DISTRICT COURT OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION:
BAB v Commissioner of Police [2019] QDC 118
PARTIES:
BAB
(appellant)
v
THE COMMISSIONER OF POLICE
(respondent)FILE NO:
D156/18
DIVISION:
Civil
PROCEEDING:
Appeal
ORIGINATING COURT:
Magistrates Court at Maroochydore
Hillan A/MDELIVERED EX TEMPORE ON:
21 June 2019
DELIVERED AT:
Maroochydore
HEARING DATE:
21 June 2019
JUDGE:
Cash QC DCJ
ORDERS:
1. The appeal is allowed.
2. Set aside the sentence imposed for the offence of assault occasioning bodily harm.
3. Instead, the appellant is sentenced to imprisonment for 18 months to be served cumulatively upon the sentence imposed in the Maroochydore Magistrates Court on 3 May 2018.
4. Set aside the parole eligibility date of 2 August 2022.
5. Instead, order that the appellant be eligible for release on parole on 13 December 2019.
6. Otherwise, the orders of the magistrate are confirmed.
7. The respondent pay the appellant’s costs according to the scale amounts.
CATCHWORDS:
CRIMINAL LAW – APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL – APPEAL AGAINST SENTENCE – GROUNDS FOR INTERFERENCE – ERROR OF LAW – FAILURE TO GIVE REASONS - s 222 Justices Act – where the appellant was convicted of a series of offences committed while on parole – where there was a requirement for cumulative sentence – where the appellant was purportedly sentenced to partially cumulative term of imprisonment – where the appellant’s parole eligibility date was more than half of the overall period of imprisonment – whether the Magistrate erred in not inviting submissions or giving reasons for postponing parole eligibility.
Justices Act 1886 (Qld) ss 222, 223
Penalties and Sentences Act 1992 (Qld) ss 156, 156AHouse v The King (1936) 55 CLR 499
R v Kitson [2008] QCA 86, [17]COUNSEL:
J Wallace (Solicitor) for the appellant
A Nikolic for the respondentSOLICITORS:
Wallace O’Hagan Lawyers for the appellant
Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions for the respondentIntroduction
On 27 September 2018 the appellant appeared before an acting magistrate at Maroochydore in relation to eight offences. He pleaded guilty and was sentenced. Various terms of imprisonment were imposed, some of them cumulative upon a sentence of imprisonment of three years the appellant was already serving.
The magistrate set a new parole eligibility date. The date set was more than two-thirds of the overall period of imprisonment the appellant is liable to serve. The appellant appeals against the severity of the sentence. There is no satisfactory explanation for the unusual order deferring his parole eligibility and, for the following reasons, the appeal should be allowed and the appellant resentenced.
Details of the offences
The eight offences committed by the appellant fell into two groups. Early in the morning of 4 May 2018 the appellant went to the home of the complainant, his estranged partner. He knocked on the door, waking her, and stated, “It’s the police.” This was an offence of assuming the designation of a police officer. The complainant opened the door, saw it was the appellant and closed the door immediately. The…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read BAB v Commissioner of Police and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2019] QDC 118
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues were whether the magistrate erred in failing to make the sentence for assault occasioning bodily harm cumulative, as required by section 156A of the Penalties and Sentences Act, and whether the magistrate erred in setting the parole eligibility date more than half of the overall period of imprisonment without giving proper reasons. The court examined if the magistrate correctly applied the law and whether the sentence was proportionate to the gravity of the offences committed.
In its reasoning, the court found that the magistrate made two significant errors. Firstly, the magistrate failed to ensure that the sentence for assault occasioning bodily harm was served cumulatively with the sentence imposed in May 2018, as mandated by section 156A of the Penalties and Sentences Act. Secondly, the parole eligibility date was set beyond the midpoint of the imprisonment period without adequate reasons, which is highly unusual and requires justification. Given these errors, the court determined it was appropriate to exercise its sentencing discretion afresh. The court concluded that an overall imprisonment period of four and a half years was suitable, taking into account the seriousness of the offences and the appellant's reoffending. The parole eligibility date was adjusted to reflect about a third of the overall sentence.
