Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Macks

Link copied
Case Copied 50 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil: Application)

AUSTRALIAN SECURITIES AND INVESTMENTS COMMISSION v MACKS

[2025] SASC 4

Judgment of the Honourable Justice Stein  

STATUTES - ACTS OF PARLIAMENT - INTERPRETATION - GENERAL APPROACHES TO INTERPRETATION - PURPOSIVE APPROACH

STATUTES - ACTS OF PARLIAMENT - INTERPRETATION - GENERAL APPROACHES TO INTERPRETATION - WORDS TO BE GIVEN LITERAL AND GRAMMATICAL MEANING

STATUTES - ACTS OF PARLIAMENT - INTERPRETATION - GENERAL APPROACHES TO INTERPRETATION - TO GIVE OPERATION AND EFFECT TO ACT

STATUTES - ACTS OF PARLIAMENT - INTERPRETATION - INTERPRETATION ACTS AND PROVISIONS - EXERCISE OF POWERS AND DUTIES

On 19 February 2021, this Court made orders suspending the respondent’s registration as a registered liquidator for a period of three years.  Prior to the expiry of that period of suspension, the respondent made an application for renewal of his registration as a liquidator.  That application was refused by the applicant on grounds including that the respondent had failed to maintain adequate and appropriate professional indemnity and fidelity insurance and accordingly the respondent’s registration lapsed on 28 March 2023.  The respondent’s failure to hold such insurance related to circumstances within the insurance market which meant he was unable to obtain relevant insurance cover until such time as any suspension had expired.

Following the expiry of the suspension period in February 2024, the respondent brought an application to be reinstated as a registered liquidator.  The applicant refused to do so on the basis that the refusal of the prior application meant the respondent was no longer registered and consequently was required to lodge a fresh application for registration.

The respondent applied to the Court for orders for an extension of time within which to lodge a further application for renewal of registration as a liquidator pursuant to the s 20-70 of the Insolvency Practice Schedule (Corporations) (Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) sch 2 (“IPSC”)). 

Held (allowing the application)

1.The prior decision to refuse the renewal of registration does not preclude the decision maker from considering a fresh application and consequently does not preclude the Court from granting an extension of time within which to make such an application.

2.The decision maker must consider any application brought pursuant to an extension of time granted by the Court on the basis of circumstances in existence as at the date the application is made. 

3.The obligation to maintain adequate and appropriate insurance in s 25-1 of the IPSC is a present obligation relating to working as a registered liquidator and consequently does not apply to a suspended liquidator not working as a registered liquidator. The insurance obligation on a suspended liquidator is an obligation to hold run off cover which is imposed only as a condition of the liquidator’s registration by r 20-5(4) of the Insolvency Practice Rules (Corporations) 2016 (Cth).

4.It is appropriate in the circumstances to exercise the discretion to grant an extension of time.

Words and Phrases:

1.“adequate and appropriate insurance”, “must maintain”, “liabilities that the person may incur working as a…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Macks and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] SASC 4
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court of Australia, the case of Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Macks revolved around the application for an extension of time for Mr Macks to renew his registration as a liquidator. Mr Macks had applied for the renewal of his registration, which was granted by ASIC, but was subsequently suspended. His suspension affected his ability to obtain professional indemnity and fidelity insurance, as no insurer was willing to provide cover during his suspension. Mr Macks sought an extension of time to renew his registration, which was opposed by ASIC.

The legal issues before the Court were whether the Court had the authority to grant an extension of time and, if so, whether such an extension should be granted in the circumstances of this case. The Court considered the statutory provisions, particularly section 33(1) of the Interpretation Act, which allows for the re-exercise of powers or duties as occasion requires. The Court also examined the principles governing extensions of time, including the length of the delay, any acceptable explanation for the delay, and whether there would be any prejudice to other parties. ASIC did not contest the interpretation of the legislation regarding the re-exercisability of the power to grant an extension.

