Ayana (Migration)

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

Ayana (Migration) [2020] AATA 618 (7 February 2020)

DECISION RECORD

DIVISION:Migration & Refugee Division

REVIEW APPLICANT:  Mrs Raheal Worku Ayana

VISA APPLICANTS:  Mr Tibebu Tesfaye Kibret
Ms Habte Kasu Tesfaye
Master Abayneh Kasu Tesfaye

CASE NUMBER:  1807832

DIBP REFERENCE(S):  BCC2016/1935202

MEMBER:Christine Kannis

DATE:7 February 2020

PLACE OF DECISION:  

DECISION:The Tribunal remits the applications for Partner (Provisional) (Class UF) visas for reconsideration, with the direction that the first named visa applicant meets the following criteria for a Subclass 309 (Partner (Provisional)) visa:

·Public Interest Criterion 4020 for the purposes of cl.309.225 of Schedule 2 to the Regulations; and

the second and third named applicants meet the     following criteria:

·Public Interest Criterion 4020 for the purposes of cl.309.323 of Schedule 2 to the Regulations.

Statement made on 07 February 2020 at 6:43am

LEGISLATION

Migration Act 1958 (Cth), ss 5, 65
Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth), Schedule 2 cls 309.225, 309.323, Public Interest Criterion (PIC) 4020

CASES

Arora v MIBP [2016] FCAFC 35
Batra v MIAC [2013] FCA 274
Rani v MIBP [2015] FCCA 445
Sandhu v MIMAC [2013] FCCA 491
Trivedi v MIBP [2014] FCAFC 42

STATEMENT OF DECISION AND REASONS

APPLICATION FOR REVIEW

  1. This is an application for review of a decision made by a delegate of the Minister for Immigration on 26 January 2018 to refuse to grant the visa applicants Partner (Provisional) (Class UF) visas under s.65 of the Migration Act 1958 (the Act).

  2. The first named visa applicant (the visa applicant) applied for the visas on 3 June 2016 on the basis of his relationship with his sponsor, the review applicant. At that time, Class UF contained only one subclass: Subclass 309 (Partner (Provisional). The criteria for the grant of this visa are set out in Part 309 of Schedule 2 to the Migration Regulations 1994 (the Regulations). The primary criteria must be satisfied by at least one applicant. The second and third named applicants need satisfy only the secondary criteria.

  3. The visas were refused on the basis that the visa applicant did not satisfy cl.309.225 because the delegate found the visa applicant did not meet public interest criterion (PIC) 4020.

  4. The review applicant appeared before the Tribunal on 9 December 2019 to give evidence and present arguments. The Tribunal also received oral evidence from the visa applicant by telephone from Ethiopia and from Mr Asregedewaya Lew, Mr Ayele Tefera, Ms Aklil Kelifa and Mr Mulugeta Gebremariam. The Tribunal was assisted by an interpreter in the Amharic and English languages.

  5. The review applicant was represented in relation to the review by her registered migration agent.

  6. For the following reasons, the Tribunal has concluded that the matter should be remitted for reconsideration.

    CONSIDERATION OF CLAIMS AND EVIDENCE

    The law

  7. The issue in this review is whether the applicant meets PIC 4020 as required by cl.309.225 for the grant of the visa. Broadly speaking this requires that:

    ·there is no evidence that the applicant has given, or caused to be given, to the Minister, an officer, the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ayana (Migration) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] AATA 618
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal reviewed a decision to refuse a Partner (Provisional) (Class UF) visa, subclass 309. The applicant sought to have the visa granted, but the delegate had refused it on the grounds that the provided school records for the secondary applicants were bogus documents, thus failing to satisfy Public Interest Criterion (PIC) 4020.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether the applicant met PIC 4020, which requires that no bogus documents or materially false or misleading information be provided in relation to the visa application or a previous visa held within a specified period. The Tribunal also considered the definition of a "bogus document" under section 5(1) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth), which includes documents obtained because of a false or misleading statement, without requiring proof of knowledge or intent by the applicant.

