Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Thorne

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Thorne [2021] FCA 209  

File number(s): QUD 358 of 2020
Judgment of: COLLIER J
Date of judgment: 11 March 2021
Catchwords: CORPORATIONS – application under s 93AA(3) Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth) – orders sought pursuant to s 93AA(4) ASIC Act – whether enforceable undertaking breached – whether appropriate to make orders under s 93AA(4) ASIC Act – discretion of Court to make orders.
COSTS – where parties agreed to substantive relief – whether no “successful” party in proceedings – general principle that costs follow the event – personal and financial toll on respondent of proceedings – lump sum costs order sought – Costs Practice Note (GPN-COSTS).  
Legislation:

Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth)

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth)

Cases cited:

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Alinta 2000 Ltd [2007] FCA 1362

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Empower Invest Pty Ltd [2010] NSWSC 1025

Northern Territory v Sangare (2019) 265 CLR 16; [2019] HCA 25

Oshlack v Richmond River Council (1998) 193 CLR 72; [1998] HCA 11

Division: General Division
Registry: Queensland
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Regulator and Consumer Protection
Number of paragraphs: 37
Date of hearing: 10 March 2021
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr S Seefeld
Solicitor for the Applicant: Australian Securities and Investments Commission
Solicitor for the Respondent: Mr A Tiplady of Mills Oakley

ORDERS

QUD 358 of 2020
BETWEEN:

AUSTRALIAN SECURITIES AND INVESTMENTS COMMISSION

Applicant

AND:

JENAN OLSEM THORNE (ALSO KNOWN AS CENAN THORNE AND CENAN DIKMEN)

Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

COLLIER J

DATE OF ORDER:

11 MARCH 2021

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Within 5 business days of the date of this order, the Respondent is to send a copy of the letter and ASIC media release attached to this order and marked “Annexure A” (together, the Letter) to each of the clients listed in the table attached to this order and marked “Annexure B” (the Clients).

2.In preparing and sending the Letter pursuant to order 1, the Respondent is to adopt the following protocol:

(a)where the Respondent has an email address for the Client, to send the Letter to the last known email address for the Client; and

(b)where the Respondent has a postal address for the Client, to send the Letter by registered post to the last address known to the Respondent; and

(c)where a Letter to a Client is returned to sender, whether sent by email or post, or where the Respondent has no email or postal address for a Client, the Respondent will, within 10 business days, conduct the following searches for that Client and re-send the Letter by registered post to any further address obtained as a result of the search:

(i)a search of Australia Post's "National Change of Address" database; and

(ii)an Internet search of the Telstra White Pages On-Line at the domain name 20 business days of the date of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Thorne and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] FCA 209
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Thorne involved the respondent, Ms Jenan Oslem Thorne, who was a director of two companies providing accounting and self-managed superannuation fund administration services. Ms Thorne was also an authorised representative of SMSF Advice Pty Ltd, providing financial product advice. ASIC brought the proceedings against Ms Thorne alleging that she contravened certain sections of the Corporations Act by failing to act in the best interests of her clients and prioritised her own interests over theirs. The court was required to decide whether Ms Thorne breached her enforceable undertaking and whether it was appropriate to make orders under section 93AA(4) of the ASIC Act.

The court found that Ms Thorne had indeed breached her enforceable undertaking by advising clients to establish self-managed superannuation funds without taking their circumstances into account. The court also found that Ms Thorne had prioritised her own interests over those of her clients and recommended services of a related party to create extra revenue for herself. The court held that it was appropriate to make orders under section 93AA(4) of the ASIC Act, and granted the orders sought by ASIC. The court also found that ASIC was entitled to its costs, fixed in the amount of $16,529.78.

The court ordered Ms Thorne to inform all her former personal advice clients about the enforceable undertaking and provide contact details of her former licensee, SMSF Advice Pty Ltd. Ms Thorne was also ordered to send a copy of the letter and ASIC media release to each of the clients listed in the table attached to the order. The court exercised its discretion to make orders in the terms agreed by the parties, and the parties have liberty to apply on three business days’ notice in writing.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Within 5 business days of the date of this order, the Respondent is to send a copy of the letter and ASIC media release attached to this order and marked “Annexure A” (together, the Letter) to each of the clients listed in the table attached to this order and marked “Annexure B” (the Clients).

