AUSTRALIAN ELECTORAL COMMISSION v. RONNEY GLENN TOWNEY; SHIRLEY JOY TRUDGETT;
ALICE JOYCE WELLS; MICHAEL ERNEST BROWN; KERRIE ANN HUTCHISON; ANTHONY ARTHUR
AMATTO; IRENE DALE PEACHEY; RUTH MARGARET NADEN; HARRY ROY BELL; NEVILLE JOHN
BROWN and WILLIAM CHARLES HILL
No. NG102 of 1994
FED No. 438/94
Number of pages - 12
Elections - Aborigines
(1994) 51 FCR 250
COURT
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY
GENERAL DIVISION
FOSTER J
CATCHWORDS
Elections - dispute concerning regional council election - error in prescribed polling procedures - detachment of original and counterfoil voter identification slips form envelopes - whether election should be declared void - power to order matching of envelopes with voter identification slips - whether exclusion of votes would reasonably affect the result of the election - reference to the "common law of elections" - reference to principle of free elections.
Aborigines - powers of Court under Schedule 4 of the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Commission Act 1989 - consideration of clauses 10(1), 14 and 23 in Schedule 4.
Commonwealth Electoral Act 1918 (Cth) - s 360(1)
Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Commission Act 1989 - s 140, Schedule 4, Part 2
Chanter v Blackwood (No. 2) (1904) 1 CLR 121
Dunbier v Mallam (1971) 2 NSWLR 169
In Re Wood (1988) 167 CLR 145
HEARING
SYDNEY, 4-5 May 1994
#DATE 22:6:1994
Counsel for the Applicant : Dr S. Kenny
Instructed By: : Australian Government Solicitor
Counsel for the first, second, third,
fifth, seventh, eighth and ninth
Respondents : Mr J. McCarthy QC
Counsel for the fourth, sixth, tenth
and eleventh Respondents : Mr J. Kildea
Instructing Solicitors for the first,
second, third, fifth, seventh, eighth,
ninth, tenth and eleventh Respondents : Aboriginal Legal Service
Instructing Solicitors for the
fourth and sixth Respondents : Craddock, Murray and Neuman
ORDER
1. The Court declares that:
(a) There has been an error made by a polling officer or polling officers, appointed by the Australian Electoral Commission for the purpose of polling, in the election held on 4 December 1993 for the Regional Councillors for the Wirawongam Ward in the Wagga Wagga Region.
(b) The said error may have affected the result of the said election.
2. The Court is satisfied, having perused the affidavits of Simon Charles Blackshield of 18 April 1994 and Lynne Elizabeth Glasson of 21 April 1994, that there is a reliable scientific technique available to enable the matching of voter detail slips with the voter card envelopes form which those slips have been detached.
3. By reason of the matter set out in paragraph 2 above, the Court does not presently propose to declare the said election void.
4. The Court directs that the documents described in the Schedule to these Orders be returned by the Australian Government Solicitor to the custody of the Australian Electoral Commission (AEC), and that the AEC cause the said documents to be conveyed to the custody of Mr Paul D Westwood…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Electoral Commission v Towney (No 2) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1994] FCA 438
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court considered the legal principles applicable to the common law of elections and the principle of free elections. It acknowledged the error made by polling officers and noted the availability of a reliable scientific technique to match the voter detail slips with the envelopes. The court was satisfied that the technique could be employed without compromising the integrity of the election process. The court determined that it was not necessary to declare the election void at that stage, given the potential to match the documents and ensure the accuracy of the results. The court ordered that the relevant documents be inspected and matched by forensic experts, with strict confidentiality and security measures in place to prevent misuse of the information.
The court outlined a detailed procedure for matching the voter detail slips with the envelopes and scrutinising the votes. It mandated that the forensic matching process be carried out by Forensic Document Services Pty Ltd, which was to prepare a report on the results. The court also directed the Regional Returning Officer to conduct further scrutinies and procedures based on the matching results. The court ordered that the Australian Electoral Commission pay the costs associated with the scientific procedures. The proceedings were to be re-listed before the court for further orders once the process was completed, without any prior public declaration of the results of the procedure. The court’s orders ensured that the integrity of the electoral process was maintained while addressing the procedural error.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The Court declares that:
(a) There has been an error made by a polling officer or polling officers, appointed by the Australian Electoral Commission for the purpose of polling, in the election held on 4 December 1993 for the Regional Councillors for the Wirawongam Ward in the Wagga Wagga Region.
(b) The said error may have affected the result of the said election.
2. The Court is satisfied, having perused the affidavits of Simon Charles Blackshield of 18 April 1994 and Lynne Elizabeth Glasson of 21 April 1994, that there is a reliable scientific technique available to enable the matching of voter detail slips with the voter card envelopes form which those slips have been detached.
