Baker & McAuliffe Holdings Pty Ltd t/as JSB Lighting v Carey

Link copied
Case Copied 50 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Baker & McAuliffe Holdings Pty Ltd t/as JSB Lighting v Carey [2018] FCA 1972

File number: NSD 1103 of 2018
Judge: MARKOVIC J
Date of judgment: 10 December 2018
Catchwords: CORPORATIONS – where the applicant seeks an interlocutory injunction against the first and second respondents to restrain them from making direct or indirect contact with certain clients of the applicant and assisting in three specified projects – where there is a serious question to be tried – where damages are an adequate remedy – where the applicant has delayed in making the injunction application – whether the balance of convenience requires the injunction to be granted – application dismissed.
Legislation: Restraints of Trade Act 1976 (NSW) s 4(1)

Cases cited:

Adamson v New South Wales Rugby League Limited (1991) 27 FCR 535

Amoco Australia Pty Ltd v Rocca Bros Motor Engineering Co Pty Ltd (1973) 133 CLR 288

Australian Broadcasting Corporation v Lenah Game Meats Pty Limited (2001) 208 CLR 199

Cactus Imaging Pty Ltd v Peters (2006) 71 NSWLR 9; [2006] NSWSC 717

Capgemini US v Case [2004] NSWSC 674

Castlemaine Tooheys Ltd v South Australia (1986) 161 CLR 148 at 153

Cerilian Pty Ltd v Graham Fraser [2008] NSWSC 1016

Curro v Beyond Productions Pty Ltd (1993) 30 NSWLR 337

Hannamax Hi-Tech Pty Ltd v O’Donnell [2001] NSWSC 634

John Fairfax Publication Pty Ltd v Birt [2006] NSWSC 995

Koops Martin Financial Services Pty Ltd v Reeves [2006] NSWSC 449

Network Ten Ltd v Fulwood (1995) 62 IR 43

Otis Elevator Co Pty Ltd v Nolan [2007] NSWSC 593

Provida Pty Ltd v Sharpe [2012] NSWSC 1041

IceTV v Ross [2007] NSWSC 635

Samsung Electronics Co Ltd v Apple Inc (2011) 217 FCR 238

Date of hearing: 22 November 2018
Registry: New South Wales
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Commercial Contracts, Banking, Finance and Insurance
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 117
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr I Neil SC with Mr M Cleary and Mr D Smith
Solicitor for the Applicant: Coleman Greig
Counsel for the Respondents: Mr Y Shariff with Mr P Reynolds
Solicitor for the Respondents: Addisons

ORDERS

NSD 1103 of 2018
BETWEEN:

BAKER & MCAULIFFE HOLDINGS PTY LTD ACN 059 756 811 T/AS JSB LIGHTING

Applicant

AND:

MATHEW CAREY

First Respondent

BFD LIGHTING PTY LIMITED ACN 626 274 600 T/AS MODULAR LIGHTING & PARTNERS

Second Respondent

DUDLEY HEWITT
Third Respondent

ANDREW WHITTLES
Fourth Respondent

IN THE INTERLOCUTORY APPLICATION:

BETWEEN:

BAKER & MCAULIFFE HOLDINGS PTY LTD ACN 059 756 811 T/AS JSB LIGHTING
Applicant

AND:

MATHEW CAREY
First Respondent

BFD LIGHTING PTY LIMITED ACN 626 274 600 T/AS MODULAR LIGHTING & PARTNERS
Second Respondent

JUDGE:

MARKOVIC J

DATE OF ORDER:

10 DECEMBER 2018

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The interlocutory application filed on 16 October 2018 be dismissed.

2.The applicant pay the first and second respondent’s costs of the interlocutory application.

3.The proceeding be listed for case management hearing on 19 December 2018 at 10.15 am.

