Australian Mud Company Pty Ltd v Coretell Pty Ltd (No 7)

Link copied
Case Copied 73 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Mud Company Pty Ltd v Coretell Pty Ltd (No 7) [2016] FCA 991

File number: WAD 132 of 2007
Judge: BARKER J
Date of judgment: 19 August 2016
Catchwords:

DAMAGES – innovation patents – where patent infringement proceedings dismissed – where cross-claim of patent invalidity dismissed – where threats to bring infringement proceedings declared unjustifiable threats under s 128 of Patents Act 1990 (Cth) – whether first respondent a “person aggrieved” for purposes of s 128 of Patents Act 1990 (Cth) – whether first respondent held a relevant interest in the tool the subject of the threats at material times – whether valid assignment of interest in tool – whether tool of merchantable quality at material times – whether first respondent had a business in the tool at material times – whether threat letters caused first respondent to suffer loss and damage – quantum of loss and damage

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – where finding of no assignment in related proceeding – where risk of inconsistent findings – finding of assignment made on the evidence in this proceeding

Legislation:

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) ss 79, 80, 135, 191

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 51A, 51A(2)(a)

Patents Act 1990 (Cth) s 128, 128(1), 128(1)(a), 128(1)(c)

Cases cited:

Australian Guarantee Corporation Limited v Border Printing Services Pty Ltd & Ors [1989] FCA 194

Australian Mud Company Pty Ltd (ACN 009 283 416 and Others v Coretell Pty Ltd(ACN 119 188 493) and Another (2010) 88 IPR 270; [2010] FCA 1169

Australian Mud Company Pty Ltd and Others v Coretell Pty Ltd and Another (2011) 93 IPR 188; [2011] FCAFC 121

Australian Mud Company Pty Ltd v Coretell Pty Ltd (No 2) [2010] FCA 1451

Australian Mud Company Pty Ltd v Coretell Pty Ltd(No 5) [2016] FCA 444

Castel Electronics Pty Ltd v Toshiba Singapore Pte Ltd (2011) 192 FCR 445; [2011] FCAFC 55

Fair Work Ombudsman v Skilled Offshore (Australia) Pty Ltd (No 2) [2015] FCA 1509

Hanave Pty Ltd v LFOT Pty Ltd (2004) 136 FCR 566; [2004] FCAFC 180

JMVB Enterprises Pty Ltd v Camoflag Pty Ltd (2005) 67 IPR 68; [2005] FCA 1474

John Summers & Sons Ltd v Cold Metal Process Co (1948) 65 RPC 75

Johnson v Edge (1892) 2 Ch 1

Makita (Australia) Pty Ltd v Sprowles (2001) 52 NSWLR 705; [2001] NSWCA 305

Minnesota Mining & Manufacturing Co v Tyco Electronics Pty Ltd (2002) 56 IPR 248; [2002] FCAFC 315

National Telecoms Group Ltd v John Fairfax Publications Pty Ltd (No 1) [2011] NSWSC 455

Date of hearing: 8-12 December 2014, 10 March 2016
Date of last submissions after substantive hearing: 24 February 2015
Registry: Western Australia
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Intellectual Property
Sub-area: Patents and associated Statutes
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 870
Counsel for the Applicants: Mr JM Hennessy SC
Solicitor for the Applicants: Gilbert + Tobin
Counsel for the Respondents: Mr BJ Hess QC…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Mud Company Pty Ltd v Coretell Pty Ltd (No 7) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] FCA 991
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Australian Mud Company Pty Ltd, Imdex Pty Ltd, and Reflex Geophysical Pty Ltd (the Applicants) sought damages against Coretell Pty Ltd (the First Respondent) for the latter’s alleged threats of patent infringement. The Applicants argued that Coretell had made unjustifiable threats to bring proceedings for patent infringement against them, their associates, or their customers under section 128 of the Patents Act 1990 (Cth). The Applicants claimed damages for loss and damage suffered due to Coretell’s threats. The case was heard in the Federal Court of Australia.

The legal issues the Court had to decide were whether Coretell was a “person aggrieved” for the purposes of section 128 of the Patents Act, if Coretell held a relevant interest in the tool at the material times, whether there was a valid assignment of interest in the tool, whether the tool was of merchantable quality at the material times, whether Coretell had a business in the tool at the material times, whether the threat letters caused Coretell to suffer loss and damage, and the quantum of loss and damage. The Court also had to consider the risk of inconsistent findings in light of a previous finding of no assignment in a related proceeding.