3. By reason of the matter set out in paragraph 2 above, the Court does not presently propose to declare the said election void.
4. The Court directs that the documents described in the Schedule to these Orders be returned by the Australian Government Solicitor to the custody of the Australian Electoral Commission (AEC), and that the AEC cause the said documents to be conveyed to the custody of Mr Paul D Westwood of Forensic Documents Services Pty Ltd.
5. The Court orders that:
(a) Subject to paragraphs 5(b) - (e) below, Mr Paul D Westwood, Mr Steven J Strach, and Mr Graeme McCormack of Forensic Document Services Pty Ltd have leave to inspect the documents described in the Schedule hereto, and to do all things necessary or convenient to be done with the said documents for the purpose of carrying out the forensic matching process described in paragraph 5(f) below.
(b) The persons named in paragraph 5(a) above not use the documents described in the Schedule of any of the information recorded in those documents (other than information recorded in the said documents and acquired by any of those persons from another source) for any purpose other than the purpose described in paragraph 5(f) below.
(c) The persons named in paragraph 5(a) above not disclose the contents of any of the documents described in the Schedule (other than information contained in the said documents and acquired by any of those persons from another source) to any person except this Court, the legal representatives of parties to these proceedings, and officers of the Australian Electoral Commission.
(d) The persons named in paragraph 5(a) above not unseal or otherwise open any envelope or like document described in the Schedule.
(e) Paul D Westwood of Forensic Document Services Pty Ltd at all times keep the documents described in the Schedule under security.
(f) Forensic Document Services Pty Ltd carry out, in relation to the documents described in the Schedule, the forensic matching process as described in the affidavits referred to in paragraph 2 above.
(g) Forensic Document Services Pty Ltd, having carried out the process described in paragraph 5(f) above, prepare a report setting out the results of the said matching process, and that Forensic Document Services Pty Ltd certify or otherwise indicate which tear off slip belongs to which voter card envelope. Such report to be provided to the Court and to the parties, and the matter thereafter to be listed before the Court for further directions or orders.
(h) In the event that the matching process described in paragraph 5(f) above is 100% successful in matching each of the voter detail slips described in the Schedule to its voter card envelope, the Regional Returning Officer conduct a preliminary scrutiny of all voter card envelopes which have been matched with a voter detail slip, in accordance with the provisions of Rules 92(2)(c)-92(6) inclusive of the ATSIC Regional Council Election Rules (the Rules).
(i) Having carried out the procedure described in paragraph 5(h) above, the Regional Returning Officer carry out, in respect of all voter card envelopes described in the Schedule which have not been matched with a voter detail slip, the procedures described in Rules 92(4)(a)(ia) -(iii) inclusive of the Rules.
(j) Having carried out the procedure described in paragraphs 5(h) and
(i) above, the Regional Returning Officer, in respect of all ballot papers which have been dealt with in accordance with Rule 92(4)(a)(ii) of the Rules (including all ballot papers so dealt with during the course of the conduct of the original scrutiny in respect of the election the subject of these proceedings), carry out the procedure described in Rule 92(7) of the Rules.
(k) The Regional Returning Officer thereafter deal with the ballot papers described in paragraph 5(j) above in accordance with the provisions of Schedule 2 to the ATSIC Act.
6. Once the process described in paragraph 5 above is completed, the proceedings be re-listed before it for further orders, without any prior public declaration of the results of the procedure.
7. The AEC pay the costs of Forensic Document Services Pty Ltd of carrying out the scientific procedures described in paragraphs 5(f) and (g) above, including the costs of Forensic Document Services of carrying out tests on unused envelopes on 11 and 28 April 1994, and those tests reported in the Report of 1 April 1994 forming annexure "b" to the affidavit of Simon Charles Blackshield of 18 April 1994 filed in these proceedings and in the Report of 20 April 1994 forming annexure "C" to the affidavit of Lynne Elizabeth Glasson of 21 April filed in these proceedings. SCHEDULE
1. All voter card envelopes used at Lithgow and Coonabarabran polling places in connection with the election held on 4 December 1993 for ATSIC Regional Councillors for the Wirawongam Ward in the Wagga Wagga Region.
2. All voter detail slips bearing the names listed in Exhibit LG1-CONFIDENTIAL to the affidavit of Lynne Elizabeth Glasson of 21 April 1994 filed in these proceedings.
3. All counterfoils bearing the names listed in Exhibit LG1-CONFIDENTIAL to the affidavit of Lynne Elizabeth Glasson of 21 April 1994 filed in these proceedings.
Note: Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Full text does not contain this section.