Australian Securities and Investments Commission v A One Multi Services Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 31 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v A One Multi Services Pty Ltd [2021] FCA 1297

File number: QUD 338 of 2021
Judgment of: DERRINGTON J
Date of judgment: 21 October 2021
Date of publication of reasons: 26 October 2021
Catchwords: CORPORATIONS – investigation by Australian Securities and Investments Commission – ex parte application for appointment of receivers, asset preservation orders, disclosure orders and travel restriction orders – whether it is necessary or desirable that orders be made – interim orders made
Legislation: Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s 1323
Cases cited:

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Australian Investors Forum Pty Ltd (2003) 44 ACSR 503

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Burke [2000] NSWSC 694

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Krecichwost (2007) 64 ACSR 411

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Ludgates Corporate and Investment Advisory Services Pty Ltd (2003) 21 ACLC 1366

Australian Securities Commission v AS Nominees Ltd (1995) 18 ACSR 459

In the matter of Courtenay House Capital Trading Group Pty Ltd [2017] NSWSC 467

In the Matter of Trio Capital Limited (in liq) [2012] NSWSC 1595

Division: General Division
Registry: Queensland
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Regulator and Consumer Protection
Number of paragraphs: 46
Date of hearing: 21 October 2021
Counsel for the Plaintiff: Mr M Steele
Solicitor for the Plaintiff: Australian Securities and Investments Commission

ORDERS

QUD 338 of 2021
BETWEEN:

AUSTRALIAN SECURITIES AND INVESTMENTS COMMISSION

Plaintiff

AND:

A ONE MULTI SERVICES PTY LTD (ACN 612 839 540)

First Defendant

ARYN HENRY HALA

Second Defendant

HEIDI ELIZABETH WALTERS

Third Defendant

ORDER MADE BY:

DERRINGTON J

DATE OF ORDER:

21 OCTOBER 2021

NOTES

In these Orders:

Books:

includes a register, any other record of information, financial reports or financial records however compiled or recorded or stored, a document, papers, records, books of account, ledgers, journals, banking records, computer records, or other documents of any type whatsoever recording or evidencing any dealings of any of the Defendants in relation to the Business.

Business:

means all activities and arrangements whereby the First, Second or Third Defendants, whether by themselves or any of them, or by their servants, agents or employees, elicited or obtained funds from investors for the ostensible purpose of reinvesting, trading with and/or otherwise dealing with such funds for the purpose of providing a return to investors on the funds invested.

Corporations Act:

means the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth).

Dealing:

includes:

(a)       removing, causing, procuring, assisting or permitting any Property in the possession or under the control of the Defendants to be removed from Australia or from the jurisdiction of this Court; and/or

(b)       selling, charging, mortgaging, encumbering, securing, diminishing, disposing of, parting with possession, making any declaration of trust in relation to, exercising any power to vary or modify any trust deed or any interest under any trust in relation to the Defendants’ Property.

Digital Currency:

means property, as defined under section 9 of the Corporations Act, that is a digital currency, virtual currency, cryptocurrency or…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Securities and Investments Commission v A One Mul... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] FCA 1297
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) filed an ex parte application against A One Multi Services Pty Ltd and its directors, Mr Hala and Ms Walters, seeking the appointment of receivers and asset preservation orders. The application was based on allegations that the defendants had engaged in conduct in breach of the Corporations Act and other legislation, involving misrepresentations about investment opportunities and the unauthorised provision of financial services. The evidence presented by ASIC suggested that substantial sums had been received by A One, yet few, if any, returns had been made to investors.

The legal issues before the Court included whether it was necessary or desirable to appoint receivers and managers to the defendants’ assets, to prevent the dissipation of assets and to secure the recovery of investor funds. The Court also needed to determine if asset preservation orders and travel restriction orders should be made to ensure that the defendants could not remove or dissipate their assets, and to prevent them from leaving Australia.

The Court found that the evidence presented by ASIC was sufficient to justify the making of the interim orders sought. The Court noted that the investigation was still in its early stages, but the allegations, if proven, constituted serious breaches of the law. The Court was satisfied that there was a risk of dissipation of assets and that the appointment of receivers and managers was necessary to protect the interests of the investors and to facilitate the investigation. The Court also found that the travel restriction orders were necessary to prevent the defendants from leaving the jurisdiction and thereby interfering with the investigation. The Court made orders appointing receivers and managers, imposing asset preservation orders, requiring the disclosure of financial information, and restricting the travel of the defendants.

