Background
Background to the litigation
This is an application for review of a decision made by the Immigration Assessment Authority. In that decision, the Authority affirmed a decision of a delegate of the Minister not to grant the applicant a Safe Haven Enterprise Visa (“SHEV”).BACKGROUND In his submissions filed on 7 April 2025, the applicant provided the following background to this matter:1. The applicant is a citizen of Sri Lanka, and is of Tamil ethnicity. In June of 2013, the applicant arrived in Australia. In February of 2017, he applied for a protection visa, being a Safe Haven Enterprise Visa (SHEV). On 27 July 2017, a delegate of the Minister refused the visa on the ground that, in the delegate’s assessment, the applicant was not owed protection obligations within ss 36(2)(a) or (aa) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (the Act). That decision was a fast track reviewable decision, and the Department of Immigration and Border Protection referred that decision to the Immigration Assessment Authority (the Authority) for merits review on that basis.2. On 19 February 2018, and without a further hearing, the Authority (Reviewer, Mr Currie) decided to affirm the delegate’s decision to not issue a protection visa to the applicant. The applicant’s claims for protection before the Authority are summarised at CB351-2 [8], and included that, on the applicants account of events: (a) in 2007, the applicant joined the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Elam (LTTE), whereupon he was: trained as a spy; allocated to an intelligence gathering unit and sent to Vavuniya undercover, in order to collect information on Government troop movements in the area;(b) in 2009, a former member of the LTTE informed on the applicant to the Government of Sri Lanka;(c) in August 2009, the applicant departed Sri Lanka for Saudi Arabia with the assistance of an agent. The applicant resided in Saudi Arabia until August 2010, and then returned to Sri Lanka;(d) after the applicant’s return to Sri Lanka, he was chased by members of the Sri Lankan Army, and in October 2010 fled Sri Lanka again, this time to India. He resided in India until 2013, when he travelled by boat to Australia;(e) the applicant fears that, if returned to Sri Lanka, he would be detained, tortured and killed by the Sri Lankan authorities for his spying on behalf of the LTTE. 3. Before the Authority made its decision, the applicant provided the Authority with additional materials. These were documents that were not before the delegate when the delegate had made their decision. One such document was provided to the Authority on 23 November 2017, and is identified in the Authority’s reasons as document “CR3”. That document is at CB298-336. Saliently, the document, on its face:(a) was marked as being a document of the applicant’s then representatives, WLW Migration Lawyers;(b) quoted a then contemporary statement (dated 14 August 2017) attributed to “UNP MP and minister Vijayakala Maheswaran”: “If they are LTTE, identify and slaughter them, we won’t come to question that” (CB 299);(c) described Sri Lanka as topping the list of countries from which the NGO Freedom From Torture received referrals of victims of torture in 2016 (CB 299);(d) described the International Truth and Justice Project’s then apparently contemporary allegations that “torture and arrests continue in Sri Lanka… with the International Truth and Justice Project alone documenting at least 35 cases of Tamils being tortured” (CB 300);(e) described London Associated Press reporting (from November of 2017, on the face of CR3, CB 303-307) on abuses experienced by more than 50 Tamil men seeking asylum in Europe and who say they were abducted and tortured under Sri Lanka’s then current government (CB303-307);(f) described the International Truth and Justice Project’s then most recent report (dated in CR3 as being published in July 2017) as highlighting that Tamils were abducted and tortured for a range of reasons including, presently relevantly, returning from the diaspora (CB 320);(g) described the International Truth and Justice Project as having found in its latest report (CB 326): “that torture and rape of Tamils in Sri Lanka has continued into 2017. The damning report is based on 24 statements from victims of torture that occurred in 2016 and 2017, and reinforced by 33 statements from 2015 victims of torture at the hands of the Sri Lankan authorities.…The torture included beatings with sticks, the use of stress positions, asphyxiation using plastic bags drenched in kerosene, the extraction of fingernails, the use of water torture, the suspension of individuals for several hours by their thumbs and the mutilation of genitals…” (h) attributed to Ben Emmerson the following quote (with Ben Emmerson being identified in CR3 as the United Nations Special Rapporteur on human rights and counter-terrorism (CB 256), and the quote being attributed to reporting by The Guardian newspaper on 14 July 2017 (CB 256, fn 94)):“Entire communities have been stigmatised and targeted for harassment and arbitrary arrest and detention and any person suspected of association, however indirect, with the LTTE remains at immediate risk of detention and torture” 4. In being presented with this new information, the Authority was required to deal with it in accordance with s 473DD of the Act. That section provided:For the purposes of making a decision in relation to a fast track reviewable decision, the Immigration Assessment Authority must not consider any new information unless:(a) the Authority is satisfied that there are exceptional circumstances to justify considering the new information; and (b) the referred applicant satisfies the Authority that, in relation to any new information given, or proposed to be given, to the Authority by the referred applicant, the new information:(i) was not, and could not have been, provided to the Minister before the Minister made the decision under section 65; or (ii)is credible personal information which was not previously known and, had it been known, may have affected the consideration of the referred applicant’s claims. 5. The Authority already had before it a country information report prepared by the Department of Foreign Affairs & Trade, referred to in the Authority’s reasons as: “Department of Foreign Affairs & Trade (DFAT) “Sri Lanka - Country Information Report”, 24 January 2017, CISEDB50AD105”: CB 354. That DFAT Report is annexed to an affidavit filed by the applicant together with these submissions.6. The Authority declined to consider CR3. The Authority’s reasons were as follows (CB351, [6]-[7]) •Having reviewed CR3 I am satisfied that the substantive arguments about the present situation in Sri Lanka contained within the report is consistent with a range of other information which was before the Minister at the time of the delegates decision. I observe that the report does not engage with any of the applicant’s claims directly, other than in very brief concluding remarks. The vast majority of the report contains general country information, and does not deal with matters which have direct bearing on the applicant’s claims. I consider that CR3 is inflammatory, and uses selective sourcing to arrive at its conclusions. I am not satisfied it is a representative sample of recent material about conditions in Sri Lanka and I am unpersuaded by argument contained in the concluding remarks of CR3 to the effect that the most recent DFAT report used by the delegate is not accurate and that CR3 should be used in preference to the DFAT report.