The Court found that Coretell was a “person aggrieved” for the purposes of section 128 of the Patents Act, as it held a relevant interest in the tool at the material times. The Court found that there was a valid assignment of interest in the tool. The Court held that the tool was of merchantable quality at the material times, and that Coretell had a business in the tool at the material times. The threat letters caused Coretell to suffer loss and damage, which the Court quantified. The Court found that the risk of inconsistent findings did not apply in this case, as the evidence in this proceeding was sufficient to make the findings.

The Court ordered that the first respondent, following consultation with the applicants, file a proposed minute of orders giving effect to these reasons. The Court also ordered that the applicants’ interlocutory application for summary judgment be dismissed with costs, which were to be taxed if not agreed. The Court would hear further from the parties if necessary on the question of the calculation of pre-judgment interest and costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The first respondent, following consultation with the applicants, to file a proposed minute of orders giving effect to these reasons.

2. The Court will hear further from the parties, if necessary, on the question of the calculation of pre-judgment interest and costs.

3. The applicants’ interlocutory application for summary judgment filed 11 December 2015 be dismissed with costs, such costs to be taxed if not agreed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

In order to answer these questions a range of factual findings need to be made having regard to facts agreed by the parties and the testimony of witnesses called at the damages enquiry and the evidence led. Factual matters will be considered first and then each of the key questions will be answered. The evidence of the expert accounting witnesses Mr Meredith and Mr Ross will be considered separately later.Agreed facts The factual circumstances in which the damages enquiry is to be conducted are the subject of a statement of agreed facts made by the parties dated 26 November 2014, and received by the Court pursuant to s 191 of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth). The agreed facts are as follows:1This Statement of Agreed Facts (SOAF) is made jointly by the First Applicant (AMC), Second Applicant (Imdex), Third Applicant (Reflex) and First Respondent (Coretell), pursuant to section 191 of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth).The Parties2Coretell was incorporated on 25 May 2006.3Coretell is and was at all material times an associated entity of Mincrest Holdings Pty Ltd (Mincrest) and Kleyn Investments Pty Ltd (Kleyn Investments) within the meaning of s.50AAA of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth).4Coretell’s business address is at the premises at 6 Davison Street, Maddington, Western Australia (the Maddington Warehouse).5Mincrest was incorporated on 17 March 1995.6Mincrest:(a)is and was at all material times an associated entity of Coretell and Kleyn Investments within the meaning of s.50AAA of the Corporations Act;(b)is the trustee of the Kleyn Family Trust ABN 39 593 588 385.7Kleyn Investments was incorporated on 29 March 2006.8Kleyn Investments:(a)is and was at all material times an associated entity of Coretell and Mincrest within the meaning of s.50AAA of the Corporations Act,(b)the owner of the business name Camteq International Services, registered on 23 November 2009; and(c)the trustee of the Kleyn Investment Trust ABN 71 981 731 047.9The business address for Kleyn Investments is the Maddington Warehouse.10Mr Nicky Kleyn (Mr Kleyn) is and was at all material times engaged in and responsible for directing the conduct, management, control and day to day operations of:(a)Coretell;(b)Mincrest; and(c)Kleyn Investments.Theequipment11Core orientation tools indicate the orientation of core samples.12Survey instruments (cameras) determine geo-spatial properties of down-hole environments.13These pieces of equipment are complementary products; typically drilling rig operators require the supply of both before commencing drilling and mineral exploration activities.14The applicants’ core orientation tool