The final orders included the appointment of receivers and managers to manage the defendants’ assets, asset preservation orders to prevent the dissipation of assets, disclosure orders requiring the defendants to provide detailed financial information, and travel restriction orders preventing the defendants from leaving Australia. The Court also made non-publication orders to protect the integrity of the investigation and to prevent prejudice to the defendants until the material could be served on them. The case is listed for a case management hearing to further the investigation and to determine the next steps in the proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Filing and service of process

1. The Plaintiff have leave to file the affidavit of Jessica Mary Latimer affirmed on 20 October 2021 (First Latimer Affidavit), the supplementary affidavit of Jessica Mary Latimer affirmed on 20 October 2021 (Second Latimer Affidavit) and the affidavit of Meaghan Lesley Brooks sworn on 19 October 2021 (Brooks Affidavit).

2. Service of the originating process filed on 20 October 2021 (Originating Process) is dispensed with.

3. The Originating Process is returnable instanter.

4. The time for service of the Originating Process, the First Latimer Affidavit, the Second Latimer Affidavit and the Brooks Affidavit on the First, Second and Third Defendants is abridged to 5:00 pm AEST on 25 October 2021.

Receiver orders

5. Pursuant to sections 1323(1)(h) and (3) of the Corporations Act, effective on and from 11:59 pm AEST on 21 October 2021, John Ross Lindholm of KPMG, 727 Collins Street, Melbourne, Victoria and Timothy James Michael of KPMG, 71 Eagle Street, Brisbane, Queensland be appointed as joint and several receivers and/or receivers and managers (Receivers) of the Property of each of the First and Second and Third Defendants, until further order, for the purpose of:

(a) identifying, collecting and securing the Property of the First, Second and Third Defendants held for the purposes of the Business;

(b) ascertaining the amount of the Investor Funds received by the First, Second or Third Defendants;

(c) identifying any dealings with, payments of, or distributions by or uses made of the Investor Funds by the First, Second or Third Defendants;

(d) identifying any Property purchased or acquired with Investor Funds;

(e) recovering Investor Funds; and

(f) providing a report to the Court within 28 days in relation to the matters referred to in sub-paragraphs (a) to (e) above.

6. The Receivers shall have the following powers:

(a) the powers set out in subsections 420(2)(a), (b), (e), (f), (g), (k), (n), (o), (p), (q), (r), (t) and (u) of the Corporations Act and can exercise those powers in respect of the Property of the First and Second and Third Defendants as if, in the case of the Second and Third Defendants, the Second and Third Defendants were corporations; and

(b) the power to apply to the Court for directions or further orders.

7. The Defendants shall immediately deliver up to the Receivers all the books, records and other papers including, but not limited to, all files, computer records and data in their possession, custody or control which relate to the Business or to the Property of the Defendants.

8. The Plaintiff shall, upon the request of the Receivers, deliver up to the Receivers copies of the First Latimer Affidavit, the Second Latimer Affidavit and the Brooks Affidavit.

9. The Receivers’ reasonable costs and expenses be payable from the Property of the First and Second and Third Defendants.

Asset prevention orders

10. Subject to Order 12 below, pursuant to section 1323 of the Corporations Act, until further order, the First and Second and Third Defendants, by themselves and their servants, agents and employees are restrained from:

(a) removing, or causing or permitting to be removed from Australia all or any of the Property of any of the Defendants;

(b) selling, charging, mortgaging or otherwise dealing with, disposing of and/or diminishing the value of all or any of the Property of any of the Defendants;

(c) causing or permitting to be sold, charged, mortgaged or otherwise dealt with, disposed of, or diminished in value, all or any of the Property of any of the Defendants;

(d) without limiting the terms of sub-paragraphs (a) to (c) above, incurring liabilities including, without limitations, liabilities incurred either directly or indirectly, through the use of a credit card, a credit facility, a drawdown facility or a re-draw facility; and

(e) without limiting the terms of sub-paragraphs (a) to (d) above, withdrawing, transferring or otherwise disposing of any monies or Digital Currency available in any account with any bank, building society, cryptocurrency exchange, recorded in any blockchain or other financial institution (in Australia and elsewhere), in which the Defendants have any legal or equitable interest.

