Ba and Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs (Migration)

Link copied
Case Copied 76 min read

Ba and Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs (Migration) [2024] AATA 2507 (20 June 2024)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number:          2021/8838

Re:Mouhamadou Ba

APPLICANT

AndMinister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Senior Member Theodore Tavoularis

Date of decision:                   20 June 2024

Date of written reasons:        16 July 2024

Place:Brisbane

Pursuant to section 43 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth), this Tribunal sets aside the decision made by a delegate of the Respondent on 16 November 2021 and substitutes it with a decision to revoke the mandatory cancellation of the Applicant’s Class BB Subclass 155 Five Year Resident Return visa.

..........................[SGD]..........................

Senior Member Theodore Tavoularis

Catchwords

MIGRATION – remittal - non-revocation of mandatory cancellation of a visa – failure to pass the character test – whether there is another reason to revoke the mandatory cancellation decision – consideration of Ministerial Direction No. 99 – alcohol addiction – family violence- risk of recidivism found to acceptable – best interest of minor child – where the child is in foster care - where factors against revocation outweighed by factors in favour - Tribunal finding there is another reason to revoke the mandatory cancellation decision - decision under review set aside and substituted.

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)
Migration Act 1958 (Cth)

Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth)

Cases

Ali v Minister for Home Affairs (2020) 278 FCR 627
Bartlett v The Minister for Immigration and Boarder Protection [2017] AATA 1561
Harrison and Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (2009) 106 ALD 666
Ismail v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2024] HCA 2
Khalil v Minister for Home Affairs (2019) 271 FCR 326
M1/2021 v Minister for Home Affairs (2022) 400 ALR 417
PGDX v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs  [2021] FCA 1235
PNLB v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2017] AATA 1561

Walker v Minister of Home Affairs [2020] FCA 909

Secondary Materials

Ministerial Direction No. 99 – Visa refusal and cancellation under section 501 and revocation of a mandatory cancellation of a visa under section 501CA (3 March 2023)

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member Theodore Tavoularis

16 July 2024

INTRODUCTION

  1. Mr Mouhamadou Ba (‘the Applicant’) is a 48-year-old citizen of Mauritania. He first arrived in Australia on 6 May 2008 when aged 33 years. He arrived here on a Refugee and Humanitarian Class XB visa and then he was later granted a Subclass 155 Five Year Resident Return visa (‘the Visa’). His movement history indicates that apart from a


    three-month period of absence from 29 August 2017 to 17 November 2017 when he went to Senegal, the Applicant has remained in Australia on a continuous basis since his initial arrival in 2008.[1] He has spent something like 16 of his 48 years in Australia which means he has spent a third of his life in this country.

    [1] R1, p 135.

    PROCEDURAL HISTORY

  2. The Applicant’s Visa history in this country has transpired thus:

    ·8 September 2020:…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ba and Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultur... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] AATA 2507
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by the Applicant, Ba, for judicial review of a decision by the Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs to refuse to revoke the mandatory cancellation of his visa. The Applicant had failed to pass the character test due to his criminal history. The core of the dispute revolved around whether there was "another reason" to revoke the mandatory cancellation, as contemplated by the relevant provisions of the *Migration Act 1958* (Cth) and Ministerial Direction No. 99.

The court was required to determine whether the Applicant had established "another reason" to revoke the mandatory cancellation of his visa. This involved assessing various factors, including the impediments the Applicant would face upon removal to his home country, Mauritania, his health conditions, his family circumstances, and the risk of recidivism. The court also had to consider the nature and seriousness of the Applicant's past conduct and the potential risk to the Australian community should he re-offend.

In its reasoning, the court applied Ministerial Direction No. 99, which outlines considerations for revoking a mandatory visa cancellation. The court found that the Applicant's evidence regarding his exile from Mauritania, his lack of documentation, and his inability to establish himself or access essential services there, including healthcare and employment, presented significant impediments to his return. Furthermore, the court acknowledged the Applicant's substantial physical and mental health issues, which were supported by medical evidence, and concluded that these conditions would impede his resettlement in Mauritania. While the Applicant's criminal history, which included driving offences, property offences, and violent offending, was characterised as "very serious," the court also noted that the risk of recidivism was not considered significant, particularly if his alcohol consumption remained under control. The court weighed these factors against the primary consideration of protecting the Australian community, ultimately finding that the impediments to removal, coupled with the Applicant's health issues and the limited risk of re-offending, constituted "another reason" to revoke the mandatory cancellation.