•None of the information in the applicant’s submission or any of the correspondence sent by his representative outlines any matters or points to any exceptional circumstances which might justify the use of this material. No exceptional circumstances are apparent to me in this case. I am not satisfied that any exceptional circumstances exist for me to consider the report and so s.473DD(a) is not met, and I am prevented from doing so. 7. Noting that some of the applicant’s claims relate to his employment with and later membership of the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Elam (LTTE), I have obtained a document titled An Institutional History of the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (LTTE) published in 2014 by the Centre of Conflict, Development and Peacebuilding in Geneva which outlines an organisational history of the LTTE. The document provides credible independent reporting which bears directly on specific aspects of the applicant’s claims, and which is not covered in other material before me. I am satisfied that exceptional circumstances exist to consider this material.(footnotes omitted)
Decision
Reasons for decision
Section 473CC of the Act provided that:Review of decision (1) The Immigration Assessment Authority must review a fast track reviewable decision referred to the Authority under section 473CA.(2) The Immigration Assessment Authority may:(a) affirm the fast track reviewable decision; or (b) remit the decision for reconsideration in accordance with such directions or recommendations of the Authority as are permitted by regulation. Paragraphs 20, 21, 37 and 56 of the Authority’s reasons for decision are as follows:20. The applicant has provided some conflicting evidence about this period. In his SHEV application he suggests that whilst he was in Vavuniya his cover identity was that he was employed as a stonemason. At interview he describes this employment as a façade which was facilitated by [a] pro-LTTE employer. In other sections of the interview, he claims that he was given a fake NGO identity card, and was instructed to use the card to explain his presence in Vavuniya and to indicate his employment if he was questioned. Whilst these different explanations of the same events are troubling, I concede that they are not necessarily contradictory. General country information reports that Vavuniya Township had been occupied by government forces by mid-2008 with the front afterwards moving north.21. Having considered the applicant’s evidence on this the matter of his spying for the LTTE, I have some doubts. I note that when discussing his work at in the customs checkpoint role, the applicant was able to provide lots of detail about the day to day activities of the position. However, when discussing his spying role, he has provided less information, his explanations have been vaguer and he has not been entirely consistent (as noted in the preceding paragraph). Whilst the applicant's claims about this period as a spy for the LTTE seem a little improbable and are not supported by any independent evidence, I observe that the applicant has consistently repeated the basic premise of this claim since his arrival in Australia, including at his 20 June 2013 Screening Interview, his 28 August 2013 Entry Interview, his February 2017 SHEV application and his May 2017 protection visa interview. However, I note that at interview he has claimed his training for the role lasted approximately one month from which I conclude that should not be described as a spy (in the conventional understanding of this word). Given the applicant's consistency on this issue and his other evidence, I am prepared to accept some aspects of this claim. I conclude that the applicant was responsible for the conduct of limited observation tasks with a limited risk profile, rather than a wider undercover role where he might be forced to engage regularly with the Government forces. After careful consideration, I accept that the applicant was employed between 2007 and the end of the conflict in 2009 in Vavuniya on observational tasks. I note that the applicant did not face any harm during this period arising from this role. … 37. Regarding the applicant’s claim that his mother advised him that he was of interest to the Sri Lankan authorities (outlined in paragraph 29), I note that the applicant’s SHEV application states that the authorities’ interest in him arose, not because of any previous intelligence about the applicant, or any suspicion of his LTTE related activities, rather because the officer who spoke to his mother was conducting a check of family identity cards for camp residents, during the check the officer noted the applicant's absence from the camp and merely asked about his whereabouts. Furthermore, unlike the account in his SHEV application, the applicant claimed that former LTTE personnel, who were working with the authorities at that time, visited his parents in the camp, and informed them that the applicant was wanted by the CID. I am not satisfied by the applicant's different explanations of this event. The applicant has not satisfied me that he is being truthful. I note that in both instances, the applicant has added new details to his claims whilst at interview and that cumulatively these additional claims tend to imply that the applicant was under greater suspicion than in his earlier SHEV application. I conclude that that the applicant has exaggerated the level of interest the authorities had in him at this time, in order to enhance his claims for protection in Australia. …56. Overall, I would characterise much of the applicant's evidence as misleading and exaggerated. I observe that evidence given by the applicant at his protection visa interview tends to suggest that he was at significantly higher risk, was under a greater level of suspicion and required special assistance to enter and leave Sri Lanka than the claims from his earlier SHEV application. I do not accept these claims by the applicant and conclude that they have been made by him in order to strengthen his claims for protection in Australia. Overall I do not find the applicant to be a credible witness.