2. In preparing and sending the Letter pursuant to order 1, the Respondent is to adopt the following protocol:

(a) where the Respondent has an email address for the Client, to send the Letter to the last known email address for the Client; and

(b) where the Respondent has a postal address for the Client, to send the Letter by registered post to the last address known to the Respondent; and

(c) where a Letter to a Client is returned to sender, whether sent by email or post, or where the Respondent has no email or postal address for a Client, the Respondent will, within 10 business days, conduct the following searches for that Client and re-send the Letter by registered post to any further address obtained as a result of the search:

(i) a search of Australia Post's "National Change of Address" database; and

(ii) an Internet search of the Telstra White Pages On-Line at the domain name www.whitepages.com.au.

3. Within 20 business days of the date of this order, the Respondent is to notify the Applicant in writing confirming whether she has complied with Orders 1 and 2 above and providing the Applicant with:

(a) a list of the names and addresses (whether email and/or postal address) of Clients to which the Respondent sent the Letter in accordance with Orders 1 and 2 above, including:

(i) where the Letter was sent to a Client by email pursuant to order 2(a) above, a copy of the email; and

(ii) where the Letter was sent to a Client by registered post pursuant to order 2(b) or 2(c) above, a copy of the Australia Post proof of posting and proof of receipt;

(b) a list of those Clients to which the Respondent was not able to send the Letter in accordance with Orders 1 and 2 above, including:

(i) where the Letter to a Client was unable to be sent to the last known email address for the Client, a copy of the email notification that the email could not be delivered; and

(ii) where the Letter to a Client was unable to be sent to the postal address for the Client, a copy of the Australia Post proof of posting and proof of non-delivery.

4. The Respondent is to pay the Applicants’ costs fixed in the amount of $16,529.78

5. The parties have liberty to apply on three business days’ notice in writing.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

ANNEXURE A

NOTICE TO CLIENTS

On 13 February 2019, I entered into an enforceable undertaking with the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) which prevents me from providing financial services for a period of three years.

You are receiving this letter because you are a client to whom I previously provided personal advice as an authorised representative of SMSF Advice Pty Ltd. Under the terms of the enforceable undertaking, I am required to provide you with certain information, which is noted below.

· My full name is Jenan Oslem Thorne. I am also known by the names Cenan Thorne and Cenan Dikmen.

· I was previously an authorised representative of SMSF Advice Pty Ltd. My authorised representative number was 456988.

· The Australian Financial Services Licence number of SMSF Advice Pty Ltd is 234664.

· The contact details of SMSF Advice Pty Ltd for dealing with any enquiries or complaints regarding my enforceable undertaking with ASIC and my conduct as an authorised representative is:

SMSF Advice Pty Ltd

National Manager, Advice Complaints

Level 16, 33 Alfred Street, Sydney, NSW, 2000

Email: information@smsfadvice.com.au or advicecomplaints@amp.com.au

· A copy of the ASIC media release dated 19 February 2019 about this enforceable undertaking and my conduct is attached.

Jenan Thorne

ASIC media releases are point-in-time statements. Please note the date of issue and use the internal search function on the site to check for other media releases on the same or related matters.

Tuesday 19 February 2019

19-034MR Court enforceable undertaking prevents Gold Coast accountant from providing financial services

ASIC has accepted a court enforceable undertaking (EU) from Gold Coast-based accountant, Jenan Oslem Thorne of Saber Superannuation Pty Ltd after it found she had failed to act in the best interests of her clients and had prioritised her own interests above their interests.

The undertaking prevents Mrs Thorne (also known as Cenan Thorne or Cenan Dikmen) from providing financial services for a period of three years effective from 13 February 2019.

ASIC decided to review Mrs Thorne's advice when it discovered, during its investigation into Park Trent Properties Group Pty Ltd, that she was receiving referrals in relation to establishing self-managed superannuation funds (SMSFs) from Park Trent.

ASIC reviewed advice provided by Mrs Thorne when she was a representative of SMSF Advice Pty Ltd, a wholly owned subsidiary of AMP Limited, and concluded that she had advised some of her clients to establish SMSFs without taking their circumstances into account.

ASIC found that Mrs Thorne hadn't properly considered her clients' existing superannuation arrangements or explored why they were interested in investing in direct residential property through an SMSF. When recommending SMSFs to some of her clients, she had inappropriately scoped advice by excluding insurance and retirement planning.

ASIC also found that Mrs Thorne did not adequately stress-test SMSF strategies and had recommended SMSFs to some of her clients despite inadequate evidence to suggest that the strategies would provide increased retirement benefits.

Furthermore, Mrs Thorne had recommended that her accountancy practice, Saber Accountants Pty Ltd, prepare the annual accounts and tax returns for the SMSF clients. This led ASIC to determine that Mrs Thorne recommended the services of a related party to create extra revenue for herself.

As part of the EU, Mrs Thorne has agreed to inform all her former personal advice clients about the EU and provide contact details of her former licensee, SMSF Advice Pty Ltd.

Former clients of Mrs Thorne who have enquiries or complaints regarding her advice or conduct should contact SMSF Advice Pty Ltd.

ASIC expects financial advisers to comply with their best interests duty and pay particular attention to how they scope their advice to clients. Prior to recommending SMSFs, advisers should critically probe why a client wants to set up an SMSF and what they hope to achieve. Advisers should also give adequate consideration to risk management and succession planning before setting up an SMSF for a client.

ASIC Commissioner Danielle Press said, 'Financial advisers have a legal obligation to provide advice that is in the best interests of their clients, not prioritise their own interests or simply implement client instructions. ASIC will continue to take action when advisers or AFS licensees don’t comply with the law.

'Consumers need to know that managing your own super is a major commitment that can be expensive and involve significant time and effort. SMSFs are not for everyone. Consumers should consider their personal circumstances carefully before deciding to establish an SMSF,' she said.

ASIC's Report 575 SMSFs: Improving the quality of advice and member experiences, includes some practical tips to assist advice providers in complying with their obligations in the context of SMSFs.

ASIC provides information on the MoneySmart website to help people choose the right

financial adviser for their needs.

Download the enforceable undertaking

Last updated: 19/02/2019 09:29

ANNEXURE B

LIST OF CLIENTS

1. E & R Mondaya Superannuation Fund

2. Hai & Lam Nguyen Tran Family Superannuation Fund

3. Furness Family Superannuation Fund

4. APS Superannuation Fund

5. J & D Superfund

6. Whalen & Taylor Superannuation Fund

7. Trixie Superannuation Fund

8. Dedaleli Superannuation Fund

9. Latulipe Superannuation Fund

10. Shalom Superannuation Fund

11. Isodale Superannuation Fund

12. As Prasad Superannuation Fund

13. GNP Superannuation Fund

14. Francisma Superannuation Fund

15. D & L Baring Superannuation Fund

16. TR and BA Faint Superannuation Fund

17. Graham & Miriam Jackson SMSF

18. Mair Superannuation Fund

19. James Superannuation Fund

20. Michalska Superannuation Fund

21. Mortgage Crusher Superannuation Fund

22. Ireneil Family Superannuation Fund

23. Jeremiah 29 Verse II Superannuation Fund

24. K & B Vongdara Superannuation Fund

25. M & L Quick Superannuation Fund

26. Raeburn Family Superannuation Fund

27. V & H Superannuation Fund

28. Beloved Superannuation Fund

29. Devenport Family Super Fund

30. Lalithan Superannuation Fund

31. Anita Harilela Superannuation Fund

32. Milvera Superfund

33. Lower Chittering Millionaires Club SMSF

34. DNA Superannuation Fund

35. Alvaro & Montgomery Superannuation Fund

36. Tupou Superannuation Fund

37. Nouveau Freedom Superannuation Fund

38. J & T Zollo SMSF

39. Osbourne SMSF

40. Haverfield SMSF

41. P & M Bestenbreur Superfund

42. J C Holdings Superannuation Fund

43. Young Superfund

44. Farrell & Wiiliams Superfund

45. Harvey Family Superfund

46. CLS and JS Superannuation Fund

47. T & D Giorgio Superfund

48. G & N French Superfund

49. Gribble McWilliam Super Fund

50. Kardi Superfund

51. Hayes Mark SMSF

52. Parker Family Superfund

53. Tupou Self Managed Superannuation Fund

54. LAP Superannuation Fund

55. Collpark SMSF

56. Vade Superannuation fund

57. CGR Superannuation fund

58. Steve & Tracy Parker Superannuation Fund

59. EBHOLTOR Superfund

60. R & R Superannuation Fund

61. GSLC Superfund

62. M & L Stirling Superannuation Fund

63. Doris Sultana clud SMSF

64. Indarra Family Finance SMSF

65. Trash Superannuation Fund

66. FLRA Superannuation Fund

67. Brett Family Superfund

68. SAAD Superfund

69. Holland Superfund

70. NUR Retirement Superfund

71. Connors Family Superfund

72. Frances Anna Hicks SMSF

73. Omar & Tasrina Superannuation Fund

74. Kusztor Superannuation Fund

75. Namanvy SMSF

76. Cilesia SMSF

77. Hangloyd Superfund

78. Correria SMSF

79. B & J Jessop Retirement SMSF

80. Baker & Bellety Superfund

81. Daniel & Sherri Henman SMSF

82. Dikson Sean SMSF

83. D'Sylva SMSF

84. Harjas Superannuation Fund

85. Murray Family SMSF

86. ESC Miller Superfund

87. Boon Family SMSF

88. BT Kennedy SMSF

89. Bloodworth and Heta SMSF

90. Rhind SMSF

91. Veneeta SMSF

92. Konnyvong Retirement SMSF

93. Super Dooper SMSF

94. Allan & Laura Cooper Superannuation Fund

95. Temelkov Superfund

96. Herrera SMSF

97. Sambo Superfund

98. Normeng SMSF

99. Boxbird SMSF

100. Sarjon SMSF

101. Albeem SMSF

102. E & G Howell SMSF

103. Briden SMSF

Background

Background to the litigation

Before turning to the question of costs on which the parties are not agreed, it is appropriate to examine material background facts.BACKGROUND FACTS At relevant times Ms Thorne was a director of two companies conducting businesses on the Gold Coast in Queensland. The companies were Saber Superannuation Pty Ltd and Saber Accountants Pty Ltd. The businesses in which the companies were engaged provided accounting, taxation and self-managed superannuation fund (SMSF) administration services. Between 28 April 2014 and 12 December 2017, Ms Thorne was a representative of the Australian Financial Services licensee SMSF Advice Pty Ltd (SMSF Advice). She was authorised to provide financial product advice, as defined in s 766B of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (Corporations Act), on behalf of SMSF Advice. During this period and under this authorisation, Ms Thorne provided personal financial advice to retail clients which recommended transfer of existing superannuation into SMSFs and the purchase of interests in property. ASIC relied on affidavits of Ms Nicole Wren, in particular her affidavit sworn 12 December 2019. At material times Ms Wren was a Senior Investigator in the Serious Financial Crime Taskforce, Enforcement, in the Brisbane office of ASIC. Ms Wren deposed that, following a review of Ms Thorne’s client files, ASIC formed the view that Ms Thorne had contravened ss 961B, 961G and 961J of the Corporations Act in respect of advice given. These sections provide:961B Provider must act in the best interests of the client(1) The provider must act in the best interests of the client in relation to the advice.(2) The provider satisfies the duty in subsection (1), if the provider proves that the provider has done each of the following:(a) identified the objectives, financial situation and needs of the client that were disclosed to the provider by the client through instructions;(b) identified:(i) the subject matter of the advice that has been sought by the client (whether explicitly or implicitly); and(ii) the objectives, financial situation and needs of the client that would reasonably be considered as relevant to advice sought on that subject matter (the client’s relevant circumstances);(c) where it was reasonably apparent that information relating to the client’s relevant circumstances was incomplete or inaccurate, made reasonable inquiries to obtain complete and accurate information;(d) assessed whether the provider has the expertise required to provide the client advice on the subject matter sought and, if not, declined to provide the advice;(e) if, in considering the subject matter of the advice sought, it would be reasonable to consider recommending a financial product:(i) conducted a reasonable