i
l . :
E':
1:
:'
l .
;.
-- 3UJ33AENT No. .52.5%.82; L.' t 1 :
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA ) I- l . 1
NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY ) No. G566 of 1987 1 .> , ~~ ) I
GENERAL DIVISION 1
I:.
; 1 :
BETWEEN: AUTODESK AUSTRALIA i PTY. LTD., AND AUTODESK INC. L>: Applicants 1%:
L : 1
AND : CHARLES CHEUNG l ' Respondent-
l - , .: , , I
_. l.
CO-: M. L. FOSTER, J
.
1 ,~: ,
DATE: 16 AUGUST 1989
I ;
PLACE: SYDNEY ; . I , :i' I
REASONS FOR JUDGHENT I
b , (EXTEMPORE) l? r . 1 . ; L : t-'
HIS HONOUR: In these proceedings the applicants, by notice of m v-.
L * motion dated 27 July 1989, seek orders that the respondent I i ; -: provide answers to interrogatories as delivered by the applicants !I f.; by notice dated 1 July 1988. The interrogatories in question are l . 1 20 in number. The respondent has objected to answering each of I. : them on the grounds of privilege against self-incrimination. l i !' r i The second named applicant is a company incorporated under the laws of the State of California in the United States of
;
1. I $ - I-
, , America and is the owner of copyright in computer programmes
1 : . :. I ' known as Autocad and documents to be used with the programme.
;.. I,
[_ ~ l
I ! 1 <
. -, ! , . I'
. . 1.1 11: i .
1'.
The first named applicant is the sole and exclusive distributor appointed by the second named applicant to import, market and distribute the Autocad programmes and associated documentation in Australia.
The statement of claim asserts, inter alia, infringement by thg respondent of the second named applicants copyright by (a) distributing for the purposes of trade the Autocad programme and documentation or a substantial part thereof; (b) reproducing in a materlal form the Autocad programme and documentation or a substantial part thereof; (c) selling or by way of trade offering or exposing for sale the Autocad programme and documentation or a substantial part thereof. The particulars supplied read as
follows : -
"The second named applicant is unable at present to give full particulars of the precise numbers and dates of all of the infringements of its copyright in the Autocad programme and documentation by the respondent but will claim at the trial of this action full compensation and relief in respect of all such infrlngements."
Paragraph 6 reads:-
" ~ t the time of the aforesaid infringements the respondent knew or ought to have known of the
Paragraph 8 makes similar claims for infringement of the first named applicant's exclusive rlght to import, market, distribute and sell in Australia the programme and documentation.
applicant." existence of the copyright of the second named
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Autodesk Australia Pty Ltd v Cheung, C and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1989] FCA 575
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
This case highlights the importance of considering the potential consequences of answering interrogatories in civil litigation, particularly when they may lead to criminal prosecution. The court applied the principle that privilege against self-incrimination applies in its full rigour in civil proceedings, even if the potential offences are not strictly petty or trivial. The court also rejected the doctrine of waiver as a basis for requiring the respondent to answer the interrogatories. The decision underscores the need for careful consideration of the scope and content of interrogatories to avoid potential issues of privilege and incrimination.
Background
Background to the litigation
This case involves an application by the applicants for an order compelling the respondent to answer interrogatories. The matter came before the Federal Court of Australia in the New South Wales District Registry. The application was heard by M.L. Foster, J, who delivered an extempore judgment on 16 August 1989. The court considered the respondent's objections to answering the interrogatories on the grounds of privilege against self-incrimination and the doctrine of waiver. The court also considered whether the claimed privilege should be overruled if the potential prosecution related only to petty or trivial offences.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the respondent is required to answer the interrogatories despite his claim of privilege against self-incrimination.
2. Whether the doctrine of waiver requires the respondent to answer the interrogatories.
3. Whether the claimed privilege should be overruled if the potential prosecution relates only to petty or trivial offences.
Held
1. The respondent is not required to answer the interrogatories despite his claim of privilege against self-incrimination.
2. The doctrine of waiver does not require the respondent to answer the interrogatories.
3. The claimed privilege should not be overruled if the potential prosecution relates only to petty or trivial offences.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court considered the respondent's objections to answering interrogatories on the ground of privilege against self-incrimination. The interrogatories related to provisions of the Copyright Act 1968 and the potential for prosecution under revenue laws. The court held that the answers could lead to a successful prosecution of the respondent, making the privilege against self-incrimination applicable. The court rejected the applicants' reliance on the doctrine of waiver, finding that the respondent's admissions were precise and did not require further elucidation through the interrogatories. The court also considered whether to overrule the privilege claim if the potential prosecution related only to petty or trivial offences, but decided to follow the precedent in Warman International Limited and Others v. Envirotech Australia Pty. Limited, which applied the traditional rule in its full rigour, leaving it to appellate courts to determine whether an exception should be made for petty or trivial offences. The court found that the penalties provided by the Copyright Act were substantial and the potential for multiple infringements could attract high monetary penalties. Therefore, the privilege against self-incrimination was upheld, and the orders sought in the notice of motion were refused. The ratio decidendi of this case is that a respondent may claim privilege against self-incrimination in interrogatories that could lead to a successful prosecution, even if the potential prosecution relates to offences that could be considered petty or trivial. The court did not depart from prior authority but followed the precedent set in Warman International Limited and Others v. Envirotech Australia Pty. Limited.