Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Pratt (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Pratt (No 2) [2008] FCA 1833

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION
v RICHARD PRATT

VID 443 of 2008

RYAN J
2 DECEMBER 2008
MELBOURNE


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

VID 443 of 2008

BETWEEN:

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION
Prosecutor

AND:

RICHARD PRATT
Defendant

JUDGE:

RYAN J

DATE OF ORDER:

2 DECEMBER 2008

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

A.Pursuant to s 189 of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) (“the Evidence Act”) and O 29 of the Rules of this Court the following questions be decided after a hearing to commence on 8 December 2008 separately from any other question and before any trial in the proceedings herein;

(1)Are any and which of the Revised Form of Proposed Order, the Penalty Statement, the relevant paragraphs of the Agreed Statement of Facts and the relevant paragraphs of the Further Amended Defence admissible as evidence in these proceedings pursuant to any of ss 81, 82(b), 87 or 88 of the Evidence Act?

(2)If yes to (1), in respect of any of the Revised Form of Proposed Order, the Penalty Statement, the relevant paragraphs of the Agreed Statement of Facts and the relevant paragraphs of the Further Amended Defence (which are hereinafter collectively called “the prima facie admissible documents”) are any and which of the prima facie admissible documents inadmissible in these proceedings by reason of;

(a)s 85(2) of the Evidence Act;  or

(b)s 137 of the Evidence Act?

(3)If (2) be answered no in respect of any of the prima facie admissible documents;

(a)will the Court refuse to admit such document as evidence in these proceedings in the exercise of the discretion conferred by;

(i)s 90 of the Evidence Act;

(ii)s 135 of the Evidence Act?

(b)is such prima facie admissible document by reason of s 138 of the Evidence Act not to be admitted as evidence in these proceedings?

B.        The costs of both parties of the hearing on 10 November 2008 be reserved.

Note:Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.  The text of entered orders can be located using eSearch on the Court’s website.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

VID 443 of 2008

BETWEEN:

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION
Prosecutor

AND:

RICHARD PRATT
Defendant

JUDGE:

RYAN J

DATE:

2 DECEMBER 2008

PLACE:

MELBOURNE

REASONS FOR FORMULATION OF QUESTIONS FOR SEPARATE RESOLUTION PURSUANT TO O 29

  1. In reasons for judgment published on 9 September 2008 (ACCC v Pratt [2008] FCA 1373) (“the earlier reasons”), I described the summons issued out of this Court by the prosecutor (“the ACCC”) against the defendant (“Pratt”) and the particulars appended to the statements of charges set forth in the summons. The present reasons should be read in conjunction with the earlier reasons.

  2. On 24 October 2008, I directed that the ACCC and Pratt respectively bring in to Court a statement…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Pratt (No 2... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] FCA 1833
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Pratt (No 2), the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) is pursuing a dispute against Pratt concerning the admissibility of certain documents as evidence in the proceedings. The court was tasked with determining the admissibility of various documents, including the Revised Form of Proposed Order, the Penalty Statement, and relevant paragraphs of the Agreed Statement of Facts and the Further Amended Defence. The primary issue revolved around whether these documents could be admitted as evidence under sections 81, 82(b), 87, or 88 of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth), and whether any of them should be excluded under sections 85(2), 137, or 138 of the same Act.

The court addressed the issue by formulating a set of preliminary questions to be resolved before any trial. It was determined that the questions regarding the admissibility of the documents should be decided separately from other issues and before any trial. The court outlined three specific questions to be answered during a hearing scheduled for 8 December 2008. The first question concerned the admissibility of the documents under the specified sections of the Evidence Act. The second question addressed whether any of the documents should be excluded under sections 85(2) or 137. The third question inquired whether the court would refuse to admit any admissible documents under sections 90 or 135, or if they should be excluded under section 138.

The court reasoned that the issue of corroboration, as proposed by the ACCC, was distinct from the questions concerning the admissibility of the documents. It decided not to include the corroboration issue in the current set of questions for separate resolution. This decision was based on the rationale that resolving the admissibility questions might render the corroboration issue unnecessary. Additionally, the court noted that resolving the corroboration issue alone would not settle the dispute unless the ACCC conceded the lack of required corroboration or if it was determined that corroboration was needed and each identified item of evidence was insufficient.

In conclusion, the court issued an order pursuant to section 189 of the Evidence Act and Order 29 of the Rules of the Court, directing that the formulated questions be decided separately and before any trial. The court also reserved the costs of the hearing on 10 November 2008.

Orders

Orders of the court

A. Pursuant to s 189 of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) (“the Evidence Act”) and O 29 of the Rules of this Court the following questions be decided after a hearing to commence on 8 December 2008 separately from any other question and before any trial in the proceedings herein;

(1) Are any and which of the Revised Form of Proposed Order, the Penalty Statement, the relevant paragraphs of the Agreed Statement of Facts and the relevant paragraphs of the Further Amended Defence admissible as evidence in these proceedings pursuant to any of ss 81, 82(b), 87 or 88 of the Evidence Act?

(2) If yes to (1), in respect of any of the Revised Form of Proposed Order, the Penalty Statement, the relevant paragraphs of the Agreed Statement of Facts and the relevant paragraphs of the Further Amended Defence (which are hereinafter collectively called “the prima facie admissible documents”) are any and which of the prima facie admissible documents inadmissible in these proceedings by reason of;

(a) s 85(2) of the Evidence Act; or

(b) s 137 of the Evidence Act?

(3) If (2) be answered no in respect of any of the prima facie admissible documents;

(a) will the Court refuse to admit such document as evidence in these proceedings in the exercise of the discretion conferred by;

(i) s 90 of the Evidence Act;

(ii) s 135 of the Evidence Act?

(b) is such prima facie admissible document by reason of s 138 of the Evidence Act not to be admitted as evidence in these proceedings?

B. The costs of both parties of the hearing on 10 November 2008 be reserved.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

RYAN J
I do not consider it appropriate to include in the current set of questions for separate resolution any question directed to this issue of corroboration. The issue is quite distinct from those which are raised by the evidentiary questions which it is agreed should be resolved. Depending on the answer to those questions it may not even arise. Moreover, its resolution would not quell the ultimate controversy between the parties unless the ACCC were to concede that there is no corroboration of the requisite kind or unless it were accompanied by a ruling that corroboration is needed in the present proceedings and that each item of evidence identified by the ACCC is incapable of constituting such corroboration. For these reasons, the present set of preliminary questions will not be extended to the issue of corroboration. Conclusion In the course of submissions during the hearing on 10 November 2008, Mr Richter QC, leading Counsel for Pratt pointed out that s 189 of the Evidence Act provides its own self-contained machinery for resolving on a voir dire preliminary questions including those as to the admissibility of admissions or evidence generally. The section also contains special provisions in sub-ss (3) and (5)(c) for the resolution of certain of such preliminary questions in criminal proceedings. I have therefore prefaced the questions which I have formulated with a reference to s 189 as well as to O 29 of the Rules of this Court. That is to make clear that s 189 will be applied, as far as appropriate, in resolving the separate questions which I have formulated. For the reasons which I have endeavoured to explain, there will be an order in the following terms;“Pursuant to s 189 of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) (“the Evidence Act”) and O 29 of the Rules of this Court the following questions be decided after a hearing to commence on 8 December 2008 separately from any other question and before any trial in the proceedings herein;(1)Are any and which of the Revised Form of Proposed Order, the Penalty Statement, the relevant paragraphs of the Agreed Statement of Facts and the relevant paragraphs of the Further Amended Defence admissible as evidence in these proceedings pursuant to any of ss 81, 82(b), 87 or 88 of the Evidence Act?(2)If yes to (1), in respect of any of the Revised Form of Proposed Order, the Penalty Statement, the relevant paragraphs of the Agreed Statement of Facts and the relevant paragraphs of the Further Amended Defence (which are hereinafter collectively called “the prima facie admissible documents”) are any and which of the prima facie admissible documents inadmissible in these proceedings by reason of;(a)s 85(2) of the Evidence Act; or(b)s 137 of the Evidence Act?(3)If (2) be answered no in respect of any of the prima facie admissible documents;(a)will the Court refuse to admit such document as evidence in these proceedings in the exercise of the discretion conferred by;(i)s 90 of the Evidence Act;(ii)s 135 of the Evidence Act?(b)is such prima facie admissible document by reason of s 138 of the Evidence Act not to be admitted as evidence in these proceedings?”

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: RYAN J

It is apparent from the description of those further alleged admissions that they each occurred after agreement had been reached on 6 October 2007 with the ACCC for settlement of the civil proceedings described at [10] of the earlier reasons. The letter said to have been sent to Visy’s staff and customers was presumably composed in the light of that agreement and with a view to its being used in support of a plea in mitigation of the penalty to be imposed by Heerey J. Likewise, I infer that the alleged admissions attributed to Senior Counsel for Pratt were made in the course of a plea of that kind or, at least, in presenting to the Court the Agreed Statement of Facts which had been finalised on 6 October 2007. Both further sets of alleged admissions postdate the agreement on which the admissibility of the four documents is said to turn. It is therefore likely that further or different legal or discretionary considerations may govern the admissibility of these further admissions and I have concluded that a ruling as to that admissibility, if necessary at all, should await the resolution of the separate questions which I have been persuaded to formulate. Accordingly, in the order reflecting these reasons, I have not formulated questions directed to the further alleged admissions raised by the ACCC. Corroboration The ACCC has sought the inclusion in the proposed questions for separate resolution of the following additional questions;‘8.Is there a rule of law that requires corroboration with respect to the evidence relied upon to prove an offence against s 155(5) of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth).9.If the answer to question 8 is “yes”, is that rule abolished by s 164(1) of the Evidence Act?’ In support of the inclusion of those further questions, Counsel for the ACCC have identified a controversy between the ACCC and Pratt as to the need for corroboration of evidence, presumably that to be given by Mr Jones as to what was communicated in his conversation with Pratt at the All Nations Hotel on 21 May 2001. This controversy arises from the terms of s 164(1) and (2) of the Evidence Act which provides;‘(1) It is not necessary that evidence on which a party relies be corroborated.(2)Subsection (1) does not affect the operation of a rule of law that requires corroboration with respect to the offence of perjury or a similar or related offence.’ The ACCC contends that s 164 does not create an affirmative requirement of corroboration but simply preserves any existing common law requirement, if there be one, for perjury or “similar or related offences” within the meaning of s 164(2). The ACCC has also foreshadowed an argument that s 155 of the TPA does not create a “similar or related offence” to perjury which is to be understood in the narrow sense of giving false evidence in the course of judicial proceedings. Counsel for Pratt have apparently indicated that each of these contentions will be contested. The ACCC has therefore submitted that the resultant dispute “can be appropriately and conveniently resolved as a preliminary issue” and, as it turns on two narrow questions of law, could be resolved without significantly prolonging the hearing of the preliminary questions.