Australian Telecommunications Commission v King, F.F.

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

CATCHWORDS

EMPLOYEES COV€~SATION - Appeal from Abninlstrative Appeals Trlbunal - Incapacity f o r work - Relevance of perknality of

worker in considering capaclty to

work - Enplogment of r? kind ?.ot

commonly available

- m e "odd lot" doctrine - Necessity fcr

TriSunal to conslder possible occupatlons outslde employees

/

previous experlence

- Inference to

be drawn from fallure of

employer to offer or suggest suitable employment

- Whether

employee suffsrinq mcapaclcy occasior?ed by rnedical crea'iment.

Comwensaticn (Commonwealth

Governnen':

Enwlovees) l - c t 1971, 5 5 . 2 5 ,

2 7 , 39,

47, 50.

Adminlstratlve Aoueals TribuKal Act

1977

5 .44

Anderscn v Australian Postal Commmlsslon (1981) 39 AL2 94,

3avcevlc -7 Commonwealth (1957) 58 CL3 296 appllea. C-2bsc.n v

Commonwealth (AAT No. N841203, 8 March i985, Glscussed.

.

I

Appellant

FRANK FPIPJAN KINC

ResFondent

REASONS FOR JUDGYEVT

CORAii:

WILCC'X

J

U:

29 WJLRCH 1985

PLACE :

SMNEY

This 1 s an appeal pursuanr: to s.44 of tne A?mlnlstra=lve

Appeals Trijunal Act

1975 agalnst a Lman;rnoLs eeclslor! If t5e

Acmlclstratlve Appeals Trljunal

- constitJted by Mr 2 G Baliard

(Senlcr Member), Er D J Xowell and Yrs J H McClmtcck clYe?nbers) -

that the respondent, F r a n K Finnan K m g , 1 s entltlea r o the

payment of co;upensar,lon pursuant to t L e CsnDensatlon

J k -

.

..

. <.

(Comrnonwealt5 Government Emalovees) Act 1971.

_.

~ -4

~.

-

The responaenr: left schocl at the age

cf 15 years, he

^.

-.

then benq in second year at h q h school. In 1967, at '.ne ac;? of

22, he became emplayed

5y che Post Yaster General, the

c

- 2 -

S'

i

. .

p r e d e c e s s o r of

=he a p s e l l a n t corporation,

xorlclnq as

a

linesman

f

a n d

c a b l e

j o i n z e r .

That

wcrk

I n v o l v e d .

d i g g ~ n g zrer.cT-,es,

ciirnl:1?5

.

t

:

ladders and. 5 c i n ~

doh= manholes.

In Tulp 1 5 7 0 , I n

t h e c o u r s e

or

._

i~s.

emploper.t ,

the respondent i n ~ ~ x e d

1115 l e f t kTee,

in ZanEarp

9

1972 E r M

J Walker, an orthocaed2c

surgeon, cpera ted

on t h e k??e-?.

2

\

He r e - a l l F e d :i=e patelis..

Zr King was cf f W2rk for some thrrs

-

montns,

durlnq zhic:?

ciae i e was

paFd

compensation,

ace

t n e r

. *

. I

>-

.

L

.

- 3 -

The knee was in plaster for a couple of months but Fr

King dld not immediately return CO work 77ith the appellant. In

.

October 1979 he was elected to

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Telecommunications Commission v King, F.F. and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1985] FCA 120
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Australian Telecommunications Commission v King is an appeal against a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal that found Frank Finnan King was entitled to compensation under the Compensation (Commonwealth Government Employees) Act 1971. The primary issue was whether King was incapacitated for work due to his medical condition and if his personality and previous employment history were relevant factors in determining his capacity to work. The court needed to decide if the Tribunal erred in considering King's personality and whether it was necessary to explore employment opportunities outside his previous experience.

The court examined the evidence presented by both Dr Arndt and Dr Guffrida. Dr Arndt, who had an extensive knowledge of King's knee condition, testified that King was unfit for clerical work. Dr Guffrida, on the other hand, attributed King's total incapacity primarily to his personality. The court considered the "odd lot" doctrine, which requires the employer to show that suitable employment is available if they claim that an employee is not incapacitated. The court concluded that the Tribunal did not err in considering King's personality and previous employment, as it was relevant to the specific circumstances of his case. The failure of the employer to offer suitable employment was also considered relevant.

The court found that King was totally incapacitated for work due to his medical condition, which was exacerbated by his personality and previous work experience. The Tribunal's decision to deem King totally incapacitated for work was upheld, and the appeal was dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established