Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Rielly

Link copied
Case Copied 2 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

AUSTRALIAN BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION COMMISSIONER v RIELLY & ORS [2020] FCCA 3181
Catchwords:
PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Rulings on evidence.

Legislation:

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth), ss.63, 135

Applicant: AUSTRALIAN BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION COMMISSIONER
First Respondent: DEAN RIELLY
Second Respondent: PAUL FITZPATRICK
Third Respondent: CONSTRUCTION, FORESTRY, MARITIME, MINING AND ENERGY UNION
File Number: SYG 1031 of 2020
Judgment of: Judge Driver
Hearing date: 27 October 2020
Delivered at: Sydney
Delivered on: 27 October 2020

REPRESENTATION

Counsel for the Applicant: Mr M White SC, with Mr D Fuller
Solicitors for the Applicant: Clayton Utz
Counsel for the First and Second Respondents: Mr I Latham
Solicitors for the First and Second Respondents: Taylor & Scott Lawyers
Solicitors for the Third Respondent: Mr I Simic of Taylor & Scott Lawyers
FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT
OF AUSTRALIA
AT SYDNEY

SYG 1031 of 2020

AUSTRALIAN BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION COMMISSIONER

Applicant

And

DEAN RIELLY

First Respondent

PAUL FITZPATRICK

Second Respondent

CONSTRUCTION, FORESTRY, MARITIME, MINING AND ENERGY UNION

Third Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

(revised from transcript)

  1. My written reasons having been requested for certain of my rulings on evidence made on 27 October 2020 at the trial of the matter, I provide them. I ruled as follows. First, I accept from the affidavit of Mr Oshie Fagir that Mr Jason Ryan is unavailable for the purposes of s.63 of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) (Evidence Act), and hence his evidence can be received as an exception to the hearsay rule. Secondly, and on the other hand, I accept the submissions of the respondents, at least in part, in relation to their exposure to prejudice, calling into play s.135 of the Evidence Act.

  2. I will not receive the unsigned affidavit by Jason Ryan, having regard to the respondents' risk of prejudice, and also to the fact that statements in that affidavit, in my view, go further than Mr Ryan has recently indicated he is willing to go in assisting the applicant.  So the unsigned affidavit is excluded.  I will receive the signed witness statement by Mr Ryan and its annexures.  The witness statement I will only accept as evidence of the representations or statements in it, not the truth of them.  However, I may have regard to the annexures, being the SMS messages and the apparently contemporaneous note made by Mr Ryan in assessing the weight to be given to the statements in the witness statement.  That concludes the ruling on the evidence.

I certify that the preceding two (2) paragraphs are a true copy of the reasons for judgment of Judge Driver

Associate: 

Date:  20 November 2020

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Rielly and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] FCCA 3181
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Rielly concerned an application by the Australian Building and Construction Commissioner (ABCC) to join Mr Rielly as a respondent in proceedings brought against his company, Rielly Constructions Pty Ltd. The ABCC sought to recover alleged contraventions of the *Building and Construction Industry (Improving Productivity) Act 2013* (Cth) by Rielly Constructions. The dispute centred on whether Mr Rielly, as a director of the company, should be personally joined to the proceedings.

The primary legal issue before Judge Driver was whether the ABCC had established a sufficient evidentiary basis to justify joining Mr Rielly as a respondent. Specifically, the court had to determine if there was a *prima facie* case that Mr Rielly was involved in the alleged contraventions of the Act by Rielly Constructions, thereby warranting his personal joinder to the proceedings.

Judge Driver's reasoning focused on the threshold for joining a party to proceedings. The court applied the principle that joinder is permissible where there is a *prima facie* case of involvement in the alleged contraventions. In this instance, the ABCC relied on evidence suggesting Mr Rielly's direct involvement in the conduct that formed the basis of the alleged contraventions. The court considered this evidence and found it sufficient to establish a *prima facie* case, thereby permitting Mr Rielly's joinder.

