Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v CC (NSW) Pty Ltd (No 9)

Link copied
Case Copied 37 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v CC (NSW) Pty Ltd (No 9)
[2000] FCA 23

TRADE PRACTICES – contravention of s 45 of Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) – imposition of pecuniary penalty under s 76 – factors relevant to level of penalty – effect of earlier cases in which other respondents had withdrawn their defences and admitted allegations in Commission’s pleading – penalties fixed in those cases on bases in some respects not applicable in light of hearing and findings in this case.

Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) s 76

Trade Practices Commission v CSR Ltd (1991) ATPR 41-076, cited

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION & CONSUMER COMMISSION (formerly called “TRADE PRACTICES COMMISSION”) v CC (NEW SOUTH WALES) PTY LIMITED (formerly called “CONCRETE CONSTRUCTIONS (NSW) PTY LIMITED”)

NG 574 OF 1994

LINDGREN J
21 JANUARY 2000
SYDNEY


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

NG 574 OF 1994

BETWEEN:

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION & CONSUMER COMMISSION (formerly called “TRADE PRACTICES COMMISSION”)
Applicant

AND:

CC (NEW SOUTH WALES) PTY LIMITED (formerly called “CONCRETE CONSTRUCTIONS (NSW) PTY LIMITED”)
First Respondent

PETER WOOLLARD
Second Respondent

HOLLAND STOLTE PTY LIMITED
Third Respondent

GRAHAM RONALD DUFF
Fourth Respondent

MULTIPLEX CONSTRUCTIONS PTY LIMITED
Fifth Respondent

GEOFFREY THOMAS PALMER
Sixth Respondent

LEIGHTON CONTRACTORS PTY LIMITED
Seventh Respondent

LEONARD DIXON
Eighth Respondent

THE AUSTRALIAN FEDERATION OF CONSTRUCTION CONTRACTORS
Ninth Respondent

RUSSELL NORMAN RICHMOND
Tenth Respondent

JUDGE:

LINDGREN J

DATE OF ORDER:

21 JANUARY 2000

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The proceeding be stood over to 7 February 2000 at 9.30 am for the making of orders including orders as to costs.

2.The applicant and the first respondent by 5.00 pm on 3 February 2000 supply to the Associate to Lindgren J agreed short minutes of the orders to be made or if agreement has not by then been reached copies of short minutes of the orders for which they will respectively contend and submissions in support.

Note:Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

NG 574 OF 1994

BETWEEN:

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION & CONSUMER COMMISSION (formerly called “TRADE PRACTICES COMMISSION”)
Applicant

AND:

CC (NEW SOUTH WALES) PTY LIMITED (formerly called “CONCRETE CONSTRUCTIONS (NSW) PTY LIMITED”)
First Respondent

PETER WOOLLARD
Second Respondent

HOLLAND STOLTE PTY LIMITED
Third Respondent

GRAHAM RONALD DUFF
Fourth Respondent

MULTIPLEX CONSTRUCTIONS PTY LIMITED
Fifth Respondent

GEOFFREY THOMAS PALMER
Sixth Respondent

LEIGHTON CONTRACTORS PTY LIMITED
Seventh Respondent

LEONARD DIXON
Eighth Respondent

THE AUSTRALIAN FEDERATION OF CONSTRUCTION CONTRACTORS
Ninth Respondent

RUSSELL NORMAN RICHMOND
Tenth Respondent

JUDGE:

LINDGREN J

DATE:

21 JANUARY 2000

PLACE:

SYDNEY


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT (No 9)

INTRODUCTION

  1. This proceeding arises out of “price fixing” by major construction companies and their association, the ninth respondent (“the AFCC”), in connection with tenders to Australian Construction Services (“ACS”), part of the Commonwealth Department of Administrative Services (“DAS”), for a project known as the “Commonwealth Offices – Haymarket” (“the Project”) in contravention of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v CC (NSW) Pt... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] FCA 23
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case between the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission and CC (NSW) Pty Ltd (No 9) dealt with allegations of anti-competitive practices in the construction industry, specifically concerning the imposition of special fees and the tendering process. The dispute was heard and determined by Justice Lindgren in the Federal Court of Australia. The central legal issues revolved around whether the conduct of the parties, including the imposition of Special Fees and the tendering process, substantially lessened competition in contravention of section 45 of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth).

