Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Zanok Technologies Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v Zanok Technologies Pty Ltd [2009] FCA 1124

TRADE PRACTICES – conduct in contravention of ss 51AA, 52, 53 and 58 of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) – whether the respondents knew or ought to have known of the special disadvantage of the job applicants and whether the respondents took unfair advantage of the opportunity presented – the conduct complained of amounted to an unconscientious exploitation of another’s inability or diminished ability to conserve his or her own interests – conduct complained of was liable to mislead a person seeking employment as to availability, nature, terms or conditions or any other matter relating to employment.

Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) ss 51AA, 52, 53B, 58, 75B, 80(1AA)
Federal Court of Australia Rules O 9 r 1(3)

Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v CG Berbatis Holdings Pty Limited (2003) 214 CLR 51 considered
Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v Chats House Investments (1996) 71 FCR 250 referred to
Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v Goldy Motors Pty Limited (2001) ATPR 41-801 cited
Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v Henry Kaye and National Investment Institute Pty Limited [2004] FCA 1363 considered
Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v Target Australia Pty Limited (2001) ATPR 41-840 cited
Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v Z-Tek Computer Pty Limited (1997) 78 FCR 197 referred to
Glev Pty Limited v Kentucky Fried Chicken Pty Limited (1994) ATPR 41-299 referred to
ICI Australia Operations Pty Limited v TPC (1992) 38 FCR 248 referred to
Louth v Diprose (1992) 175 CLR 621 referred to
Tobacco Institute of Australia Limited v Australian Federation of Consumer Organisations Inc (1993) 41 FCR 89 applied
TPC v Mobil Oil Australia Limited (1985) 4 FCR 296 cited
Yorke v Lucas (1985) 158 CLR 661 applied

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION v ZANOK TECHNOLOGIES PTY LIMITED, DARLEY STEPHEN and VANITHA DARLEY

NSD 385 of 2009

EDMONDS J
2 OCTOBER 2009
SYDNEY


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 385 of 2009

BETWEEN:

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION
Applicant

AND:

ZANOK TECHNOLOGIES PTY LIMITED
First Respondent

DARLEY STEPHEN
Second Respondent

VANITHA DARLEY
Third Respondent

JUDGE:

EDMONDS J

DATE OF ORDER:

2 OCTOBER 2009

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT DECLARES THAT:

1.The first respondent in trade or commerce, in the period from about December 2008 to about May 2009, engaged in unconscionable conduct contrary to s 51AA of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) (‘the Act’) by requiring consumers to pay a fee for information technology training, in circumstances where the first respondent knew or ought to have known that the consumer:

1.1Was seeking paid employment in the information technology industry whether by responding to an advertisement or advertisements placed by or on behalf of the first respondent or otherwise;

1.2was not seeking information technology training;

1.3only paid for and undertook information technology training provided by the first respondent because he or she understood that the first…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Zanok Techn... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] FCA 1124
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) brought an action against Zanok Technologies Pty Ltd, its directors, and AREA, an employment agency, for misleading conduct in relation to employment opportunities for IT graduates. Zanok and AREA advertised IT jobs through websites targeting individuals with temporary visas, promising employment after a training period. However, the training was unstructured, of no value, and trainees were instead used to help Zanok establish its business. The ACCC sought declarations and injunctive relief to prevent misleading representations and conduct.

The primary legal issues were whether Zanok and its agents engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct under the Australian Consumer Law by falsely advertising IT job opportunities and requiring trainees to pay for a training that was not provided. The court had to determine whether Zanok's conduct was misleading or deceptive, and if so, whether it was likely to mislead or deceive the target audience of visa holders seeking IT jobs.

The court found that Zanok and its agents engaged in misleading conduct by advertising IT job opportunities and requiring trainees to pay for training that was not provided, thus misleading and deceiving visa holders. The court noted that the advertisements created an expectation of employment after training, which was not met. The court granted the ACCC's requests for declarations, injunctive relief, and costs against Zanok and its directors. The orders prohibited Zanok and its directors from making certain representations and engaging in specified conduct for five years. Additionally, Zanok and its directors were liable for costs and potential imprisonment or sequestration.

In summary, the Federal Court found Zanok and its agents guilty of misleading and deceptive conduct and granted the ACCC's requests for declarations, injunctive relief, and costs. The orders restrain Zanok and its directors from making certain representations and engaging in specified conduct for five years. The respondents were also liable for costs and potential imprisonment or sequestration.

