Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v ABB Power Transmission Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 72 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v ABB Power Transmission Pty Ltd [2003] FCA 626

PRACTICE & PROCEDURE - privilege - without prejudice privilege - legal professional privilege - public interest privilege - where cooperation between Australian Competition & Consumer Commission and certain respondents during investigation - where proceedings continued against other respondents - where statements of agreed facts filed in proceedings - extent of privilege

Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) s 155, Pt IV

ACCC v ABB Transmission and Distribution Ltd (2001) ATPR 41-815 cited
ACCC v ABB Transmission and Distribution Ltd (2001) ATPR 41-839 cited
ACCC v ABB Transmission & Distribution Ltd (No 2 - Power Transformers) (2002) ATPR 41-871 cited
Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v ABB Transmission and Distribution Ltd (No 2) (2001) 190 ALR 169 cited
Rush & Tompkins Ltd v Greater London Council [1989] 1 AC 1280 cited

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION v ALSTOM AUSTRALIA LTD (ACN 000 215 092), WILSON TRANSFORMER COMPANY PTY LTD (ACN 004 216 979), DAVID TOOGOOD, CHRIS TAPE, PAUL GRABHAM, R G ELLIOTT, COLIN JAMES, ROBERT WILSON, DAVID PECK, DOUGLAS PITT AND ABB POWER TRANSMISSION PTY LTD (IN LIQ) (ACN 000 102 616)

V533 OF 1999

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION v ABB TRANSMISSION AND DISTRIBUTION LTD (ACN 000 169 568), ABB POWER TRANSMISSION PTY LTD (IN LIQ) (ACN 000 102 616), WILSON TRANSFORMER COMPANY PTY LTD (ACN 004 216 979), SCHNEIDER ELECTRIC (AUSTRALIA) PTY LTD (ACN 004 969 304), A W TYREE TRANSFORMERS PTY LTD (ACN 002 584 278), ALSTOM AUSTRALIA LTD (ACN 000 215 092), DOUGLAS PITT, GRAHAM JONES, RUSSELL ELLEN, ROBERT WILSON, RUSSELL STOCKER, ASHLEY SMOUT, WENDY MINNE, RAYMOND BOYCE, PAUL GRABHAM AND COLIN JAMES

V868 OF 2000

EMMETT J
20 JUNE 2003
SYDNEY

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

V553 OF 1999

BETWEEN:

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION
APPLICANT

AND:

ALSTOM AUSTRALIA LTD
(ACN 000 215 092)
SECOND RESPONDENT

AND:

WILSON TRANSFORMER COMPANY PTY LTD
(ACN 004 216 979)
THIRD RESPONDENT

AND:

DAVID TOOGOOD
FOURTH RESPONDENT

AND:

CHRIS TAPE
FIFTH RESPONDENT

AND:

PAUL GRABHAM
SIXTH RESPONDENT

AND:

R G ELLIOTT
SEVENTH RESPONDENT

AND:

COLIN JAMES
EIGHTH RESPONDENT

AND:

ROBERT WILSON
NINTH RESPONDENT

AND:

DAVID PECK
TENTH RESPONDENT

AND:

DOUGLAS PITT
ELEVENTH RESPONDENT

AND:

ABB POWER TRANSMISSION PTY LTD (IN LIQ)
(ACN 000 102 616)
TWELFTH RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

EMMETT J

DATE OF ORDER:

20 JUNE 2003

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.        the proceeding, including all current notices of motion, be stood over for directions on 27 June 2003 at 9.30 am.

Note:   Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

V868 OF 2000

BETWEEN:

AUSTRALIAN COMPETITION AND CONSUMER COMMISSION
APPLICANT

AND:

ABB TRANSMISSION AND DISTRIBUTION LTD
(ACN 000 169 568)
FIRST RESPONDENT

AND:

ABB POWER TRANSMISSION PTY LTD (IN LIQ)
(ACN 000 102 616)
SECOND RESPONDENT

AND:

WILSON TRANSFORMER COMPANY PTY LTD

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v ABB Power T... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2003] FCA 626
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) filed a case against ABB Power Transmission Pty Ltd, alleging violations of the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth). The primary dispute concerned the admissibility of certain documents and statements under consideration in the context of the ongoing proceedings. The Federal Court was tasked with determining whether these documents and statements were subject to legal privilege and, if so, which type of privilege applied.

The court had to decide whether the documents in question were covered by without prejudice privilege, legal professional privilege, or another form of privilege. It also needed to establish the context and purpose for which the documents were prepared. The court considered the nature of the communications, the stage of the litigation, and the relationship between the parties involved.

