Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Ithaca Ice Works Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v Ithaca Ice Works Pty Ltd [2000] FCA 997

TRADE PRACTICES – restrictive trade practices – enforcement and remedies – agreement between parties as to appropriate remedy – substantial weight to be given to agreement – need for proportionality to be maintained in various penalties imposed

Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth), subpars 45(2)(a)(i), 45(2)(a)(ii), 45(2)(b)(i), 45(2)(b)(ii)

Trade Practices Commission v Allied Mills(No 4) (1981) 37 ALR 256

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION v ITHACA ICE WORKS PTY LIMITED, QUEENSLAND ICE SUPPLIES PTY LIMITED, ANSONGUARD PTY LIMITED, KENNETH JOHN SMITH, ANTHONY JOHN MEE, GREGORY PAUL MEE, BRIAN BRADLEY, LEO GREVIS, GARY JOHN GREVIS, RODERICK IAN MATHESON AND JACK NUMAN BERRY

Q 216 OF 1999

DOWSETT J
26 JULY 2000
BRISBANE


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

QUEENSLAND DISTRICT REGISTRY

Q 216 OF 1999

BETWEEN:

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION
APPLICANT

AND:

ITHACA ICE WORKS PTY LIMITED (ACN 009 660 306)
FIRST RESPONDENT

QUEENSLAND ICE SUPPLIES PTY LIMITED (ACN 010 201 180)
SECOND RESPONDENT

ANSONGUARD PTY LIMITED (ACN 010 589 929)
THIRD RESPONDENT

KENNETH JOHN SMITH
FOURTH RESPONDENT

ANTHONY JOHN MEE
FIFTH RESPONDENT

GREGORY PAUL MEE
SIXTH RESPONDENT

BRIAN BRADLEY
SEVENTH RESPONDENT

LEO GREVIS
EIGHTH RESPONDENT

GARY JOHN GREVIS
NINTH RESPONDENT

RODERICK IAN MATHESON
TENTH RESPONDENT

JACK NUMAN BERRY
ELEVENTH RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

DOWSETT J

DATE:

26 JULY 2000

PLACE:

BRISBANE

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. In these proceedings the applicant seeks pecuniary penalties and injunctive relief against various persons engaged in the market for the supply of party ice, block ice and bulk ice in the geographical area which includes Brisbane, Ipswich, the Sunshine Coast and the Gold Coast (including Tweed Heads) during the period 1993 – 1996.  All of the respondents were either suppliers of ice within that market area or were employed by one or other of those suppliers.  In 1993 the annual turnover in the market was of the order of $2.5 - $3 million, rising to about $5.5 million by September 1996.  The following table gives particulars of relevant market shares:

Supplier Market Share
1993 1996 Presently
1st Respondent 50 – 60 % 60 – 70 % > 75 %
2nd Respondent 20 – 25 % 20 – 25 % 15%
3rd Respondent < 5 % < 5 % < 5 %
4th Respondent < 1 % < 1 % Sold Business
10th Respondent < 5 % < 5 % 5 %
11th Respondent < 5 % < 5 % < 5 %
  1. There are relatively low barriers to entry into the market, apart from the cost of plant and equipment.  However economies of scale achieved by large operators would render it difficult for a smaller operator to enter it.

  2. The allegations centre on two meetings held on 13 August 1993 and 5 October 1993 (the “1993 meetings”).  The meeting on 13 August 1993 was attended by the fifth and sixth respondents, (representing the first respondent), the seventh respondent, (representing the second respondent), the eighth and ninth respondents, (representing the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Ithaca Ice... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] FCA 997
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Federal Court of Australia was asked to consider a case brought by the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) against several parties involved in the ice supply market in Queensland, including Ithaca Ice Works Pty Ltd, Queensland Ice Supplies Pty Ltd, Ansonguard Pty Ltd, and several individuals. The ACCC alleged that the parties had entered into agreements that contravened the Trade Practices Act 1974 by fixing prices and restricting competition in the market for the supply of party ice, block ice, and bulk ice. The agreements in question were made in meetings held in August and October 1993 and involved setting minimum prices, refraining from competing with each other for existing customers, and not supplying the first fill of ice cabinets free of charge.