investigation into the financial products that might achieve those of the objectives and meet those of the needs of the client that would reasonably be considered as relevant to advice on that subject matter; and(ii) assessed the information gathered in the investigation;(f) based all judgements in advising the client on the client’s relevant circumstances;(g) taken any other step that, at the time the advice is provided, would reasonably be regarded as being in the best interests of the client, given the client’s relevant circumstances.Note: The matters that must be proved under subsection (2) relate to the subject matter of the advice sought by the client and the circumstances of the client relevant to that subject matter (the client’s relevant circumstances). That subject matter and the client’s relevant circumstances may be broad or narrow, and so the subsection anticipates that a client may seek scaled advice and that the inquiries made by the provider will be tailored to the advice sought.Advice given by Australian ADIs—best interests duty satisfied if certain steps are taken(3) If:(a) the provider is:(i) an agent or employee of an Australian ADI; or(ii) otherwise acting by arrangement with an Australian ADI under the name of the Australian ADI; and(b) the subject matter of the advice sought by the client relates only to the following:(i) a basic banking product;(ii) a general insurance product;(iii) consumer credit insurance;(iv) a combination of any of those products;the provider satisfies the duty in subsection (1) in relation to the advice given in relation to the basic banking product and the general insurance product if the provider takes the steps mentioned in paragraphs (2)(a), (b) and (c).General insurance products—best interests duty satisfied if certain steps are taken(4) To the extent that the subject matter of the advice sought by the client is a general insurance product, the provider satisfies the duty in subsection (1) if the provider takes the steps mentioned in paragraphs (2)(a), (b) and (c).Regulations(5) The regulations may prescribe:(a) a step, in addition to or substitution for the steps mentioned in subsection (2), that the provider must, in prescribed circumstances, prove that the provider has taken, to satisfy the duty in subsection (1); or(b) that the provider is not required, in prescribed circumstances, to prove that the provider has taken a step mentioned in subsection (2), to satisfy the duty in subsection (1); or(c) circumstances in which the duty in subsection (1) does not apply.…961G Resulting advice must be appropriate to the clientThe provider must only provide the advice to the client if it would be reasonable to conclude that the advice is appropriate to the client, had the provider satisfied the duty under section 961B to act in the best interests of the client.Note: A responsible licensee or an authorised representative may contravene a civil penalty provision if a provider fails to comply with this section (see sections 961K and 961Q). The provider may be subject to a banning order (see section 920A).…961J Conflict between client’s interests and those of provider, licensee, authorised representative or associates(1) If the provider knows, or reasonably ought to know, that there is a conflict between the interests of the client and the interests of:(a) the provider; or(b) an associate of the provider; or(c) a financial services licensee of whom the provider is a representative; or(d) an associate of a financial services licensee of whom the provider is a representative; or(e) an authorised representative who has authorised the provider, under subsection 916B(3), to provide a specified financial service or financial services on behalf of a financial services licensee; or(f) an associate of an authorised representative who has authorised the provider, under subsection 916B(3), to provide a specified financial service or financial services on behalf of a financial services licensee;the provider must give priority to the client’s interests when giving the advice.Note: A responsible licensee or an authorised representative may contravene a civil penalty provision if a provider fails to comply with this section (see sections 961K and 961Q). The provider may be subject to a banning order (see section 920A).(2) If:(a) the provider is:(i) an agent or employee of an Australian ADI; or(ii) otherwise acting by arrangement with an Australian ADI under the name of the Australian ADI; and(b) the subject matter of the advice sought by the client relates only to the following:(i) a basic banking product;(ii) a general insurance product;(iii) consumer credit insurance;(iv) a combination of any of those products;subsection (1) does not apply to the extent that the advice relates to a basic banking product or a general insurance product or a combination of those 2 products.(3) Subsection (1) does not apply to the extent that the subject matter of the advice sought by the client is a general insurance product.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Turning now to the quantum of costs sought, clause 4.1 of the Federal Court of Australia’s Costs Practice Note (GPN-COSTS) provides that the Court’s preference, wherever it is practicable and appropriate to do so, is for the making of a lump-sum costs order. During the hearing, Mr Tiplady for Ms Thorne submitted that, if I considered a costs order warranted, Ms Thorne took no issue with the quantum (transcript p 20 ll 38-43). I consider this concession appropriate in the face of the undisputed submissions of ASIC concerning the limited nature of the costs it has sought in this matter.CONCLUSION I am satisfied that the Court should exercise its discretion to make orders in the terms agreed by the parties pursuant to s 93AA(4) of the ASIC Act. I am also satisfied that ASIC is entitled to its costs, fixed in the amount of $16,529.78.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established