The court was required to determine whether the arrangement and understanding among the Tenderers, including Concretes, had the purpose or effect of substantially lessening competition. The court examined whether the Special Fee and the understandings regarding UTFs constituted an arrangement or understanding that was likely to fix, control, or maintain prices, thereby contravening section 45 of the Trade Practices Act. Justice Lindgren concluded that the Special Fee was unilaterally imposed by the AFCC, not the result of a mutual understanding among the Tenderers. However, there was an understanding among the Tenderers that if one was the successful Tenderer, it would pay a UTF to the unsuccessful Tenderers. The court found that while the Tenderers did not explicitly agree to consider these commitments in their tender prices, they independently expected that these commitments would be honored.

Justice Lindgren ruled that the understanding, even if limited, satisfied the criteria of section 45(2) of the Trade Practices Act as it was likely to have the effect of fixing, controlling, or maintaining the price for services in competition with each other. The court found that the Tenderers were indeed competitive with each other in relation to the supply of construction services in New South Wales. Consequently, the court found that the actions of the Tenderers, including Concretes, contravened the Trade Practices Act.

The final orders of the court included standing the proceeding over to a later date for the making of further orders, including those regarding costs. The parties were required to submit agreed short minutes of the orders or, if they could not agree, copies of the minutes and submissions in support, to the Associate to Lindgren J by a specified date.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The proceeding be stood over to 7 February 2000 at 9.30 am for the making of orders including orders as to costs.

2. The applicant and the first respondent by 5.00 pm on 3 February 2000 supply to the Associate to Lindgren J agreed short minutes of the orders to be made or if agreement has not by then been reached copies of short minutes of the orders for which they will respectively contend and submissions in support.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Memories fade and the imposition of a pecuniary penalty and the official opprobrium attached will serve to remind Concretes’ officers for all the longer period of time that it does not pay to contravene the TP Act. General deterrence might be non-existent if a penalty were not to be imposed. Other persons might know nothing more than the fact that Concretes “got off” without penalty.Affidavit evidence filed since delivery of Reasons for Judgment (No 8) on contravention Since Reasons for Judgment (No 8) on contravention were delivered on 14 July last, Concretes and the Commission have each filed an affidavit relating to penalty. The affidavits are not controversial and the deponents were not cross-examined. The affidavit sworn 22 September 1999 of Paul Richard McCann of Concretes’ solicitors proves as follows. On 18 July 1990 the Governor of New South Wales appointed the then Mr Roger Vincent Gyles QC (now Justice Gyles of this Court) (the “Royal Commissioner”) sole Commissioner to inquire into three identified practices within the building industry in New South Wales. In July and August 1990 the Royal Commissioner called for submissions and information relevant to the terms of the inquiry and wrote to 265 companies and organisations connected with the building industry, including Concretes, seeking submissions. Shortly after August 1990 Mr McCann met with three senior officers of Concretes, none of whom remains an employee of Concretes, to discuss the notice received from a Royal Commissioner. The Assistant to the Managing Director told Mr McCann shortly afterwards that Concretes had agreed to cooperate with the Royal Commissioner fully and actively and that this information had been relayed to the Royal Commissioner. Mr McCann was told subsequently that the Managing Director of Concretes had met with the Royal Commissioner and furnished information to him. On 3 May 1991, the Honourable Kevin James Holland QC (the “Second Royal Commissioner”) was issued with Letters Patent requiring him to inquire into:“[t]he existence of collusive conduct and practices in or in relation to tendering for building contracts in New South Wales from 1 January 1986 to date and continuing.” Concretes identified Woollard, who was then a qualified quantity surveyor and Concretes’ Chief Estimator as the person having the most intimate knowledge of the identified practices described and as the person with whom Mr McCann was to work in dealing with the Second Royal Commissioner. Mr McCann and Woollard met with officers of the Royal Commission over several weeks prior to the commencement of formal hearings before the Second Royal Commissioner, for the purpose of producing records relating to Special Fees and UTFs and for the purpose of preparing a statement. Public hearings relating to Special Fees and UTFs were conducted before the Second Royal Commissioner over a period of thirty-one days, between 20 May 1991 and 9 September 1991. Because of the cooperation of Woollard and Concretes and their profile in the building construction industry, the Commission concentrated much of its efforts on Woollard’s evidence. He appeared before the Commission on 11, 12 and 13 June 1991 when he was questioned at length by counsel assisting the Commission, Mr J M Stowe QC, as well as by counsel retained by “consumers” of services provided by construction contractors. His evidence was publicised widely and daily. The major metropolitan and Australia-wide newspapers, such as the Sydney Morning Herald and The Australian Financial Review, contained headlines which were damaging to Concretes’ reputation. That publicity created the perception that Concretes was alone in engaging in the practices the subject of the Second Royal Commissioner’s inquiry.

