Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Boost Tel Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 51 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Boost Tel Pty Limited [2010] FCA 701

Citation: Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Boost Tel Pty Limited [2010] FCA 701
Parties: AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION
v
BOOST TEL PTY LIMITED (ACN 092 384 417) and PREPAID SERVICES PTY LIMITED (ACN 094 689 219)
File number: WAD 125 of 2009
Judge: SIOPIS J
Date of judgment: 5 July 2010
Catchwords: TRADE PRACTICES – whether representations made in advertisements for international phone cards were false and misleading or deceptive – small print and asterisks – whether disclaimer was sufficient to qualify content of primary statement – what was the composition of the class of consumers likely to be affected by the impugned conduct – whether orders for corrective advertising should be made.
Legislation: Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) ss 52, 53(aa), 53(c), 53(e)
Cases cited: Parkdale Custom Built Furniture Proprietary Limited v Puxu Proprietary Limited (1982) 149 CLR 191
Darwin Bakery Pty Ltd v Sully (1981) 36 ALR 371
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Tel.Pacific Limited [2009] FCA 279
Medical Benefits Fund of Australia Ltd v Cassidy (2003) 135 FCR 1
Date of hearing: 10 December 2009
Date of last submissions: 23 December 2009
Date of Publication of Orders:

12 July 2010

Place: Perth
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 124
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr W Keane
Solicitor for the Applicant: Corrs Chambers Westgarth
Counsel for the First Respondent:

Mr D Perrignon

Solicitor for the First Respondent:

Makinson & d’Apice Lawyers

Solicitor for the Second Respondent:

Minter Ellison


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

WAD 125 of 2009

BETWEEN:

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION
Applicant

AND:

BOOST TEL PTY LIMITED (ACN 092 384 417)
First Respondent

PREPAID SERVICES PTY LIMITED (ACN 094 689 219)
Second Respondent

JUDGE:

SIOPIS J

DATE OF PUBLICATION OF ORDERs:

12 JULY 2010

WHERE MADE:

PERTH

THE COURT DECLARES THAT:

1.Boost Tel Pty Limited (Boost), from at least February 2007 until the date of this order, in trade or commerce:

(a)engaged in conduct that was misleading or deceptive or likely to mislead or deceive, in contravention of section 52(1) of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth);

(b)in connexion with the supply or possible supply of services or in connexion with the promotion of the supply or use of services, falsely represented that the services were of a particular value, in contravention of section 53(aa) of the Trade Practices Act; and

(c)in connexion with the supply or possible supply of services or in connexion with the promotion of the supply or use of services, represented that the services had performance characteristics or benefits that they did not have, in contravention of section 53(c) of the Trade Practices Act,

by publishing, in relation to the Boost pre-paid phone cards (Boost Cards), advertising material, which contained the statements “24Hr Flat Rates” and “New No Connection Fee!!!” and thereby represented that no fees other than timed call charges…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Boost Tel P... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] FCA 701
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) brought proceedings against Boost Tel Pty Ltd in the Federal Court of Australia, alleging that Boost had engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct in contravention of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth). The ACCC claimed that Boost had made several false or misleading representations in its advertising for international phone cards, including that certain call rates and durations would be available to users, which was not the case. The court was required to decide whether Boost's conduct breached the Trade Practices Act and, if so, what orders should be made against Boost.

The court found that Boost had indeed engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct by making false representations regarding the call rates and durations available on its phone cards. The court held that Boost's representations were false because the stipulated call rates and durations could only be achieved under very specific circumstances, which were highly unlikely to be met by consumers. The court also found that the disclaimers in the small print did not negate or diminish the falsity or misleading nature of Boost's representations. The court held that Boost's conduct contravened sections 52(1), 53(aa), 53(c), and 53(e) of the Trade Practices Act.

As a result, the court made several orders against Boost. These orders included an injunction requiring Boost to sufficiently disclose all fees, rates, charges, and other relevant information when making representations about its phone cards. Boost was also required to remove its misleading advertising material and publish a corrective notice. Additionally, Boost was ordered to implement a trade practices compliance program and pay the ACCC's costs.

