\ \ , l 4 9 3
JUDGMENT No. .....,.,....,.,... .,,,,,,,- i
I N THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA )
GENERAL DIVISION ) STATE OF OUEENSLAND
1 QP 2247 of 1992
BETWEEN: JORG ERIC BACKHAUS
AND : ADELLA PTP LIMITED
10 MAR 1993
FEDERAL COURT OF
PRINCIPAL EX TEMPORE JUDGMENT
BRISBANE 22 FEBRUARY 1993
Adella Proprietary Limited (the creditor) seeks sequestration against the debtor Jorg Eric Backhaus on the basis of a judgment obtained in the District Court of Queensland on 22 July 1992 for some $22,605.39, which would now be a little higher due to interest.
The debtor seeks to have the bankruptcy notice set aside and
has appeared in person on the application. The basis of the
application is that there was an agreement which he entered
into with the petitioning creditor in August 1991, to pay off
the debt over a period of time. There seems to be no doubt
monthly purchases as they accrued, and something additional off the arrears each month. As it happens, it is not necessary for me to decide which of these two accounts of the agreement are correct, because it is now undisputed that throughout the period of the agreement - that is, in the months which followed August 1991 up to the time when the last payments were made by the debtor in February or March 1992 - he only on one occasion paid more than the amount of monthly purchases. In other words, the debtor himself admits to being in breach even of his own account of the agreement. This admission was made both in the witness box and from the bar table. Accordingly, even if I am to conclude that the agreement was as the debtor alleges, I must also conclude on his own evidence, that he was himself in breach of the agreement. In this event, the agreement of the creditor to postpone action or not to press the debt in its entirety, was thereby repudiated by the debtor thus releasing the creditor from the agreement as alleged. In these circumstances, the basis upon which the debtor seeks
to set aside the bankruptcy notice falls to the ground. The debtor says that from April 1992 he changed his arrangements with his own customers, so that instead of giving them credit of 30 days, he required cash payments. He says that he explained to a representative of the creditor that in the light of that change of arrangement, he would be able to pay off the debt if he was given time. In fact, nine months have since passed, and it seems from what the debtor says that he is actually in no better position to pay off the debt than he was before he changed his own credit arrangements, except that he has paid off some of his other accrued debts. Thus his overall net liabilities, he says, are less than they were a year ago, although his liability to the creditor has not decreased. Even if…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Backhaus, J.E. v Adella Pty Limited and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1993] FCA 111
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court considered the evidence presented by the debtor, who admitted to only making one payment that exceeded the amount of his monthly purchases, thereby breaching the terms of any alleged agreement. The debtor's account of the agreement, which involved paying off the arrears monthly and covering ongoing purchases, was contrasted with the creditor's version, which required a fixed monthly payment towards the arrears. Regardless of which version was accurate, the debtor's own testimony confirmed that he was in breach of the agreement. This breach repudiated any agreement to postpone action on the debt, releasing the creditor from the terms of the alleged agreement.
Based on the debtor's admission of breach and the undisputed fact that the debt remained unpaid, the court dismissed the debtor's application to set aside the bankruptcy notice. The court ruled that the debtor's assertion that he could pay off the debt with more time did not constitute a valid reason to set aside the notice. The debtor's claim that he could trade out of his debts was also rejected, as there was no evidence to suggest an improvement in his financial position or that he would be able to pay off his debts in the near future. Consequently, the court proceeded with the sequestration petition, making an order against the debtor's estate and appointing Ross Andrew Duus as trustee. The debtor was also ordered to pay the creditor's costs.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi