Australian Fisheries Authority v Kaka & Arsat

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read
CITATION: Australian Fisheries Authority v Kaka & Arsat [2009] NTMC 065

PARTIES: AUSTRALIAN FISHERIES AUTHORITY

v

KAKA AND ARSAT

TITLE OF COURT: Court of Summary Jurisdiction

JURISDICTION: Court of Summary Jurisdiction

FILE NO(s): 20930329 & 20930339

DELIVERED ON: 2nd December 2009

DELIVERED AT: Darwin

HEARING DATE(s): 26th November 2009

JUDGMENT OF: Ms Fong Lim SM

CATCHWORDS:

Criminal Law – Fisheries Prosecution – Illegal Indonesian fishing – Mistake of fact – Sections 100, 101 and 166 Fisheries Management Act, Section 6.1 & 9.2 Criminal Code (Cth)

Australian Fisheries Management Authority v Su [2009] FCAFC 56 - distinguished

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:
Plaintiff: Mr McCarthy
Defendant: Mr Lees

Solicitors:
Plaintiff: Director of Public Prosecution (Cth)
Defendant: NT Legal Aid

Judgment category classification: C
Judgment ID number: [2009] NTMC 065
Number of paragraphs: 26


IN THE COURT OF SUMMARY JURISDICTION
AT DARWIN IN THE NORTHERN
TERRITORY OF AUSTRALIA

No. 20930329 & 20930339
[2009] NTMC 065

BETWEEN:

AUSTRALIAN FISHERIES AUTHORITIES
Plaintiff

AND:

KAKA AND ARSAT
Defendants

REASONS FOR DECISION

(Delivered 2nd December 2009)

Ms FONG LIM SM:
1. Foreign fishing vessel KM Rahmat Sainal was apprehended by Customs on the 18th August 2009. The defendants are charged with using a foreign boat in the Australian Fishing Zone (AFZ) for commercial fishing and in the case of Arsat having in his charge a foreign boat equipped for fishing. There are a number of agreed facts (P1). The agreed facts establish most elements of the offences and leave two narrow issues to decide. Was the Rahmat Sainal within the AFZ when fishing and had the Defendants been fishing in the AFZ.
2. The position of the Rahmat Sainal was averred in the information as Latitude11 degrees 33.153 minutes South and Longtitude125 degrees 57.722 minutes East at the time of committing the offences. It is agreed that position sits approximately 2 nautical miles within the AFZ. What is not agreed is actual the position of the Rahmat Sainal when first sighted and then apprehended and whether they had been fishing within the AFZ.
3. The master of the Rahmat Sainal, Arsat, was navigating with charts and a handheld GPS and at all times insisted that at time of apprehension the boat was 11degrees 32.670 minutes South and 125 degrees 55.765 minutes East a position outside of the AFZ. In his defence he argues that he had the reasonably held belief that the Rahmat Sainal was outside the AFZ when apprehended and if it was in the AFZ the Rahmat Sainal must have drifted on the current into the zone after they were sighted by customs. The only evidence of a current is from Arsat who stated the current was from the north to the south. The captain of the Corio Bay, the customs vessel, did not do a calculation of the current because it would have required some time.
4. Evidence was heard from the captain of the Corio Bay, the Fisheries officer and customs officer who boarded the Rahmat Sainal, the naval officer who downloaded the information from…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Fisheries Authority v Kaka & Arsat and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] NTMC 65
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Australian Fisheries Authority brought charges against Kaka and Arsat for using a foreign vessel, the KM Rahmat Sainal, to conduct commercial fishing activities within the Australian Fishing Zone (AFZ). The defendants were charged under sections 100 and 101 of the Fisheries Management Act, as well as Section 6.1 and 9.2 of the Criminal Code (Cth). The primary legal issues before the Court were whether the vessel was within the AFZ at the time of apprehension and whether the defendants had conducted commercial fishing activities within the AFZ. The Court had to determine if the defendants had a reasonable belief that they were outside the AFZ, which could potentially serve as a defence under the law.

The Court examined various pieces of evidence, including GPS data, ship logs, and witness testimonies. The Court found that the GPS data and ship logs consistently placed the vessel within the AFZ at the time of apprehension. The defendants' argument that the vessel drifted into the AFZ was rejected due to the lack of substantial evidence supporting such a claim. Furthermore, the Court found that Arsat's evidence regarding his belief about the vessel's location was not credible, as it contradicted the other evidence presented. The Court concluded that Arsat did not genuinely believe they were outside the AFZ, and therefore, the defence of mistake of fact did not apply. Consequently, both defendants were found guilty of using a foreign fishing vessel for commercial fishing within the AFZ without a licence.

In summary, the Court found the defendants guilty of the charges brought against them under the Fisheries Management Act and the Criminal Code (Cth). The Court's decision was based on the credible evidence presented, which demonstrated that the defendants were aware of their location within the AFZ and had conducted commercial fishing activities in violation of the law. The defendants' claims of a reasonable mistake of fact were rejected due to inconsistencies in their evidence and lack of supporting data.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established