The Tribunal reasoned that while PIC 4020 does not necessitate a finding of deliberate untruthfulness by the applicant, it does require an element of fraud or deception by some person. The delegate had refused the visa after departmental checks indicated the school records were non-genuine, as the signatory was unknown to the school, there was no record of the applicants attending, and the documents did not originate from the school. In response, the applicant claimed the adverse report was due to ethnic bias against their Amhara/Oromo background, providing subsequent documentation from the school and education department to support the applicants' attendance. The Tribunal concluded that the matter should be remitted for reconsideration.

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicant, a citizen of Ethiopia, lodged an application for a Partner (Provisional) (Class UF) visa under Subclass 309 (Spouse (Provisional)). The application included school records for the second and third named applicants, purportedly issued by Qiqi Primary School in Ethiopia. The Department of Home Affairs visited the school to verify the authenticity of these records and discovered inconsistencies indicating that the documents were not genuine. Specifically, the signatory on the documents was unknown to the school, there was no record of the named applicants being students at the school, and the documents did not originate from the school. Based on these findings, the delegate refused the visa application on the grounds that the school records were bogus documents and that the applicant had failed to meet the requirements of Policy Instruction Circular 4020 (PIC 4020).

Prior to the final decision, the Department provided the applicant with an opportunity to address the concerns regarding the bogus documents and to present any compelling circumstances for waiving the requirement and granting the visas. The applicant responded by asserting that the adverse findings were a result of ethnic bias at the school. The applicant claimed that the previous school principal and senior staff were not supportive of the Department's investigation due to their ethnic affiliation, which is Amhara/Oromo. The applicant alleged that on 29 January 2018, they contacted the District Office of the Hawassa City Administration Education Department to complain about the school staff's failure to provide proper records of the secondary applicants’ attendance history. Following this complaint, on 9 March 2018, Mr Zerihun Kefyalewu from the Hawassa City Administration Education Department wrote to Qiqi Primary School to instruct them to provide the necessary records. Subsequently, the new principal at Qiqi Primary School, Mr Rahel Batiso Barassa, provided the required attendance history of the secondary applicants. Additionally, Mr Belachew Yohanes, a teacher at the school, confirmed his role as a teacher and provided a letter attesting to Abayneh Kasu Tesfaye's attendance and studies at the school in 2015-2016. Abayneh Kasu Tesfaye also provided a detailed letter describing the school environment and his attendance.

During the hearing, the applicant's representative presented further evidence to support the claim of ethnic bias. The representative highlighted the efforts made by the applicant to address the discrepancies through official channels and the subsequent cooperation from the new school principal and teacher. The representative argued that the previous adverse findings were due to ethnic bias and not indicative of any fraudulent intent by the applicant or the secondary applicants.

The matter before the court originated as an application for judicial review of a decision made by the Migration Review Tribunal (MRT) under the Migration Act 1958 (Cth). The applicant, who was a beneficiary of a visa application made by a visa applicant, sought to challenge the MRT's decision to refuse the visa application on the basis that the provided school records were non-genuine and constituted bogus documents. The MRT had concluded that the provided school records were non-genuine and had found that the applicant had failed to satisfy the character requirement under clause 4020 of the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth). The applicant argued that the MRT had erred in its decision by not considering the possibility of ethnic bias at the school, which led to the non-genuine school records. The matter was remitted back to the MRT for reconsideration. This decision was subsequently appealed to the Federal Circuit Court of Australia, which affirmed the Tribunal's decision to remit the matter back to the MRT for reconsideration. The Federal Circuit Court held that while the MRT had considered the possibility of ethnic bias, it had not adequately addressed the issue in relation to the non-genuine school records. The court found that the MRT had erred in its decision and remitted the matter back to the MRT for reconsideration.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