11. Further to the Orders 6, 7 and 8 above, subject to Order 12 below, and without limiting the terms of Order 10 above, the First and Second and Third Defendants are to do all things necessary to effect forthwith, or at least before 5:00 pm AEST on 23 October 2021, the transfer of control over any and all Digital Currency held by the Defendants to the Receivers, including but not limited to providing the Receivers with:

(a) all relevant credentials and passwords for access to any cryptocurrency held by the Defendants, including but not limited to, the public and private keys and / or seed string for any soft or cold wallet held or controlled by the Defendants;

(b) any and all authentication devices required to facilitate access, operation or control of any cryptocurrency held or controlled by the Defendants;

(c) all relevant credentials and passwords for access to the authentication devices or systems, including email, SMS or mobile apps, that facilitate access, operation or control of cryptocurrency held or controlled by the Defendants; and

(d) any cold wallet device containing cryptocurrency held or controlled by the Defendants together with that device’s access code.

The information to be provided by the Defendants to give effect to this Order may, amongst other means, be provided to the Receivers in person, by contacting the Receivers by telephone (John Ross Lindholm on 0419 307 879 or Timothy James Michael on 0412 090 170) or by email addressed to jlindholm@kpmg.com.au or tmichael2@kpmg.com.au.

12. Orders 10 and 11 above do not prevent:

(a) the First or Second or Third Defendants from paying or otherwise incurring a liability for ordinary living and operating expenses up to an amount of eight hundred dollars ($800) per week each;

(b) the First or Second or Third Defendants from paying or otherwise incurring a liability for costs reasonably incurred in these proceedings and any criminal proceedings arising from the Plaintiff’s investigation into the affairs of the First or Second or Third Defendants; and

(c) any bank, building society or financial institution from exercising any right of set-off which it may have in respect of a facility afforded by it to the First or Second or Third Defendants prior to the date of this Order.

Disclosure orders

13. Except to the extent that a claim of privilege against self-incrimination or civil penalty privilege is made, the First Defendant, by a proper officer, is to deliver or cause to be delivered to the Plaintiff and any Receivers appointed by the Court, by 9:45 am AEST on the date which is 14 days after service of this Order, a full and detailed affidavit sworn or affirmed by a proper officer of the First Defendant setting out:

(a) the name and address of any bank, building society or other financial institution at which there is an account in the name of or under the control of the First Defendant, together with the number of such account, the name of such account and the balance of that account;

(b) a list of the locations for all cryptocurrency held or controlled by the First Defendant together with the public access keys for any soft or cold wallets held or controlled by the First Defendant and the nature and amount of the cryptocurrency held in any such wallets;

(c) a list of any escrow accounts which hold cryptocurrency on the First Defendant’s behalf;

(d) the name and address of any person or persons indebted to the First Defendant and the amount of the indebtedness;

(e) an itemised inventory of the First Defendant's assets and liabilities;

(f) an itemised inventory of any and all Property whether real or personal owned or controlled by the First Defendant or in which the First Defendant has any legal or beneficial interest;

(g) in respect of any of the Property of the First Defendant which has been given as security for any debt, the details of that Property and the nature of the security and the debt so incurred; and

(h) a comprehensive and detailed list of all persons who, in the period 1 January 2019 to the date of this Order, have provided monies to the First Defendant or any entity associated with it for the purpose of investing in the Business, such list to include particulars of:

(i) the name, address and other contact details of each such person;

(ii) the amount(s) paid by such person identifying the date or dates on which payment was received;

(iii) the manner in which each payment was received, and how that money or part thereof, was expended or applied; and

(iv) the amount calculated by the First Defendant as presently owing to each such person arising out of operation of the Business (including a full statement of debits and credits relating to such person’s investment).

14. Except to the extent that a claim of privilege against self-incrimination or civil penalty privilege is made, the Second Defendant is to deliver or cause to be delivered to the Plaintiff and any Receivers appointed by the Court, by 9:45 am AEST on the date which is 14 days after service of this Order, a full and detailed affidavit sworn or affirmed by the Second Defendant setting out to the best of the Second Defendant’s knowledge or belief:

(a) the name and address of any bank, building society or other financial institution at which there is an account in the name of or under the control of the Second Defendant, together with the number of such accounts, the name of any such account and the balance of any such account;

(b) a list of the locations of all cryptocurrency held or controlled by the Second Defendant together with the public access keys for any soft or cold wallets held or controlled by the Second Defendant and the nature and amount of the cryptocurrency held in any such wallets;

(c) a list of all escrow accounts which hold cryptocurrency on behalf of the Second Defendant;

(d) the name and address of any person or persons indebted to the Second Defendant and the amount of the indebtedness;

(e) an itemised inventory of the Second Defendant's assets and liabilities;

(f) an itemised inventory of any and all Property whether real or personal owned or controlled by the Second Defendant or in which the Second Defendant has any legal or beneficial interest; and

(g) in respect of any of the Property of the Second Defendant which has been given as security for any debt, the details of that Property and the nature of the security and the debt so incurred.