The court found that certain documents and statements were indeed subject to without prejudice privilege, as they were prepared in the context of negotiations aimed at resolving disputes between the ACCC and the defendants. These documents included draft statements of facts and correspondence regarding proposed statements of agreed facts. Other documents, such as those furnished as part of a cooperation agreement with Alstom, were not subject to without prejudice privilege but rather legal professional privilege.

Ultimately, the court ruled that some documents were privileged and could not be disclosed to the defendants, while others were not privileged and could be produced. The court's decision was based on the specific circumstances of each document and the purpose for which it was prepared.

The court ordered the proceeding to be stood over for directions on 27 June 2003 at 9.30 am, allowing further proceedings to address the specific issues raised by the privilege claims.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. the proceeding, including all current notices of motion, be stood over for directions on 27 June 2003 at 9.30 am.

Background

Background to the litigation

The question of maintaining confidentiality in relation to the material, however, is a different matter. Public policy may well require that the material not be disclosed except in the interests of the administration of justice. Even then, it may be appropriate to limit the extent of any disclosure. It may be appropriate for orders to be made in due course that evidence in relation to such material be given in confidence. Nevertheless, I do not consider that it would be contrary to public policy to permit ABB to have access to the September Statements, subject to appropriate undertakings as to confidentiality.Agreed Statements Of Facts On 5 November 1999, Gilbert + Tobin wrote to the AGS requesting further particulars of an amended statement of claim that had been filed in the Power Proceeding on 1 November 1999. On 19 November 1999, the AGS replied to Gilbert + Tobin in connection with the Power Proceeding. In the letter the AGS relevantly said:‘As discussed, the Commission suggest the most efficient way to progress this matter with your clients would be by way of an agreed statement of fact. This will not only obviate the need for defences to be filed but will also ensure that the matter is dealt with in an expeditious and cost effective manner. I note that you will obtain instructions from your clients about this matter and I await your response.’The letter then went on to respond to the request for further particulars. The letter ended by saying that a letter would be written separately ‘on a without prejudice basis’ in relation to another matter. In anticipation of a directions hearing in the Power Proceeding fixed for 17 December 1999, the AGS wrote to Gilbert + Tobin on 14 December 1999 saying:‘The Commission considers it appropriate, in light of its proposal to proceed by way of Agreed Statement of Facts, to have the matter adjourned until 5 February 2000. It is envisaged by this time we will be in a position to propose further orders.’The proceeding was subsequently stood over for further mention. On 7 January 2000, the AGS wrote to Gilbert + Tobin enclosing a draft statement of facts ‘for your consideration’. The letter, which was marked ‘Without Prejudice’, went on to say:‘As previously discussed, the Commission considers it appropriate to settle the question of liability with your clients by way of an Agreed Statement of Facts. You will note that this draft does not incorporate conduct by your clients in the Distribution Transformer industry however it is envisaged that a further Agreed Statement of Facts will be prepared to deal with distribution transformers.’ On 3 March 2000, as foreshadowed in the letter of 7 January 2000, Mr Kiley wrote to Ms Cass-Gottlieb enclosing a draft statement of facts in relation to the ‘Distribution Transformer Market’. Mr Kiley said that he would like to have discussions about that document at the meeting that had been scheduled for 9 March 2000 in relation to the Power Proceeding.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

