Australian Consumer and Competition Commission v Launceston Superstore Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Consumer and Competition Commission v Launceston Superstore Pty Ltd [2013] FCA 297

Citation: Australian Consumer and Competition Commission v Launceston Superstore Pty Ltd [2013] FCA 297
Parties: AUSTRALIAN CONSUMER AND COMPETITION COMMISSION v LAUNCESTON SUPERSTORE PTY LIMITED ACN 144 592 941, AVITALB PTY LIMITED ACN 152 309 503, HP SUPERSTORE PTY LIMITED ACN 142 549 308, MANDURVIT PTY LIMITED ACN 147 626 284, SALECOMP PTY LIMITED ACN 094 346 522, BUNAVIT PTY LIMITED ACN 144 589 613, GORDON SUPERSTORE PTY LIMITED ACN 142 549 022, IPAVIT PTY LIMITED ACN 152 327 538, CAMAVIT PTY LIMITED ACN 142 548 945, OXTEHA PTY LIMITED ACN 152 310 122 and MOONAH SUPERSTORE PTY LIMITED ACN 147 625 910
File number: NSD 1866 of 2012
Judge: EDMONDS J
Date of judgment: 8 April 2013
Catchwords: PRACTICE & PROCEDURE – proceeding commenced against multiple respondents – application by applicant for continuation of joinder of respondents – whether claims against each respondent are related disputes – respondents reside in different States – each claim raises different factual scenarios requiring separate hearings – whether joinder removes multiplication of time, effort or cost – whether in the alternative separate claims should be case managed in one docket out of Sydney – application dismissed – all respondents removed apart from seventh respondent which trades in NSW
Legislation: Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) ss 18, 29
Federal Court Rules 2011 Rule 9.05
Cases cited:

CBI Contractors Pty Ltd v Abbott [No.2] [2009] FCA 1129 cited
Cheque One Pty Ltd v Cheque Exchange (Aust) Pty Ltd (in liq) [2002] FCA 593 cited
Knight v Beyond Properties Pty Ltd & Ors (No.2) (2006) FCA 192 cited
Robin Bishop v Bridgelands Securities Ltd and John Hyla Preston [1990] FCA 410 cited
Sensis Pty Ltd v Bivami Pty Ltd [2012] FCA 1365 distinguished

Macquarie Dictionary (Revised 3rd ed., Macquarie Dictionary Publishers, 1997)   

Date of hearing: Heard on the papers
Place: Sydney
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 48
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr M Rennie
Solicitor for the Applicant: Norton Rose Australia
Counsel for the First, Second, Fourth and Eleventh Respondents: Mr H Stowie
Solicitor for the First, Second, Fourth and Eleventh Respondents: Shanahan Tudhope
Counsel for the Third and Fifth Respondents: Mr FP Carnovale
Solicitor for the Third and Fifth Respondents: Beazley Singleton Lawyers
Counsel for the Sixth, Seventh, Ninth and Tenth Respondents: Mr R Newlinds SC
Solicitor for the Sixth, Seventh, Ninth and Tenth Respondents: Brown Wright Stein

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 1866 of 2012

BETWEEN:

AUSTRALIAN CONSUMER AND COMPETITION COMMISSION
Applicant

AND:

LAUNCESTON SUPERSTORE PTY LIMITED ACN 144 592 941
First Respondent

AVITALB PTY LIMITED ACN 152 309 503
Second Respondent

HP SUPERSTORE PTY LIMITED ACN 142 549 308
Third Respondent

MANDURVIT PTY LIMITED ACN 147 626 284
Fourth Respondent

SALECOMP PTY LIMITED ACN 094 346 522
Fifth Respondent

BUNAVIT PTY LIMITED ACN 144 589 613
Sixth Respondent

GORDON…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Consumer and Competition Commission v Launceston... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] FCA 297
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Australian Consumer and Competition Commission v Launceston Superstore Pty Ltd involves the Australian Consumer and Competition Commission (ACCC) as the applicant, seeking to maintain the joinder of multiple respondents in a proceeding that has already been commenced against them. The respondents include various businesses, each potentially engaged in different activities in different states across Australia. The legal issue at hand is whether the proceeding can continue to be heard jointly against all respondents, given the distinct nature of the claims against each one. Additionally, the court must determine if the alternative of separate case management in one docket would be feasible.

The court's analysis centres on the interpretation of Rule 9.05(1) of the Federal Court Rules 2011, which governs the joinder of parties. The court found that the rule is not intended to allow for the continuation of a proceeding against multiple respondents who were not initially joined through an order. The rule specifically enables the application for a person to be joined as a party to avoid multiplicity of proceedings, but it does not address the scenario where a proceeding has already been initiated against multiple respondents without prior joinder orders. The court further noted that the ACCC's decision to commence the proceeding in the New South Wales registry, despite the respondents being based in various states, was not a factor that should influence the joinder of parties.

Consequently, the court dismissed the ACCC's interlocutory application and ordered the removal of all respondents except the seventh respondent, which is trading in New South Wales. The court reasoned that, without agreement among the parties, proceedings of this nature should not be heard in a registry outside the state where the respondent is trading. The court also rejected the notion that joint case management could be easily accommodated due to the ACCC's strategic choice of registry. The court emphasised that the ACCC should not benefit from initiating proceedings without obtaining necessary joinder orders beforehand.