Orders

Orders of the court

10. The first respondent, for a period of five years, by itself, its agents or otherwise, be restrained from representing, on any website or by other means, that:

10.1 The first respondent is recruiting to fill vacancies in the information technology sector;

10.2 the first respondent offers information technology scholarships in the form of paid information technology training courses;

10.3 the first respondent offers a guarantee of paid employment at the end of the information technology training;

10.4 the first respondent is a global company with offices in countries including the USA;

10.5 the first respondent has developed and sells functional information technology software products;

10.6 the first respondent will pay graduates of the information technology training course a salary of a minimum specified amount per annum once employed by the first respondent;

10.7 the first respondent offers a referral program whereby trainees are paid a specified amount for each individual they refer to the first respondent who signs up for the information technology training course;

unless:

10.8 the first respondent has vacancies in the information technology sector which are not dependent on the completion of an information technology training course conducted by or on behalf of the first respondent;

10.9 the information technology scholarships offered by the first respondent:

10.9.1 exist; and

10.9.2 pay for the cost of the relevant information technology training course;

10.10 the first respondent is in a position to guarantee paid employment to all graduates of the information technology training course;

10.11 the first respondent has offices in the relevant countries;

10.12 the first respondent either has developed, or has made available for sale, functional information technology software products;

10.13 the first respondent is in a position to pay graduates of the information technology training course a salary of a minimum of the specified amount per annum once employed by the first respondent; and

10.14 the first respondent offers a referral program whereby trainees are paid the specified amount for each individual they refer to the first respondent who signs up for the information technology training course.

11. The first respondent, for a period of five years, by itself, its agents or otherwise, be restrained from:

11.1 Soliciting a person to enter into an agreement in relation to information technology training and/or requiring the person to pay for the cost of that information technology training; or

11.2 being directly or indirectly knowingly concerned in or party to a corporation soliciting entry into the agreement or requiring payment as the case may be,

in circumstances where:

11.3 the person is seeking paid employment in the information technology industry, whether by responding to an advertisement or advertisements placed by or on behalf of the first respondent or otherwise,

until seven (7) days after the person has been informed of the requirement for the information technology training.

12. The first respondent, for a period of five years, by itself, its agents or otherwise, be restrained from providing information technology training to a person which is materially different from the information technology training in respect of which the payment from the person is accepted.

13. The second respondent, for a period of five years, by himself, his agents or otherwise, be restrained from being directly or indirectly knowingly concerned in or party to any corporation representing, on any website or by other means, that:

13.1 The corporation is recruiting to fill employment vacancies in the information technology sector;

13.2 the corporation offers information technology scholarships in the form of paid information technology training courses;

13.3 the corporation offers a guarantee of paid employment at the end of the information technology training;

13.4 the corporation is a global company with offices in countries including the USA;

13.5 the corporation has developed and sells functional information technology software products;

13.6 the corporation will pay graduates of the information technology training course a salary of a minimum of a specified amount per annum once employed by the corporation;

13.7 the corporation offers a referral program whereby trainees are paid a specified amount for each individual they refer to the corporation who signs up for the information technology training course;

unless:

13.8 the corporation has vacancies in the information technology sector which are not dependent on the completion of an IT training course conducted by or on behalf of the corporation;

13.9 the information technology scholarships offered by the corporation:

13.9.1 exist; and

13.9.2 pay for the cost of the relevant information technology training course;

13.10 the corporation is in a position to guarantee paid employment to all graduates of the information technology training course;

13.11 the corporation has offices in the relevant countries;

13.12 the corporation either has developed, or has made available for sale, functional information technology software products;

13.13 the corporation is in a position to pay graduates of the information technology training course a salary of a minimum of the specified amount per annum once employed by the corporation; and

13.14 the corporation offers a referral program whereby trainees are paid the specified amount for each individual they refer to the corporation who signs up for the information technology training course.

14. The second respondent, for a period of five years, by himself, his agents or otherwise, be restrained from:

14.1 Soliciting a person to enter into an agreement in relation to information technology training and/or requiring the person to pay for the cost of that information technology training; or

14.2 being directly or indirectly knowingly concerned in or party to a corporation soliciting entry into the agreement or requiring payment as the case may be,

in circumstances where:

14.3 the person is seeking paid employment in the information technology industry, whether by responding to an advertisement or advertisements placed by or on behalf of the first respondent or otherwise,

until seven (7) days after the person has been informed of the requirement for the information technology training.

15. The second respondent, for a period of five years, by himself, his agents or otherwise, be restrained from providing, or being directly or indirectly knowingly concerned in or party to a corporation providing, information technology training to a person which is materially different from the information technology training in respect of which the payment from the person is accepted.

