Australian Licenced Aircraft Engineers Association, the

Link copied
Case Copied 4 min read

[2014] FWCD 5011

DECISION

Fair Work (Registered Organisations) Act 2009
s.159—Alteration of other rules of organisation
The Australian Licenced Aircraft Engineers Association
(R2014/114)
MR ENRIGHT MELBOURNE, 31 JULY 2014
Alteration of other rules of organisation.

[1] On 9 May 2014 The Australian Licenced Aircraft Engineers Association (the Association) lodged with the Fair Work Commission a notice and declaration setting out particulars of alterations to the rules of The Australian Licenced Aircraft Engineers Association.

[2] The particulars set out alterations to Rule 22 of the rules of The Australian Licenced Aircraft Engineers Association.

[3]        In an explanatory note attached to the application, the Association stated that:

In the course of its current eligibility rule change application in matter D2013/130, the Association has had cause to review Rule 22(e) of the ALAEA Rules in regard to qualifications to hold office as Federal President, Senior Vice President, Vice President, Federal Secretary, Assistant Federal Secretary or Trustee of the Association. Rule 22(e) currently provides:

(e) An Officer of the Federal Executive as defined by Rule 11 sub-Rule 4(d) must hold qualifications as a Licenced Aircraft Maintenance Engineer to be eligible for the nomination to that Office.
Rule 11 sub-Rule 4(d) defines ‘Officer’ as any of the offices listed in the paragraph above.
Consistent with the Association’s objective of extending its coverage to Technical Salaried Staff employed at Qantas, deleting Rule 22(e) is a sensible step to take that will permit any financial member of the Association to nominate as an Officer of the Association.

[4] I note that the matter listed as D2013/130 is currently before the Fair Work Commission. At this stage, Vice President Hatcher has handed down a decision granting partial consent to the alteration of eligibility rules conditional upon the Association limiting the scope of the eligibility rules to encompass only the Technical Salaried Staff (TSS) traditionally represented by the Association – 20 June 2014, [2014] FWC 3658. The [2014] FWCD 5011

Association must also provide an undertaking to the Fair Work Commission that it will ensure that its practice of enrolling as members and seeking to represent persons beyond the scope of its eligibility rules comes to an end.

[5]        In the decision at paragraphs [47] to [49], His Honour stated:

There was one matter which caused me some concern as whether TSS Staff could conveniently belong to the ALAEA. At the time the ALAEA’s application in this matter was filed, and at the time of the hearing, sub-rule 22(e) of its Rules provided as follows:

(e) An Officer of the Federal Executive as defined by Rule 11 sub-Rule 4(d) must hold qualifications as a Licenced Aircraft Maintenance Engineer to be eligible for the nomination to that Office.
Under sub-rule 11(4)(d), “Officer” means “Federal President, Senior Vice-President,
Vice-President, Federal Secretary, Assistant Federal Secretary or Trustee”. The
effect of sub-rule 22(e), if the new sub-rule 3.3 was given consent, would therefore be to exclude any TSS Staff member who thereby became eligible to join the ALAEA from election to…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Licenced Aircraft Engineers Association, the and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] FWCD 5011
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Australian Licenced Aircraft Engineers Association (the Association) applied to the Fair Work Commission to amend its rules to remove the qualification for holding office as Federal President, Senior Vice President, Vice President, Federal Secretary, Assistant Federal Secretary, or Trustee. The application sought to delete Rule 22(e) of the Association’s rules, which required an Officer of the Federal Executive to hold qualifications as a Licensed Aircraft Maintenance Engineer to be eligible for nomination to those offices. The Association argued that this change would facilitate greater democratic participation in the organisation's affairs, in line with the objectives of the Fair Work (Registered Organisations) Act 2009.

The court was required to determine whether the proposed alteration to the Association's rules complied with the Act and was consistent with the objectives of the Act. The court needed to assess whether the removal of the qualification for holding office aligned with the Act's provisions and whether it would facilitate greater democratic participation within the organisation.

The court concluded that the removal of Rule 22(e) would facilitate greater democratic participation in the Association's affairs. The court found that the removal of the qualification did not affect the eligibility rules and did not interfere with the qualification itself. The court was satisfied that the alterations complied with the Act and were not contrary to the Act, the Fair Work Act 2009, modern awards, or enterprise agreements. The court certified that the alterations complied with the requirements of the Act.

The court approved the alteration of the Association's rules, allowing the removal of the qualification for holding office as Federal President, Senior Vice President, Vice President, Federal Secretary, Assistant Federal Secretary, or Trustee.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Australian Licenced Aircraft Engineers Association (the Association) lodged a notice and declaration with the Fair Work Commission on 9 May 2014, seeking consent to alter Rule 22 of the Association's rules. The proposed alteration involved removing Rule 22(e), which stipulated that an officer of the Federal Executive must hold qualifications as a Licensed Aircraft Maintenance Engineer to be eligible for nomination to that office. The Association explained that this change was necessary to extend its coverage to Technical Salaried Staff employed at Qantas, allowing any financial member of the Association to nominate as an officer. The decision to revise the eligibility rules followed a review prompted by another application before the Fair Work Commission, D2013/130, which dealt with the eligibility rules for Association members. In a decision on 20 June 2014, Vice President Hatcher granted partial consent to the alteration of eligibility rules, subject to conditions including the limitation of eligibility rules to Technical Salaried Staff traditionally represented by the Association. The Association was also required to ensure that its practice of enrolling and seeking to represent persons beyond the scope of its eligibility rules would cease. The proposed removal of Rule 22(e) was seen as facilitating greater democratic participation in the Association's affairs, consistent with the objectives of the Fair Work (Registered Organisations) Act 2009. The alterations were deemed to comply with the Act, the Fair Work Act 2009, modern awards and enterprise agreements, and were not otherwise contrary to law.

