Australian Education Union v Yooralla

Link copied
Case Copied 47 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Education Union v Yooralla [2019] FCA 1511

Appeal from: Australian Education Union v Yooralla [2018] FCCA 2758
File number: VID 1344 of 2018
Judge: STEWARD J
Date of judgment: 17 September 2019
Catchwords: INDUSTRIAL LAW – construction of awards –  pre‑modern award – whether employee was an “instructor” under the Disability Services Award (Victoria) 1999 or an “attendant carer” under the Attendant Care - Victoria Award 2004 – modern award – whether employee was a Level 2 or Level 3 social and community services employee under the Social, Community, Home Care and Disability Services Industry Award 2010
Legislation: Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth)
Cases cited:

Amcor Ltd v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union (2005) 222 CLR 241

Choppair Helicopters Pty Ltd v Bobridge [2018] FCA 325

Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v Anglo Coal (Callide Management) Pty Ltd [2015] FCA 696

Maribyrnong City Council v Australian Municipal, Administrative, Clerical and Services Union [2019] FCA 773

Shop Distributive and Allied Employees’ Association v Woolworths SA Pty Ltd [2011] FCAFC 67

Transport Workers’ Union of Australia v Coles Supermarkets Australia Pty Ltd [2014] FCAFC 148; (2014) 245 IR 449

Date of hearing: 17 July 2019
Date of last submissions: 25 July 2019
Registry: Victoria
Division: Fair Work Division
National Practice Area: Employment & Industrial Relations
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 60
Counsel for the Appellant: Mr M Irving, Q.C. with Ms F Knowles
Solicitor for the Appellant: Mr M McIver of the Australian Education Union
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr M G Rinaldi
Solicitor for the Respondent: DLA Piper

ORDERS

VID 1344 of 2018
BETWEEN:

AUSTRALIAN EDUCATION UNION

Appellant

AND:

YOORALLA

Respondent

JUDGE:

STEWARD J

DATE OF ORDER:

17 SEPTEMBER 2019

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Within 14 days the parties are to file orders by agreement giving effect to the reasons for judgment or, if no agreement is reached, submissions of no more than four pages in length as to the form of final relief to be ordered.

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

STEWARD J:

  1. This is an appeal from a decision of the Federal Circuit Court dismissing the Australian Education Union’s (the “AEU”) application for declaratory and ancillary relief.  The AEU claims that one of its members, a Ms Legg, has been underpaid in contravention of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) by reason of the application of the wrong industry awards. Ms Legg had been an employee of Yooralla, a provider of disability services. She had worked at the “Naroo Day Service” at Naroo Street, Balwyn (the “Naroo Centre”). What she did there is not disputed but is nonetheless important for the disposition of this appeal. That is because the parties are in disagreement about the correct characterisation of her services at the Naroo Centre in the context of various industry awards which applied during Ms Legg’s period of employment.

  2. The AEU contended below: (i) that Ms…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Education Union v Yooralla and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] FCA 1511
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Australian Education Union v Yooralla, the Federal Court was tasked with determining the appropriate classification and remuneration for Ms Legg, an employee of Yooralla, an organisation that provides disability services. The dispute centred around whether Ms Legg should be classified as an "instructor" under the Disability Services Award (Victoria) 1999, or as an "attendant carer" under the Attendant Care - Victoria Award 2004, and subsequently, whether she should be categorised as a Level 2 or Level 3 employee under the Social, Community, Home Care and Disability Services Industry Award 2010. The Court was required to consider the nature of Ms Legg's duties, which included training individuals with disabilities, developing and supporting individual training programs, and preparing and maintaining client and service documentation, among other tasks.

The Court examined the evidence and submissions from both parties to ascertain the predominant nature of Ms Legg's work. The Court held that the primary judge erred in his consideration of Ms Legg's Transitional Minimal Wage and the Modern Award. The Court found that both quality and quantity of the different types of work performed by Ms Legg were relevant in determining her classification, in accordance with the principle of major and substantial employment. This principle, established in previous case law, allows for a practical approach to determining the application of awards where duties are of a mixed character. Ultimately, the Court determined that Ms Legg should be categorised as a "Level 2" employee for the purposes of the Modern Award.