In summary, the court found that Boost had made false or misleading representations in its advertising for international phone cards, which contravened the Trade Practices Act. The court made orders against Boost to prevent it from engaging in similar conduct in the future, require it to publish a corrective notice, and implement a trade practices compliance program.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Boost Tel Pty Limited (Boost), from at least February 2007 until the date of this order, in trade or commerce:

(a) engaged in conduct that was misleading or deceptive or likely to mislead or deceive, in contravention of section 52(1) of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth);

(b) in connexion with the supply or possible supply of services or in connexion with the promotion of the supply or use of services, falsely represented that the services were of a particular value, in contravention of section 53(aa) of the Trade Practices Act; and

(c) in connexion with the supply or possible supply of services or in connexion with the promotion of the supply or use of services, represented that the services had performance characteristics or benefits that they did not have, in contravention of section 53(c) of the Trade Practices Act,

by publishing, in relation to the Boost pre-paid phone cards (Boost Cards), advertising material, which contained the statements “24Hr Flat Rates” and “New No Connection Fee!!!” and thereby represented that no fees other than timed call charges applied to the use of the Boost Cards (Boost No Fee Representation), when, in fact, an in-call surcharge applied to the Boost Cards and calls made using the Boost Cards.

2. Boost, from at least February 2007 until the date of this order, in trade or commerce:

(a) engaged in conduct that was misleading or deceptive or likely to mislead or deceive in contravention of section 52(1) of the Trade Practices Act;

(b) in connexion with the supply or possible supply of services or in connexion with the promotion of the supply or use of services, falsely represented that the services were of a particular value, in contravention of section 53(aa) of the Trade Practices Act;

(c) in connexion with the supply or possible supply of services or in connexion with the promotion of the supply or use of services, represented that the services had performance characteristics or benefits that they did not have, in contravention of section 53(c) of the Trade Practices Act; and

(d) made false or misleading representation with respect to the price of services, in contravention of section 53(e) of the Trade Practices Act;

by publishing, in relation to the Boost pre-paid phone cards (Boost Cards), advertising material, which contained the statements to the effect that calls to certain locations were charged at certain rates per minute on those cards and thereby represented that regardless of the number and length of calls, users will be able to achieve the stipulated call rate for the location and type of connexion (landline or mobile) specified (Boost Call Rate Representations), when, in fact:

(e) the stipulated call rate could, at best, only be achieved if:

(A) one continuous call were made; or

(B) calls made precisely matched the length of the charging increments specified in the applicable terms and conditions (up to but not exceeding the time at which any in-call surcharge is applied); and

(f) the stipulated call rate is unlikely to be achieved because the actual cost of calls made using the relevant Card is increased by the fact that calls were charged in incremental periods, an in-call surcharge applied and other additional fees and charges were payable in respect of certain calls; and

(g) statements made in the fine print in the relevant advertising material did not negate or diminish the falsity or the misleading or deceptive nature of the Boost Call Rate Representations.

3. Boost, from at least February 2007 until the date of this order, in trade or commerce:

(a) engaged in conduct that was misleading or deceptive or likely to mislead or deceive, in contravention of section 52(1) of the Trade Practices Act;

(b) in connexion with the supply or possible supply of services or in connexion with the promotion of the supply or use of services, falsely represented that the services were of a particular value, in contravention of section 53(aa) of the Trade Practices Act;

(c) in connexion with the supply or possible supply of services or in connexion with the promotion of the supply or use of services, represented that the services had performance characteristics or benefits that they did not have, in contravention of section 53(c) of the Trade Practices Act; and

by publishing, in relation to the Boost pre-paid phone cards (Boost Cards), advertising material, which contained the statements to the effect that a stipulated number of minutes or calls was available on that card and thereby represented that regardless of the number and length of calls, users will be able to achieve the total stipulated call duration for the location and type of connexion (landline or mobile) specified (Boost Call Duration Representations), when, in fact:

(d) the stipulated call rate could, at best, only be achieved if:

(i) one continuous call were made; or

(ii) calls made precisely matched the length of the charging increments specified in the applicable terms and conditions (up to but not exceeding the time at which any in-call surcharge is applied); and

(e) the number of available minutes is diminished by the fact that calls were charged in incremental periods, an in-call surcharge applied and other additional fees and charges were payable in respect of certain calls; and