The Australian Licenced Aircraft Engineers Association (the Association) applied to the Fair Work Commission for approval of alterations to its rules under section 159 of the Fair Work (Registered Organisations) Act 2009. The Association sought to alter Rule 22 of its rules by deleting the requirement that officers of the Federal Executive hold qualifications as a Licenced Aircraft Maintenance Engineer to be eligible for nomination to office. This application followed a review of the Association’s eligibility rules in a separate matter currently before the Fair Work Commission. In that matter, the Vice President granted partial consent for the eligibility rule changes on the condition that the Association limit the scope of the changes to Technical Salaried Staff traditionally represented by the Association. In light of this decision, the Association's application to remove the qualification requirement for holding office was considered by a Delegate of the General Manager. The Delegate concluded that the alteration was consistent with the objectives of the Act and did not contravene any other laws, thus certifying approval of the rule change.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the alteration to Rule 22 of the Australian Licenced Aircraft Engineers Association's rules comply with section 159 of the Fair Work (Registered Organisations) Act 2009?
2. Does the removal of Rule 22(e) facilitate greater democratic participation in the affairs of the organisation consistent with the objectives of the Fair Work (Registered Organisations) Act 2009?
3. Are the alterations to the rules of the Australian Licenced Aircraft Engineers Association contrary to the Fair Work Act 2009, modern awards, enterprise agreements, or otherwise contrary to law?
4. Are the alterations to the rules of the Australian Licenced Aircraft Engineers Association consistent with the objectives of the Fair Work (Registered Organisations) Act 2009 and the Fair Work Act 2009?

Held
1. The alteration to Rule 22 of the Australian Licenced Aircraft Engineers Association's rules complies with section 159 of the Fair Work (Registered Organisations) Act 2009, as the alterations have been made under the rules of the organisation.
2. The removal of Rule 22(e) facilitates greater democratic participation in the affairs of the organisation consistent with the objectives of the Fair Work (Registered Organisations) Act 2009.
3. The alterations to the rules of the Australian Licenced Aircraft Engineers Association are not contrary to the Fair Work Act 2009, modern awards, enterprise agreements, or otherwise contrary to law.
4. The alterations to the rules of the Australian Licenced Aircraft Engineers Association are consistent with the objectives of the Fair Work (Registered Organisations) Act 2009 and the Fair Work Act 2009.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court's reasoning in this case focused on the alterations made to Rule 22 of the Australian Licensed Aircraft Engineers Association's (ALAEA) rules, specifically the removal of Rule 22(e), which required certain officers to hold qualifications as a Licensed Aircraft Maintenance Engineer. The court examined whether these alterations complied with section 159 of the Fair Work (Registered Organisations) Act 2009 (RO Act), facilitated greater democratic participation, and were consistent with other relevant laws and the objectives of the RO Act.

The court began by addressing whether the alterations to Rule 22 complied with section 159 of the RO Act. The Association submitted the alterations to the Fair Work Commission, which included the removal of Rule 22(e) to permit any financial member of the Association to nominate for office. The court found that the removal of this rule was consistent with the Association's objective of extending its coverage to Technical Salaried Staff employed at Qantas, and it facilitated greater democratic participation within the organisation. The court concluded that the alterations were made under the rules of the organisation and thus complied with section 159 of the RO Act.

The court then considered whether the removal of Rule 22(e) facilitated greater democratic participation in the affairs of the organisation consistent with the objectives of the RO Act. The court noted that the removal of this qualification for holding office would allow a broader range of members to nominate for positions within the organisation, thereby enhancing democratic participation. The court found that this alteration aligned with the objectives of the RO Act, which include promoting democratic participation within registered organisations.

Next, the court assessed whether the alterations to the rules were contrary to the Fair Work Act 2009, modern awards, enterprise agreements, or otherwise contrary to law. The court concluded that the alterations were not contrary to these laws, as they did not conflict with the Fair Work Act 2009, modern awards, or enterprise agreements. Additionally, the court found that the alterations were not otherwise contrary to law, as they were made in accordance with the rules of the organisation.

Finally, the court determined whether the alterations to the rules were consistent with the objectives of the RO Act and the Fair Work Act 2009. The court found that the removal of Rule 22(e) was consistent with the objectives of the RO Act, which include promoting democratic participation within registered organisations. The court also noted that the alterations were consistent with the Fair Work Act 2009, as they did not conflict with any provisions of that Act.

In summary, the court applied the principles outlined in section 159 of the RO Act and considered the objectives of the RO Act and the Fair Work Act 2009 in determining whether the alterations to the ALAEA's rules were valid. The court found that the removal of Rule 22(e) facilitated greater democratic participation and was consistent with the objectives of the RO Act and the Fair Work Act 2009. The court also concluded that the alterations were not contrary to any other relevant laws. The ratio decidendi of this case is that the removal of Rule 22(e) of the ALAEA's rules, which required certain officers to hold qualifications as a Licensed Aircraft Maintenance Engineer, is consistent with the objectives of the Fair Work (Registered Organisations) Act 2009 and does not conflict with the Fair Work Act 2009, modern awards, enterprise agreements, or any other relevant laws.