is the Ace Core Tool (ACT). Coretellequipment15There are two models of ‘Coretell Equipment’:(a)the core orientation tool (the First Tool) as described in the document entitled “Camteq- Orientation Tool quick user guide” (Camteq User Manual); and(b)the core orientation tool (the Second Tool), as described in the documents entitled “ORishot Tool - Quick user guide” and “ORishot multifunction Orientation Instrument” available at: .com.au/ppp_oritool.htm (together, the ORishot User Manual),(together, the Coretell Equipment).16The Second Tool is comprised of probe Part Number CNPS100 and handset Part Number CNH 100.17Coretell updated, amongst other things, the Second Tool’s handset design and wireless communication means in about May 2012.18Photographs of the First Tool are at Annexure A.19Photographs of the Second Tool are at Annexure B.Development of the Coretell Equipment20In late 2004, Mincrest engaged Mr Ashley Barker (Mr Barker) to develop and manufacture a core orientation tool, which would become the First Tool.21Between 5 September 2005 and November 2006, Mincrest:(a)manufactured or caused to be manufactured the First Tool; and(b)kept stock of the First Tool at Lot 4 Reservoir Road, Orange Grove, Western Australia (Orange Grove).22From about December 2005 until around December 2006 the First Tools were trialled without payment with potential customers by Mincrest.23On 31 October 2006, Mincrest supplied six First Tools to MTL Philippines. Mincrest invoiced MTL Philippines and was paid by MTL Philippines for these tools.24On 16 November 2006, Mincrest received the first unjustified threat in these proceedings, being a letter from Mallon & Co to Mincrest dated 14 November 2006 alleging infringement of AMC’s patent.25On 22 November 2006 Arns & Associates replied to Mallon & Co on behalf of Coretell denying infringement of the patent and challenging its validity.26On around 5 December 2006, the Applicants made a further unjustified threat of patent infringement by a letter from Mallon & Co to Arns & Associates.27On 14 December 2006 Arns & Associates replied to Mallon & Co.28On 31 January 2007, two invoices issued on Mincrest letterhead to Silver City Drilling (NSW) Pty Ltd (Silver City) for the hire of four First Tools. Mincrest was paid by Silver City for these tools.29On 13 February 2007, the Applicants made a further unjustified threat of patent infringement by letter from Mallon & Co to Arns & Associates.30On 28 February 2007 and monthly until 1 July 2007, Coretell invoiced Silver City for the hire of kits of the First Tool. These invoices were paid by Silver City.31On 31 May 2007 and 1 July 2007, Coretell issued invoices in respect of the hire of kits of the First Tool to GOS Drilling (GOS). These invoices were paid by GOS.32On 2 July 2007, the Applicants commenced these proceedings.33By 31 July 2007, Mr Barker was instructed to cease manufacturing the First Tool.34Since January 2009, Coretell has:(a)made and thereafter supplied, hired and offered for supply and hire and kept for the purposes of supply and hire Second Tools to customers and distribution agents for use:-1 in Australia; and2 in countries outside Australia;(b)kept Second Tools at Orange Grove and, since September 2010, at the Maddington Warehouse; and(c)supplied Second Tools to customers and distribution agents in Australia and in countries outside Australia together with the ORishot User Manual and such Second Tools have been used in accordance with the ORishot User Manual.Previous Proceedings35The First Tool and the Second Tool were the subject of a claim of patent infringement of Innovation Patent 2006100113 by Imdex and the First and Second Applicants, which claim was unsuccessful:(a)at trial (WAD 132 of 2007; [2010] FCA 1169); and(b)on appeal (WAD 8 of 2011; [2011] FCAFC 121).36The First Tool and the Second Tool were subject of a claim of patent infringement in respect of Australian Innovation Patent No AU2010101356 entitled ‘Core Sample Orientation’ and Australian Innovation Patent No AU20111 01041 entitled ‘Core Sample Orientation’ in proceedings NSD 2082 of 2011. The claims of patent infringement were heard in a trial that concluded in July 2014 and in respect of which judgment is yet to be delivered.[insert photographs]Evidence received at the hearing

