B & M PROPERTY ENTERPRISES PTY LTD
(IN LIQUIDATION) v PETTINGILL
[2001] SASC 75
Civil
1................ PERRY J.......................... This is an action by the liquidator of a company to secure vacant possession of a suburban house property occupied by the defendant Scott Aaron Pettingill, of which the company is the registered proprietor in fee simple (“the Nelson Road property”).
BACKGROUND
In 1992, Mr Malcolm Pettingill, the father of Scott Pettingill, wished to purchase some properties for investment. He approached a chartered accountant, Mr Bruce Adam, who at that time had been acting for the Pettingill family for some 12 to 18 months, to assist in obtaining a company with a view to it becoming the trading entity through which the investment properties might be acquired.
Mr Adam had on hand, as it were, a company, Dr J.S. Wallace Pty Ltd, which another client no longer wished to retain. On the instructions of Mr Malcolm Pettingill, he arranged for a change of name of the company to B & M Property Enterprises Pty Ltd (“B & M”). A certificate of registration on change of name was issued on 1 October 1992.
There were two shareholders; Mr Adam and Mr Malcolm Pettingill’s daughter, Mrs Marie Ann McLaughlin. Mr Adam was appointed secretary. Mrs McLaughlin and the defendant, Scott Pettingill, were appointed directors effective from 28 August 1992, which was before the change of name.
The defendant alleges that a meeting of directors was held at Mr Adam’s office on 6 September 1992, and that those present were, apart from himself, Mr Adam, Mr Malcolm Pettingill and the defendant. Mrs McLaughlin, who lives in Queensland, purported to participate in the meeting by telephone.
The defendant tendered in evidence what purport to be minutes of the meeting, which read as follows:
“It was resolved that the company contract to purchase a property at 111 Nelson Road, Valley View in South Australia, the company acting as Trustee for Scott Aaron Pettingill.”
No contract evidencing the purchase was tendered at the trial, but a transfer dated 6 October 1992 was executed by the then registered proprietors. It records the consideration for the purchase as $100,000.
The transfer was accepted by B & M under its common seal. This was not regularly affixed, as Mr Malcolm Pettingill signed as one of the attesting directors when it is clear that he did not hold office as such until 1997. The other attesting director was Scott Pettingill. The same irregularity appears on the face of a registered Memorandum of Mortgage, apparently executed on the same day, which records a loan by several mortgagees of $126,000. That is a surprising figure, given the consideration expressed in the transfer.
There is no evidence to displace the assumption which I consider that I am entitled to make, namely, that the balance of the mortgage advance over and above the $100,000 purchase price of the Nelson Road property, was applied by B & M for its own purposes.
The defendant tendered in evidence…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read B & M Property Enterprises Pty Ltd (in liq) v Pettingill and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2001] SASC 75
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court concluded that the evidence did not support the authenticity of the minutes of the directors' meeting or the declaration of trust. Even if the documents were authentic, the declaration of trust was ineffective because it did not immediately transfer the beneficial interest to Scott Pettingill. The company retained control and benefits from the property, which undermined the declaration of trust. The court also noted procedural irregularities in the meeting and breaches of fiduciary duty by Scott Pettingill, but these did not affect the outcome as the declaration of trust was ineffective for other reasons.
The court ordered Scott Pettingill to vacate the property and dismissed his counterclaim. The liquidator was permitted to enter possession of the property, but the court directed that an inquiry be conducted to assess any payments made by Scott Pettingill during his occupation, which could result in reimbursement from the proceeds of any sale of the property. The court emphasized that the decision was based on the ineffectiveness of the declaration of trust and not on the credibility of the parties or the procedural irregularities.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi