FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v High Adventure Pty Ltd [2005] FCA 762
TRADE PRACTICES – resale price maintenance – proposed consent orders dealing with injunctive and declaratory relief – whether orders in appropriate form – pecuniary penalties – appropriate quantum – whether community service order or probation order would have been more appropriate remedy
COSTS– whether Court should fix costs – quantum of costs order
BMW Australia Ltd v Australian Competition & Consumer Commission [2004] FCAFC 167 (2004) 207 ALR 452
Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) ss 48, 4(1), 96, 75B, 76, 77, 80, 86C, 97
Federal Court Rules O 62 r 4(2)(c)AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION v HIGH ADVENTURE PTY LIMITED (ACN 096 423 255) AND LEE SCOTT
V 1140 of 2003GRAY J
10 JUNE 2005
MELBOURNE
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY
V 1140 of 2003
BETWEEN:
AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION
APPLICANTAND:
HIGH ADVENTURE PTY LIMITED (ACN 096 423 255)
FIRST RESPONDENTLEE SCOTT
SECOND RESPONDENTJUDGE:
GRAY J
DATE OF ORDER:
10 JUNE 2005
WHERE MADE:
MELBOURNE
THE COURT DECLARES THAT:
1.The first respondent, on or about 12 July 2003, engaged in the practice of resale price maintenance, in contravention of s 48 of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) (‘the Trade Practices Act’), by:
(a)engaging in an act referred to in s 96(3)(a) of the Trade Practices Act, by making it known to The Pioneering Spirit Pty Ltd, trading as Walkerjet (‘Walkerjet’), and to a director of Walkerjet, Ross Atkin, that the first respondent would not supply Sky Paragliders products to Walkerjet, unless Walkerjet agreed not to sell or advertise for sale a Sky Paragliders product at a price less than a price specified by the first respondent;
(b)engaging in an act referred to in s 96(3)(c) of the Trade Practices Act by offering to enter into an agreement for the supply of Sky Paragliders products by the first respondent to Walkerjet, being an agreement one of the terms of which would be that Walkerjet would not sell or advertise for sale a Sky Paragliders product at a price less than a price that would be specified by the first respondent; and
(c)engaging in an act referred to in s 96(3)(f) of the Trade Practices Act by using in relation to Sky Paragliders products that may be supplied by the first respondent to Walkerjet a statement of price that, by reason of the presence of the words ‘Retail Price in AUD’, unqualified by any indication that the price was a recommended price only, was likely to be understood by Walkerjet and Ross Atkin as a price below which a Sky Paragliders product was not to be sold or advertised for sale.
2.The second respondent, on or about 12 July 2003, was directly knowingly concerned in the first respondent’s conduct of engaging in the practice of resale price maintenance, referred to in pars 1(a), (b) and (c), in contravention of s 48 of the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v High Advent... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2005] FCA 762
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court had to decide whether the declarations and orders proposed by the parties were appropriate and sufficiently precise to address the contraventions of the Trade Practices Act. Specifically, the court examined whether the declarations accurately reflected the nature of the contraventions and whether the injunctions proposed were suitable to prevent future breaches. The court also considered the appropriateness of the pecuniary penalties imposed on the respondents and whether the costs awarded to the ACCC were justified.
The court found that while some of the proposed declarations were sufficiently precise, others needed amendments to accurately reflect the contraventions. The court made minor amendments to the declarations to ensure they were specific and informative. Regarding the injunctions, the court agreed to the proposed terms, subject to minor changes, to prevent the respondents from engaging in similar conduct in the future. The court also confirmed the pecuniary penalties and costs awarded to the ACCC, considering them appropriate in the circumstances.
The court made several orders to address the breaches identified. These included restraining the respondents from engaging in specified conduct, requiring HAPL to offer certain terms to a distributor, imposing pecuniary penalties on both respondents, and ordering the respondents to pay the ACCC's costs. The court also allowed the respondents the liberty to pay the penalties and costs in instalments over time.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The first respondent be and is hereby restrained, until the expiration of three years from the date of this order, whether by itself, its servants or agents or otherwise howsoever, from:
(a) making it known to any person that the first respondent will not supply, or will cease to supply, a Sky Paragliders product to that person, unless that person agrees not to sell or advertise for sale a Sky Paragliders product at a price less than a price specified by the first respondent;
(b) offering to enter into an agreement with any person, for the supply of a Sky Paragliders product by the first respondent to that person, being an agreement one of the terms of which is, or would be, that the person will not sell or advertise for sale a Sky Paragliders product at a price less than a price specified, or that would be specified, by the first respondent; and
(c) using in relation to a Sky Paragliders product supplied, or that may be supplied, by the first respondent to any person, a statement of price that, by reason of the presence of the words ‘Retail Price in AUD’, unqualified by any indication that the price is a recommended price only, is likely to be understood by that person as a price below which a Sky Paragliders product is not to be sold or advertised for sale.
2. The second respondent be and is hereby restrained, until the expiration of three years from the date of this order, whether by himself, his servants or agents or otherwise howsoever, from being directly knowingly concerned in conduct by the first respondent whereby the first respondent, whether by itself, its servants, agents or otherwise howsoever:
(a) makes it known to any person that the first respondent will not supply, or will cease to supply, a Sky Paragliders product to that person, unless that person agrees not to sell or advertise for sale a Sky Paragliders product at a price less than a price specified by the first respondent;
(b) offers to enter into an agreement with any person, for the supply of a Sky Paragliders product by the first respondent to that person, being an agreement one of the terms of which is, or would be, that the person will not sell or advertise for sale a Sky Paragliders product at a price less than a price specified, or that would be specified, by the first respondent; and
(c) uses in relation to a Sky Paragliders product supplied, or that may be supplied, by the first respondent to any person, a statement of price that, by reason of the presence of the words ‘Retail Price in AUD’, unqualified by any indication that the price is a recommended price only, is likely to be understood by that person as a price below which a Sky Paragliders product is not to be sold or advertised for sale.