(f) statements made in the fine print in the relevant advertising material did not negate or diminish the falsity or the misleading or deceptive nature of the Boost Call Duration Representations.

the court orders that:

Boost Injunctions

4. Boost, whether by itself, its servants or agents or otherwise howsoever in connexion with the supply or possible supply of telecommunication services by way of telecommunications products known as “calling cards” or “pre-paid phone cards” (Cards), in trade or commerce, for a period of 2 years from the date of the Court’s order be required, when making representations as to the price (including any rate, charge or fee) or duration of use of the telecommunication services available by way of its Cards to sufficiently disclose the following matters:

(a) all fees applicable to the use of the Card;

(b) the applicable rates and charges including surcharges;

(c) any charging by incremental periods;

(d) any qualifications on the stipulated call duration; and

(e) any qualifications on the stipulated call rate per minute.

5. Boost, whether by itself, its servants or agents or otherwise howsoever in connexion with the supply or possible supply of telecommunication services by way of Cards be restrained for a period of 2 years from the date of the Court’s order, in trade or commerce, from:

(a) representing that no fees other than the timed call charges apply to the use of Cards when other fees are applicable;

(b) representing that a stipulated number of minutes is available for calls using a specified Card when the stipulated call duration can only be achieved by making:

(i) one continuous phone call; or

(ii) a particular number of calls precisely corresponding to the increments of time in which the cost of a call is charged;

(c) representing that a stipulated number of minutes is available for calls using a Card without sufficiently disclosing:

(i) any charging by incremental periods;

(ii) that call charges are rounded up; and

(iii) all applicable fees, including:

(A) any surcharges; and

(B) any higher rates that are payable in respect of certain calls;

(d) representing that a Card can be used for calls at a stipulated call rate per minute for the location and type of connexion (landline or mobile) specified without sufficiently disclosing:

(i) any charging by incremental periods;

(ii) that call charges are rounded up; and

(iii) all applicable fees, including:

(A) any surcharges; and

(B) any higher rates that are payable in respect of certain calls.

Boost Corrective Advertising

6. Boost, within 21 days of the date of this order, shall take all reasonable steps to cause the Boost advertising material and any of its other promotional material that contains representations with similar purport or effect to the No Fee Representations, the Boost Call Duration Representations and the Boost Call Rate Representations to be removed from display and further publication by retailers or any other person.

7. Boost, within 21 days of the date of this order, shall cause to be published a notice in the terms and form set out in Schedule 1 (Boost Notice) including the font size and form specified in the Boost Notice and with the business logo on the top of the Boost Notice as appearing on Boost letterhead, and

(a) distribute or cause to be distributed the Boost Notice to its Card retailers and take reasonable steps and use its best endeavours to require the display of the Boost Notice in the form of an A4 poster in the same locations as the Boost Advertising Material was located for a period of 90 days;

(b) cause the Boost Notice to be published on the Internet at the homepage of all websites which are owned, operated or maintained by or on behalf of Boost, including the website accessible via uniform resource located at the address (URL) www.boost.com.au (Boost Website) (or if any such URL is replaced or changed, the Internet home page of the corresponding website) for a period of 90 days and use its best endeavours to ensure that:

(i) the Boost Notice is to be viewable by clicking a “click-through” icon located on the Boost Website;

(ii) the “click-through” icon referred to in the previous sub-paragraph is located in a central position on the page first accessed when the user opens to the homepage of the Boost Website (or the first page of the calling cards section of the Boost Website if changes are made to the Boost Website);

(iii) the “click-through” icon shall contain the words “Misleading Advertising by Boost – Corrective Notice Ordered by Federal Court of Australia” clearly and prominently in red on a contrasting background and the words “click here”; and

(iv) the Boost Notice occupies the entire webpage which is accessed via the “click-through” icon referred to above.

Boost Community Service Orders

8. Within 21 days of the date of this order, Boost shall send by mail to its 20 largest competitors copies of:

(a) the notice attached in Schedule 2;

(b) these orders; and

(c) any reasons for decision given with these orders.

Boost Compliance Program

9. Boost, within 21 days of the date of this order, shall establish a compliance policy and associated complaints handling system, training and review system in accordance with the program set out in Schedule 3 (Boost Compliance Program).

