Australian Taxation Office and Comcare (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

Australian Taxation Office and Comcare (Compensation) [2016] AATA 280 (2 May 2016) 

Division

GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s)

2015/0654

Re

Australian Taxation Office

APPLICANT

And

Comcare

RESPONDENT

And

Olga Kusiak

OTHER PARTY

DECISION

Tribunal

Deputy President Gary Humphries

Date 2 May 2016
Place Canberra

The Tribunal does not have jurisdiction to make a declaration that Ms Kusiak has a reasonable excuse for not attending a medical appointment with Dr Skinner.

..................................[sgd]......................................

Deputy President Gary Humphries

Catchwords

COMPENSATION – application for declaration that other party has reasonable excuse not to attend medical appointment – Tribunal’s jurisdiction to direct attendance – Tribunal’s discretion to determine procedure – application for declaration refused.

Legislation

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) ss 36, 57

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) ss 25, 33

Cases

Richards and Comcare [2015] AATA 1031

Von Stieglitz and Comcare [2012] AATA 729

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President Gary Humphries

2 May 2016

  1. The Tribunal has no jurisdiction to compel Ms Kusiak to attend a medical appointment with Dr Skinner, or to direct that she not attend such an appointment. The application is refused.

    Background

  2. The other party in these proceedings, Olga Kusiak, suffered a neck sprain (right) while employed by the Australian Taxation Office (the ATO). This condition was accepted by Comcare by determination dated 10 May 2011. On 13 June 2014 Comcare issued a further determination which indicated that Ms Kusiak had no present entitlement to compensation under ss 16 and 19 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (the SRC Act). On 21 August 2014 Comcare affirmed the decision of 13 June 2014 but noted that the issue of whether Ms Kusiak suffered from a further condition was being remitted to a Claims Services Officer to determine. On 10 October 2014 Comcare accepted liability for cervicobrachial pain disorder under s 14 of the SRC Act.

  3. The ATO then took the unusual step of seeking reconsideration of Comcare’s determination accepting liability for Ms Kusiak’s cervicobrachial pain disorder. Comcare affirmed the determination on 16 January 2015, and on 13 February 2015 the ATO sought to have that decision reviewed by this Tribunal.

  4. As the review process has proceeded, Ms Kusiak has been required to attend a number of medical appointments. Specifically, on 30 July 2015 she attended an appointment with Dr Graeme Edwards. Dr Edwards subsequently produced a detailed report in which he commented that Over the past four years in particular, there has been a major restructure of our understanding of the persistent pain disorders... Dr Edwards also recommended further investigations in relation to the claim. Pursuant to that recommendation, on 15 February 2016 lawyers for the ATO advised the other party by email that a medical appointment had been made for her to attend on Dr Yvonne Skinner, forensic psychiatrist, in Sydney on 7 June 2016. The email also indicated that the ATO would seek to have Ms Kusiak undergo a sleep study and an MRI prior to attending Dr Skinner’s examination.

  5. The other…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Taxation Office and Comcare (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] AATA 280
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by Olga Kusiak, an employee of the Australian Taxation Office (ATO), for a declaration that she had a reasonable excuse not to attend a medical appointment with Dr Yvonne Skinner. The ATO had directed Ms Kusiak to attend this appointment as part of the review process concerning her compensation claim, which had been accepted by Comcare for cervicobrachial pain disorder. The application was heard by Deputy President Gary Humphries of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal.

The primary legal issues before the Tribunal were whether it possessed the jurisdiction to make a declaration that Ms Kusiak had a reasonable excuse for not attending the medical appointment, and whether it had the power to compel her attendance or direct her not to attend. The Tribunal was required to consider the scope of its review powers under the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (SRC Act) and the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (AAT Act) in relation to decisions made under sections 36 and 57 of the SRC Act.

The Tribunal reasoned that its power to review decisions is derived from the AAT Act and specific provisions within the SRC Act. It determined that while the Tribunal has the power to review decisions made under section 36 of the SRC Act concerning an employee's capability of undertaking a rehabilitation program, it does not have the power to review decisions made under section 57(1) which require an employee to undergo a medical examination to assess a compensation claim. Crucially, the Tribunal found it also lacked the power to make a declaration under section 57(2) that an employee has a reasonable excuse for refusing to attend such an appointment.

