| [2020] FWC 2557 |
| FAIR WORK COMMISSION |
DECISION |
Fair Work Act 2009
s.739 - Application to deal with a dispute
Australian Workers' Union, The
v
Groundhog Civil (Vic) Pty Ltd
(C2019/1064)
DEPUTY PRESIDENT GOSTENCNIK | MELBOURNE, 19 MAY 2020 |
Application to deal with a dispute arising under an agreement in accordance with a dispute settlement term – evidentiary issue – admission of judgments into evidence – judgments not admitted.
[1] This decision deals with the objections raised by Groundhog Civil (Vic) Pty Ltd (Respondent) to the admission into evidence of the judgments in Eastern Pearl Corporation v Groundhog Sales and Rentals Pty Ltd1 (Eastern Pearl No 1)and in Groundhog Sales and Rentals Pty Ltd v Eastern Pearl Corporation2 (Eastern Pearl No 2). The principal proceeding during which the objection was made concerns an application by the Australian Workers' Union (Applicant) under s.739 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Act) for the Commission to deal with a dispute about the proper construction of clause 52.2 of the Ground Hog Civil (Vic) & Australian Workers' Union Agreement 2018 (Agreement). An application made pursuant to s.217 of the Act by the Respondent to vary the Agreement to remove an ambiguity or uncertainty is being heard concurrently.
[2] The circumstances leading to the objection arose during the Applicant’s cross-examination of Mr Glenn Mackay. Mr Mackay was being asked questions about litigation involving Groundhog Sales and Rentals Pty Ltd of which he was director.3
[3] During the cross-examination Mr Mackay accepted certain propositions put to him by Counsel for the Applicant including that:
• Groundhog Sales and Rentals Pty Ltd was sued in the Federal Court by Eastern Pearl Corporation; 4
• the claim related to a joint venture between Groundhog Sales and Rentals Pty Ltdand Eastern Pearl Corporation for the purchase and sale of an item of earthmoving equipment; 5 and
• Groundhog Sales and Rentals Pty Ltd sold the equipment in late October 2008 for $1.2M plus GST. 6
[4] Mr Mackay also gave evidence that he had given instructions to his solicitors to appeal from the judgment of the primary judge. 7
[5] Counsel for the Applicant also suggested to Mr Mackay that:
• he had sent false emails to Eastern Pearl Corporation; 8
• Eastern Pearl Corporation served a statutory demand on Groundhog Sales and Rentals Pty Ltd; 9
• Groundhog Sales and Rentals Pty Ltd applied to set it aside; 10 and
• in support of the application to set aside the statutory demand Mr Mackay had made an affidavit containing false statements. 11
[6] Mr Mackay’s evidence was in essence that he did not recall those matters. 12 Counsel for the Applicant showed Mr Mackay a document and Mr Mackay was asked whether he stood by his evidence that he did not recall.13 He said that he did.14
[7] Thereafter the Applicant sought to tender the judgment in Eastern Pearl No 1. The Respondent objects to receipt thereof. The Applicant also seeks to…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Workers' Union, The v Groundhog Civil (Vic) Pty L... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2020] FWC 2557
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The principal legal issue before the Court was whether the Commission was correct to refuse to admit the judgments into evidence. The Union argued that the Commission had erred in its decision, and that the judgments were properly admitted. The Union submitted that the judgments were relevant to the resolution of the dispute and were properly admitted as evidence. The Court held that the Commission had erred in law in refusing to admit the judgments into evidence. The Court found that the Commission's decision was unreasonable because it failed to consider the relevance of the judgments to the dispute and the proper procedures for admitting evidence.
The Court held that the Commission had not applied the correct legal test in determining whether the judgments should be admitted into evidence. The Court held that the Commission should have considered whether the judgments were relevant to the dispute and whether they were properly admitted in accordance with the procedures set out in the Fair Work Act 2009. The Court held that the Commission's failure to consider these matters was a failure to apply the correct legal test and was therefore a failure to exercise its discretion in a legally correct manner. The Court held that the Commission's decision was therefore unreasonable and should be set aside.
The Court allowed the appeal and remitted the matter to the Commission for reconsideration. The Court held that the Commission should consider whether the judgments were relevant to the dispute and whether they were properly admitted in accordance with the procedures set out in the Fair Work Act 2009. The Court held that the Commission should also consider whether the judgments were properly admitted into evidence and whether they should be given probative weight. The Court held that the Commission should reconsider the matter in light of these findings. The Court did not make any orders as to costs.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi