Bain v The State of South Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil: Application)

BAIN v THE STATE OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

[2020] SASC 234

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Stanley

10 December 2020

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW - JUDICIAL REVIEW - GROUNDS OF REVIEW - PROCEDURAL FAIRNESS - HEARING - GENERALLY

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW - JUDICIAL REVIEW - GROUNDS OF REVIEW - UNREASONABLENESS

CRIMINAL LAW - SENTENCE - POST-CUSTODIAL ORDERS - PAROLE - BOARDS, TRIBUNALS ETC: POWERS, DUTIES AND CONSTITUTION

This is an application for judicial review of a decision made by the Parole Board (the Board) to defer consideration of the applicant’s application for release on parole until he had completed a violence prevention program. 

The applicant is a prisoner serving a sentence of five years and three months imprisonment with a non-parole period of three years and three months which commenced on 21 November 2016.  The sentence was imposed for offences of aggravated intentionally causing harm, assault, disorderly behaviour, serious criminal trespass in a place of residence (three counts), dishonestly taking property (seven counts) and unlawful possession. 

The applicant has engaged with all rehabilitation programs available to him both prior to and after sentencing.  He has made considerable efforts to prepare for his release by seeking employment, commencing counselling with Relationships Australia and engagement after release with PsychMed.  He has not completed the violence prevention program because, despite his requests, the Department for Correctional Services (DCS) did not make that program available to him during his non-parole period. 

The applicant made an application for release on parole on 1 September 2019.  His non-parole period expired on 20 February 2020.  On 26 February 2020 the Board considered the status of his application for parole and “resolved to interview [the applicant] on a date to be advised after completion of the Violence Prevention Program, and receipt of the post treatment report, in relation to the following issues:  risk of reoffending; violence; post-release plans.”  The applicant has commenced the violence prevention program.  It takes 10 months to complete.  He is due to complete it in about May 2021.   The applicant’s head sentence will be completed on 20 February 2022. 

The applicant contends that the decision of the Board was unreasonable, failed to take into account all of his circumstances, and involved a denial of procedural fairness.

Held:

1. The Board was not required to accord the applicant procedural fairness when deferring its decision on his application for parole without affording him the opportunity to be heard orally.

2. Even if the Board was obliged to accord the applicant procedural fairness, he was granted an opportunity to be heard, albeit in writing only and without being informed that the Board might defer a decision on his application until he had completed the violence prevention program.  The applicant was not denied procedural fairness by the Board's decision to defer consideration of his application for parole. 

3. The decision of the Board to defer consideration of the applicant’s application for release on parole until he had completed the violence prevention program was not irrational…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bain v The State of South Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] SASC 234
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Bain v The State of South Australia case involves a prisoner, Bain, who is challenging the decision of the Parole Board of South Australia to defer his parole application until he completes a violence prevention program. Bain argues that he has not been afforded procedural fairness, that the Board’s requirement for him to complete the program before being considered for parole is unreasonable, and that the Board has failed to take into account all of his circumstances, including the Department for Correctional Services' failure to provide the program during his non-parole period.

The legal issues the court had to decide included whether the Board accorded Bain procedural fairness by deferring its decision without allowing him to be heard, whether it was unreasonable for the Board to require him to complete the program before considering his parole application, and whether the Board failed to take into account all of Bain's circumstances. The court examined whether the Board's decision-making process adhered to the requirements of procedural fairness, and if the Board acted unreasonably by imposing the condition of completing the program before parole consideration. Additionally, the court assessed if the Board overlooked Bain's efforts to address the causes of his offending behaviour and the failure of the Department for Correctional Services to provide the program during his non-parole period.

