Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Bill Express Limited (ACN 090 059 564) (In Liq)

Link copied
Case Copied 49 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Bill Express Limited (ACN 090 059 564) (In Liq) [2009] FCA 1022

TRADE PRACTICES – third line forcing – meaning of “on the condition” – misleading and deceptive conduct – false and misleading representations

Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth): ss 47(1), 47(6), 47(13)(a), 52, 53(g)

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Dukemaster Pty Ltd (ACN 050 275 226) [2009] FCA 682
Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v IMB Group Pty Ltd (ACN 050 411 946) (in liq) [2002] FCA 402
Castlemaine Tooheys Ltd v Williams and Hodgson Transport Pty Ltd (1986) 162 CLR 395

Dowling v Dalgety Australia Ltd (1992) 34 FCR 109
Family Credit Union Ltd v Parramatta Tourist Services Pty Ltd (1980) 48 FLR 445
Global Sportsman Pty Ltd v Mirror Newspapers Pty Ltd (1984) 2 FCR 82
Ku-ring-gai Co-operative Building Society, Re (No. 12) Ltd (1978) 36 FLR 134
Master Education Services Pty Ltd v Ketchell (2008) 236 CLR 101
Miller v Fiona’s Clothes Horse of Centrepoint Pty Ltd (1989) ATPR 40-693
SST Consulting Services Pty Ltd v Rieson (2006) 225 CLR 516
Stationers Supply Pty Ltd v Victorian Authorised Newsagents Association Limited (1993) 44 FCR 35
The Paul Dainty Corporation Pty Ltd v The National Tennis Centre Trust (1990) 22 FCR 495
Trade Practices Commission v Radio World Pty Ltd (1989) 16 IPR 407

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION v BILL EXPRESS LIMITED (ACN 090 059 564) (IN LIQUIDATION), TECHNOLOGY BUSINESS INTERNATIONAL PTY LTD (ACN 092 574 804) (IN LIQUIDATION), BNY TRUST COMPANY OF AUSTRALIA PTY LTD (ACN 050 294 052) and MOBIUS FINANCIAL SERVICES PTY LTD (ACN 099 088 365) (IN LIQUIDATION)

VID 894 of 2008

GORDON J
14 SEPTEMBER 2009
MELBOURNE


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

VID 894 of 2008

GENERAL DIVISION

BETWEEN:

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION
Applicant

AND:

BILL EXPRESS LIMITED (ACN 090 059 564) (IN LIQUIDATION)
First Respondent

TECHNOLOGY BUSINESS INTERNATIONAL PTY LTD (ACN 092 574 804) (IN LIQUIDATION)
Second Respondent

BNY TRUST COMPANY OF AUSTRALIA PTY LTD (ACN 050 294 052)
Third Respondent

MOBIUS FINANCIAL SERVICES PTY LTD (ACN 099 088 365) (IN LIQUIDATION)
Fourth Respondent

JUDGE:

GORDON J

DATE OF ORDER:

14 SEPTEMBER 2009

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

THE COURT DECLARES THAT:

1.On each occasion, between 2003 and July 2008, on which the First Respondent (“BXP”) and the Second Respondent (“TBI”) entered into a contract with merchants substantially in the form of one of the contracts which are Exhibit “SG-5” to the affidavit of Shane Christopher Grosser sworn on 19 May 2009 and available for inspection at the Victorian Registry of the Federal Court of Australia (respectively, a “Merchant Contract” and a “Rental Contract”) they engaged in the practice of exclusive dealing as defined in s 47(6) of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) (“the TPA”) (as in force at the relevant time) in contravention of s 47(1) of the TPA, by offering to supply to merchants electronic products and services under a…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Bill Expres... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] FCA 1022
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) filed a case against Bill Express Limited (BXP) (ACN 090 059 564) (In Liq), along with other related entities, challenging the legality of certain contractual arrangements and seeking various declarations and orders. The ACCC claimed that the defendants engaged in exclusive dealing practices and third-line forcing, which contravened the Trade Practices Act 1974 (TPA). The defendants, BXP and Technology Business International (TBI), were in liquidation, with specific individuals appointed as liquidators. The court had to determine whether the exclusive dealing and third-line forcing practices were unlawful under the TPA and if the relevant contracts were void due to illegality.