Decision

Reasons for decision

LINDGREN J
Hollands was the successful Tenderer. Richmond caused or procured the AFCC, through its National Executive Committee, to ratify and levy the Special Fee on Hollands. The AFCC sent invoices for instalments of the Special Fee to Hollands which paid them. Similarly, each of Concretes, Multiplex and Leightons sent to Hollands invoices for instalments of the UTFs and Hollands paid the UTF of $750,000 to each of Concretes, Multiplex and Leightons (totalling $2,250,000). Each of the invoices sent by the AFCC and by Concretes, Multiplex and Leightons purported to make claims on Hollands for fees for “consultancy services” but such services were not provided and were never intended to be provided by Hollands.FINDINGS IN REASONS FOR JUDGMENT (No 8) As explained in Reasons for Judgment (No 8) I was not satisfied on the evidence that the Special Fee understanding had been arrived at. Rather, I concluded that on the evidence the Special Fee of $1,000,000 was unilaterally imposed by the AFCC on the Tenderers as a means of raising revenue from its members. I did find, however, that each Tenderer undertook to the others that if it was the successful Tenderer, it would pay a UTF of $750,000 to each unsuccessful Tenderer. I did not find that each Tenderer undertook to the others that it would take this commitment into account in the preparation of its tender price or, if it should be the successful Tenderer, that it would pay the UTFs out of the proceeds of the job. I did conclude, however, that each Tenderer had an independent expectation that as a matter of fact each Tenderer would do both of those things. Although the independent expectations to which I have just referred were not part of the understanding arrived at by the Tenderers, this did not, in my view, foreclose the question whether that understanding, limited in the manner mentioned though it was, satisfied the terms of s 45 of the TP Act. Section 45(2)(a) and (b) provided relevantly as follows:“45(2) A corporation shall not -(a)make a[n] … arrangement, or arrive at an understanding, if -(i)…(ii)a provision of the proposed … arrangement or understanding has the purpose, or would have or be likely to have the effect, of substantially lessening competition; or(b)give effect to a provision of a[n] … arrangement or understanding, …if that provision -(i)…(ii)has the purpose, or has or is likely to have the effect, of substantially lessening competition.”Section 45A provided, relevantly, that a provision of an understanding was deemed “ … for the purposes of [s 45] to have the purpose, or to have or to be likely to have the effect, of substantially lessening competition if the provision … [was] likely to have the effect … of fixing, controlling or maintaining … the price for … goods or services … to be supplied … by the parties … or by any of them … in competition with each other.” The Tenderers were competitive with one another in relation to the supply of construction services in New South Wales.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: LINDGREN J