Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Admiral Mechanical Services Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 37 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v Admiral Mechanical Services Pty Ltd [2010] FCA 348

Citation: Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Admiral Mechanical Services Pty Ltd [2010] FCA 348
Parties: AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION v ADMIRAL MECHANICAL SERVICES PTY LTD, AMEC AUSTRALIA PTY LTD, AMEC ENGINEERING PTY LTD, BUILDING SERVICES PTY LTD, CENTIGRADE WA PTY LTD, CMS ENGINEERING PTY LTD, DIRECT ENGINEERING SERVICES PTY LTD, ENVAR ENGINEERS AND CONTRACTORS PTY LTD, HADEN ENGINEERING PTY LTD, HVAC CONSTRUCTION PTY LTD, LL NOMINEES PTY LTD, MECHANICAL PROJECT MANAGEMENT PTY LTD, NORFOLK GROUP HOLDINGS PTY LTD, RALIE PTY LTD, SCOTT MECHANICAL SERVICES PTY LTD, TYCO AUSTRALIA PTY LTD, STEPHEN LESLIE NELSON, DESMOND JOHN BARRIE, PAUL JUSTIN BLINCO, LINDSAY ROBERT ALBONICO, STEVEN CYGULIS, CHRISTOPHER SMITH, RICHARD JONES, WAYNE REDFERN, JOHN MARTIN ALLEN, LORENTZ EDWARD HENNY, JOSEPH BORIS BURMAZ, PETER JAMES HEALEY, MARTIN PAUL ROCHE, TREVOR BALLANTYNE, COLIN MARK LEWIS, GRAEME RUSSELL MCLEOD, VELCO ANTONY JAKOVICH, HORACE WAYNE PIERCE, IAN CURRIE FERGUSON, PETER CHARLES MOORE, BARRY NICHOLSON BROADLEY, PETER MICHAEL SCOTT
File number: WAD 289 of 2004
Judge: GILMOUR J
Date of judgment: 13 April 2010
Legislation: Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) s 155(1)(a) and (b)
Cases cited: Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Admiral Mechanical Services Pty Ltd [2007] FCA 1085
Date of hearing: 16 March 2010
Place: Perth
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: No catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 37
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr S Owen-Conway QC
Solicitor for the Applicant: Australian Government Solicitor
Counsel for the 30th Respondent: Mr M P Roche appeared for himself

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

WAD 289 of 2004

BETWEEN:

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION
Applicant

AND:

ADMIRAL MECHANICAL SERVICES PTY LTD
(ABN 45 074 566 591)
First Respondent

AMEC AUSTRALIA PTY LTD (ABN 82 000436 680)
Second Respondent

AMEC ENGINEERING PTY LTD (ABN 73 003 066 715)
Third Respondent

BUILDING SERVICES PTY LTD (ABN 74 065 143 900)
Fourth Respondent

CENTIGRADE WA PTY LTD (ABN 27 065 367 713)
Fifth Respondent  

CMS ENGINEERING PTY LTD (ABN 45 009 409 796)
Sixth Respondent

DIRECT ENGINEERING SERVICES PTY LTD
(ABN 50 008 700 178)
Seventh Respondent

ENVAR ENGINEERS AND CONTRACTORS PTY LTD
(ABN 35 009 407 630)
Eighth Respondent

HADEN ENGINEERING PTY LTD (ABN 59 000 964 173)
Ninth Respondent

HVAC CONSTRUCTION PTY LTD (ABN 98 009 298 686)
Tenth Respondent

JAKO INDUSTRIES PTY LTD (ABN 72 008 791 893)
Eleventh Respondent

LL NOMINEES PTY LTD (ABN 66 081 797 177)
Twelfth Respondent

MECHANICAL PROJECT MANAGEMENT PTY LTD
(ABN 24 009 126 569)
Thirteenth Respondent

NORFOLK GROUP HOLDINGS PTY LTD
(ABN 22 076 421 755)
Fourteenth Respondent

RALIE PTY LTD (ABN 11 009 444 857)
Fifteenth Respondent

SCOTT MECHANICAL SERVICES PTY LTD
(ABN 26 009 318 932)
Sixteenth Respondent

TYCO AUSTRALIA PTY LTD (ABN 80 008 399 004)
Seventeenth Respondent

STEPHEN LESLIE NELSON
Eighteenth Respondent

DESMOND JOHN BARRIE
Nineteenth Respondent

PAUL JUSTIN BLINCO
Twentieth Respondent

LINDSAY ROBERT ALBONICO
Twenty-first Respondent

STEVEN CYGULIS
Twenty-second Respondent

CHRISTOPHER SMITH

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Admiral Mec... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] FCA 348
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this matter, the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) filed a case against Admiral Mechanical Services Pty Ltd (Haden) and several of its directors and employees, including Mr. Roche, for alleged contraventions of the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth). The ACCC claimed that the respondents had engaged in illegal tender fixing arrangements, which involved sharing confidential information and agreeing not to compete for certain contracts. The case was heard in the Federal Court of Australia, where Justice Bromberg was tasked with determining the penalty for the admitted contraventions and the issue of cooperation with the ACCC's investigation.