The court had to decide on the appropriate penalties for the parties who admitted to their involvement in the illegal agreements. The legal issues included determining the extent of each party's involvement, the seriousness of the breaches, and the appropriate level of penalty considering factors such as deterrence, proportionality, and the parties' capacity to pay. The court also had to consider the submissions made jointly by the ACCC and the respondents regarding the appropriate penalties.

The court found that the second and seventh respondents, representing Queensland Ice Supplies Pty Ltd, were significantly involved in the price-fixing agreement and their conduct was deliberate and extended over several years. Given their substantial market share and the serious nature of their breaches, the court agreed to the proposed penalty of $25,000 for the second respondent, while deeming it unfair to impose any penalty on the seventh respondent due to his limited personal assets. For the tenth respondent, who was involved to a lesser extent, the court imposed a penalty of $7,500 and ordered him to pay costs of $2,500. The fourth respondent, who played a more facilitative role in the meetings but had a minimal market share, was ordered to pay a penalty of $15,000 and costs of $12,500, reflecting his greater involvement in fostering the agreements despite his limited direct benefit.

Background

Background to the litigation

In 1993, the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) initiated proceedings against various parties in the market for the supply of party ice, block ice, and bulk ice in Brisbane, Ipswich, the Sunshine Coast, and the Gold Coast. The respondents were either suppliers of ice or employed by suppliers in the market. The annual turnover of the market was approximately $2.5-3 million in 1993, rising to about $5.5 million by September 1996. The case centered on two meetings held in August and October 1993, where an agreement was reached to cease aggressive competition, set minimum prices, and refrain from supplying free-fills for ice cabinets. The agreement was implemented until it collapsed in 1996. The ACCC alleged that this agreement contravened the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) by substantially lessening competition.

The case was brought before the Federal Court of Australia as a proceeding under the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth). The ACCC sought pecuniary penalties and injunctive relief against various respondents, including corporate entities and individuals, for their involvement in the restrictive trade practices. Several respondents admitted to their complicity in the alleged misconduct and made joint submissions with the ACCC regarding the appropriate penalties. The court considered these submissions and the respective roles and market shares of the respondents in determining the penalties.

Decision

Reasons for decision

DOWSETT J
Issues
1. What is the appropriate pecuniary penalty for the second and seventh respondents, given their admitted involvement in the restrictive trade practices?
2. What is the appropriate pecuniary penalty for the tenth respondent, considering his limited involvement and market share?
3. What is the appropriate pecuniary penalty for the fourth respondent, given his role in convening and chairing the meetings and his limited market share?

Held
1. The court held that the appropriate pecuniary penalty for the second and seventh respondents, given their admitted involvement in the restrictive trade practices, is $25,000 for the second respondent and no penalty for the seventh respondent.
2. The court held that the appropriate pecuniary penalty for the tenth respondent, considering his limited involvement and market share, is $7,500.
3. The court held that the appropriate pecuniary penalty for the fourth respondent, given his role in convening and chairing the meetings and his limited market share, is $15,000.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: DOWSETT J

The Federal Court considered the seriousness of the misconduct, the market shares of the respondents, and the degree of cooperation offered by the respondents in the investigation. In determining the appropriate penalties, the court gave substantial weight to the agreement reached by the parties. For the second and seventh respondents, the court considered the seriousness of the misconduct, the second respondent's substantial market share, and the cooperation offered by the respondents. The court decided that a penalty of $25,000 for the second respondent would serve as an adequate deterrent, while no penalty was imposed on the seventh respondent due to his limited assets and ownership of the second respondent. For the tenth respondent, the court considered his limited involvement and market share, as well as his cooperation with the applicant. The court determined that a penalty of $7,500, along with the costs of the proceedings, would be an effective deterrent. For the fourth respondent, the court considered his role in convening and chairing the meetings, as well as his limited market share and benefit derived from the misconduct. The court decided on a penalty of $15,000, attributing substantial culpability for fostering the meetings and agreement, but also recognizing his limited role in implementing the agreement and the limited benefit derived from it. The ratio decidendi of this case is that the court must consider the seriousness of the misconduct, the market shares of the respondents, and the degree of cooperation offered by the respondents when determining appropriate pecuniary penalties in cases of restrictive trade practices.