Bakers Creek Developments Pty Ltd atf the Bakers Creek Trust v Gaviglio

Link copied
Case Copied 72 min read

DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Bakers Creek Developments Pty Ltd atf The Bakers Creek Trust v Gaviglio & Anor [2013] QDC 295

PARTIES:

BAKERS CREEK DEVELOPMENTS PTY LTD ACN 118020581 ATF THE BAKERS CREEK TRUST
(Plaintiff)

V

JOSEPH PETER GAVIGLIO
(Defendant)

and

RUTH MARCIA GAVIGLIO
(Defendant)

FILE NO/S:

D108/10

DIVISION:

Commercial List

PROCEEDING:

Trial

ORIGINATING COURT:

District Court of Queensland

DELIVERED ON:

28 November 2013  

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

13, 14, 15 May 2013 written submissions to 22 May 2013

JUDGE:

Andrews SC DCJ

ORDER:

The plaintiff is at liberty to submit a draft of a declaration and orders to be made in accordance with these reasons

The hearing is adjourned to allow the plaintiff to do so

CATCHWORDS:

CONTRACT – where vendors sold to the purchaser their only share in a cooperative – where the cooperative became a corporation before registration of the transfer of the share in the cooperative – where upon registration of the corporation the vendors were the holder of one share in the corporation – where the corporation issued valuable shares to the vendors – whether the valuable shares issued to the vendors on the basis that they held one share in the corporation or on the basis that they had been active members of the cooperative – whether the purchaser had a beneficial interest in the valuable shares

CONTRACT – INTERPRETATION – where vendors sold to the purchaser their only share in a cooperative – where vendors agreed to give the purchaser the benefits of past production from the land sold when the cooperative “is determining the distribution of bonuses” of the cooperative cooperative – whether “bonuses” in the contract has same meaning as in the rules of the cooperative – where cooperative determined to transfer to a corporation with a constitution providing for the issue of valuable shares to the vendors based on the past production from the land sold – where the corporation issued valuable shares to the vendors based on the past production from the land sold – whether  the shares issued by the corporation were a distribution of bonuses determined by the cooperative and on the basis of the past production of the land sold

CONTRACT – SPECIFIC PERFORMANCE – whether appropriate to order specific performance of transfer of shares – where no discretionary arguments against specific performance – where shares unable to be traded on open market – where trade restricted to sugar cane growers

Cooperatives Act 1997 sections 101(8), 166(1) and (2), 169 and 303(3)

Agricultural and Rural Finance P/L v Gardiner (2008) 238 CLR 570

Black v Homersham (1878) LR 4 Ex D24

Re Kerrisk; Ex p Duus (1993) 41 FCR 276

Wimbush , Richards v Wimbush [1940] 1 Ch 92

Ford & Lee, Principles of the Law of Trusts, [22.2120]

COUNSEL:

Handran for the plaintiff

A Barlow for the defendant

SOLICITORS:

McKays Solicitors for the plaintiff

BC & A for the defendant

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Précis of facts found

Facts

Was there a conversation…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bakers Creek Developments Pty Ltd atf the Bakers Creek Trust... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] QDC 295
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Bakers Creek Developments Pty Ltd atf the Bakers Creek Trust v Gaviglio involved a dispute between the plaintiff, a developer, and the defendant, a purchaser, regarding the sale of a share in a cooperative. The cooperative subsequently transitioned into a corporation, and the issue at hand was whether the purchaser had any entitlement to the valuable shares issued to the vendors upon the formation of the corporation. Additionally, the court needed to determine whether the term "bonuses" in the contract had the same meaning as in the cooperative's rules, and if the shares issued by the corporation could be considered a distribution of such bonuses.

The court held that the vendors' share in the cooperative became a share in the corporation upon its registration, and the number of shares they held was based on their past production from the land sold. The court further ruled that the shares issued by the corporation were indeed a distribution of bonuses, as determined by the cooperative, based on the past production of the land sold. The court found that the purchaser had a beneficial interest in the valuable shares issued to the vendors. Lastly, the court concluded that specific performance was an appropriate remedy, as the shares could not be traded on the open market and were restricted to sugar cane growers.

The court's analysis revealed that the vendors' share in the corporation was derived from their share in the cooperative, and the number of shares they held was determined by their past production from the land sold. The court held that the shares issued by the corporation were a distribution of bonuses, and the purchaser had a beneficial interest in those shares. The plaintiff was granted liberty to submit a draft declaration and orders, and the hearing was adjourned to allow for this.

Orders

Orders of the court

The plaintiff is at liberty to submit a draft of a declaration and orders to be made in accordance with these reasons

The hearing is adjourned to allow the plaintiff to do so

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

On the third business day after registration of MSL the 1,020 Investment Shares divided into a total of 200 million Investment Shares and the vendors’ one Investment Share divided into 375,413 Investment Shares. The rights to dividends and to participate in a winding up or reduction of capital changed[50] from the rights of the prior business day. The change meant that the rights became rights:[50]Constitution rule 4.2(e) and schedule 4 When the process is analysed in that way, one sees that the vendors’ first share in MSL came to be held by them when MSL was registered. It came to be held by them as a consequence of their ownership as members of the cooperative of the one share in the cooperative which they had sold to the purchaser. Their rights to the number of Investment Shares they came to hold after division was as a consequence of their ownership of one Investment Share and also as a result of the constitution of MSL at Schedule 4 which provided for an increase in the number of Investment Shares and as a result of MSL’s dividing the vendors’ one Investment Share into a larger number determined in accordance with the constitution, which is to say that it was determined in accordance with the Ten Year Production History of that shareholder of the Land sold and the other land retained by the vendors. Another feature of the process is seen by contrasting the process with what would have occurred if the cooperative had been wound up and the assets of the cooperative had been distributed among its members in accordance with rule 68 of the cooperative. If the cooperative had been wound up the vendors would have received their share of the assets of the cooperative calculated by reference to the ten year production history of the Land and the ten year production history of the other land. Instead, on the third business day after the transfer to MSL the vendors received no assets of the cooperative or of MSL. They received their share of the Investment Shares in MSL calculated by reference to the ten year production history of the Land and the ten year production history of the other land. If there had been a winding up before the transfer of the one share in the cooperative, the contract’s special condition 6.4 would have meant that the vendors would have held on trust for the purchaser any distribution to the vendors of the proceeds of sale of the cooperative’s assets. On that hypothesis, it would be accurate to say that the parties did not intend a distribution of the proceeds of sale of the cooperative’s assets to be conveyed as part of the property the subject of the contract. The vendors submitted that the parties “did not intend investment shares to be conveyed as part of the property the subject of the Contract”.[52]I accept that the contract had no reference to Investment Shares. They did not exist when the contract was signed. They did not exist on the date for completion, though the parties anticipated at that date that they would come into existence after that date. If the submission was intended to mean that the parties intended that Investment Shares be excluded from the benefits to which the purchaser could become entitled, I would reject the submission. I am not satisfied that the contract reveals such intent. [52]Defendants’ submissions par 8.