The court determined that the Board had accorded Bain procedural fairness as it was aware that he had previously attempted to undertake the program. It found that the Board had not acted unreasonably by requiring Bain to complete the program, as this was necessary for community safety. The court rejected the argument that the Board's discretion was misapplied, as the primary consideration was the safety of the community, and the completion of the program was relevant to this consideration. Therefore, the court dismissed Bain's application for judicial review. The court indicated it would hear the parties on the issue of costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The matter proceeded on the papers. The only factual issue was whether the Board was aware when it reviewed the applicant’s application that he had made previous attempts to commence the violence prevention program. I am satisfied that there was material before the Board, namely, the letter from the applicant’s solicitor of 21 February 2020 which advised the Board of previous attempts made by the applicant to undertake the program. Facts It is common ground that the applicant is a prisoner serving a sentence of five years and three months imprisonment with a non-parole period of three years and three months which commenced on 21 November 2016. The sentence was imposed for offences of aggravated intentionally causing harm, assault, disorderly behaviour, serious criminal trespass in a place of residence (three counts), dishonestly taking property (seven counts) and unlawful possession. The applicant has engaged with all rehabilitation programs available to him both prior to and after sentencing. He has made considerable efforts to prepare for his release by seeking employment, commencing counselling with Relationships Australia and engagement after release with PsychMed. He has not completed the violence prevention program because, despite his requests, the Department for Correctional Services (DCS) did not make that program available to him during his non-parole period. The applicant made an application for release on parole on 1 September 2019. His non-parole period expired on 20 February 2020. On 26 February 2020 the Board considered the status of his application for parole and “resolved to interview [the applicant] on a date to be advised after completion of the Violence Prevention Program, and receipt of the post treatment report, in relation to the following issues: risk of reoffending; violence; post-release plans.” The applicant has commenced the violence prevention program. It takes 10 months to complete. He is due to complete it in about May 2021. The applicant’s head sentence will be completed on 20 February 2022. By a letter from the applicant’s solicitors to the Board of 21 February 2020 the applicant informed the Board, inter alia, that he had not been able to avail himself of the opportunity to undertake the violence prevention program and that he had previously applied to undertake the program. On the applicant’s behalf his solicitor submitted to the Board that the combination of the courses undertaken by the application in relation to domestic violence, drug and alcohol counselling and positive psychology were akin to the violence prevention program. The issues The issues on the application are:1.Whether the Board has accorded the applicant procedural fairness by deferring its decision on his application for parole without affording the applicant the opportunity to be heard; 2.Whether the Board has acted unreasonably in requiring the applicant to complete the violence prevention program before being considered for release on parole; and3.Whether the Board has failed to take into account all of the applicant’s circumstances, particularly the efforts he has made to address the causes of his offending behaviour and the failure by the DCS to provide the violence prevention program to the applicant during his non-parole period.Submissions

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The applicant seeks orders quashing the decision of the Board and directing that the Board forthwith consider the applicant’s application according to law.The evidence The applicant relied on an affidavit of his solicitor, Yan Robson, of 23 August 2020 that exhibited an affidavit of the applicant dated 21 August 2020. The applicant also tendered a letter from his solicitor to the Parole Board dated 21 February 2020. The respondent relied on an affidavit of its Chair, E F Nelson QC, dated 28 September 2020. The matter proceeded on the papers. The only factual issue was whether the Board was aware when it reviewed the applicant’s application that he had made previous attempts to commence the violence prevention program. I am satisfied that there was material before the Board, namely, the letter from the applicant’s solicitor of 21 February 2020 which advised the Board of previous attempts made by the applicant to undertake the program. Facts It is common ground that the applicant is a prisoner serving a sentence of five years and three months imprisonment with a non-parole period of three years and three months which commenced on 21 November 2016. The sentence was imposed for offences of aggravated intentionally causing harm, assault, disorderly behaviour, serious criminal trespass in a place of residence (three counts), dishonestly taking property (seven counts) and unlawful possession. The applicant has engaged with all rehabilitation programs available to him both prior to and after sentencing. He has made considerable efforts to prepare for his release by seeking employment, commencing counselling with Relationships Australia and engagement after release with PsychMed. He has not completed the violence prevention program because, despite his requests, the Department for Correctional Services (DCS) did not make that program available to him during his non-parole period. The applicant made an application for release on parole on 1 September 2019. His non-parole period expired on 20 February 2020. On 26 February 2020 the Board considered the status of his application for parole and “resolved to interview [the applicant] on a date to be advised after completion of the Violence Prevention Program, and receipt of the post treatment report, in relation to the following issues: risk of reoffending; violence; post-release plans.” The applicant has commenced the violence prevention program. It takes 10 months to complete. He is due to complete it in about May 2021. The applicant’s head sentence will be completed on 20 February 2022. By a letter from the applicant’s solicitors to the Board of 21 February 2020 the applicant informed the Board, inter alia, that he had not been able to avail himself of the opportunity to undertake the violence prevention program and that he had previously applied to undertake the program. On the applicant’s behalf his solicitor submitted to the Board that the combination of the courses undertaken by the application in relation to domestic violence, drug and alcohol counselling and positive psychology were akin to the violence prevention program. The issues

Decision

Reasons for decision

The applicant is aggrieved that his prospect of release on parole has been delayed by the failure of the DCS to arrange for him to undertake the violence prevention program during his non-parole period. He submits this was not his fault and accordingly is unfair. Again, the Board must exercise its decision-making power in accordance with the scope, purpose and object of the Act. That it was not the fault of the applicant that he had not undertaken the violence prevention program earlier is not a factor to be considered by the Board in deciding whether to grant him release on parole. Again, the paramount consideration for the Board in determining his application is the safety of the community. In addition, the Board must consider, where relevant, those matters prescribed by s 67(4). In this case it is relevant that the applicant had not completed a program which the Board considered was necessary for the protection of community safety. On that basis I reject the suggestion that the exercise of the Board’s discretion miscarried. Conclusion I would dismiss the application for judicial review. I would hear the parties as to costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established