10. Boost shall maintain and operate the Boost Compliance Program for a period of three years from the date of this order.

Costs

11. The first respondent is to pay the applicant’s costs.

SCHEDULE 1

Boost Tel Pty Limited (Boost) found by Court to have made false representations regarding phone cards

The Federal Court declared that Boost engaged in false misleading or deceptive conduct in relation to cards promoted from at least February 2007 to 5 July 2010 by:

§ representing that no fees other than timed call charges would apply when, in fact, an in-call surcharge applied

§ representing that, on the cards:

o a certain number of minutes was available

o a certain call rate per minute was available

when in fact:

o total number of minutes and stipulated call rate could, at best, be achieved if:

§ one continuous call was made, or

§ calls made precisely matched particular charging increments;

o number of minutes available and call rate per minute were diminished in value by an in-call surcharge and other additional fees and charges which applied in respect of certain calls.

Consumers are urged to make sure they are aware of all applicable fees and charges when buying phone cards.

The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission brought the proceedings in the Federal Court of Australia in relation to breaches of sections 52(1), 53(aa) and 53(c) of the Trade Practices Act 1974 which prohibit false, misleading or deceptive conduct.

The Court made orders that restrained Boost from engaging in similar conduct for a period of 2 years, required it to publish this notice and to implement a trade practices compliance program. A copy of the decision and the detailed orders can be found at www.fedcourt.gov.au.

_____________________________________________________________________________

SCHEDULE 2

Federal Court declares Boost engaged in false, misleading or deceptive conduct in advertising its pre-paid phone cards

Following legal action by the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC), the Federal Court of Australia declared Boost Tel Pty Limited (Boost) made false, misleading or deceptive representations in contravention of sections 52(1), 53(aa), 53(c) and 53(e) of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) (Act).

Boost engaged in the offending conduct over a sustained period of time in connexion with statements it made in advertising for the sale of its pre-paid phone card.

The Court declared that Boost’s conduct contravened the Act because it represented in relation to its phone card that no fees other than timed call charges would apply, when in fact an in-call surcharge was charged for calls beyond certain durations.

The Court also declared Boost contravened the Act because it represented that certain phone cards would have a specific number of minutes’ call time or a stipulated rate per minute when this was not the case. The total stipulated call duration and rate per minute could at best be achieved if one continuous call was made or calls made were precisely 1 or 5 minutes in length.

Further, calls on the Boost card were charged in incremental periods, diminishing the total number of minutes available for use of the card for multiple calls if the call durations did not match the incremental periods. Each of the incremental charging periods and the in‑call surcharges diminished the value of the card and number of minutes available while increasing the cost of the calls.

The Court made orders that restrained Boost from engaging in similar conduct for a period of 2 years, required Boost to publish this notice and to implement a trade practices compliance program and to pay the ACCC’s costs of the proceeding.

A copy of the decision can be found at www.fedcourt.gov.au.

SCHEDULE 3

BOOST TRADE PRACTICES COMPLIANCE AND EDUCATION / TRAINING PROGRAM

Interpretation

1. In this Annexure:

(a) “ACCC” means the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission;

(b) “Act” means the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth);

(c) “Compliance Officer” means the person appointed under paragraph 2 or paragraph 3 below;

(d) “Compliance Program” means the Trade Practices Compliance and Education / Training Program in this Annexure;

(e) “Court’s Order” means the relevant order(s) of the Federal Court of Australia made in these proceedings;

(f) “Relevant Provisions” means sections 52(1), 53(aa), 53(c) and 53(e) of the Act which were contravened by the Contravening Conduct, and Division 1 of Part V of the Act which deals with similar or related conduct.

Compliance Officer

2. Boost must, within 28 days of the date of the Court’s Order, appoint a Director or a senior employee with suitable qualifications or experience in corporate compliance as Compliance Officer with responsibility for ensuring that the Compliance Program is effectively established, maintained and administered in accordance with the Court’s Order.

3. After the appointment of the Compliance Officer in accordance with paragraph 2, Boost must take all reasonable steps to ensure that, for the duration of the Court’s Order, there is a Director or a senior employee with suitable qualifications or experience in corporate compliance appointed as Compliance Officer with responsibility for ensuring that the Compliance Program is effectively established, maintained and administered in accordance with the Court’s Order.