Note:…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Baker & McAuliffe Holdings Pty Ltd t/as JSB Lighting v Carey and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] FCA 1972
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Baker & McAuliffe Holdings Pty Ltd t/as JSB Lighting sought an interlocutory injunction against Carey and another respondent to restrain them from contacting certain clients of JSB and assisting in three specified projects. The matter was heard by the Federal Court of Australia. The primary legal issues were whether there was a serious question to be tried regarding the validity of a restraint clause in a contract and whether damages would be an adequate remedy for any loss suffered by JSB if the injunction was not granted.

The court found that there was a serious question to be tried regarding the validity of the restraint clause, as it was necessary to determine whether the clause was reasonable and not against public policy. The court also found that damages would be an adequate remedy for any loss suffered by JSB if the injunction was not granted, as the loss could be quantified and compensated accordingly. The court further found that the balance of convenience did not require the injunction to be granted, as JSB had delayed in making the injunction application and there was no evidence of immediate or irreparable harm if the injunction was not granted. The court dismissed the interlocutory application with costs.

The court ordered that the interlocutory application filed on 16 October 2018 be dismissed, that the applicant pay the first and second respondent’s costs of the interlocutory application, and that the proceeding be listed for case management hearing on 19 December 2018 at 10.15 am.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The interlocutory application filed on 16 October 2018 be dismissed.

2. The applicant pay the first and second respondent’s costs of the interlocutory application.

3. The proceeding be listed for case management hearing on 19 December 2018 at 10.15 am.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons that follow the Interlocutory Application should be dismissed.BACKGROUND FACTSJSB and its business JSB was incorporated on 13 April 1993. It operates across Australia and New Zealand and has offices in New South Wales, Victoria, Queensland, South Australia, Western Australia and Auckland. JSB is a supplier of indoor and outdoor lighting products, providing services to a broad commercial and residential customer base. Its core business is the procurement and supply of lighting products to builders to match specifications on project designs. JSB supplies a number of different brands of lighting including, relevantly, Modular. As at 18 April 2018 it had distribution arrangements with the manufacturers of ten brands, including Modular (Suppliers). JSB’s turnover for the fiscal year ending 31 October 2017 was in excess of $23m and, for the 2018 financial year as at 8 August 2018, its turnover exceeded $20m. Suppliers accounted for approximately 80% of JSB’s current financial year revenue and historically have represented approximately 90% of its total lighting supply business. JSB’s Western Australian business operation accounts for approximately 26% of its total revenue. In the 2018 financial year to March 2018, sales in Western Australia generated revenue of over $3.2m. Modular, which is owned by Phillips Lighting, is a Belgium based lighting manufacturer specialising in high end commercial and residential lighting products. JSB has been a distributor of Modular products in Australia and New Zealand since about 1993. According to Mr Penhall, JSB’s chief executive officer, JSB has worked closely with Modular over the last 25 years to establish the brand. The sale of Modular products represents approximately 45% of JSB’s total sales and generates annual gross turnover of approximately $9m with a gross annual margin of about $4.7m. According to Mr Penhall, JSB’s business is generated through its relationships with the decision makers responsible for incorporating its products into design specifications for construction projects. Those decision makers comprise a range of building and construction industry partners including architects, designers, engineers and developers (Specifiers). The purchase orders for lighting products are usually placed with JSB by the builders, electricians and wholesalers contracted to build or supply to developments designed by the Specifiers (Referred Customers). That is, JSB does not supply lighting products directly to Specifiers. In some cases, a Referred Customer will invite lighting suppliers, such as JSB, to tender for lighting supply contracts to supply specified brands in accordance with directions given by the Specifier responsible for the building design specification. Suppliers also refer work to JSB if they are contacted directly by an Australian or New Zealand Specifier or building contractor. Mr Penhall described the usual steps in securing and delivering a lighting products sale to include:(1)a salesperson meets with a Specifier and receives a design specification;(2)relevant information received from the Specifier is entered by the salesperson into JSB’s database including:(a)the Specifier and the names of its contact people for the particular project;(b)the lighting specification information including the specified brands and quantities;(c)project site information including the address and names of contractors engaged on the project, such as engineers, consultants, builders and electrical contractors (if known); and(d)the estimated completion dates for stages of construction;(3)JSB produces a purchase order from the design specification and sends it to the manufacturer of the specified brand;(4)in some cases it is necessary to request a quote from the manufacturer for the purchase order. However, in most cases, JSB prepares a quote from price lists recorded in its management database;(5)on the basis of the quote received from the brand manufacturer, the salesperson responsible for the project or a member of the internal sales support team prepares and provides a quote for supply to the Referred Customer. Any negotiation on price will occur at this stage of the sale process; and(6)if the Referred Customer accepts JSB’s quote, it will issue a purchase order to JSB. JSB then confirms its purchase order with the relevant brand manufacturer and the manufacturer assembles and ships the order to JSB’s warehouse in Sydney.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Finally, the hardship that may be suffered by JSB as a result of the Court withholding injunctive relief is the alleged loss of business on specified projects. That is a loss that can be quantified and compensated accordingly by an award of damages. CONCLUSION For those reasons the Interlocutory Application should be dismissed with costs. Given the nature of the allegations, in my opinion, this matter should proceed to hearing as expeditiously as possible. The proceeding will be listed for case management hearing on 19 December 2018 at 10.15 am, when the matter is otherwise listed before me for hearing of other applications. I will make orders accordingly.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Finally, if interlocutory relief is to be sought, it should be sought promptly and any delay in applying for injunctive relief should be adequately explained: see Network Ten Ltd v Fulwood (1995) 62 IR 43 at 46-47. CONSIDERATIONSerious question to be triedCommon law or Restraints of Trade Act Whether there is a serious question to be tried in this case depends on whether there is a serious case that the Restraint Clause is valid and there has been a breach or apprehended breach of it. At common law, a restraint of trade is contrary to public policy and void unless it can be shown that the restraint is, in the circumstances of the particular case, reasonable: see Amoco Australia Pty Ltd v Rocca Bros Motor Engineering Co Pty Ltd (1973) 133 CLR 288 at 315. However, where a written contract of employment is subject to the laws of New South Wales, then s 4(1) of the Restraints of Trade Act 1976 (NSW) (ROT Act) may apply. That section provides that a restraint of trade is valid to the extent it is not against public policy, whether it is in severable terms or not. If the ROT Act applies it is necessary to first determine whether the alleged breach does or will infringe the terms of the restraint properly construed and then whether the restraint is, in its application to that breach, against public policy. If it is not then, in its application to restrain the alleged infringing conduct, the restraint is valid unless the court makes an order under s 4(3) of the ROT Act: see John Fairfax Publication Pty Ltd v Birt [2006] NSWSC 995 (Fairfax v Birt) at [6] (per Brereton J). At common law, the onus of showing the restraint goes no further than is reasonably necessary to protect the interests of the person in whose favour it operates lies on the party seeking to argue that the restraint is reasonable: see Adamson v New South Wales Rugby League Limited (1991) 27 FCR 535 at 554 (per Hill J) (Adamson). The validity and reasonableness of a restraint, if the subject of a contract, is to be determined at the time the contract is entered into, although facts occurring after that date are not necessarily irrelevant as they may shed light on the circumstances existing at that time: Adamson at 555. The test of reasonableness of a restraint clause is measured by reference to the interests of the parties concerned and the public. The requirement that the restraint be reasonable in the interests of the parties means that it must afford no more than adequate protection to the party in whose favour it is imposed: Adamson at 554. The question of whether the ROT Act applies is an important one as it affects the approach to a determination of the validity of the Restraint Clause. Whether it applies depends on a determination of the proper law of the contract: Provida Pty Ltd v Sharpe [2012] NSWSC 1041 (Provida) at [21] (per Pembroke J). The term “proper law of the contract” means the system of law to which the contract has the closest and most real connection: Provida at [21].