The Court ordered that within 14 days, the parties were to file orders by agreement giving effect to the reasons for judgment. If the parties could not reach an agreement, they were to submit written arguments of no more than four pages in length as to the form of final relief to be ordered. This case highlights the importance of carefully considering the nature of an employee's duties when determining their classification and remuneration under relevant awards and agreements.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Within 14 days the parties are to file orders by agreement giving effect to the reasons for judgment or, if no agreement is reached, submissions of no more than four pages in length as to the form of final relief to be ordered.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The learned primary judge dismissed the AEU’s application. His Honour found that Ms Legg had not been underpaid. For the reasons given below, and with the greatest of respect, I have found that the learned primary judge erred in considering Ms Legg’s Transitional Minimal Wage, and in his Honour’s consideration of the Modern Award. However, I nonetheless agree for other reasons that Ms Legg should be categorised as a “Level 2” employee for the purposes of that Modern Award. Facts The learned primary judge summarised the primary facts as follows at [19] and [23]-[30]:19.On or about 28 October 2013 Ms Legg applied to Yooralla for employment in the role of “disability support worker 2” and on 3 December 2013 she was employed in that role. Her contract of employment provided that she was a disability support worker classified as an attendant carer award grade 2 year one. As mentioned above, it was common cause between the parties that Yooralla provided disability services including the provision of personal care and lifestyle support to persons with a disability in a community or residential setting including respite care and day services. One of those services was Naroo Day Service (“Naroo”). Persons who attended Naroo were called “clients” in this proceeding. They had varying degrees of disability and varying degrees of ability. The day service now known as Naroo was previously owned by Eastern Disability Access and Resource (“EDAR”) and operated by Yooralla.…. 23.On and from July 2014 Ms Legg reported to her supervisor, Sonia Marie Faulkner, Yooralla’s programme manager.24.Ms Legg gave evidence that at any given time she had responsibility for between four and six of Yooralla’s clients. She said her duties that she was required to and in fact performed included ‒a) training people with an intellectual, physical or sensory disability;b)developing and maintaining and supporting individual training programs, in a variety of settings;c) preparing and maintaining client and service documentation;d) conducting client lifestyle programmes; ande) administrative duties.25.Ms Legg gave evidence that she did not usually assist people with a disability to perform day-to-day activities that a person without a disability would do for himself or herself, including eating, bathing, picking up items and so on.26.Ms Legg said that person centred planning, as it was called at Naroo, involved the development of programmes, tailored to the specific needs and disabilities of Yooralla’s clients on an individual basis. It focused on the specific goals each client sought to achieve. Ms Legg gave evidence that person centred planning was a key aspect of her role. She said she prepared various documents, individual versions of which were kept in folders for each client and on a regular basis Ms Legg and Ms Faulkner reviewed the content page to ensure each client was supported in the planned manner. The documents that Ms Legg prepared were identified by her as ‒a) “client specific dictionaries”;b) “my lifestyle plan”; c) “lifestyle plan action plan”; and d) “client support plan”.27.Ms Legg said she prepared individual weekly plans for each of the clients in consultation with Ms Faulkner. Ms Legg said she prepared progress notes and graph documents for each client. She also prepared programme outlines with specific client information concerning each client. The programmes Yooralla offered to its clients at Naroo included bowling, pamphlet collation, pamphlet delivery, cooking, swimming, disco, scrapbooking, iPad operation and café outings. 28.Ms Legg gave evidence that she took two programmes each day. She said that typically she ‒a) informed clients where they were to keep food and medication; b) assisted clients having lunch;c)where another colleague was available, Ms Legg took half hour breaks; d) kept records of clients who took medication at lunch; e)assisted clients to use toilets prior to commencing the programme held after lunch; and f) completed progress notes and assessments during the break.29.On a monthly basis Ms Legg communicated with Ms Faulkner on feedback given about the services provided at Naroo. Ms Legg also prepared interim progress reports in respect of clients after evaluating each client’s progress during each of the four terms during which Naroo was in operation. 30. According to Ms Faulkner, Ms Legg performed her duties to a high standard.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The AEU also relied upon the decision of Logan J in Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v Anglo Coal (Callide Management) Pty Ltd [2015] FCA 696, which I have found to be of assistance. At [38]-[39] his Honour said:More recently, in Logan v Otis Elevator Company Pty Ltd [1997] IRCA 200 at 68-73 (Logan v Otis Elevator) Moore J collected and discussed many of the plethora of cases in which courts or the industrial commission have had to confront the phenomenon of an employee whose position required the undertaking of multiple duties only some of which were mentioned in a particular classification in an industrial instrument or, as the case may be, were disparately stated in different industrial instruments. Like Moore J in that case, I consider that a [judgment] given by Sheldon J in Ware v O’Donnell Griffin (Television Services) Pty Ltd [1971] AR (NSW) 18 offers assistance. Also like Moore J, I do not consider that the observations made by Sheldon J are to be confined just to a case where it is necessary to choose as between which of two industrial instruments applies to particular employment. That circumstance merely provided the context in which observations of pervasive relevance came to be made by Sheldon J. What Sheldon J observed was this (as set out in Logan v Otis Elevator at 68):The finding of the Chief Industrial Magistrate raises two questions: Firstly, whether this is a case to be determined on the principle of major and substantial employment; and, secondly, if it is, whether the evidence justified his finding as to what the major and substantial employment of the complainant was.It seems to me that this is clearly a case to which this principle is applicable. This principle is almost as old as industrial arbitration and it makes a practical approach to determining the application of awards where duties are of a mixed character and contain elements which have taken alone would be covered by more than one award. This is not an appropriate occasion on which to discuss the method by which this test should be applied except to say that it is not merely a matter of quantifying the time spent on the various elements of work performed by a complainant; the quality of the different types of work done is also a relevant consideration. A pithy way of putting the same proposition is that both quality and quantity are relevant when it comes to employee classification, subject always to the language employed in the particular industrial instrument.The Decision Below I have already set out the key part of the reasons of the learned primary judge. In essence, his Honour decided that Ms Legg performed the work of an “attendant carer” in respect of which some training was involved but that this training was not “the mainstay or even a substantial part of her work” (at [41]). The fact that she held an academic degree was said to be not “determinative nor even useful” in ascertaining the “principal purpose of her work” (at [34]).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.