4. Boost must take all reasonable steps to ensure that for the duration of the Court’s Order the Compliance Officer discharges his or her responsibility of ensuring that the Compliance Program is effectively established, maintained and administered in accordance with the Court’s Order.

Compliance Officer Training

5. Boost will:

(a) ensure that, within 90 days of the date of the Court’s Order, the Compliance Officer attends practical trade practices training focusing on the Relevant Provisions of the Act;

(b) ensure that the training is administered by a suitably qualified, compliance professional or legal practitioner with expertise in trade practices law;

(c) within 14 days of completion of training, provide the ACCC with a written statement from the trade practices professional confirming the completion of the training conducted in accordance with 5(a) and 5(b) above.

Staff Training

6. Boost will cause all employees of Boost whose duties could result in them being concerned with conduct that may contravene the Relevant Provisions of the Act to receive regular (at least once a year) practical training that focuses on the Relevant Provisions of the Act.

Complaints Handling

7. Boost will:

(a) develop procedures for recording, storing and responding to trade practice complaints within six weeks of the Court’s Order; and

(b) provide the ACCC with an outline of the complaint handling system within two months of the Court’s Order.

8. The implementation and continuing effectiveness of the Compliance Program will be regularly discussed at management meetings.

Review

9. If requested by the ACCC, Boost shall, at its own expense, provide copies of documents and information in respect of matters which are the subject of the Compliance Program.

10. In the event the ACCC has sufficient reason to suspect that the Compliance Program is not being implemented effectively, Boost shall, at its own expense and if requested by the ACCC, cause an interim or additional Review to be conducted and cause the resulting Review Report to be provided to the ACCC.

Note: Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The “call rate representation” also falsely represented the price of the services. This was because Boost represented that the stipulated call rate would be the price of making calls in the course of the normal usage of the card and this was untrue. Accordingly, Boost’s conduct in making the “call rate representation” also contravened s 53(e) of the Trade Practices Act.the call duration representation The third representation which the ACCC alleges that Boost made was referred to as the “call duration representation”. This representation, contended the ACCC, was made in the February 2007 and October 2007 flyers. This representation is derived from the following statements in each of the impugned documents. Each of the impugned flyers contains the phrase, “1896 total minutes” immediately adjacent to the words “½ c per minute calls”. The words are in capital letters and in bold font. I have already said that the notation ”½ c” dominates the front page of the two relevant flyers. Further, lower down on the front page of each of the flyers the phrase, “366 total minutes” appears similarly juxtaposed of the phrase, “2½ c per minute calls”. These words are also in capital letters and bold font. The ACCC pleaded that by publishing these statements, Boost represented that the Boost card could be used to make calls to the countries specified on the flyers for an aggregate period equal to 1896 minutes, when the ½ cent rate applied, and 366 minutes, when the 2½ cent rate applied, regardless of the number and length of individual calls made. It was then contended by the ACCC that the representations were false or misleading, because:(a)the Stipulated Duration could, at best, only be achieved if:(i)one continuous call were made; or(ii)calls made precisely matched the length of the charging increments specified in the applicable terms and conditions (up to but not exceeding the time at which any in-call surcharge is applied);when it is highly unlikely that a purchaser of a Card would use the Card in that manner;(b)further or alternatively, calls were charged in incremental blocks and call charges for each completed call were rounded up to the next charging increment;(c)further or alternatively, surcharges, other additional charges or higher rates may be payable in respect of certain calls; and(d)further or alternatively, service fees and in-call surcharges applied to multiple uses of the relevant Card. Boost contended that the phrase, “1896 total minutes” does not convey the representation to a reasonable consumer that the applicable card could be used to make calls for the aggregate period of 1896 minutes, regardless of the number and length of individual calls. Boost contended that the statement conveyed the impression that the “stipulated number of minutes may be achieved on a given use of the card”. A reasonable consumer, said Boost, would regard the statement as being a statement of a potential time for the use of the card; and it was contended that the word “total” suggested a maximum capacity. It was said that a reasonable consumer would know the prevalence in the market place of the practice of charging in incremental blocks and the use of surcharges.