3. The first respondent forthwith offer to appoint Walkerjet, for a term of no less than three years, or until the first respondent should cease to be the importer of Sky Paragliders products, whichever occurs earlier, as a dealer in Sky Paragliders products on terms no less advantageous than those offered to the first respondent’s other dealers and, in the event that the first respondent terminates that appointment, for any reason other than that the first respondent ceases to be an importer of Sky Paragliders products, the first respondent provide Walkerjet with written reasons for the termination.
4. The first respondent pay to the Commonwealth of Australia a pecuniary penalty in the sum of $3000.
5. The first respondent be at liberty to pay the pecuniary penalty by instalments of $1000 each, at intervals of six months, commencing on 9 December 2005.
6. The second respondent pay to the Commonwealth of Australia a pecuniary penalty in the sum of $2000.
7. The second respondent be at liberty to pay the pecuniary penalty by instalments of $1000 each, at intervals of six months, commencing on 9 December 2005.
8. The respondents pay the applicant’s costs of the proceeding, fixed at $15 000.
9. The respondents be at liberty to pay the applicant’s costs by instalments of $1500 each, at intervals of six months, commencing on 9 December 2005.
10. Liberty be reserved to the respondents to apply in respect of the instalments and the periods referred to in pars 5, 7 and 9 of this order.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter came before the court following an application by the ACCC for declarations, injunctions, pecuniary penalties, and costs against the respondents. The application was made in the Federal Court of Australia. The court considered the agreed statements of fact and submissions from both the ACCC and the respondents. The court had to decide whether to make the declarations and grant the injunctions as requested, and if so, in what terms. The court also had to determine the appropriate pecuniary penalties and costs to be imposed on the respondents.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the declarations sought by the ACCC should be made, and if so, in what terms.
2. Whether the injunctions sought by the ACCC should be granted, and if so, in what terms.
3. What pecuniary penalties should be imposed on the respondents.
4. What costs should be awarded to the ACCC.
Held
1. The court granted the declarations sought by the ACCC with minor amendments. Declarations 1(a) and (b) were found to be sufficiently precise, while declaration 1(c) was amended to include the phrase "by reason of the presence of the words ‘Retail Price in AUD’, unqualified by any indication that the price was a recommended price only." Declaration 2 was also amended to remove the words "or indirectly," the comma following the word "in," and the words "or party to."
2. The court granted the injunctions sought by the ACCC with minor amendments. The injunctions were modified to reflect the changes made to the declarations.
3. The first respondent was ordered to pay a pecuniary penalty of $3000, which could be paid in instalments of $1000 every six months. The second respondent was ordered to pay a penalty of $2000, also payable in instalments of $1000 every six months.
4. The court ordered the respondents to pay the ACCC's costs of the proceeding, fixed at $15,000. The payment of these costs could also be made in instalments of $1,500 every six months.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Established by: GRAY J
It is necessary to consider whether these orders are appropriate in the circumstances, because the making of orders is an exercise of the judicial power. Whatever the agreement between the parties, the Court must be satisfied that it is appropriate to make the orders to which consent is given.The declarations If the Court is to make declarations, merely recording the fact that contraventions of the Trade Practices Act have occurred, it is important that they be in terms sufficiently specific to inform the reader of the precise nature of the contravention. See BMW Australia Ltd v Australian Competition & Consumer Commission [2004] FCAFC 167 (2004) 207 ALR 452 at [35]. Declarations 1(a) and (b) are sufficiently precise to satisfy this criterion. Declaration 1(c) is not. It does not disclose what element of the statement of price it was that made it likely to be understood as containing a price below which the product was not to be sold or advertised for sale. It is not necessarily easy to frame an adequate description of the element of the price list that brought about the contravention. In [26], I have rejected the contention that resort to the accompanying statement of terms supplies the requisite element, because the term numbered seven seems to contemplate that Walkerjet would be able to sell Sky Paragliders products at less than the ‘Retail Price in AUD’ by way of ‘specials’ for specified periods. This brings me back to the words ‘Retail Price in AUD’ themselves. It is not so much the fact that those words appear on the price list as the fact that they are unqualified by any words indicating that the price is not to be regarded as absolute, that causes the problem. Section 97 of the Trade Practices Act sanctions the use of the word ‘recommended’ in conjunction with ‘price’, although s 97 in its terms relates only to the act specified in s 96(3)(b), not to the act specified in s 96(3)(f). It does, however, suggest that, if the first respondent had used the words ‘recommended Retail Price in AUD’ in its price list, it would not have been regarded as contravening s 48 by reference to s 96(3)(f). Accordingly, to make declaration 1(c) sensible, I should insert after the words ‘a statement of price that’ a comma and the words ‘by reason of the presence of the words “Retail Price in AUD”, unqualified by any indication that the price was a recommended price only,’. As to the declaration numbered two, it contains alternatives (‘directly or indirectly knowingly concerned in, or party to’). In my view, it does not express precisely what finding has been made against the second respondent. The agreed statement of facts discloses that the second respondent was directly knowingly concerned in the first respondent’s conduct. Accordingly, the words ‘or indirectly’, the comma following the word ‘in’ and the words ‘or party to,’ should be omitted from this declaration. In the exercise of my discretion, and subject to minor amendments, including punctuation amendments, I am prepared to make declarations in those terms.The injunctions