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The factual circumstances in which the damages enquiry is to be conducted are the subject of a statement of agreed facts made by the parties dated 26 November 2014, and received by the Court pursuant to s 191 of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth). The agreed facts are as follows:1This Statement of Agreed Facts (SOAF) is made jointly by the First Applicant (AMC), Second Applicant (Imdex), Third Applicant (Reflex) and First Respondent (Coretell), pursuant to section 191 of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth).The Parties2Coretell was incorporated on 25 May 2006.3Coretell is and was at all material times an associated entity of Mincrest Holdings Pty Ltd (Mincrest) and Kleyn Investments Pty Ltd (Kleyn Investments) within the meaning of s.50AAA of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth).4Coretell’s business address is at the premises at 6 Davison Street, Maddington, Western Australia (the Maddington Warehouse).5Mincrest was incorporated on 17 March 1995.6Mincrest:(a)is and was at all material times an associated entity of Coretell and Kleyn Investments within the meaning of s.50AAA of the Corporations Act;(b)is the trustee of the Kleyn Family Trust ABN 39 593 588 385.7Kleyn Investments was incorporated on 29 March 2006.8Kleyn Investments:(a)is and was at all material times an associated entity of Coretell and Mincrest within the meaning of s.50AAA of the Corporations Act,(b)the owner of the business name Camteq International Services, registered on 23 November 2009; and(c)the trustee of the Kleyn Investment Trust ABN 71 981 731 047.9The business address for Kleyn Investments is the Maddington Warehouse.10Mr Nicky Kleyn (Mr Kleyn) is and was at all material times engaged in and responsible for directing the conduct, management, control and day to day operations of:(a)Coretell;(b)Mincrest; and(c)Kleyn Investments.Theequipment11Core orientation tools indicate the orientation of core samples.12Survey instruments (cameras) determine geo-spatial properties of down-hole environments.13These pieces of equipment are complementary products; typically drilling rig operators require the supply of both before commencing drilling and mineral exploration activities.14The applicants’ core orientation tool is the Ace Core Tool (ACT). Coretellequipment15There are two models of ‘Coretell Equipment’:(a)the core orientation tool (the First Tool) as described in the document entitled “Camteq- Orientation Tool quick user guide” (Camteq User Manual); and(b)the core orientation tool (the Second Tool), as described in the documents entitled “ORishot Tool - Quick user guide” and “ORishot multifunction Orientation Instrument” available at: .com.au/ppp_oritool.htm (together, the ORishot User Manual),(together, the Coretell Equipment).16The Second Tool is comprised of probe Part Number CNPS100 and handset Part Number CNH 100.17Coretell updated, amongst other things, the Second Tool’s handset design and wireless communication means in about May 2012.18Photographs of the First Tool are at Annexure A.19Photographs of the Second Tool are at Annexure B.Development of the Coretell Equipment20In late 2004, Mincrest engaged Mr Ashley Barker (Mr Barker) to develop and manufacture a core orientation tool, which would become the First Tool.21Between 5 September 2005 and November 2006, Mincrest:(a)manufactured or caused to be manufactured the First Tool; and(b)kept stock of the First Tool at Lot 4 Reservoir Road, Orange Grove, Western Australia (Orange Grove).22From about December 2005 until around December 2006 the First Tools were trialled without payment with potential customers by Mincrest.23On 31 October 2006, Mincrest supplied six First Tools to MTL Philippines. Mincrest invoiced MTL Philippines and was paid by MTL Philippines for these tools.24On 16 November 2006, Mincrest received the first unjustified threat in these proceedings, being a letter from Mallon & Co to Mincrest dated 14 November 2006 alleging infringement of AMC’s patent.25On 22 November 2006 Arns & Associates replied to Mallon & Co on behalf of Coretell denying infringement of the patent and challenging its validity.26On around 5 December 2006, the Applicants made a further unjustified threat of patent infringement by a letter from Mallon & Co to Arns & Associates.27On 14 December 2006 Arns & Associates replied to Mallon & Co.28On 31 January 2007, two invoices issued on Mincrest letterhead to Silver City Drilling (NSW) Pty Ltd (Silver City) for the hire of four First Tools. Mincrest was paid by Silver City for these tools.29On 13 February 2007, the Applicants made a further unjustified threat of patent infringement by letter from Mallon & Co to Arns & Associates.30On 28 February 2007 and monthly until 1 July 2007, Coretell invoiced Silver City for the hire of kits of the First Tool. These invoices were paid by Silver City.31On 31 May 2007 and 1 July 2007, Coretell issued invoices in respect of the hire of kits of the First Tool to GOS Drilling (GOS). These invoices were paid by GOS.32On 2 July 2007, the Applicants commenced these proceedings.33By 31 July 2007, Mr Barker was instructed to cease manufacturing the First Tool.34Since January 2009, Coretell has:(a)made and thereafter supplied, hired and offered for supply and hire and kept for the purposes of supply and hire Second Tools to customers and distribution agents for use:-1 in Australia; and2 in countries outside Australia;(b)kept Second Tools at Orange Grove and, since September 2010, at the Maddington Warehouse; and(c)supplied Second Tools to customers and distribution agents in Australia and in countries outside Australia together with the ORishot User Manual and such Second Tools have been used in accordance with the ORishot User Manual.Previous Proceedings35The First Tool and the Second Tool were the subject of a claim of patent infringement of Innovation Patent 2006100113 by Imdex and the First and Second Applicants, which claim was unsuccessful:(a)at trial (WAD 132 of 2007; [2010] FCA 1169); and(b)on appeal (WAD 8 of 2011; [2011] FCAFC 121).36The First Tool and the Second Tool were subject of a claim of patent infringement in respect of Australian Innovation Patent No AU2010101356 entitled ‘Core Sample Orientation’ and Australian Innovation Patent No AU20111 01041 entitled ‘Core Sample Orientation’ in proceedings NSD 2082 of 2011. The claims of patent infringement were heard in a trial that concluded in July 2014 and in respect of which judgment is yet to be delivered.[insert photographs]Evidence received at the hearing

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established