The primary legal issues involved whether the defendants' actions constituted exclusive dealing and third-line forcing, both of which are prohibited under section 47 of the TPA. The court examined the nature of the contractual relationships between BXP, TBI, and merchants, as well as the specific terms of the rental contracts. The ACCC argued that these practices led to an illegal third-line forcing scenario, where merchants were compelled to enter into contracts with TBI due to the arrangements between TBI and BXP. The defendants, however, contended that their actions did not amount to exclusive dealing or third-line forcing.

The court concluded that the defendants' actions did not constitute exclusive dealing as defined under section 4A(5) of the TPA. It found that BXP and TBI were not related entities during the relevant period, and thus, the exclusive dealing provisions did not apply. Regarding third-line forcing, the court noted that while there was an element of third-line forcing, it did not find it necessary to declare the rental contracts void due to illegality. The court held that the contracts were commercially and contractually linked, and it was inappropriate to void only the rental contracts without considering the merchant contracts. Furthermore, the defendants were in liquidation, and BNY had already committed to not recover further money from merchants and to repay rental fees collected but not yet paid over. As such, the court refused to grant the declarations and orders sought by the ACCC.

The court ordered that the reasons for judgment be retained on the Court file for the purposes of section 83 of the TPA. No costs were ordered in the absence of submissions from the ACCC.

Orders

Orders of the court

4. A copy of the reasons for judgment be retained on the Court file for the purposes of s 83 of the TPA.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

The form and content of these declarations and orders require further explanation. FACTS The facts are dealt with in two parts: the relevant entities and their directors and then the Bill Express Contracts and the history of dealings between BXP and TBI and the merchants.(1) Relevant EntitiesBXP BXP was incorporated on 21 October 1999. Until 2 September 2004, BXP was called Dial Time Pty Ltd. It became a public company on 3 September 2004. Its ultimate holding company was On Q Group Limited (ABN 57 009 104 330). On 8 July 2008, Craig David Crosbie (“Crosbie”) and Ian Menzies Carson (“Carson”) were appointed joint administrators of BXP. On 12 December 2008, BXP was wound up and Crosbie and Carson were appointed joint liquidators. Since incorporation, BXP’s directors have been and are: From 14 June 2002, its principal place of business was at 677 The Boulevard, Eaglemont, Victoria. TBI TBI was incorporated on 26 April 2000. Prior to 10 April 2003, it was called On Q International Pty Ltd. It had a sole shareholder – Technology Business Holdings Pty Ltd (“TBH”). On 30 June 2008, TBI was wound up and Geoffrey Niels Handberg (“Handberg”) was appointed liquidator. Since incorporation, TBI’s directors have been and are: From 14 June 2002, its principal place of business was also 677 The Boulevard, Eaglemont, Victoria. TBH TBH was incorporated on 11 April 2000. Prior to 10 April 2003, it was called On Q Holdings Pty Ltd. It is majority owned by Equip Rentals Pty Ltd. Since incorporation, TBH’s directors have been and are: From 10 July 2002, its principal place of business has been and remains 677 The Boulevard, Eaglemont, Victoria. On Q Companies There are three companies: On Q Group Limited, On Q Company Pty Ltd and On Q Technologies Pty Ltd. At least from 2003, On Q Group Ltd was the ultimate holding company of On Q Company Pty Ltd and On Q Technologies Pty Ltd. Each of Harold Christiansen, Ian Christiansen and Julian Little was a director of the following companies from the date specified: As the facts demonstrate, in the period between 2003 and 2008, BXP and TBI were not related as that term is defined in s 4A(5) of the TPA: Dowling v Dalgety Australia Ltd (1992) 34 FCR 109 at 139 and The Paul Dainty Corporation Pty Ltd v The National Tennis Centre Trust (1990) 22 FCR 495 at 523. During the relevant period, one was not the holding company or subsidiary of the other and BXP and TBI were not subsidiaries of the same holding company. Mobius and BNY Mobius was approached by TBI to provide finance to TBI for the equipment and installation costs. Mobius is the trust manager of the Mobius ERT-W04, ERT-W05 and ELR-01 Trusts (“the Trusts”). Mobius performed various managerial functions for the Trusts. BNY is the trustee of the Trusts. (2) AGREEMENTS AND HISTORY OF DEALINGS Notwithstanding that the Respondents did not appear at the hearing, Counsel for the ACCC sought to rely upon admissions made by BXP prior to the appointment of the administrator in July 2008. Those admissions were contained in letters sent by BXP’s solicitors to the ACCC responding to complaints made to the ACCC about the Bill Express Payment System. The first letter from BXP’s solicitors dated 4 June 2008 described the Bill Express Payment System and its operation. Although the letter stated that it did not purport to provide a comprehensive overview of all of the matters in issue, I accept that it provides a useful summary of the structure, implementation and operation of the Bill Express Payment System at that time. Except where noted, the following summary is extracted from that 4 June 2008 letter.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