The court set aside the Minister's decision and substituted a decision to revoke the mandatory cancellation of the Applicant's visa.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Paragraph 9.2 of the Direction directs a decision-maker to take into account the extent of any impediments that the non-citizen may face if removed from Australia to their home country, in establishing themselves and maintaining basic living standards (in the context of what is generally available to other citizens of that country), taking into account: (a)the non-citizen’s age and health; (b)whether there are any substantial language or cultural barriers; and (c)any social, medical and/or economic support available to that non-citizen in that country.The Applicant’s evidence In his most recent statement made on 9 October 2023, the Applicant says the following:‘93.I am not able to return to Mauritania as I was exiled from there in 1989 when they forced my family to leave and to cross the border into Senegal. I do not have any documentation that identifies me as a citizen there and I do not wish to seek this out after what I have gone through in my life and the trauma it has caused to me and my family.94.I cannot return to Mauritania. I would not be able to earn a living to support myself, I would have no accommodation, I would have difficulties finding a job and accessing health care and mental health care services. I would not be able to support my children financially, including by sending money for my young son to have surgery on his throat. I would also lose the opportunity to be in [Child W]’s life and be a father to her, which would cause me considerable distress if I was permanently separated from her.’[163][163] A2, p 13 [93]-[94]. Paragraph 9.2(1)(a): In the Applicant’s SFIC the following contentions are made:‘In this case, the impediments to removal should attract significant weight because the Applicant is likely to face severe economic hardship, difficulty finding employment, and difficulty living a normal life due to a lack of basic services irrespective of any impediments. This includes difficulty accessing medical treatment for the following conditions: (a)Non-cirrhotic portal hypertension secondary to schistosomiasis; (b)Multiple liver lesions that are likely adenomas; (c)Hepatitis B; (d)Likely depression; (e)Iron deficiency (Anaemia); and (f)Cluster headaches or severe migraines.’ [164][Internal citations omitted][164] A1, p 9 [51]. In terms of mental health diagnoses, it will be recalled that Dr Davis is of the opinion that the Applicant currently meets the criteria for three diagnoses, they being (1) Complex Post-Traumatic Disorder; (2) Persistent Depressive Disorder (with anxious distress); and (3) Panic Disorder. The Applicant is currently 48 years of age. His abovementioned physical health symptoms, especially his liver disease which he says is a result of him drinking contaminated water in Africa, can be taken at face value because, to my mind, they are adequately supported by the evidence. Likewise his mental health diagnoses as made by Dr Davis with which I will not cavil. Such is the nature and extent of the Applicant’s physical and mental health issues that it can now be safely found they will impede his capacity to return and resettlement in Mauritania. As against that, he is of an age (48-years) where his constitution and overall capacity to deal with or live with those conditions is still something that works in his favour. But for the purposes of the present paragraph 9.2(a), I am of the view that the Applicant’s combined physical and mental health issue will impede his return and resettlement in Mauritania.