15. Except to the extent that a claim of privilege against self-incrimination or civil penalty privilege is made, the Third Defendant is to deliver or cause to be delivered to the Plaintiff and any Receivers appointed by the Court, by 9:45 am AEST on the date which is 14 days after service of this Order, a full and detailed affidavit sworn or affirmed by the Third Defendant setting out to the best of the Third Defendant’s knowledge or belief:

(a) the name and address of any bank, building society or other financial institution at which there is an account in the name of or under the control of the Third Defendant, together with the number of such accounts, the name of any such account and the balance of any such account;

(b) a list of the locations of all cryptocurrency held or controlled by the Third Defendant together with the public access keys for any soft or cold wallets held or controlled by the Third Defendant and the nature and amount of the cryptocurrency held in any such wallets;

(c) a list of any escrow accounts which hold cryptocurrency on the Third Defendant’s behalf;

(d) the name and address of any person or persons indebted to the Third Defendant and the amount of the indebtedness;

(e) an itemised inventory of the Third Defendant's assets and liabilities;

(f) an itemised inventory of any and all Property whether real or personal owned or controlled by the Third Defendant or in which the Third Defendant has any legal or beneficial interest; and

(g) in respect of any of the Property of the Third Defendant which has been given as security for any debt, the details of that Property and the nature of the security and the debt so incurred.

16. In the event that the First or Second or Third Defendant wishes to object to compliance with Orders 13 or 14 or 15 above, on the basis that compliance may tend to incriminate the Defendant or make the Defendant liable to a civil penalty, the relevant Defendant is to, in accordance with section 128A of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth):

(a) prepare, file and serve on the Plaintiff an affidavit disclosing so much of the information required to be disclosed by Orders 13, 14 or 15 to which no objection is taken;

(b) prepare an affidavit containing so much of the information required to be disclosed by Orders 13, 14 or 15 to which objection is taken and deliver it to the Court in a sealed envelope; and

(c) prepare, file and serve on the Plaintiff a separate affidavit setting out the basis of the objection.

Travel restraint orders

17. Pursuant to section 1323(1)(k) of the Corporations Act, until further order, the Second Defendant and the Third Defendant are restrained from leaving or attempting to leave Australia.

18. Pursuant to section 1323(1)(j) of the Corporations Act, until further order, the Second Defendant is to deliver up to the Registry of this Court, all passports in his name which are in his possession, custody or control and any airline tickets concerning any travel arrangements made for the twelve (12) month period commencing from the date of this Order.

19. Pursuant to section 1323(1)(j) of the Corporations Act, until further order, the Third Defendant is to deliver up to the Registry of this Court, all passports in her name which are in her possession, custody or control and any airline tickets concerning any travel arrangements made for the twelve (12) month period commencing from the date of this Order.

20. The documents delivered up to the Registry pursuant to Orders 18 and 19 above are to be held by the Registry until further order.

21. Pursuant to section 1323(1)(j) of the Corporations Act, in the event that the Second Defendant cannot locate any passport, he is to:

(a) give notification to the Australian Passport Office, or other relevant authorities responsible for the issue and control of Australian passports, confirming that he has lost his passport; and

(b) file an affidavit within 14 days of the date of this Order stating that fact and exhibiting a copy of the notification sent.

22. Pursuant to section 1323(1)(j) of the Corporations Act, in the event that the Third Defendant cannot locate any passport, she is to:

(a) give notification to the Australian Passport Office, or other relevant authorities responsible for the issue and control of Australian passports, confirming that she has lost her passport; and

(b) file an affidavit within 14 days of the date of this Order stating that fact and exhibiting a copy of the notification sent.