GORDON J

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: GORDON J

Secondly, BNY has agreed to give an undertaking that if the Court finds that BXP and TBI engaged in the practice of exclusive dealing within the meaning of s 47(6) of the TPA, BNY will not take steps to recover any further money from merchants under the Rental Contracts and will use reasonable endeavours to repay to merchants the rental fees which BNY has collected but not yet paid over. Declarations and Orders in relation to Rental Contracts The ACCC also sought a declaration that all Rental Contracts were void on the basis of unlawful third line forcing. The ACCC submitted that the Rental Contracts were unlawful at common law because of the breach of s 47 of the TPA and thus void. I would not grant such a declaration. The ACCC could not and did not submit in evidence each of the thousands of Rental Contracts executed by TBI and the merchants. There are other reasons for refusing to grant a declaration of the kind sought by the ACCC. First, I am not persuaded that contravention of s 47(6) necessarily gives rise to a finding that the contracts are infected by illegality and thus are void at common law: Master Education Services Pty Ltd v Ketchell (2008) 236 CLR 101. However, even if I was persuaded that there was illegality, what is illegal? In the context of s 47(6), the ACCC submitted (properly in my view), that the third line forcing operated in respect of both the Rental Contract and the Merchant Contract. In those circumstances, I do not consider that the form of declaration sought by the ACCC is appropriate. I can see no basis for choosing one contract over the other – they are contractually and commercially linked. In fact, the form of the first declaration proceeds on that basis. Thirdly, BXP and TBI are in liquidation and BNY has given an undertaking in the terms earlier identified (see [90] above). In those circumstances, it is by no means clear why such a declaration is necessary. For the same reasons, I refuse to grant the order sought by the ACCC that the following Rental Contracts which were adduced in evidence were void, namely:1.the Rental Contract executed by HDF Nominees Pty Ltd (ACN 007 007 132) on 8 November 2005 and by TBI on 17 November 2005; and 2.the Rental Contract executed by Neil Brennan on 13 November 2006 and by TBI on 15 November 2006. If there is some compelling legal or other reason why such a declaration (or order in relation to the two Rental Contracts identified in [94]) is necessary, the ACCC may seek to have the matter relisted and I will consider the issue upon the receipt of further submissions.Costs The ACCC made no submissions as to costs. Again, if the ACCC seeks costs, it should file a submission (of not more than two A4 pages) by no later than 18 September 2009 directed at the question of costs. In the absence of such a submission, there will be no order as to costs as between the ACCC and each of BXP, TBI and Mobius.