BAE SYSTEMS AUSTRALIA LTD, BAE SYSTEMS AUSTRALIA DEFENCE P/L & BAE SYSTEMS AUSTRALIA LOGISTICS P/L

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

EQUAL OPPORTUNITY TRIBUNAL

(District Court Administrative and Disciplinary Division)

In the Matter of AN APPLICATION FOR EXEMPTION UNDER THE EQUAL OPPORTUNITY ACT 1984

BAE SYSTEMS AUSTRALIA LTD, BAE SYSTEMS AUSTRALIA DEFENCE P/L & BAE SYSTEMS AUSTRALIA LOGISTICS P/L

[2014] SAEOT 3

Judgment of His Honour Judge Costello, Member Ms A Bachmann and Member Mr R Altman

29 August 2014

HUMAN RIGHTS - DISCRIMINATION

Application by BAE Systems Australia Limited (BAE) for renewal of exemption, previously granted, to enable it to discriminate on grounds of nationality – applications by BAE Systems Australia Defence Pty Ltd and BAE Systems Australia Logistics Pty Ltd (wholly owned subsidiaries of BAE) for grant of exemptions to enable them to discriminate on same grounds – applicants’ businesses require them to have access to security sensitive material controlled by the Government of USA – that Government insists that persons of proscribed nationalities, who may be employed by or wish to be employed by the applicants, not have access to such material – grounds exist for a renewal (in the case of BAE) and a grant of the exemptions in the ‘wider public interest’ – Exemptions granted on same terms and conditions as the previous exemption granted to BAE.

Equal Opportunity Act 1984 ss 52, 54, 92, referred to.
Pulteney Grammar School v Equal Opportunity Tribunal & Ors [2007] SASC 308; BAE Systems Australia Ltd [2008] SAEOT 1; BAE Systems Australia Limited [2011] SAEOT 3, considered.

BAE SYSTEMS AUSTRALIA LTD, BAE SYSTEMS AUSTRALIA DEFENCE P/L & BAE SYSTEMS AUSTRALIA LOGISTICS P/L
[2014] SAEOT 3

Introduction

  1. On 20 July 2011 the Tribunal made an order that BAE Systems Australia Ltd (‘BAE’) be granted an exemption for a further period of three years pursuant to s 92 of the Equal Opportunity Act 1984 (SA) (‘the Act’) from the provisions of ss 52 and 54 of the Act to enable it to discriminate in its employment practices with respect to persons of particular nationalities on the same terms and conditions as set out in paras 64-66 of the Judgment of the Tribunal in Judgment No. [2008] SAEOT 1.

  2. On 17 June 2014 BAE applied pursuant to s 92 of the Act for a renewal of the exemption previously granted to it for a further period of three years from 21 July 2014 on the same terms and conditions as are referred to in paragraph 1.

  3. BAE Systems Australia Defence Pty Ltd (‘BAE Defence’) and BAE Systems Australia Logistics Pty Ltd (‘BAE Logistics’) are wholly owned subsidiaries of BAE.

  4. On 17 June 2014 BAE Defence and BAE Logistics applied pursuant to s 92 of the Act for a grant of the exemption previously granted to BAE for a period of three years from 21 July 2014 on the same terms and conditions as are referred to in paragraph 1.

  5. Although BAE Defence and BAE Logistics are wholly owned subsidiaries of BAE they seek separate exemptions because both companies employ personnel in South Australia. In addition, the exemption is…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read BAE SYSTEMS AUSTRALIA LTD, BAE SYSTEMS AUSTRALIA DEFENCE P/L... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] SAEOT 3
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

BAE Systems Australia Limited, along with its subsidiaries, BAE Systems Australia Defence Pty Ltd and BAE Systems Australia Logistics Pty Ltd, sought renewal and new exemptions from certain human rights provisions to allow them to discriminate on the grounds of nationality. The companies argued that the exemptions were necessary for their businesses, which required access to security-sensitive material controlled by the United States Government. The US Government had a policy that individuals of certain nationalities should not have access to such sensitive information. The applicants contended that granting these exemptions would be in the wider public interest.

The legal issues before the court involved whether the exemptions were justified on the grounds of wider public interest and whether the exemptions complied with the applicable human rights legislation. The court needed to determine if the exemptions would enable the applicants to carry out their business activities without contravening human rights provisions, particularly the right to non-discrimination. The court also had to assess if the exemptions were necessary and proportionate to the legitimate aim pursued by the applicants.

The court found that there were indeed grounds for both the renewal and the grant of the exemptions in the wider public interest. The court considered the necessity and proportionality of the exemptions, balancing the applicants’ need to access sensitive material with the human rights implications of the discrimination. The court concluded that the exemptions were justified as they allowed the applicants to engage in activities that were crucial for national security and international relations. The exemptions were granted on the same terms and conditions as the previous exemption granted to BAE Systems Australia Limited.

The court granted the exemptions, allowing the applicants to discriminate on the grounds of nationality in their employment practices. The exemptions were made subject to specific terms and conditions designed to mitigate the impact of the discrimination and ensure that the exemptions were used only for the specified purposes. The court's decision recognised the legitimate interests of the applicants and the importance of their business activities in the context of national security and international cooperation.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established