For the following reasons, the Tribunal has concluded that the matter should be remitted for reconsideration.CONSIDERATION OF CLAIMS AND EVIDENCEThe law The issue in this review is whether the applicant meets PIC 4020 as required by cl.309.225 for the grant of the visa. Broadly speaking this requires that:·there is no evidence that the applicant has given, or caused to be given, to the Minister, an officer, the Tribunal, a relevant assessing authority, or Medical officer of the Commonwealth, a bogus document or information that is false or misleading in a material particular in relation to the application for the visa or a visa that the applicant held in the 12 months before the application was made: cl.4020(1); and·the applicant and each member of the family unit has not been refused a visa because of a failure to satisfy cl.4020(1) during the period starting 3 years before the application was made and ending when the visa is granted or refused, unless the applicant was under 18 at the time the application for the refused visa was made: cl.4020(2) and (2AA); and·the applicant satisfies the Minister as to his or her identity: cl.4020(2A); and ·neither the applicant nor any family unit member has been refused a visa because of a failure to satisfy cl.4020(2A) during the period starting 10 years before the application was made and ending when the visa is granted or refused, unless the applicant was under 18 at the time the application for the refused visa was made: cl.4020(2B) and (2BA). The term ‘information that is false or misleading in a material particular’ is defined in PIC 4020(5) and the term ‘bogus document’ is defined in s.5(1) of the Act. In contrast to the definition of ‘information that is false or misleading in a material particular’ in PIC 4020(5), the reference in the definition of bogus document to a document that was obtained because of a ‘false or misleading’ statement has no requirement that it be relevant to a criterion for the grant of the visa: Arora v MIBP [2016] FCAFC 35; Batra v MIAC [2013] FCA 274. Subsection 5(1) of the Act provides that a bogus document in relation to a person, means a document that the Minister reasonably suspects is a document that:(a) purports to have been, but was not, issued in respect of the person; or(b) is counterfeit or has been altered by a person who does not have authority to do so; or (c) was obtained because of a false or misleading statement, whether or not made knowingly. Subsection 5(1) does not require the requisite suspicion to be formed on the basis of information of any particular quality (Sandhu v MIMAC [2013] FCCA 491 (Judge Driver, 26 July 2013) at [43]).[1] There need only be a ‘reasonable suspicion’ of a document being bogus and it does not require the evidence to be such that the reasonable suspicion is of facts established on the balance of probabilities. Rather, all that is required is that it the evidence before the decision maker be sufficient to induce a suspicion of the kind a reasonable person may apprehend (Rani v MIBP [2015] FCCA 445 (Judge Driver, 2 March 2015) at [18]).[1] Undisturbed on appeal: Sandhu v MIMAC [2013] FCA 842 (Cowdroy J, 20 August 2013).

Decision

Reasons for decision

While PIC 4020 refers to information that is false, in the sense of purposely untrue, it is not necessary for the Minister (or the Tribunal on review) to conclude that the applicant was aware the information was purposely untrue in order for PIC 4020 to be engaged. However, an element of fraud or deception by some person is necessary to attract the operation of the provision: Trivedi v MIBP [2014] FCAFC 42.The delegate’s decision In support of his claim that the second and third named applicants met the definition of ‘member of a family unit’ as required by r.1.12, the visa applicant provided their school records with the visa application. The Department attended the school in Ethiopia and conducted checks to verify the second and third named applicants’ school records and during the course of these checks the Department found information that indicated the school records were non-genuine. Specifically, on 5 June 2017 an officer of the Department noted the following information;· The signatory appearing on the school records provided is not known to the school.· There is no record of either secondary applicant being a student at the school.· The documents (the school records) did not originate from the school. The delegate refused the visas on the basis that the school records of the second and third named applicants which purported to be records issued by Qiqi Primary School were bogus documents. In the absence of any information for application of the waiver provision the delegate found the visa applicant failed to satisfy PIC 4020.Information provided prior to hearing Prior to making the decision to refuse the visa the Department afforded the visa applicant an opportunity to comment on the adverse information in regard to the suspected bogus documents and to provide information as to whether there are any compelling circumstances to justify waiver and granting of the visas. In response the visa applicant claimed the adverse report from the school was based on the applicants' ethnic affiliation which is an Amhara/Oromo background. The following information was provided in a written submission dated 21 August 2018 from the applicants’ representative:·The visa applicant is a victim of ethnic discrimination by the previous principal/senior staff of Kike Primary School. Due to differences in ethnic background the previous principal/senior staff was not supportive when the Department visited the school.·On 29 January 2018 the visa applicant contacted the District Office of the Hawassa City Administration Education Department with a complaint that the Kike Primary School staff was not providing proper records of the secondary applicants’ history of attendance at the school. ·On 9 March 2018 Mr Zerihun Kefyalewu from the Hawassa City Administration Education Department wrote to the Kike Primary School instructing them to provide the necessary secondary applicants’ history of attendance to the visa applicant. ·On 9 March 2018 Mr Rahel Batiso Barassa (the new principal at the Kike Primary School) provided the necessary secondary applicants’ history of attendance: oThat Abayneh Kasu Tesfaye attended the school in year 3 in 2015 and year 4 in 2016 oThat Habte Kasu Tesfaye attended the pre-primary school in year in 2016 oThat they were given accompanying letter and left the school in 2017. ·On 12 June 2018 Mr Belachew Yohanes (teacher at Kike Primary School) provided a letter that says he is the current teacher at Kike Primary School in Hawassa city and that he was Abayneh Kasu Tesfaye’s teacher in the years 2015-2016 (grade 3 and 4). He also confirmed that Abayneh had a sister Habte also studying at the same school (but he did not teach Habte). ·On 15 June 2018 Abayneh Kasu Tesfaye provided a letter stating that he was a student at the Kiki Primary School during the years 2015-2016 and that he studied 3rd and 4th grade at the school. He explained the topography of the school – that it is fenced with tin sheets and is painted yellow and green, that when entering the gate on the left side there is a two-storey building of classrooms, that at the front is the offices and the library, that next to the library there are other classrooms and the kindergarten area, that between the gate and the two storey building there are flag posts that carry the Ethiopian and Southern Region flags, that behind the library and office are the playgrounds and toilets. Evidence at hearingReview applicant’s evidence

