporate and Community Management. The appeal was filed by Ron Bakir, and the Body Corporate for Chevron Renaissance and Tran opposed the appeal. The case involved several procedural steps, including applications and submissions filed by both parties. The tribunal made orders pertaining to the service of appeal documents, the timing and manner of joining additional parties to the appeal, and the handling of preliminary issues related to the nature of the appeal and the admissibility of fresh evidence. The tribunal also reserved the matter for a future directions hearing and costs.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Who must have notice of the application for appeal?
2. Who is a respondent in the context of this appeal?
3. Whether the appeal is an appeal in the strict sense or an appeal by way of re-hearing?
4. To what extent and when fresh evidence may be admitted in the appeal and whether the leave of the Tribunal is required?

Held
1. The court held that Ron Bakir must serve all lot owners who made submissions to the Commissioner for Body Corporate and Community Management with a copy of the application for appeal, copies of all submissions filed by the parties in these appeal proceedings, the orders of the Appeal Tribunal, and a copy of the Appeal Tribunal’s reasons for decision.
2. The court held that any person served in accordance with the order who wishes to be heard on the appeal must file in the Tribunal and serve upon the named parties an application to be joined as a party to the appeal by a specified date.
3. The court held that the appeal will be considered an appeal in the strict sense, an appeal by way of re-hearing, and the admissibility of fresh evidence will be determined on the papers and without an oral hearing unless a party requests an oral hearing by a specified date.
4. The court held that Ron Bakir must file in the Tribunal and provide a copy to each named party to the appeal submissions in relation to the determination by the Appeals Tribunal of the preliminary issues raised by him by a specified date.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court's reasoning began by addressing the requirements under the Body Corporate and Community Management Act 1997 (Qld) and the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld) concerning the service of applications for appeal. The court noted that the appeals process mandates that all relevant parties, specifically the lot owners who made submissions, must be served with the application and related documents. This aligns with the legislative requirement to ensure transparency and fairness in the appeals process. The court also clarified that any individual served who wishes to participate in the appeal must formally apply to join the proceedings by a specified deadline, thereby maintaining the procedural integrity and allowing the tribunal to manage the number of participants effectively.

Turning to the nature of the appeal, the court examined the distinctions between an appeal in the strict sense and an appeal by way of re-hearing. It referred to the need to determine whether the appeal would merely review the decision-making process of the Tribunal or involve a comprehensive review of the evidence and findings. The court emphasised the importance of this distinction for setting the scope and parameters of the appeal, which was critical for the efficiency and fairness of the appeal process.

The court then addressed the admissibility of fresh evidence, considering the procedural rules and the necessity for maintaining the integrity of the appeal process. It concluded that unless a party requested an oral hearing, the preliminary issues regarding the nature of the appeal and the admissibility of fresh evidence would be determined based on the submissions and documentation filed by the parties. This decision was consistent with the tribunal’s procedural rules and aimed at expediting the resolution of foundational issues before proceeding with the substantive aspects of the appeal.

The ratio decidendi of this decision establishes that under the Body Corporate and Community Management Act 1997 (Qld) and the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld), lot owners who made submissions must be served with the application for appeal and related documents. Additionally, the court reinforced the procedural requirement for any interested party to formally apply to join the appeal if they wish to participate. The court also set the procedural framework for determining the nature of the appeal and the admissibility of fresh evidence, ensuring that these foundational issues are addressed efficiently before the substantive aspects of the appeal are considered.