ACCC v Australian Safeway Stores Pty Ltd & Others [1999] FCA 1170
ACCC v Australian Safeway Stores Pty Ltd [1999] FCA 1170
AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION v AUSTRALIAN SAFEWAY STORES PTY LTD & ORS
VG 762 of 1996
GOLDBERG J
MELBOURNE
18 MAY 1999
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY VG 762 of 1996
BETWEEN: AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION Applicant
AND: AUSTRALIAN SAFEWAY STORES PTY LTD (ACN 004 319 939)
First Respondent
GEORGE WESTON FOODS
(ACN 008 429 623)
Second Respondent
MARK JONES
Third Respondent
BERNIE BROOKES
Fourth Respondent
JUDGE: GOLDBERG J DATE: 18 MAY 1999 PLACE: MELBOURNE RULING
HIS HONOUR:
1 I am satisfied that the application for leave to amend the defences of the first and the third respondents should be allowed. Consistently with established authority such as State of Queensland v JL Holdings Ltd (1997) 189 CLR 146, it is desirable that I adhere to the interests of justice and ensure that the merits of the matter are dealt with. What is sought to be amended is the withdrawal of words in the earlier defence which, in substance, admitted that in four cases deletions of Buttercup products were at the direction of the third respondent, Mr Jones. Mr Glick, who appears on behalf of Mr Jones, points to a potential ambiguity in relation to the admissions in relation to two of these incidents - Lalor and Frankston and it seems to me that the amendments to those paragraphs are such that the matter is made clear, in the sense that the evidence which apparently is intended to be led from Mr Jones makes it clear what his involvement is.
2 Mr Fajgenbaum QC, who appears with Messrs Brett QC, Ginnane and Star for the applicant, does not suggest that there is any question of estoppel, but he does submit there is prejudice to the applicant by virtue of the operation of s 84 of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth). It seems to me that, having regard to the fact that both Mr Brookes and Mr Jones are going to give evidence of their involvement, the relevant prejudice to which I should have regard is not in existence at this point of time because Mr Fajgenbaum will have the opportunity to investigate with both witnesses their relevant involvement in both matters. The position might be different if this application was made in closing submissions, but at the moment the respondents are yet to open their case. The main basis of Mr Fajgenbaum's opposition to the amendment is that there is no evidence of a solid or substantial character as to how the need for the amendment came about. The matter is deposed to by Mr Andrew John Christopher, a solicitor for Mr Jones, who has not been cross-examined, and I accept his evidence. In short he says that in preparing the amended defence to the fourth further amended statement of claim he took instructions from Mr Jones. Mr Jones said…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v Australian Sa... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1999] FCA 1170
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the court was whether the respondents should be allowed to amend their defences to withdraw admissions made in their earlier statements. The court considered the principles established in State of Queensland v JL Holdings Ltd, which emphasised the importance of ensuring the interests of justice are met and that the merits of the case are properly addressed. The applicant argued that the proposed amendments could prejudice the ACCC's case, but the court found that the respondents' evidence of their involvement would allow the applicant to investigate further and that no estoppel or significant prejudice was present at that stage of the proceedings.
Justice Goldberg determined that the evidence presented was sufficient to establish that an error had occurred in the drafting of the initial defences. Mr Jones' solicitor provided an affidavit stating that Mr Jones had not fully appreciated the effects of the earlier defences and that amendments were necessary to clarify his involvement. Given this evidence, the court concluded that it was appropriate to exercise its discretion to allow the amendments to the defences, ensuring that the case could proceed fairly and that the merits of the matter would be adequately addressed.
The final order of the court was to grant the application for leave to amend the defences of the first and third respondents, thereby permitting them to withdraw certain admissions made in their earlier defences. This decision allowed the case to proceed with the necessary clarifications regarding the respondents' involvement in the incidents at hand.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter came before the Federal Court of Australia in the Victoria District Registry. The ACCC filed an application for leave to amend the defences of the first and third respondents. The application was heard by Justice Goldberg on 18 May 1999. Justice Goldberg allowed the application for leave to amend the defences, considering the interests of justice and the need to ensure the merits of the matter are dealt with. The amendments sought to clarify the admissions made by Mr Jones regarding the deletions of Buttercup products.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Should the application for leave to amend the defences of the first and third respondents be allowed?
2. What is the potential prejudice to the applicant if the amendments are allowed, and does it outweigh the interests of justice?
3. Is there sufficient evidence to establish that an error was made in the earlier defences concerning the deletions of Buttercup products?
Held
1. The application for leave to amend the defences of the first and the third respondents should be allowed.
2. The potential prejudice to the applicant, if any, does not outweigh the interests of justice in this instance.
3. There is sufficient evidence to establish that an error was made in the earlier defences concerning the deletions of Buttercup products.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Justice Goldberg considered it desirable to adhere to the interests of justice and ensure that the merits of the matter were dealt with, consistent with established authority such as State of Queensland v JL Holdings Ltd (1997) 189 CLR 146. The proposed amendments sought to clarify the admissions in the earlier defences relating to the deletion of Buttercup products, which were allegedly at the direction of the third respondent, Mr Jones. Goldberg J accepted the evidence of Mr Andrew John Christopher, a solicitor for Mr Jones, who deposed that Mr Jones had not fully appreciated the effects of the relevant paragraphs in the earlier defence. This evidence was sufficient for Goldberg J to conclude that an error was made, thereby allowing the amendments. The judge also found that the potential prejudice to the applicant did not outweigh the interests of justice, as the applicant would have the opportunity to investigate the respondents' involvement in the matters. Goldberg J relied on the discretion given under s 84 of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) to allow the amendments. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that where there is a demonstrated error in earlier pleadings, and the amendments do not significantly prejudice the opposing party, the court should allow such amendments to ensure the proper administration of justice.