Service of Orders on Third Parties

23. To the extent necessary, the Plaintiff has leave to give to:

(a) the relevant authorities that record, control and regulate the ownership of real property;

(b) the relevant authorities that record, control and regulate the ownership of motor vehicles;

(c) the relevant authorities that record, control and regulate the ownership of maritime vessels and craft;

(d) any bank, building society, cryptocurrency exchange or other financial institution through which, to the best of the Plaintiff’s belief, Property belongs to the First or Second or Third Defendant;

(e) any other person or entity, holding or controlling Property, which, to the best of the Plaintiff’s belief, belongs to the First or Second or Third Defendant;

(f) the relevant authorities that issue and control passports; and

(g) the Australian Border Force;

notice of the making of any of the foregoing interim orders by giving a copy of the minute of the orders to a person apparently in the employ of any such entity or person.

Non-publication orders

24. Pursuant to sections 37AF(1)(a) and (b) and 37AG(1)(a) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth), in order to avoid prejudice to the proper administration of justice, the publication or disclosure of the following is prohibited until 11:00 am AEST on 22 October 2021, except to enable the Plaintiff to serve the Defendants, provide copies of the material to the Receivers pursuant to Order 8 and provide copies of the Orders to the entities set out in Order 23 for the purpose of enforcing the Orders:

(a) any ex-parte orders obtained by the Plaintiff;

(b) this Originating Process;

(c) the First Latimer Affidavit (including the exhibits to that affidavit);

(d) the Second Latimer Affidavit;

(e) the Brooks Affidavit (including the exhibits to that affidavit);

(f) the Receivers’ Consent; and

(g) any written submissions advanced by the Plaintiff in support of the ex-parte orders.

General orders

25. Costs be reserved.

26. There be liberty to any party to apply to the Commercial & Corporations List Judge on reasonable notice.

27. There be a case management hearing at 10:00 am AEST on 1 November 2021.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

In seeking the relief which it does, ASIC relies upon the Court’s powers pursuant to s 1323 of the Corporations Act to make orders to protect the assets currently in the possession of the defendants from dissipation on the basis that they might be used to compensate the persons from whom the funds have been borrowed. Background A One is a company of which Mr Hala, the second defendant, and Ms Walters, the third defendant, are each shareholders. Since 17 September 2019, Mr Hala has been its sole director and secretary. Prior to that, Ms Walters had been the sole director and shareholder. It is significant that Mr Hala and Ms Walters are the sole signatories on a number of A One’s bank accounts. The evidence before this Court establishes that none of the defendants hold or has ever held an Australian Financial Services Licence (AFSL), none have ever been the authorised representatives of the holder of an AFSL and none are authorised to provide financial services in Australia, or, for that matter, to deal with financial products to the extent there is any difference. By an affidavit of Ms Jessica Latimer, a senior manager in ASIC, evidence has been adduced as to the course of an investigation into the activities of the defendants. That investigation commenced on 18 June 2021 and was concerned with contraventions of certain provisions of the Corporations Act relating to the requirement to hold an AFSL (s 911A), making false or misleading statements (s 1041E), engaging in misleading or deceptive conduct (s 1041H), engaging in dishonest conduct (s 1041G), as well as s 408C of the Criminal Code, being the offence of fraud, and s 68B of the Superannuation Industry (Supervision) Act, being the promotion of illegal early release scheme. It should be mentioned that the investigation has evolved over time and, in particular, that part of the investigation in relation to a contravention of section 68B has subsequently been abandoned. In any event, the evidence before the Court discloses that Mr Hala and Ms Walters made representations to individuals as being potential investors and advised them of Mr Hala’s business of investment and his alleged apparent success. It appears that Mr Hala promoted his ability to earn substantial returns on investments if money were invested in his businesses. Representations were made of his ability to generate returns of between 10% and 20% on the investment and perhaps as high as 26%. As part of the process of securing investments, it is apparent that Mr Hala and Ms Walters advised many potential investors to establish their own SMSFs and to transfer existing superannuation from their managed or industry superannuation funds into the SMSFs from which they could lend money to A One. It is apparent that the defendants, through intermediaries, arranged the documentation by which these SMSFs would be established. Once the funds had been transferred to the SMSF, a loan agreement was entered into with A One. I mention that the investigations at this stage are in an embryonic stage. The evidence adduced suggests a pattern of behaviour of the above nature, but it must always be kept steadily in mind that full investigations have yet to be completed. Nevertheless, on the evidence presently available, it seems that very few returns, if any, have been made to investors. ASIC has conducted thorough examinations of the bank accounts of A One, in particular it has examined the activities of an A One CBA account and an A One ANZ account. It has ascertained that in the period between 1 January 2019 and 22 June 2021 a total of $25 million was deposited into those accounts.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established