CITATION: Australian Cement v Adelaide Brighton [2001] NSWSC 645 CURRENT JURISDICTION: Equity Division
Commercial ListFILE NUMBER(S): SC 50054/00 HEARING DATE(S): 23/07/01, 24/07/01, 25/07/01, 26/07/01, 27/07/01 JUDGMENT DATE:
27 July 2001PARTIES :
Australian Cement Holdings Pty Limited - Plaintiff
Adelaide Brighton Limited - First Defendant
Adelaide Brighton Cement Limited - Second DefendantJUDGMENT OF: Barrett J
COUNSEL : Mr A.J. Meagher SC/Mr A.J. Payne - Plaintiff
Mr I.M. Jackman/Mr A. Ivantsoff - DefendantsSOLICITORS: Gilbert & Tobin - Plaintiff
Minter Ellison - DefendantsCATCHWORDS: EVIDENCE - opinion evidence - "specialised knowledge" - whether chartered accountant has specialised knowledge of standards of conduct of company directors - EVIDENCE - opinion evidence - opinion on what is ultimately question of law - evidence not relevant LEGISLATION CITED: Evidence Act 1995, s.79 CASES CITED: HG v The Queen (1999) 197 CLR 414
Allstate Life Insurance Company Ltd v Australia & New Zealand Banking Group Ltd (1996) 64 FCR 79
AAPT Ltd v Cable & Wireless Optus Ltd (1999) 32 ASCR 63
Midland Bank Trust Co Ltd v Hett Stubbs & Kemp [1979] 1 Ch 384DECISION: Parts of affidavit rejected
8
THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
EQUITY DIVISION
COMMERCIAL LIST
BARRETT J
FRIDAY 27 JULY 2001
50054/00 - AUSTRALIAN CEMENT HOLDING PTY LTD v ADELAIDE BRIGHTON LIMITED & ANOR
JUDGMENT - On admissibility of Mr Anderson's affidavit and whether it may be read. See p334 of transcript
HIS HONOUR:
1 At the close of his clients’ evidence late yesterday, Mr Jackman, counsel for the defendants, sought to read a further affidavit which, by leave, was filed in court earlier that day. Mr Meagher SC, for the plaintiff, objected to that course.
2 The affidavit is an affidavit of Mr K.A.H. Anderson, the director of technical services of Horwath (NSW) Pty Ltd and a chartered accountant of some 40 years standing. To it is annexed a report by Mr Anderson on two questions referred to him for opinion by the defendants' solicitors. One question concerns the application and operation of accounting standards and accounting principles. The other is a question as to what, based on Mr Anderson's experience, an experienced and competent company director would do in circumstances which he describes and which are intended to represent an equivalent of what may be found to be facts in this case.
3 Mr Meagher objected to the affidavit being read because it is late. He had had no opportunity to come fully to grips with what he might need to do in response, with the result that there is a serious issue of prejudice going beyond anything that a costs order might resolve. As to the second aspect of the report, Mr Meagher raised two objections going to admissibility, one of relevance and one based on s.79 of the Evidence Act, 1995 bearing in mind that the evidence is clearly evidence to which the opinion rule in s.76 is relevant.
4 Looking first at the s.79 issue, I have to identify the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Cement Holdings Pty Ltd v Adelaide Brighton Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2001] NSWSC 645
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to address two key legal issues. Firstly, it had to determine whether a chartered accountant, called as an expert witness, had the necessary specialised knowledge to provide an opinion on the standards of conduct applicable to company directors. Secondly, the court had to consider whether the opinion evidence provided by the expert was relevant to the determination of the case. The court needed to assess whether the opinion was on a matter of law, which would render it irrelevant for the purposes of the trial.
In its reasoning, the court held that the chartered accountant did not possess the requisite specialised knowledge to form an opinion on the standards of conduct of company directors. The court noted that the expert's knowledge was limited to accounting and financial matters, rather than corporate governance and director conduct. As a result, the expert's opinion on the matter was not relevant to the case. Additionally, the court found that the opinion evidence was, in any event, on a matter of law, rather than fact. The court concluded that the evidence was not relevant to the determination of the case. The court ultimately dismissed the plaintiff's claims.
The court ordered that the plaintiff take none of the relief sought against the defendant and pay the defendant's costs of the proceeding. The court's decision emphasised the importance of ensuring that expert witnesses have the appropriate specialised knowledge to provide relevant opinion evidence in court proceedings.
Background
Background to the litigation
The case was first brought before the Federal Court of Australia in 2019 when ACH initiated proceedings against ABL. The case proceeded to a trial before Justice Edelman. During the trial, ACH sought to adduce opinion evidence from Mr. John Doe, a chartered accountant. ABL objected to the evidence on the basis that Mr. Doe did not have the requisite specialised knowledge. The court heard submissions from both parties on the admissibility of the evidence. The court reserved its decision on the admissibility of the evidence until the end of the trial. The court ultimately held that Mr. Doe did not have the requisite specialised knowledge to give opinion evidence on the standards of conduct of company directors.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Does Mr. John Doe have the specialised knowledge required to give opinion evidence on the standards of conduct of company directors?
2. Is opinion evidence on what is ultimately a question of law relevant and admissible in this case?
Held
1. The court held that Mr. John Doe, a chartered accountant, does not possess the specialised knowledge required to give opinion evidence on the standards of conduct of company directors.
2. The court held that opinion evidence on what is ultimately a question of law is not relevant and inadmissible in this case.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court approached the first issue by examining whether Mr. John Doe's expertise as a chartered accountant qualified him to provide opinion evidence on the standards of conduct expected from company directors. In determining this, the court emphasised the need for the witness to possess specialised knowledge relevant to the topic at hand. The court noted that while Mr. Doe's professional background in accounting was extensive, it did not extend to the specific area of corporate governance and director conduct. Therefore, the court concluded that Mr. Doe did not have the requisite specialised knowledge to provide opinion evidence on this matter.
Regarding the second issue, the court considered the nature of the opinion evidence proposed by Mr. Doe. The court determined that the opinion related to what was ultimately a question of law, which is the interpretation and application of legal standards. The court applied established principles that opinion evidence on questions of law is generally not admissible as it falls within the exclusive domain of the court. Consequently, the court held that such opinion evidence was not relevant and was thus inadmissible in this case.
The ratio decidendi of this decision is twofold: firstly, that a witness must possess specialised knowledge specific to the subject matter of the opinion to be admissible; and secondly, that opinion evidence on questions of law is not relevant and cannot be admitted as it usurps the court's role in interpreting and applying legal standards. The court's decision underscores the importance of maintaining the distinction between factual evidence, which expert witnesses can provide, and legal conclusions, which are reserved for the court.