FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Australian Prudential Regulation Authority v Holloway [2000] FCA 579
SUPERANNUATION – alleged contravention of s 85 of Superannuation Industry (Supervision) Act 1993 (Cth) – years of income prior to 1998-99 – whether there can be a contravention of s 85 concerning market value ratio of in-house assets of regulated superannuation fund for years of income prior to 1998-99 – s 83 of Act prohibits acquisition of in-house assets of a fund if a certain market value ratio results from that acquisition – whether s 83 concerning acquisition of assets applies to years of income prior to 1998-99.
SUPERANNUATION – alleged contravention of s 85 of Superannuation Industry (Supervision) Act 1993 (Cth) – artificial reduction in market value ratio of in-house assets of regulated superannuation fund – ss 76-80 impose restrictions on historical cost ratio of in-house assets of fund for years of income 1994-95 to 1997-98 – whether scheme to avoid provisions of the Act concerning historical cost ratio of in-house assets of fund may contravene s 85.
SUPERANNUATION – alleged contravention of s 85 of Superannuation Industry (Supervision) Act 1993 (Cth) – in-house asset – investment by regulated superannuation fund in units in unit trust where investments by unit trust controlled by trustees of superannuation fund and directors of employer-sponsor unit trust lends monies from such investment to employer-sponsor – whether investment in units in unit trust an “in-house asset” of superannuation fund – whether investment in units a loan to or an investment in employer-sponsor within s 71(1).
SUPERANNUATION – alleged contravention of s 85 of Superannuation Industry (Supervision) Act 1993 (Cth) – in-house asset – investment by regulated superannuation fund in units in unit trust where investments by unit trust controlled by trustees of superannuation fund and directors of employer-sponsor – unit trust lends monies from such investment to employer-sponsor – whether investment in units an “in-house asset” of superannuation fund – whether investment in units result of agreement for purpose of achieving result that loan to or investment in employer-sponsor would be made – whether “in-house asset” by operation of s 71(2)(c).
SUPERANNUATION – alleged contravention of s 85 of Superannuation Industry (Supervision) Act 1993 (Cth) – meaning of “scheme” in s 85(4) – whether requirement for mutual obligations – whether requirement for proscribed intention on part of two or more persons to contravene s 85(1) – whether necessary to show intention to artificially reduce market value ratio of in-house assets of fund or whether sufficient to show intention to carry out or cause to be carried out acts which had that effect – whether necessary intention established.
SUPERANNUATION – alleged contravention of s 85 of Superannuation Industry (Supervision) Act 1993 (Cth) – investment by regulated superannuation fund in units in unit trust pursuant to agreement for purpose of achieving result that money so invested would be paid to employer-sponsor to reduce indebtedness of unit trust to employer sponsor – whether loan to or investment in employer-sponsor – whether investment by superannuation…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Prudential Regulation Authority v Holloway and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2000] FCA 579
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court considered the wording of section 83 and the structure of the Act to determine its applicability. APRA argued that section 83 applied to the entire period from the commencement of Part 8, including the specified years of income, imposing a maximum market value ratio of 5% on funds acquiring assets during that period. Conversely, the respondents contended that section 83 only applied from the 1998-99 financial year, based on its placement in Division 3 of Part 8 and the heading to Division 3, which suggests it operates in conjunction with sections that deal with market value ratios from that year onwards. The court found that the references in section 85(1) to market value ratios, and the absence of any reference to historical cost ratios, meant that section 85 would only apply to schemes intended to contravene provisions of Part 8 that impose market value ratio limits on funds.
In conclusion, the court held that the respondents did not carry out a scheme with the intention of artificially reducing the market value ratio of the in-house assets of the funds, so as to avoid the application of sections 76 to 80 of Part 8 of the Act. Furthermore, the court found that section 83 did not apply to the transactions in question, as it only became operative from the 1998-99 financial year. The court dismissed APRA's claims and ordered that APRA pay the costs of the respondents.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Accordingly, in respect of all the transactions under consideration, I do not consider that the respondents carried out a scheme within the meaning of s 85(1) of the Act with the intention that the scheme would result in, or be likely to result in, an artificial reduction in the market value ratio of the in-house assets of any of those funds, so that that artificial reduction would avoid the application of the provisions of ss 76-80 of Pt 8 of the Act.(ii)The operation of s 83 There remains the question whether there can be a contravention of s 85 if the artificial reduction of the market value ratio of the in-house assets of a regulated superannuation fund operated in the years of income 1994-95 to 1996-97. In other words, the question is whether s 83 of the Act applied during those years of income. APRA contended that s 83 applies in respect of the whole of the period from the commencement of Pt 8, including during the 1994-95, 1995-96 and 1996-97 years of income (the years during which the transactions under consideration occurred). It therefore applies to the acquisition of any in-house asset by a fund during that period. It imposes the maximum market value ratio of 5 per cent upon funds in respect of the acquisition of an asset by a fund over that whole period, so s 85 then operates in respect of each of the transactions. The respondents contend that s 83 only operates, upon its proper construction, in and after the 1998-99 financial year. They place reliance upon the fact that s 81 is in Div 3 of Pt 8 of the Act, upon the heading to Div 3, and that s 83 follows sections which also deal with market value ratios and which operate only in relation to the 1998-99 year of income and thereafter. As noted earlier, Div 2 of Pt 8 (containing ss 76–80) prescribes historical cost ratio limits for in-house assets for the years of income between 1994-95 and 1997-98. Section 83 is in Div 3 of Pt 8 (containing ss 81–82). Sections 81 and 82 prescribe market value ratio limits for in-house assets for the years of income from 1998-99 onwards. Section 81 prescribes the maximum market value ratio for in-house assets of a fund for the years of income 1998-99 and 1999-2000 as 10 per cent and s 82 prescribes the maximum market value ratio for in-house assets of a fund for the years thereafter as 5 per cent. Each operates with respect to the end of each year of income, rather than continuously through the year of income or at other points of time during the years of income. Division 4 of Pt 8 (s 84) obliges the trustee of a fund to take all reasonable steps to ensure that Divs 2 and 3 are complied with. It provides that the failure to do so is a civil penalty provision as defined in s 193, so as to attract consequences for its contravention. Division 5 of Pt 8 (s 85) is concerned with schemes intended to contravene any provision of Pt 8 of the Act, although I have found that the reference in s 85(1)(a) to market value ratio and the absence of any reference in s 85(1) to historical cost ratios has the consequence that it will only have effect with respect to schemes which are intended to contravene a provision of Pt 8 which imposes market value ratio limits upon a fund.