The court's final orders included dismissing the interlocutory application with costs and removing all respondents except the seventh respondent from the proceeding. The decision underscores the importance of adhering to procedural rules and the necessity for clear legal grounds when seeking to join parties in multi-jurisdictional cases.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The applicant’s interlocutory application dated 21 December 2012 be dismissed with costs as agreed or taxed.

2. The first to sixth and the eighth to eleventh respondents be removed as, and cease to be, parties to the proceeding.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

No party has pressed for reasons to be given but the two firms of solicitors respectively representing the first, second, fourth and eleventh respondents and the sixth, seventh, ninth and tenth respondents have submitted that reasons may be helpful in providing guidance on an important issue of principle in relation to the conduct of multi-party prosecutions. I agree and have, therefore, reduced my reasons to writing.CONCLUSION For a number of reasons set out below, I am not prepared to grant the leave sought by the interlocutory application which must be dismissed with costs. I propose to order the removal of all the respondents, other than the seventh respondent, a company trading as Harvey Norman AV/IT Superstore Gordon, at Gordon in New South Wales, as parties to the proceeding. I propose to do this because, so far as I can ascertain, only it and one other of the respondents are trading in New South Wales; the balance are trading in other States of Australia and, without agreement, any proceeding of this kind, by a regulator such as the ACCC, should not be brought in a registry of this Court other than in the registry of a State in which a respondent is trading. Norton Rose, lawyers for the ACCC, assert in their letter dated 25 January 2013 (p 7 of the affidavit of Mr Trevor Cheung sworn 18 February 2013) that it should be relatively simple to accommodate joint case management because every respondent chose to appoint counsel based in Sydney. With respect, that has occurred as a consequence of the ACCC commencing the proceeding against every respondent in the New South Wales registry of the Court.ANALYSIS AND CONSIDERATION First and foremost, Rule 9.05(1) of the Rules, of which Rule 9.05(1)(b)(iii) forms part, does not, in its terms, accommodate an application of the kind sought. Rule 9.05(1) exists to enable a party to apply to the Court, in advance, for an order “that a person be joined as a party to the proceeding” and, in the case of Rule 9.05(1)(b)(iii), “if the person is a person who should be joined as a party in order to enable determination of a related dispute and, as a result, avoid multiplicity of proceedings”. Neither Rule 9.05(1), nor its constituent parts, contemplates an application for an order that, a proceeding commenced against a number of persons, be continued against them. Had the ACCC commenced the proceeding against one of the respondents, it could have applied to the Court for an order pursuant to Rule 9.05(1)(b)(iii) to join the other 10 respondents as parties to the proceeding; alternatively, it could have commenced 11 separate proceedings and applied to the Court for an order that the other 10 proceedings be heard together with the first. The ACCC is not to be afforded any benefit in the consideration of its application by virtue of having commenced a single proceeding against 11 respondents without first obtaining an order from the Court. I have considered this application as if there is currently one respondent to this proceeding and that the ACCC is seeking to join 10 (now nine) new persons as respondents or, in the alternative, to have all the cases heard together.Rule 9.05(1)(b)(iii)

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

For a number of reasons set out below, I am not prepared to grant the leave sought by the interlocutory application which must be dismissed with costs. I propose to order the removal of all the respondents, other than the seventh respondent, a company trading as Harvey Norman AV/IT Superstore Gordon, at Gordon in New South Wales, as parties to the proceeding. I propose to do this because, so far as I can ascertain, only it and one other of the respondents are trading in New South Wales; the balance are trading in other States of Australia and, without agreement, any proceeding of this kind, by a regulator such as the ACCC, should not be brought in a registry of this Court other than in the registry of a State in which a respondent is trading. Norton Rose, lawyers for the ACCC, assert in their letter dated 25 January 2013 (p 7 of the affidavit of Mr Trevor Cheung sworn 18 February 2013) that it should be relatively simple to accommodate joint case management because every respondent chose to appoint counsel based in Sydney. With respect, that has occurred as a consequence of the ACCC commencing the proceeding against every respondent in the New South Wales registry of the Court.ANALYSIS AND CONSIDERATION First and foremost, Rule 9.05(1) of the Rules, of which Rule 9.05(1)(b)(iii) forms part, does not, in its terms, accommodate an application of the kind sought. Rule 9.05(1) exists to enable a party to apply to the Court, in advance, for an order “that a person be joined as a party to the proceeding” and, in the case of Rule 9.05(1)(b)(iii), “if the person is a person who should be joined as a party in order to enable determination of a related dispute and, as a result, avoid multiplicity of proceedings”. Neither Rule 9.05(1), nor its constituent parts, contemplates an application for an order that, a proceeding commenced against a number of persons, be continued against them. Had the ACCC commenced the proceeding against one of the respondents, it could have applied to the Court for an order pursuant to Rule 9.05(1)(b)(iii) to join the other 10 respondents as parties to the proceeding; alternatively, it could have commenced 11 separate proceedings and applied to the Court for an order that the other 10 proceedings be heard together with the first. The ACCC is not to be afforded any benefit in the consideration of its application by virtue of having commenced a single proceeding against 11 respondents without first obtaining an order from the Court. I have considered this application as if there is currently one respondent to this proceeding and that the ACCC is seeking to join 10 (now nine) new persons as respondents or, in the alternative, to have all the cases heard together.Rule 9.05(1)(b)(iii) Rule 9.05(1)(b)(iii) provides as follows:(1)A party may apply to the Court for an order that a person be joined as a party to the proceeding if the person:…(b)is a person:…(iii)who should be joined as a party in order to enable determination of a related dispute and, as a result, avoid multiplicity of proceedings.ACCC bears the onus