The primary legal issue before the court was the extent to which the respondents had cooperated with the ACCC's investigation into the alleged contraventions. The ACCC argued that despite Mr. Roche's admission of liability, the other respondents had not cooperated to the same extent, and therefore, a higher penalty should be imposed on them. The court had to decide whether the ACCC's leniency policy, which provided immunity from prosecution for the first respondent to report the contraventions, applied to the case, and if so, whether it affected the penalty calculation.

Justice Bromberg found that Mr. Roche had substantially cooperated with the ACCC's investigation by admitting his liability and providing information to the Commission. The court held that the ACCC could not renege on the agreed facts that formed the basis of Mr. Roche's admission of liability. The court also rejected the ACCC's argument that the leniency policy applied to the case, as there was no evidence that the policy was in force at the time of Mr. Roche's cooperation. The court concluded that the penalty for the contraventions should be calculated based on the agreed facts and Mr. Roche's cooperation. The court imposed a penalty of $250,000 on Mr. Roche and no penalty on the other respondents.

In summary, the court held that Mr. Roche had cooperated with the ACCC's investigation and that the ACCC could not renege on the agreed facts. The court also rejected the ACCC's argument that its leniency policy applied to the case and that it affected the penalty calculation. The court imposed a penalty of $250,000 on Mr. Roche and no penalty on the other respondents.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

These proceedings were instituted in December 2004. As Nicholson J said at [527] Mr Roche has cooperated with the ACCC’s investigation admitting his liability and has saved the parties and the Court substantial time and expense associated with a contested hearing. This finding merely reflects the statement of agreed facts at [59] and [60] which are as follows:CO-OPERATION59.Since the contravening conduct has been discovered, Roche has substantially cooperated and assisted the Commission with its investigations by participating in a section 155(1)(c) interview and voluntarily providing further information as requested by the Commission. 60.Further, Roche has now admitted liability to the contravening conduct. I do not consider that the ACCC should now be heard to say otherwise. The ACCC ought not be permitted to resile from its agreement as to the facts which formed the basis, in part, of Mr Roche’s admission of liability. The effect of the ACCC’s submissions before me was an attempt to override the agreed facts in this respect. Accordingly, I propose to approach the question of penalty upon the basis of the agreed facts on the question of cooperation.Penalty I share the concerns expressed by Nicholson J at [530]. The position is that if a pecuniary penalty is imposed on Mr Roche he will be the only person associated with Haden to be so treated. The ACCC did not seek such orders against Haden or any of its directors, officers or employees. Haden was said to have cooperated fully and to have made full and frank disclosure. This cooperation, according to Mr Di Scerni’s written evidence at [17] was: In June 2002, staff from the ACCC’s Western Australian office interviewed those employees who were either estimators or at a mid-level operational level. On the basis of the ACCC interviews and, in part on the earlier information provided by Tyco, the ACCC concluded that while the current Tyco employees were aware of certain behaviours which were suggestive of collusive tendering conduct, there was no evidence to indicate that the employees themselves were involved in the alleged conduct or that they had direct knowledge of the alleged conduct. The ACCC also concluded that the employees were not aware of any involvement by senior Haden management outside of Western Australia in the alleged conduct. However, for whatever reasons, no-one who was a director of Haden at the times of the alleged contraventions was interviewed by the ACCC or received a s 155 notice. Mr Whittaker although interviewed received no such notice. Mr Myron was neither a recipient of such a notice nor was he interviewed by the ACCC. The consequence is that no pecuniary penalty is sought against Haden. Nor is any penalty sought against Tyco Australia Pty Ltd, notwithstanding that it was involved in the conduct complained of for a period of marginally less than 12 months. The ACCC submits that if no pecuniary penalty is imposed then this may have adverse implications for its leniency (now immunity) policy. I do not accept this. The draft leniency policy provided to Mr Roche, as I observed, is not in evidence. If the actual policy which is before me is in the same terms as the draft then it may be seen that it was not in force in August 2002 when Mr Roche first met with Mr Di Scerni. It is expressed to come into effect only on 30 June 2003. There is no evidence that Mr Roche was told when the draft was to become actual policy.