Consequently, the Tribunal concluded that it did not have jurisdiction to make the declaration sought by Ms Kusiak, nor did it have the power to compel her attendance or direct her not to attend the medical appointment with Dr Skinner. The application was therefore refused.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Tribunal does not have jurisdiction to make a declaration that Ms Kusiak has a reasonable excuse for not attending a medical appointment with Dr Skinner.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Tribunal has no jurisdiction to compel Ms Kusiak to attend a medical appointment with Dr Skinner, or to direct that she not attend such an appointment. The application is refused.Background The other party in these proceedings, Olga Kusiak, suffered a neck sprain (right) while employed by the Australian Taxation Office (the ATO). This condition was accepted by Comcare by determination dated 10 May 2011. On 13 June 2014 Comcare issued a further determination which indicated that Ms Kusiak had no present entitlement to compensation under ss 16 and 19 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (the SRC Act). On 21 August 2014 Comcare affirmed the decision of 13 June 2014 but noted that the issue of whether Ms Kusiak suffered from a further condition was being remitted to a Claims Services Officer to determine. On 10 October 2014 Comcare accepted liability for cervicobrachial pain disorder under s 14 of the SRC Act. The ATO then took the unusual step of seeking reconsideration of Comcare’s determination accepting liability for Ms Kusiak’s cervicobrachial pain disorder. Comcare affirmed the determination on 16 January 2015, and on 13 February 2015 the ATO sought to have that decision reviewed by this Tribunal. As the review process has proceeded, Ms Kusiak has been required to attend a number of medical appointments. Specifically, on 30 July 2015 she attended an appointment with Dr Graeme Edwards. Dr Edwards subsequently produced a detailed report in which he commented that Over the past four years in particular, there has been a major restructure of our understanding of the persistent pain disorders... Dr Edwards also recommended further investigations in relation to the claim. Pursuant to that recommendation, on 15 February 2016 lawyers for the ATO advised the other party by email that a medical appointment had been made for her to attend on Dr Yvonne Skinner, forensic psychiatrist, in Sydney on 7 June 2016. The email also indicated that the ATO would seek to have Ms Kusiak undergo a sleep study and an MRI prior to attending Dr Skinner’s examination. The other party then made an application to the Tribunal for an order that she not be compelled to attend the appointment with Dr Skinner. In an email dated 18 February 2016, the other party stated that she had already attended on nine medical practitioners in the preceding two or three years in relation to her claim, and that being required to attend upon yet a further specialist is an instrument of oppression. A directions hearing was conducted by teleconference on 29 February and 3 March 2016, to deal with Ms Kusiak’s application. After hearing all three parties, I determined that I would not grant the application. The other party asked for written reasons for this decision, which I undertook to provide. As I undertook the writing of the reasons for my decision, however, it became apparent that an issue of jurisdiction arose which had not been adequately canvassed at the directions hearings. Accordingly, a further directions hearing was conducted by telephone on 4 April 2016, for the purpose of considering what power was available to the Tribunal to direct a party to proceedings to attend a medical appointment. After hearing the parties on that day, I reserved my decision.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The question facing the Tribunal in the present application is whether the Tribunal itself has the capacity to exercise either of the powers conferred by the provisions referred to above in lieu of the authority upon whom they are specifically conferred, or to review such powers as they are exercised by an authority in such a way that it can substitute a different decision to the one made by that authority.The Tribunal’s power to review decisions The Tribunal has no intrinsic authority to review (and substitute) decisions made by government agencies or licensees. Its power to do so in respect of government agencies derives from s 25 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (the AAT Act):Tribunal may review certain decisions(1) An enactment may provide that applications may be made to the Tribunal:(a) for review of decisions made in the exercise of powers conferred by that enactment; or(b) for the review of decisions made in the exercise of powers conferred, or that may be conferred, by another enactment having effect under that enactment. In the case of the SRC Act, s 64 makes provision for a claimant to apply to the Tribunal for review of a reviewable decision. Section 60(1) defines a reviewable decision to mean a decision made under subsection 38(4) or s 62. Section 38(4), in turn, deals with the power of Comcare to review a decision by a rehabilitation authority to determine either that an employee is capable of undertaking a rehabilitation program or should in fact undertake such a program. It appears not to be relevant to the circumstances of this application. Section 62 refers to decisions made under s 36, but does not refer to decisions made under s 57. From this construction it seems clear that the Tribunal has the power to review a decision to require an employee to undergo an examination, pursuant to s 36(3), for the purpose of assessing his or her capability of undertaking a rehabilitation program. It is also clear that the Tribunal has no power to review a decision under s 57(1) to require an employee to undergo an examination by a medical practitioner, nor does it have the power to make a declaration that an employee has a reasonable excuse under s 57(2) for refusing to attend a medical appointment at some point in the future: Richards and Comcare [2015] AATA 1031 at [19].Consideration Ms Kusiak is reluctant to attend a further medical appointment. She can only be required to do so if an appropriate legislative power is available to compel her. I will consider each of the possible sources of compulsion available to the ATO.Section 36 As already mentioned, the Tribunal appears to have the power to review a decision of a rehabilitation authority to require an employee to undergo an examination for the purpose of assessing the employee’s capability of undertaking a rehabilitation program (s 36(1)). The following questions then arise: is the ATO a rehabilitation authority, and has it directed Ms Kusiak to undergo an examination for the purpose referred to in s 36?