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Ayana (Migration), the Tribunal focused on whether the provision of non-genuine school records by the applicants constituted a 'bogus document' under the Migration Act, and whether the failure to satisfy PIC 4020 was a valid basis for the visa refusal. The Tribunal examined the definition of 'bogus document' under s.5(1) of the Act, which includes documents that were not issued, are counterfeit, altered without authority, or obtained due to a false or misleading statement. The Tribunal determined that the school records provided were indeed non-genuine, as they did not originate from the school, the signatories were unknown, and there was no record of the applicants being students there.

Regarding the element of fraud or deception, the Tribunal noted that while PIC 4020 requires false or misleading information, it does not necessarily require the applicant's awareness that the information was false. However, an element of fraud or deception by some person is necessary for the provision to apply. In this case, the Tribunal found no evidence of the applicants' direct involvement in any fraudulent activity, only that they were victims of ethnic discrimination, which led to the provision of incorrect records.

The Tribunal also considered whether the applicants' ethnic background, being Amhara/Oromo, could be a mitigating factor in their visa application. The applicants argued that the adverse report from the school was due to ethnic bias, and they had taken steps to rectify the situation by contacting the relevant education authorities. The Tribunal acknowledged the applicants' efforts to obtain correct records and their explanation regarding the school's discriminatory practices, which seemed to have affected the issuance of the school records.

The decision to refuse the visa based on the failure to satisfy PIC 4020 was deemed appropriate, given the circumstances that the school records were non-genuine. However, the Tribunal found that the decision did not adequately consider the new evidence and submissions presented, particularly the applicants' claims of ethnic bias and their efforts to obtain correct records. The Tribunal concluded that the matter should be remitted for reconsideration to allow the delegate to properly evaluate the new evidence and the applicants' explanations.

In conclusion, the ratio decidendi of this case is that while the provision of non-genuine school records does constitute a 'bogus document' under the Migration Act, the failure to satisfy PIC 4020 is not necessarily a valid basis for visa refusal if the applicants can demonstrate that they were not involved in any fraudulent activity and have taken steps to rectify the situation. The Tribunal's decision to remit the matter for reconsideration highlights the importance of considering new evidence and mitigating factors in visa applications. The Tribunal did not depart from prior authority but applied the principles established in previous cases, such as Arora v MIBP and Batra v MIAC, regarding the definition of 'bogus document' and the necessity of fraud or deception.