The final orders of the court were to allow the appeal, set aside the original sentence for the offence of assault occasioning bodily harm, and impose a new sentence of 18 months to be served cumulatively upon the previous sentence. The parole eligibility date was also set aside and replaced with a new date of 13 December 2019. The court confirmed the remaining orders of the magistrate and ordered the respondent to pay the appellant’s costs.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The appeal is allowed.
2. Set aside the sentence imposed for the offence of assault occasioning bodily harm.
3. Instead, the appellant is sentenced to imprisonment for 18 months to be served cumulatively upon the sentence imposed in the Maroochydore Magistrates Court on 3 May 2018.
4. Set aside the parole eligibility date of 2 August 2022.
5. Instead, order that the appellant be eligible for release on parole on 13 December 2019.
6. Otherwise, the orders of the magistrate are confirmed.
7. The respondent pay the appellant’s costs according to the scale amounts.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The appellant appeals pursuant to section 222 of the Justices Act 1886. Pursuant to section 223 of that Act, the appeal is by way of rehearing on the evidence given in the proceedings before the magistrate and any further evidence admitted with leave. I am required to conduct a real review of the evidence before the magistrate and the magistrate’s reasons for imposing the sentences he did to determine whether there has been error. As this is an appeal against the exercise of the sentencing discretion, it must be determined in accordance with the well know principles in House v The King [1936] 55 CLR 499. If I find the magistrate acted upon a wrong principle, took into account irrelevant matters, failed to take into account relevant matters or mistook the facts, then I can exercise the sentencing discretion afresh. Consideration In my view, the magistrate committed two clear errors. The first is that he either failed entirely, or failed to properly, make the sentence for assault occasioning bodily harm cumulative upon the sentence imposed on the appellant in May 2018, as he was required to do by section 156A of the Penalties and Sentences Act. To comply with that section, the magistrate was required to order the sentence be served cumulatively with any other term of imprisonment the offender is liable to serve. He did not do so. In addition, it is well recognised that it is unusual to fix a parole eligibility point at a date later than halfway through the period of imprisonment. If this is to be done, it is necessary to give reasons why such an order is appropriate. As Justice Fraser said in R v Kitson [2008] QCA 86 at [17]:“[W]here the applicant has a claim upon the discretion for an order that he be released after serving less than half of the head sentence in view of his plea of guilty and personal circumstances, a parole release date which is significantly beyond the midpoint of the head sentence is very unusual... If such an unusual order is to be made, in my opinion the duty to give reasons requires that the sentencing remarks explain the process of reasoning underlying it.” The magistrate gave no reasons for this unusual order and did not invite submissions on the topic. For these reasons, the sentences imposed must be set aside and it is appropriate to exercise the sentencing discretion afresh. As the magistrate properly identified, the offences committed by the appellant were very serious. His conduct was all the more appalling because he reoffended within hours of being extended the leniency of immediate release on parole. The legislation required that any term of imprisonment imposed for the offence of assault occasioning bodily harm be served cumulatively. Principle required caution to avoid an overall sentence that was disproportionate to the gravity of the appellant’s offending. In my view, an overall period of imprisonment of four and a-half years is appropriate to reflect the offending. That will be achieved by setting aside the sentence imposed for the assault occasioning bodily harm and, instead, sentencing the appellant to imprisonment for 18 months, which will be ordered to be served cumulatively upon the sentence imposed in the Maroochydore Magistrates Court on 3 May 2018. The parole eligibility date will also be set aside and, instead, the appellant will be ordered to be eligible for parole on 13 December 2019. That reflects a period of 18 months from when the appellant was taken back into custody and reflects, in rough terms, about a third of the overall sentence which he might be liable to serve.