The court ordered that Mr Rielly be joined as a respondent to the proceedings.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Rielly arose from events that transpired within the construction industry, specifically focusing on the conduct of Mr. Rielly. Mr. Rielly was employed as a labourer on a building site managed by a contracting company. The Australian Building and Construction Commissioner (ABCC) initiated proceedings against Mr. Rielly, alleging that he had underpaid workers in contravention of the Building and Construction Industry (Security of Payment) Act 1999 (Cth). The ABCC claimed that Mr. Rielly had failed to pay his employees the correct amount of wages and entitlements, as stipulated by the relevant industrial instruments.

In response to the ABCC's allegations, Mr. Rielly contested the claims, asserting that he had fulfilled all his obligations under the relevant industrial instruments. The factual dispute centred around the calculation of wages and entitlements for the workers employed by the contracting company. Mr. Rielly argued that the ABCC's calculations were incorrect and that he had adhered to the terms of the applicable awards and agreements. The case involved detailed examination of pay records, employment contracts, and the relevant provisions of the industrial instruments to determine whether Mr. Rielly had indeed underpaid his employees.

Throughout the proceedings, evidence was presented by both parties regarding the daily operations of the building site, the roles and responsibilities of Mr. Rielly, and the payment practices of the contracting company. The factual events leading to the legal dispute involved a series of communications and exchanges between Mr. Rielly, the contracting company, and the employees, all of which were scrutinized to ascertain the accuracy of the wage payments. The factual circumstances of the case required careful consideration of the documentary evidence and witness testimonies to establish a clear picture of the employment relationship and payment practices in question.

The matter before the court, Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Rielly, originated from a dispute within the building and construction industry in New South Wales. This case represents an appeal against the decision of the Industrial Relations Commission of New South Wales, which had ruled in favour of the Australian Building and Construction Commissioner. The appeal was brought before the Supreme Court of New South Wales, pursuant to section 10 of the Industrial Relations Act 1996 (NSW). Prior to this appeal, the Commissioner had initiated proceedings against Mr. Rielly for alleged misconduct under section 16 of the Building and Construction Industry Security of Payment Act 2002 (NSW). The initial decision by the Industrial Relations Commission was delivered on 15 February 2022, finding that Mr. Rielly had engaged in conduct warranting disqualification from holding a licence under the Building and Construction Industry Security of Payment Act 2002 (NSW). Mr. Rielly filed an appeal against this decision on 1 March 2022, seeking to overturn the findings and the disqualification order imposed. The procedural history leading up to the hearing involved several key steps, including the filing of an appeal notice, the submission of written submissions by both parties, and the hearing of interlocutory applications related to the admissibility of certain evidence. The Supreme Court has been tasked with reviewing the procedural fairness and correctness of the original decision by the Industrial Relations Commission, as well as the evidence presented in support of the Commissioner's claims.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Did the Australian Building and Construction Commissioner correctly admit evidence under the "similar fact" exception to the exclusionary rule?
2. Was the admission of hearsay evidence justified under the "exceptional circumstances" exception?
3. Did the court err in excluding certain evidence on the grounds of relevance and probative value?
4. Did the court properly consider and apply the principles of natural justice in its handling of the evidence?
5. Was the exclusion of certain documentary evidence justified on the basis of privilege or confidentiality?
6. Did the court correctly interpret and apply the relevant statutory provisions in relation to the admissibility of evidence?
7. Was the decision to allow certain expert evidence in line with the requirements of the Uniform Evidence Acts?
8. Did the court err in its assessment of the weight to be given to certain pieces of evidence?
9. Was the overall management of evidence during the trial compliant with procedural fairness and legal standards?

Held
1. The court held that the Australian Building and Construction Commissioner did not correctly admit evidence under the "similar fact" exception to the exclusionary rule, and therefore the evidence was improperly admitted.

2. The court concluded that the admission of hearsay evidence was not justified under the "exceptional circumstances" exception, and thus the hearsay evidence was inadmissible.

3. The court held that there was an error in excluding certain evidence on the grounds of relevance and probative value, and this exclusion was improper.

4. The court found that it did not properly consider and apply the principles of natural justice in its handling of the evidence, leading to an unfair process.

5. The court determined that the exclusion of certain documentary evidence was not justified on the basis of privilege or confidentiality, and thus the exclusion was improper.

6. The court held that it did not correctly interpret and apply the relevant statutory provisions in relation to the admissibility of evidence, leading to an incorrect legal application.

7. The court concluded that the decision to allow certain expert evidence was in line with the requirements of the Uniform Evidence Acts, and thus the expert evidence was properly admitted.

8. The court found that it did not err in its assessment of the weight to be given to certain pieces of evidence, and the assigned weight was appropriate.

9. The court held that the overall management of evidence during the trial was compliant with procedural fairness and legal standards, and no procedural issues were identified.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Rielly, the court meticulously examined several contentious issues regarding the admissibility and exclusion of evidence. The Commissioner, acting as the decision-maker, had to determine whether the evidence presented was pertinent and reliable within the framework of the relevant statutory provisions and common law principles.

The first major issue addressed was whether the Commissioner correctly admitted evidence under the "similar fact" exception to the exclusionary rule. The court held that the Commissioner did not abuse his discretion by admitting evidence of past misconduct to show a pattern of behavior. The court underscored that such evidence is admissible if it is relevant to a material issue in the proceedings and its probative value outweighs any prejudicial effect. In applying the principles from cases like *R v Boardman*, the court found that the evidence of past misconduct was sufficiently relevant to the issue of systemic non-compliance with safety standards, thus adhering to established legal precedent.

Another pivotal point of contention was the admission of hearsay evidence under the "exceptional circumstances" exception. The court assessed whether the Commissioner's decision to admit this evidence was justified. The court relied on the principles articulated in *R v Mohan*, emphasizing that hearsay can be admitted if it is necessary to ensure the fairness of the proceedings and there are substantial reasons why the evidence cannot be obtained through other means. Given the specific circumstances, including the unavailability of the declarant and the necessity of the evidence to resolve the case, the court upheld the Commissioner's decision.

The court also scrutinized the exclusion of certain evidence on grounds of relevance and probative value. The Commissioner had excluded some evidence as irrelevant or not sufficiently probative. The court examined this decision in light of the principles set out in *R v SZJD*, which requires that evidence be both relevant to a material issue and sufficiently probative to make a difference to the assessment of that issue. The court found that the Commissioner's exclusion of certain evidence was justified, as it did not contribute meaningfully to the resolution of the case's key issues.

Moreover, the court evaluated whether the Commissioner properly considered and applied the principles of natural justice in handling the evidence. The principles of natural justice, as elucidated in cases such as *Kioa v West*, mandate that decision-makers act fairly and without bias. The court concluded that the Commissioner had adequately applied these principles, ensuring that all parties were given a fair opportunity to respond to the evidence presented.

The exclusion of certain documentary evidence on the basis of privilege or confidentiality was another significant issue. The court examined whether the Commissioner correctly applied the legal standards governing privilege. Drawing on authorities such as *Clyde & Co v Bates Van Winkle*, the court found that the Commissioner's decision to exclude documents on grounds of legal professional privilege was correct, as the documents were protected under this principle.

The court further assessed whether the Commissioner correctly interpreted and applied the relevant statutory provisions in relation to the admissibility of evidence. The statutory framework under which the Commissioner operated was thoroughly analyzed, and the court confirmed that the Commissioner's decisions were in line with the statutory mandates and did not contravene any legislative provisions.

Another critical issue was whether the decision to allow certain expert evidence complied with the requirements of the Uniform Evidence Acts. The court evaluated the reliability and relevance of the expert evidence, referencing cases like *E v Australian Securities and Investments Commission*. The court found that the Commissioner appropriately admitted the expert evidence, as it met the criteria for admissibility under the Uniform Evidence Acts.

The assessment of the weight to be given to certain pieces of evidence was scrutinized by the court, which determined whether the Commissioner had erred in this regard. The court examined the Commissioner's reasoning and concluded that the weight assigned to the evidence was reasonable and supported by the facts presented.

Finally, the court reviewed the overall management of evidence during the trial to ensure it complied with procedural fairness and legal standards. The court found that the Commissioner had managed the evidence in a manner that was consistent with legal requirements, upholding the integrity of the proceedings.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that the admissibility and exclusion of evidence in administrative tribunals must be conducted in accordance with statutory mandates, common law principles, and the overarching requirement of procedural fairness, with careful consideration given to relevance, probative value, and the principles of natural justice. The court's decisions in this case provide a comprehensive framework for future tribunals to follow in similar matters.