16. The third respondent, for a period of five years, by herself, her agents or otherwise, be restrained from being directly or indirectly knowingly concerned in or party to any corporation representing, on any website or by other means, that:

16.1 The corporation is recruiting to fill paid employment vacancies in the information technology sector;

16.2 the corporation offers information technology scholarships in the form of paid information technology training courses;

16.3 the corporation offers a guarantee of paid employment at the end of the information technology training;

16.4 the corporation is a global company with offices in countries including the USA;

16.5 the corporation has developed and sells functional information technology software products;

16.6 the corporation will pay graduates of the information technology training course a salary of a minimum of a specified amount per annum once employed by the corporation;

16.7 the corporation offers a referral program whereby trainees are paid a specified amount for each individual they refer to the corporation who signs up for the information technology training course;

unless:

16.8 the corporation has vacancies in the information technology sector which are not dependent on the completion of a information technology training course conducted by or on behalf of the corporation;

16.9 the information technology scholarships offered by the corporation:

16.9.1 exist; and

16.9.2 pay for the cost of the relevant information technology training course;

16.10 the corporation is in a position to guarantee paid employment to all graduates of the information technology training course;

16.11 the corporation has offices in the relevant countries;

16.12 the corporation either has developed, or has made available for sale, functional information technology software products;

16.13 the corporation is in a position to pay graduates of the information technology training course a salary of a minimum of the specified amount per annum once employed by the corporation; and

16.14 the corporation offers a referral program whereby trainees are paid the specified amount for each individual they refer to the corporation who signs up for the information technology training course.

17. The third respondent, for a period of five years, by herself, her agents or otherwise, be restrained from:

17.1 Training and/or requiring the person to pay for the cost of that information technology training; or

17.2 being directly or indirectly knowingly concerned in or party to a corporation soliciting entry into the agreement or requiring payment as the case may be,

in circumstances where:

17.3 the person is seeking paid employment in the information technology industry, whether by responding to an advertisement or advertisements placed by or on behalf of the first respondent or otherwise,

until seven (7) days after the person has been informed of the requirement for the information technology training.

18. The third respondent, for a period of five years, by herself, her agents or otherwise, be restrained from providing, or being directly or indirectly knowingly concerned in or party to a corporation providing, information technology training to a person which is materially different from the information technology training in respect of which the payment from the person is accepted.

19. The respondents pay the applicant’s costs in an amount to be agreed, or in lieu of agreement, as taxed.

Note pursuant to Order 37 Subrule 2(3) of the Federal Court Rules

1. The second and third respondents (Darley Stephen and Vanitha Darley) may be liable to imprisonment or sequestration of property unless each abstains from the conduct referred to in the above orders; and

2. The first respondent (Zanok Technologies Pty Limited) may be liable to sequestration of property unless it abstains from the conduct referred to in the above orders.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

EDMONDS J

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: EDMONDS J

What follows in these reasons is largely taken from the written submissions of the ACCC dated 21 September 2009.Declarations The ACCC submitted the modus operandi of the first respondent (‘Zanok’) was as follows:(1)It both directly, and through its agent Australian Regional Employment Agencies Pty Ltd (‘AREA’), placed advertisements on websites, offering members of the public employment opportunities for Information Technology (‘IT’) graduates;(2)during ‘interviews’, the prospective employee would be informed that Zanok had an established business in providing IT services and that a period of training was required at a cost to the trainee of up to $4,700 which would prepare the trainee for employment with Zanok that was guaranteed on completion of the training, or earlier if the trainee ‘proved’ themselves to the company;(3)the training in fact provided by Zanok was unstructured, disorganised and of no assistance or value to the trainees;(4)the period set aside for the training was in fact used by Zanok to have a number of the trainees contact prospective customers of Zanok and otherwise assist Zanok to establish its business;(5)Zanok deceived the trainees into believing they would be offered employment in return for paying a fee for the pre-employment training when in fact Zanok had no available employment opportunities and in lieu of providing the promised training, required the trainees to assist Zanok in setting up its business. Zanok was incorporated on 4 March 2008. The second respondent (Mr Darley Stephen) and the third respondent (Ms Vanitha Darley) are listed as directors of Zanok. Zanok’s website ( described Zanok as a ‘Global Consultancy and IT Solutions Company’ based in the USA, Australia, India and Malaysia. The Zanok website was registered on 15 March 2008, that is, less than two weeks after Zanok was incorporated. AREA is a company based in South Australia. It was incorporated in 2007 and is engaged in the business of locating employment for students. Mr Shreyas Narayana was the National Recruitment Manager for AREA located at AREA’s Melbourne office. AREA was retained by Zanok to assist with finding and interviewing applicants for employment with Zanok. During the period February 2009 to May 2009, Zanok, and AREA on behalf of Zanok, placed a number of advertisements on various websites. The advertising placed by or on behalf of Zanok was directed to persons residing in Australia by reason of a temporary visa issued by the Department of Immigration and Citizenship. Most notably, it applied to persons residing in Australia by reason of a ‘485 visa’ or skilled graduate visa. A 485 visa or skilled graduate visa permits the holder to remain in Australia for up to 18 months after completing higher education to enable the person to obtain the relevant points needed to meet the requirements of a permanent general skilled migrant visa. Points are rewarded depending on certain factors including whether the applicant has a job offer in Australia. To obtain sufficient points to attain the permanent general skilled migrant visa one option is for a person to have been employed in a skilled occupation in Australia for at least 12 of the last 24 months.