EMMETT J
Tyree was not involved in the Power Proceeding. On 16 June 2001, Tyree filed an agreed statement of facts in the Distribution Proceeding. The hearing in relation to penalty concerning Tyree took place on 30 July 2001 and, as indicated above, judgment was delivered on 3 May 2002. Discussions that took place between Allen Allen & Hemsley on behalf of Tyree and Mr Boyce, on the one hand, and the Commission, on the other, concerning statements were in the context of the continuation of the proceeding against ABB. That is apparent from the letter of 3 July 2001 from Deacons to Allens Arthur Robinson saying that the statement that the Commission then required from Mr Boyce was to address the issues in dispute with ABB.CONCLUSIONSAlstom The September Statements were furnished as an element of the cooperation agreed to by Alstom following the exchange of 14 July 1999 and 16 July 1999. There was no settlement negotiation or discussion on foot at the time. The documents were not subject to without prejudice privilege. They were furnished to the Commission so that the Commission could use them in the course of its investigation and in the course of proceedings against, inter alia, Alstom and its officers. While they may have been prepared when litigation was commenced, they were not prepared for the purposes of the litigation with a view to obtaining evidence to be used in the Power Proceeding or the Distribution Proceeding. Nor are they subject to any public interest privilege in the circumstances. There is no privilege against production to ABB for inspection. The draft statements of facts were prepared by the Commission and its solicitors and commented on by Alstom’s solicitors by way of endeavour to compromise the proceedings against Alstom. The compromise was to make admissions in terms of agreed statements of facts with a view to avoiding the costs of litigation and the consequences of the possible unsuccessful defence of the allegations, resulting in what might have been a higher penalty. They are subject to without prejudice privilege. The response to the Commission’s letter of 3 March 2000 concerning the power transformer market is not privileged. The statements furnished following the disposition of the proceedings as against Alstom were obtained by the Commission for the purposes of the litigation with a view to obtaining evidence to be used in the litigation as against ABB. They are subject to legal professional privilege. Wilson Consistently with the conclusions reached in relation to draft statements of facts and subsequent witness statements of Alstom, the communications passing between the Commission and Allens Arthur Robinson concerning proposed agreed statements of facts and draft witness statements and affidavits would attract without prejudice privilege and legal professional privilege respectively. Schneider The correspondence between Mr Kiley and Mr Toy, on the one hand, and Truman Hoyle, on the other concerning a proposed statement of agreed facts occurred in the context of foreshadowed commencement and subsequent commencement of the Distribution Proceeding. While the correspondence was headed by reference to ‘ACCC Investigation of Transformer Distribution Market’, I consider that it is fair to categorise the communications as negotiations directed towards a resolution of a dispute between the Commission, on the one hand, and Schneider and its executives, on the other, as to the penalty that should be imposed as a consequence of alleged contraventions of Pt IV of the Act. Where the Commission or its solicitor furnished additional information to Truman Hoyle, it did so in order to endeavour to resolve a dispute as to the facts upon which the Court should be invited to assess penalties in respect of contraventions made out on the basis of those facts. I consider that the communications described above in relation to agreed statements of facts and the successive drafts of the agreed statements of facts are subject to without prejudice privilege.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: EMMETT J

Before dealing with the claims for privilege by the Commission, it is necessary to say something about the circumstances surrounding the bringing into existence of the documents in question. Of significance in relation to each of the categories is an arrangement entered into between Alstom and the Commission in July 1999 involving co-operation by Alstom with the Commission in relation to the investigation by the Commission of alleged contraventions of Pt IV of the Act. COOPERATION BETWEEN ALSTOM AND THE COMMISSION On 14 July 1999, the Commission wrote to Alstom under the heading ‘Transformer Market Arrangements’. After referring to a meeting on 13 July 1999, the Commission’s letter relevantly said:‘The Commission is aware that Alstom Australia Limited (Alstom) and senior executives of Alstom have been involved in collusive arrangements involving price fixing and market sharing agreements in the Australian and New Zealand markets for power transformers.…The Commission wishes to give Alstom and its officers the opportunity to cooperate with its investigation at an early stage. The investigation will proceed with or without cooperation.The Commission and the Federal Court recognise the benefits to all parties of cooperation. The Commission has developed a leniency policy for corporations and individuals that provide full cooperation with it in an investigation.Full cooperation of your corporation and officers and employees involved in breaches of the Act in this matter will comprise the following elements:a)Providing the Commission with full and frank disclosure of the activity and all relevant documentary and other evidence available. This would include:i)details of all meetings and communications including dates, venues, participants and the agreements/arrangements reached or attempted to be reached;ii)details of the implementation of the arrangements including details of market shares, prices, identification of customers affected, volume of business involved and all relevant documentation;iii)details of all officers and employees of Alsom who were involved in or had knowledge of the arrangements including complete details of their involvement or knowledge, their position and who they reported to;iv)providing these details to the Commission in a comprehensive and open report;b)Cooperating fully with the Commission’s investigation and any ensuing court action. This would include:i)providing officers to be interviewed as required;ii)providing evidence in any subsequent proceedings (including making witnesses available);c)Your company taking immediate steps to discontinue this conduct and ensuring that it does not happen again.Material provided by Alstom and its officers must be complete, accurate, truthful and open. The Commission considers complete, accurate, truthful and open cooperation beginning at an early stage to be a matter that would be favourably reflected in subsequent court imposed penalties. At the appropriate time the Commission would be prepared to discuss with Alstom possible settlement proposals which might be put to the Court on an agreed basis.The Commission does not propose to give any publicity to the matter, nor issue s 155 notices upon Alstom or its current officers or employees until its consideration and assessment of the report provided by Alstom. After consideration of the report the Commission will discuss the further conduct of the matter with you.The Commission seeks an in principle agreement from Alstom to cooperate on the above mentioned basis by no later than close of business Friday 16 July 1999.Should this undertaking of cooperation be given the Commission seeks the full report outlined above by no later than Tuesday 3 August 1999.’ (First emphasis added; later emphasis original).