Decision

Reasons for decision

It seems common ground between the parties that paragraphs (f), (g) and (h) are not relevant to the instant determination. I agree and will put these paragraphs to one side for present purposes.Conclusion about the nature and seriousness of the Applicant’s conduct I have applied each of the relevant paragraphs appearing in paragraph 8.1.1(1) of the Direction to the evidence. The relevant paragraphs applicable to the instant facts safely lead me to the conclusion (and finding) that the totality of this Applicant’s unlawful conduct in this country can be readily characterised as ‘very serious’. I so find.The risk to the Australian community should the Applicant commit further offences or engage in other serious conduct Paragraph 8.1.2(1) provides that in considering the risk to the Australian community, a decision-maker should have regard to the Government’s view that the Australian community’s tolerance for any risk of future harm becomes lower as the seriousness of the potential harm increases. Some conduct and the harm that would be caused, if it were to be repeated, is so serious that any risk of it being repeated may be unacceptable. Paragraph 8.1.2(2) provides that in considering the risk to the Australian community, a decision-maker must have regard to the three following factors on a cumulative basis:(a)the nature of the harm to individuals or the Australian community should the non-citizen engage in further criminal or other serious conduct; (b)the likelihood of the non-citizen engaging in further criminal or other serious conduct, taking into account:(i) information and evidence on the risk of the non-citizen re-offending; and(ii) evidence of rehabilitation achieved by the time of the decision, giving weight to time spent in the community since the most recent offence; and(c)where consideration is being given to whether to refuse to grant a visa to the non-citizen – whether the risk of harm may be affected by the duration and purpose of the non-citizen’s intended stay, the type of visa being applied for, and whether there are strong or compassionate reasons for granting a short stay visa.The nature of the harm to individuals or the Australian community were the Applicant to engage in further criminal or other serious conduct There is a multitude of harms that the Australian community would experience if this Applicant resumed his pattern of offending from the past. First, were he to again fail to meet the lawful and/or regulatory requirements relating to the ownership and/or operation of a motor vehicle, the community’s policing and judicial sentencing resources would again be needlessly consumed by conduct the Applicant could easily remedy by a simple visit (in person) to his state Transport Department (or equivalent) or, even more likely in this digital age, the Applicant could remedy that conduct by meeting these lawful/regulatory requirements online. Second, I do not need to verbalise the now decades-long governmental campaign against the often dreadful and/or fatal consequences of drink-driving. Were he to repeat this conduct, the Applicant could fatally hurt himself, other road users (be they passengers or drivers) as well as pedestrians merely accessing a thoroughfare on foot. Recommission of such conduct can realistically have catastrophic consequences. Third, the community’s respective apparatus in the realm of policing and even judicial sentencing would again be consumed were he to recommit of any of the balance of his offending.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Paragraph 9 of the Direction sets out four Other Considerations which must be taken into account. These considerations are:(a)legal consequences of the decision;(b)extent of impediments if removed;(c)impact on victims; and(d)impact on Australian business interests.PRIMARY CONSIDERATION 1: PROTECTION OF THE AUSTRALIAN COMMUNITY In considering this Primary Consideration 1, paragraph 8.1(1) of the Direction compels decision-makers to keep in mind the Government is committed to protecting the Australian community from harm as a result of criminal activity or other serious conduct by non-citizens. Decision-makers should have particular regard to the principle that entering or remaining in Australia is a privilege that this country confers on non-citizens in the expectation that they are, and have been, law abiding, that they will respect important institutions and that they will not cause or threaten harm to individuals or the Australian community. In determining the weight allocable to this Primary Consideration 1, paragraph 8.1(2) of the Direction requires decision-makers to consider:(a)the nature and seriousness of the non-citizen’s conduct to date; and(b)the risk to the Australian community should the non-citizen commit further offences or engage in other serious conduct. Before considering the above two elements: (1) nature of seriousness of the conduct; and (2) recidivist risk it is pertinent to reach an understanding of the nature and totality of the Applicant’s unlawful conduct in this country.The Applicant’s offending – an overview The parameters of the Applicant’s offending may be stated as follows:·total number of offences: 30;·total offending period (in terms of sentencing episodes): February 2010 – September 2020;·total number of sentencing episodes: 18;·total head custodial time imposed during the sentencing history: 22 months;·totality of fines imposed during the sentencing period: $11,250; and·total period of disqualification from driving: 57 months (or six years and seven months). The nature of his offending comprises the following:·driving offences:15;oof these 15 driving offences six of them were for drink-driving, five of which were in the middle range and one in the low range;·property offences: four; othese four offences were convicted as ‘gains benefit by fraud (x2)’ and ‘stealing (x2)’.·violent offending: three;othese three offences were convicted as ‘being armed or pretending to be armed in a way that may cause fear (x1)’ and ‘acts of omission causing bodily harm to any person (x2)’.·regulatory-type offences: eight;othese offences were convicted as ‘disorderly behaviour in public (x1)’, ‘false name (x1)’, ‘breach of police order (x3)’, ‘give false personal details to police (x1)’, ‘fail to obey order given by an officer (x1)’ and ‘breach of bail (x1)’. The criminal history indicates the first 28 of the Applicant’s convictions were exclusively punished by way of the imposition of monetary fines with nine of those imposed fines being accompanied by a period of disqualification from driving. The sole custodial term he received arose from respective convictions imposed by the Perth District Court on 3 September 2020 on two counts of ‘acts or omissions causing bodily harm or danger to any person’. The head custodial term was 22 months. The learned sentencing Judge, Her Honour Justice Gillan DCJ, noted the following in formulating a regime of sentencing for the Applicant:‘Now, you entered pleas of guilty on 5 May 2020. And it’s been conceded by the State that your plea of guilty was at the earliest reasonable opportunity. And you will get a substantial discount for that. And I also accept that you are remorseful and sorry for you actions. I accept that because you don’t have prior offences of violence, and because of your guilty plea, and because of what you told the pre-sentence report writer.I’ve considered some other issues. For instance, your risk of reoffending. I don’t think that you are a significant risk of reoffending in this way, as long as your alcohol consumption is under control. So that’s something that you are going to have to continue to work on.’[9][9] R1, p 40.