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Section 38(4), in turn, deals with the power of Comcare to review a decision by a rehabilitation authority to determine either that an employee is capable of undertaking a rehabilitation program or should in fact undertake such a program. It appears not to be relevant to the circumstances of this application. Section 62 refers to decisions made under s 36, but does not refer to decisions made under s 57. From this construction it seems clear that the Tribunal has the power to review a decision to require an employee to undergo an examination, pursuant to s 36(3), for the purpose of assessing his or her capability of undertaking a rehabilitation program. It is also clear that the Tribunal has no power to review a decision under s 57(1) to require an employee to undergo an examination by a medical practitioner, nor does it have the power to make a declaration that an employee has a reasonable excuse under s 57(2) for refusing to attend a medical appointment at some point in the future: Richards and Comcare [2015] AATA 1031 at [19].Consideration Ms Kusiak is reluctant to attend a further medical appointment. She can only be required to do so if an appropriate legislative power is available to compel her. I will consider each of the possible sources of compulsion available to the ATO.Section 36 As already mentioned, the Tribunal appears to have the power to review a decision of a rehabilitation authority to require an employee to undergo an examination for the purpose of assessing the employee’s capability of undertaking a rehabilitation program (s 36(1)). The following questions then arise: is the ATO a rehabilitation authority, and has it directed Ms Kusiak to undergo an examination for the purpose referred to in s 36? No evidence was before the Tribunal at the hearings as to whether the ATO had been designated a rehabilitation authority (see s 4(1)). However, even if it had been so designated, it appears clear that it was not exercising the power in s 36 in requiring Ms Kusiak to attend an appointment with Dr Skinner. On the Tribunal file is an email from Ms Kusiak’s representative to Comcare’s representative in which the former urges the latter to stop the use of a s36 report for collateral unauthorised s57 purposes. However in the submissions by parties in the hearings, s 36 was not relied on as the basis for the ATO’s direction. Even if it had been, it appears clear from the evidence overall that the purpose of the medical examination with Dr Skinner is not to assess Ms Kusiak’s capability of undertaking a rehabilitation program but rather to assess the basis of her overall claim for compensation under the Act.Section 57 At the hearings, the ATO’s representative cited s 57 as the basis for its direction to Ms Kusiak. Generally speaking, s 57 should be considered the proper basis on which to require an employee to undergo a medical examination to assess a claim for compensation under the Act. However, in the present circumstances two difficulties arise with that course of action.