B & L ARMANINI INVESTMENTS PTY LTD (Migration) [2023] AATA 4329 (18 December 2023)
DECISION RECORD
DIVISION:Migration & Refugee Division
APPLICANT: B & L Armanini Investments Pty Ltd
REPRESENTATIVE: Mr Manoj Kumar Nanda (MARN: 1568823)
CASE NUMBER: 2109246
HOME AFFAIRS REFERENCE(S): BCC2020/1898222
MEMBER:Katie Malyon
DATE:18 December 2023
PLACE OF DECISION: Sydney
DECISION:The Tribunal affirms the decision not to approve the nomination.
Statement made on 18 December 2023 at 4:29 pm
This is an application for review of a decision made by a delegate of the Minister for Home Affairs on 1 July 2021 to refuse to approve the applicant’s nomination under s 140GB of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (the Act) and reg 2.72 of the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth) (the Regulations).
The applicant, B & L Armanini Investments Pty ltd ABN 45 526 226 387 (the Company), applied for approval on 14 July 2020. A nomination of an occupation for a Subclass 482 visa is made under s 140GB of the Act and reg 2.73 of the Regulations. The occupation must be nominated for a Subclass 482 visa in one of 3 alternative streams: the Short-term stream; the Medium-term stream; or, the Labour Agreement stream. Regulation 2.72 prescribes general and stream-specific criteria that must be satisfied for the Minister to approve a nomination by a person. These criteria are extracted in the Attachment to this decision. Additional criteria are specified in s 140GBA of the Act. In this case, the Company nominated Estonian national George Vainaru to work in the nominated occupation of Accommodation and Hospitality Manager nec ANZSCO 141999.
The delegate decided not to approve the Company’s nomination on the basis that it did not meet reg 2.72(10)(a) of the Regulations because, after reviewing the evidence provided in support of the nomination, the delegate was not satisfied that the majority of the tasks that the nominee Mr Vainaru is likely to perform in the position, or the skill or responsibility level required, are commensurate with those of the nominated occupation of Accommodation and Hospitality Manager ANZSCO 141999. As a consequence, the delegate was not satisfied that the position is genuine. A copy of the delegate’s decision was provided to the Tribunal.
Following the delegate’s refusal of its nomination, the Company sought review of that refusal to the Tribunal. Despite the delegate clearly articulating the reasons for refusing the Company’s nomination, no documentation whatsoever was lodged with the Tribunal in support of the review application, apart from the copy of the delegate’s decision. This is inconsistent with cl 5.1(a) of the Tribunal’s Practice Direction – Migration and Refugee Matters dated 1 August 2018.
The Tribunal’s s 359(2) letter
To enable the Tribunal to assess whether the Company currently meets all of the relevant requirements for approval of its nomination, the Tribunal wrote to the Company pursuant to
s 359(2) of the Act on 16 October 2023. It invited the Company to provide updated and current information addressing all of…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read B & L ARMANINI INVESTMENTS PTY LTD (Migration) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2023] AATA 4329
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues before the Tribunal were whether the nominated position was genuine and full-time, as required by regulation 2.72(10) of the Regulations. The Tribunal also considered whether the nominee's tasks and the skill level of the position corresponded to the nominated occupation of Accommodation and Hospitality Manager nec ANZSCO 141999. The Tribunal had invited the Company to provide updated information addressing these criteria, but no response was received.
The Tribunal applied the principles established in *Cargo First Pty Ltd v MIBP* [2016] FCA 30, which affirmed a qualitative assessment of a nominated position to determine its genuineness. Regulation 2.72(10)(a) requires the position to be genuine, and regulation 2.72(10)(b) requires it to be full-time, unless this requirement can be reasonably disregarded. In this instance, the Tribunal was not satisfied that the Company had demonstrated the position was both genuine and full-time, nor that the tasks and skill level aligned with the nominated occupation.
Consequently, the Tribunal affirmed the delegate's decision to refuse the nomination. The Tribunal found that the Company had not met the applicable criteria for its nomination to be approved.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter before the Tribunal is an appeal against a decision made by the delegate of the Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Migrant Services, dated 15 September 2023, to refuse the nomination by B & L Armanini Investments Pty Ltd of Mr Vainaru for a Subclass 457 (Temporary Work (Skilled)) visa under the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) and the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth). The delegate's decision was made pursuant to section 140GA of the Act and regulation 2.72 of the Regulations. Following the delegate’s refusal, the Company lodged an application for review of that decision with the Migration Review Tribunal under section 384 of the Act. The Tribunal conducted a review of the decision and heard evidence and submissions from the Company, ultimately affirming the delegate’s decision to refuse the nomination. The Tribunal found that the Company did not meet the criteria for approval of the nomination, particularly in relation to the requirements that the nominated position must be genuine and full-time. The Tribunal’s decision to affirm the delegate's decision is now the subject of this appeal.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (the Tribunal) considered whether the nomination of Mr Vainaru as an Accommodation and Hospitality Manager by B & L Armanini Investments Pty Ltd (the Company) should be approved. The Tribunal ultimately affirmed the decision to refuse the nomination based on the Company's failure to meet the criteria outlined in regulation 2.72 of the Migration Regulations 1994.
First, the Tribunal examined whether the nominated position aligned with the occupation of Accommodation and Hospitality Manager (ANZSCO 141999). Regulation 2.72(10)(a) mandates that the position must be genuine. The Tribunal followed the approach from Cargo First Pty Ltd v MIBP [2016] FCA 30, where the Federal Court upheld a qualitative assessment of the position against the nominated occupation to determine its genuineness. However, the Tribunal found that the majority of the tasks Mr Vainaru was likely to perform, or the skill and responsibility level required, did not align with the occupation of Accommodation and Hospitality Manager, and thus, the position was not genuine.
Second, the Tribunal considered whether the nominated position was genuinely required by the business. Regulation 2.72(10)(a) requires that the position be genuine and not created solely for the purpose of employing the nominee. The Tribunal did not find sufficient evidence to conclude that the position was genuinely required by the business.
Third, the Tribunal assessed whether the nominated position was a full-time position as required by regulation 2.72(10)(b). Although the Tribunal did not find any evidence suggesting that the position was not full-time, it was not satisfied that the position met the full-time requirement due to the lack of evidencing the nominee performing the role.
Fourth, the Tribunal reviewed whether the Company met all the criteria for approval of the nomination as outlined in regulation 2.72 of the Migration Regulations 1994. The Tribunal noted that the Company did not provide updated financial information or other relevant information in response to the Tribunal’s request. Without such information, the Tribunal was unable to determine whether the Company met the applicable criteria for approval of the nomination.
Finally, the Tribunal concluded that the decision to refuse the nomination should be upheld based on the evidence and arguments presented. The Tribunal found that the Company had not demonstrated that the position associated with the occupation was genuine and full-time as required by regulation 2.72(10) of the Regulations. Therefore, the Tribunal affirmed the decision to refuse the nomination.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that for a nomination to be approved, the nominated position must align with the occupation, be genuinely required by the business, and be a full-time position. If any of these criteria are not met, the nomination can be refused. Additionally, the Tribunal must be satisfied that the company has provided sufficient evidence to demonstrate that all the criteria for approval have been met.