Bajo v iCare

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read

CERTIFICATE OF DETERMINATION OF MERIT REVIEWER

CITATION:

Bajo v iCare [2024] NSWPICMR 69

CLAIMANT:

Kenneth Bajo

INSURER:

iCare

MERIT REVIEWER:

Katherine Ruschen

DATE OF DECISION:

30 September 2024

CATCHWORDS:

MOTOR ACCIDENTS - Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017; merit review; dispute about whether cost of treatment and care provided or to be provided to the claimant is reasonable for the purposes of section 3.24(1) (entitlement to statutory benefits for treatment and care) attendant care services; everyday tasks; home modification; tree slashing; support worker; transport assistance; jurisdiction; schedule 2(1)(i); Held – the reviewable decision is set aside.

DETERMINATIONS MADE: 

CERTIFICATE

Issued under s 7.13(4) of the Motor Accident Injuries Act2017

DETERMINATION

The reviewable decision is about whether the cost of treatment and care provided, or to be provided, to the claimant is reasonable for the purposes of s 3.24(1) (Entitlement to statutory benefits for treatment and care) of the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017 (the MAI Act) and is therefore a merit review matter under Schedule 2(1)(i) of the MAI Act.

1.     The reviewable decision is set aside and the following determination is made:

(a)    Quote 1 is a reasonable cost of treatment and care and subject to the outcome of a medial assessment dispute, is payable by the insurer;

(b)    Quote 2 is not a reasonable cost of treatment and care and therefore not payable by the insurer;

(c) car washing and garage cleaning are costs of treatment and care and subject to medical assessment as to the number of hours that are reasonable and necessary, if any, under s 3.24(2), is a cost payable by the insurer;

(d)    prima facie, maintenance tasks in the home is a cost of treatment and care but depending on the nature of the task some may fall outside the scope of treatment and care therefore no formal determination is made. Once medical assessment is determined, the insurer is to redetermine the extent to which home maintenance tasks are treatment and care and issue a new determination;

(e)    the cost of setting up a work area for guitar maintenance is a cost of treatment and care and subject to the outcome of a medical assessment, is a cost payable by the insurer;

(f)    the cost of assistance with transport to cafes and other hospitality places by way of additional support worker hours is not a reasonable cost of treatment and care;

(g)    the cost of assistance with transport and shopping at Bunnings and other retail outlets or shopping centres is not a reasonable cost of treatment and care, and

(h) the insurer is directed to redetermine the reasonable costs of treatment and care payable following the outcome of a medical assessment by applying the above determination regarding items determined in this merit review to be “treatment and care” within the meaning of the MAI Act and the insurer is to issue a new determination.

STATEMENT OF REASONS

INTRODUCTION

  1. There is a dispute between Kenneth Bajo (the claimant) and the insurer about whether the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bajo v iCare and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] NSWPICMR 69
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Bajo v iCare concerns a dispute under the Motor Accidents Injuries Act 2017 (MAI Act) about the reasonable cost of treatment and care provided or to be provided to the claimant, Bajo. The dispute specifically involves three items: front gate replacement, slashing, tree-lined clearing and removal of trees (tree slashing), and additional personal assistance/support worker hours. Bajo requested a merit review of the insurer's internal review decision, which was partly affirmed and partly varied on 24 April 2024. The primary issues before the court were whether the front gate replacement and the additional support worker hours and tree slashing were reasonable and necessary, and if they qualified as "treatment and care" under section 3.24(1)(a) of the MAI Act. The court had to determine its jurisdiction over the dispute and whether it could assess the reasonableness of the costs in question.

The court considered whether it had jurisdiction to review the insurer's decision regarding the additional support worker hours and tree slashing, given that the dispute involved whether these services qualified as "treatment and care". The court found that while there was no explicit provision in Schedule 2 of the MAI Act addressing disputes solely about whether a particular item or service is "treatment and care", the jurisdiction to determine the reasonableness of the cost of treatment and care under section 3.24(1)(a) implicitly includes assessing whether the cost relates to "treatment and care". The court concluded that it had jurisdiction to determine whether the additional support worker hours and tree slashing constituted "treatment and care", as this was necessary to decide if the costs were reasonable under section 3.24(1)(a). The court noted that if a cost was not a cost "of treatment and care", it could not be considered a "reasonable cost of treatment and care" payable under section 3.24(1)(a).

In its decision, the court determined that the insurer's internal review decision was set aside to the extent it related to the dispute about whether the additional support worker hours and tree slashing were "treatment and care" within the definition of section 1.4 of the MAI Act. The court held that it had the jurisdiction to review this part of the dispute and that the decision needed to be reconsidered in light of the court's findings. The claimant was instructed to lodge an application for a medical assessment for the parts of the dispute that required such an assessment. The court's decision underscores the importance of determining whether certain costs and services qualify as "treatment and care" before assessing their reasonableness under the MAI Act.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 24 April 2024 the insurer issued their internal review decision in which they partly affirmed and partly varied their 1 March 2024 decision. The claimant has requested a merit review of the insurer’s internal review decision dated 24 April 2024 (the Application). There are three items in respect of which the claimant seeks costs of treatment and care in dispute:(a) front gate replacement;(b) slashing, tree-lined clearing and removal of trees (tree slashing), and(c) additional personal assistance/support worker hours (additional support worker hours). At the teleconference on 9 July 2024 the parties confirmed the dispute about the front gate is whether front gate replacement is reasonable and necessary in the circumstances or relates to the injury caused by the motor accident. That dispute is a matter for a medical assessment pursuant to Sch 2(2)(b) of the MAI Act. Accordingly, that dispute will not be determined in this merit review. The claimant will lodge an application for a medical assessment. The parties also confirmed there is a dispute about whether additional support worker hours and tree slashing is reasonable and necessary but in addition, there is a dispute about whether these items are treatment and care for the purpose of s 3.24. To the extent the parties dispute whether tree slashing, and additional support worker hours are reasonable and necessary, the claimant will lodge an application for a medical assessment. To the extent the dispute about tree slashing and additional support worker hours concerns whether such services are “treatment and care” for the purpose of s 3.24 I have concluded that I have jurisdiction to determine that part of the dispute for the reasons outlined below. The proceedings are identified by the parties as a dispute about the reasonable cost of treatment and care. Schedule 2(1)(i) provides power to a merit reviewer to determine “whether the cost of treatment and care provided to the claimant is reasonable for the purposes of section 3.24(1)(a)”. In addition to questions for medical assessment, an issue in the proceedings is whether additional support worker hours and tree slashing is “treatment and care” within the definition of s 1.4 of the MAI Act. There is no express matter listed in Sch 2 of the MAI Act concerning a dispute confined to whether a particular item or service provided to an injured person is “treatment and care”. However, the starting point is cl 3.24. Relevantly, s 3.24(1)(a) provides that an injured person is entitled to statutory benefits for “the reasonable cost of treatment and care”. It follows from this that if a cost is not a cost “of treatment and care” it is not a “reasonable cost of treatment and care” payable under s 3.24(1)(a). Schedule 2(1)(i) provides that a dispute about “whether the cost of treatment and care provided or to be provided to the claimant is reasonable” is a merit review matter. Section 3.24(1)(a) is clearly the precursor to/genesis of the jurisdiction prescribed in Sch 2(1)(i) in the same way s 3.24(2) is the precursor to, or provides the foundation for, the medical assessment jurisdiction prescribed in Sch 2(2(b).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.