The Court determined that it had the power to grant an extension of time under the relevant legislation. It further concluded that, given the circumstances, including Mr Macks' inability to obtain insurance due to his suspension and the absence of significant prejudice to ASIC, the application for an extension should be granted. The Court emphasised that the extension would merely allow Mr Macks to make a fresh application for registration renewal, subject to ASIC's consideration of the application anew. The Court allowed the application for an extension of time and directed further discussions between the parties regarding the form of the order to be made, including the requirement for Mr Macks to file a new application for renewal.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons below, I conclude that the Court has the power to grant an extension of time and I have determined to exercise my discretion to grant such an extension. Background The circumstances giving rise to Mr Macks’ application are as follows. On 28 February 2020, Mr Macks applied for renewal of his registration as a liquidator for the period ending 27 March 2023. That application was granted by ASIC. The orders suspending Mr Macks’ registration were made after Mr Macks’ registration was renewed and had the effect of suspending Mr Macks for a period which extended beyond his then current registration. While suspended, Mr Macks continued to undertake the necessary hours of continuing professional education, continued to lodge annual liquidator returns and paid an annual industry funding levy. However, Mr Macks was unable to obtain professional indemnity and fidelity insurance[1] because he was unable to source insurance cover which otherwise compiled with the requirements of the ASIC Regulatory Guide 258 – Registered Liquidators: Registration, disciplinary actions and insurance requirements (“RG 258”). [1] For simplicity, I refer to professional indemnity and fidelity insurance simply as “insurance” throughout these reasons. Mr Macks’ attempts to obtain insurance commenced in February 2021 when Mr Macks contacted his insurance broker to renew his and his firm’s insurance that was due to expire at the end of February 2021. Mr Macks’ broker informed Mr Macks that they could not locate any insurer willing to provide cover to him for the period of his suspension irrespective of whether it related to future or historical claims concerning his conduct as a liquidator. Mr Macks was informed that his existing insurer, Liberty, would only extend cover to Mr Macks’ firm and its employees if an endorsement or exclusion in respect of Mr Macks was inserted into the policy. In early March 2021, another broker informed Mr Macks that of the four insurers offering insurance policies to registered liquidators which were compliant with the requirements of RG258, one was Liberty and the remaining three would not provide cover to Mr Macks while suspended and/or were not willing to write new business. It was not in dispute that Mr Macks’ firm was thereafter provided with cover by Liberty and such cover excluded Mr Macks. The policies taken out by Mr Macks and his firm were “claims made” policies, that is, the policies would respond to claims made during the period of the policy. The insurance policy issued by Liberty, with an effective date of 28 February 2021 (and the yearly policies thereafter), provided relevant insurance for Mr Macks’ firm (Macks Advisory) and the firm’s employees, including Mr Burford, a registered liquidator. The policy excluded cover for Mr Macks. Mr Macks accepts that the effect of the exclusion was that, for the period of Mr Macks’ suspension, he did not hold cover for potential claims which may have been made during the policy period arising from his past conduct as a registered liquidator prior to the date he ceased to practice as a registered liquidator.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Accordingly, I am not persuaded that I should refuse Mr Macks’ application on the basis of criticisms about his conduct. In the context of all of the matters to which I have referred, I do not consider Mr Macks’ failure to hold run off cover or asserted breaches of the annual return or notice obligations sufficiently weighs against the exercise of my discretion to allow the application for an extension of time. Taking into account all of the matters to which I have referred, I have determined to allow Mr Macks’ application for an extension. The extension will do no more than enable Mr Macks to apply to renew his registration, such application to be addressed afresh by ASIC on the basis of the application and supporting material. If any issues arise thereafter, they can be addressed separately. Conclusion I allow the application. I will hear the parties as to the form of the order I should make including to address the requirement on Mr Macks to file an application for renewal on the portal.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

During the hearing, counsel for ASIC did not take issue with Mr Macks’ submissions concerning the effect of s 33(1) of the Interpretation Act. Counsel accepted that ASIC could consider a further application with the proviso that, if that were to occur after the date of cessation of registration, the only option would be to apply to Court to use the extension of time provision to obtain the necessary extension. Consideration The first issue for determination is whether the Court has power to grant an extension of time. If so, the second issue is whether I should grant an extension of time. Does the Court have the power to grant an extension of time?Judicial consideration of the extension of time provision The power of the Court to grant an extension of time within which an individual may apply to ASIC to have their registration as a liquidator renewed is not expressly fettered or conditioned upon any specified factors. In Deppeler, In the Matter of Deppeler (“Deppeler”),[21] O’Callaghan J addressed an application for an extension of time by liquidators who had inadvertently failed to renew their registration within time. Justice O’Callaghan regarded the considerations for an extension of time as analogous to those applying to the application for an extension of time within which to appeal, including the length of the delay, any acceptable explanation for delay, and whether there is any prejudice to any other party.[22] [21] Deppeler, In the Matter of Deppeler [2017] FCA 768.[22] Deppeler, In the Matter of Deppeler [2017] FCA 768 at [21] (O’Callaghan J). Counsel could not locate any other authorities addressing the extension of time provision and both parties adopted O’Callaghan J’s approach. Does ASIC’s prior decision preclude an extension of time? As set out above, in response to the position set out in ASIC’s written submissions concerning Mr Macks’ failure to seek judicial review in 2023, Mr Macks’ counsel confirmed Mr Macks did not seek judicial review and relied on the Interpretation Act in support of the submission that, if an extension were granted, ASIC could make a fresh decision on the application. ASIC did not take issue with those submissions, subject to questions of the proper interpretation of the legislation. Section 33(1) of the Interpretation Act provides that where an Act confers a power or function or imposes a duty, the power may be exercised and the function or duty must be performed from time to time as occasion requires. In Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v Makasa,[23] the High Court explained that the section was enacted against the background of a common law doctrine to the effect that the first exercise of a power conferred by statute exhausted that power. Section 33(1) of the Interpretation Act counteracts the doctrine by requiring the interpretation of such a provision as authorising the power it confers to be re-exercised from time to time. Section 33(1) of the Interpretation Act does not alter the incidence of the power contained in the provision conferring that power.[24][23]Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v Makasa [2021] HCA 1; (2021) 270 CLR 430.[24] Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v Makasa [2021] HCA 1; (2021) 270 CLR 430 at [45] (Kiefel CJ, Gageler, Keane, Gordon and Edelman JJ).